Kuldip Singh v. Punjab National Bank And ORS

-1-



  
     

 !"#$# %&'('(
)*+,#-.#%/0 ((((((--++ 12$*$

*%3 4

# % + %5 %, 02$  (((((( $- %,% $
 &  6 ( .
 1
.) 7
  .
   6 ( .


 
  





 


 








 
7(











!


"
 





#$
 
%& '( %')*







+



$

+

 
,
- .


 .

/



 
)0 )'

%')1
+

  

$

$

+
$

  



2

 
$

$

+$
 


$ " 





 
$ +
 

$
 

 


3

 +
+





 

 


)&

 
 
$ 

#
 $

 




 
+
 
$ 
2


 






+
 

$

4 



/




5

$
67
36)

36%
 +

 



 









 

 

+
$
$




$

,
 
 











-2- 
 
 



 
$

+


 .

/

 
,
- .

-



8$ 9
5





 
$ 


 :



 





$



$





 
 .

)& '% %')1.
8 * "2,# , 9 *2 "" *%  '::';<=  % ,#!!2% ,

$ 49 ,4# #%/ "" *% $ ! ,#!!2%  "*$ >2$ ! 42 %"0 ?# 0 * %9 > %,

$>% # %,4+ ?& . @% (

A" > !"*$ A" ;< :AA' B ;::  %$.#%/0 '::' ;<= B< <ABA' < '::' ;<:'< *2"0 %.#%/0 '::' ;<= : BB;: 'A;A' ' ;::  %$.#%/0 '::' ;<=  B:<B: A;A' '< ;  ,*2.#%/0 '::' ;<= < ':' ':A;A' ' :< )2#$0 C

# '::' ;<=  B<=B 'A=A'  '::' ;;=< .*50?#%,2) *2 '::' ;<= B B;: '<A=A' ' '::' ;B':B .*50,D.#%/0 '::' ;<= ; '<'<< A=A'  '::' ;;=< .*50?#%,2) *2 '::' ;<= = B;< BA=A' < '::' =;B  2,-) *2 '::' ;<= ' 'B< A'A' ' :< )2#$0 C

# '::' ;<= '' 'B' 'A'A' < '::' ;;=< .*50?#%,2) *2 '::' ;<= ' '';'' 'A'A' : ;::  %$.#%/0 '::' ;<= ': B<: BA'A' < ;  ,*2.#%/0 '::' ;<= ' B: ;A'A' B ==  %.#%/0 '::' ;<= '< <:<=< :'A'A' ' ==  %.#%/0 '::' ;<= ' <BB :'A'A'  :< )2#$0 C

# '::' ;<= 'B <=:B :'A'A' ; ==  %.#%/0 '::' ;<= '; =B 'A''A'  ==  %$.#%/0 '::' ;<= '= :=: :A''A'  ;  ,*2.#%/0 '::' ;<=  '''; BA''A' ' '::' =B )*+?

.#%/0 '::' ;<=

-3- ' :'<: ;A''A' '< '::' =':B .

%.#%/0 '::' ;<=  =='; ;A''A' = :< )2#$0 C

# '::' ;<= : B::=; 'A''A'  '::' ;; ) - +> .#%/0 '::' ;<=  B:'<; 'A''A' < '::' =''B

40- +.#%/0 '::' ;<= < BB:': ''A''A'  '::' ''B< *24 @.#%/0 '::' ;<=  :='< ';A''A' '; '::' <<B'  +?#%,2) *2 '::' ;<= B <' A''A' : '::' := )*+?

.#%/0 '::' ;<= ##( 

 * % 2,  - $ , ! ++ ?#%/ ,4#  % 2#$ #% 0

"" *% $ !,#!!2% "*$ >2$?# 09 *2*$,
=<<;).

%,"2,#

0 > *%  9 *2 ?% "" *%  4* 0 D *"02$ 2 %  $*-- 2 , 49 $-

> %,

 !"*$ >2$ $2E*#2,*%,2 %5F$2*+$& . @% (

A" > !"*$ A" ':B: AA'  ==  %.#%/0 '::' ;<= 'B:= :AA' '; ;::  %$.#%/0 ':B: :B:;< : :B<B< ;A;A' ' ;::  %$.#%/0 '::' ;<=  B<'= 'A=A' < '::' =;B  2,-) *2 '::' ;<= < <B= 'A'A' ; '::' =''' .*23# ) *2 '::' ;<=  :'= '<A'A'  '::' =''' .*23# ) *2 '::' ;<= B B: ;A'A' < :< )2#$0 C

# '::' ;<= ; : BA''A'  '::' ;''  +?#%,2.#%/0 '::' ;<= = ;<;' A''A' ' '::' <= 2$0 %.#%/0 '::' ;<= ' B;<: A'A' < '::' B:='

%3# .#%/0 '::' ;<= '' 'B< A'A'  '::' B:='

%3# .#%/0 '::' ;<= ' :: =A'A'< ' '::' ;; ) - +> .#%/0 '::' ;<= ': <BB 'AA'< '< ;  ,*2.#%/0 '::' ;<=  4   * ,4# , ! ++ ?#%/ ?# 0,2 ?

+ $+#-$ 0 "" *%  ! .(  ,*2 .#%/0 ?# 0 9 *2 *$2
 %,G ++ ?, "

$0 - 9>% %, +

2

-4-

,>#

,D#,9 *2+

2,

,


0$ ? ?# 0,2 ?

+$ 2-  ! B*% * 0 2#H, %$ "

# %$ > *% #%/ $(''<A @% (B:<B: ,

, (;('7 B'; ,

, ('('7 '='= ,

, ('('7 B<: ,

, B('('7 :=: ,

, :(''('7 B<:<: ,

'('('<7 <BB ,

, '(('<  ,4# 0 "" *%  ! .(  ,*2 .#%/0499 *! 2"2,# #%/9 *2 ?% "" *% 3*$  % 04 $#$ ! 2 +2E*$ !"*$ >2& . @% (

A",4# > !"*$ '='= A'A'  ':::;  ,*2.#%/0 B<:<: 'A'A'<  ':::;  ,*2.#%/0 *  ! 0$B*% * 0 2#H,% 2#$ ! $(''<A79 *2 *2%,

$(A  "*$ >2 .(  ,*2 .#%/0 02 */0 -2$ % + $

+>% * $#,4 %5 %,$ >?

$" %!#2>,49.( ,*2.#%/0D#,+

2,

B(:('<( ###( 

 %('('79 *>#$*$,*$2
A- $$? 2, !$(

>3# ) *2 

  (;<BB   , "

$0#2

 42 %"0  ! 2 ,4# #%/ "" *%  ! .(  ,*2 .#%/0 ?# 0 $(  %, "2,# 0 > *%  9 *2 "" *% '::';<= ( 0#$ 0 $ 4% ,>#

, 49 *2 D#, +

2 ,

:(:('<( . @% (

A" > ! "*$ >2 A"

A"

> 25$ B'; A'A'  ;  ,*2 .#%/0 '::' ;<= 1 *"02$ 0+, %2" 2,( 4  %$ >, 9#((A'A'! ++ ?#%/ %$!2% 2#$0 D +$  4% "2,#  9 *2 "" *%  ?# 0 *$,
 ! $(

>3#  ) *2 0  ! "" *%  !.( %.#%/04* " 22$- %,#%/D *"02$ 2% 0+, %2" 2,&

-5- . @% (

A" > ! "*$

A"

> 25$ = A'A'  ==  % .#%/0 ':B: :B:;< 1 *"02$ 0+, %2" 2,( <B<B A'A' < ==  % .#%/0 ':B: :B:;< 1 *"02$ 0+, %2" 2,(  *2 4 D ++/, "

#$-23*,#"# + 0#% 2$  ! 0 %5 ?0#"0

> *% 2 $$#$" %,*"

#% 2>$ !- <3  ! .,

'(( $ >%,,*- ,

(I 5

 
 


+



 +


$

2+
 
 

$
,
 
 

() '0 %')1



 
$
+

62+
-

$






 
 +
4   


 


 +


2+
 

  
$

$

#
 


 

3

 +
+


 


$ 






#
$
+



 
 

 

$  

; <0(*''4.
$
)&




$



$




89



 
 +


$

$


08#9





 $
 
)'

'< %'%%
 +


 

 
)* '* %')1

3

 +
+
 

$ 

$

$

+
$

  




2

 
$

$

+$



 

 +


 




+


 







 





 
 


 
)0 )'

%')1

3

 +
+
$

 
$
, 







+


$ 





+



-6-




+

 




$



') '% %')& "/



 
+
$



$

'1 )'

%')&

5


+





+

3

 +
+



 







+
 
%= '* %')1



 

 

 

 
 




$


$
6.)(%
6.)((


6.)<'
  +



$4 
 

$


 

$
67
36)

36%

 +



+
$
2 +
$




 


 

 

 
 

 

 


 





 

#
 $



)&

 
 






+
 

$



$
 
2

5


<0


$ 

+
+




 




#+


 




 
 

$+








 


2+
 



 
$ 

  
+




>3




? 


 

,


7



#


 










$ 
+


+
 







+
 +

4


 






 

#






 4

+

62+
-



3

 +
+



+


   
 



 


$ 

 
5


$
 
 




 






 
@ 

 +

/






  










+


+



$ 


#$

-7- 
$
+
$ 





+

 
 +





>

 /





 




$ 


#$

+


 







$

 +
$   1
.)  

 
  
  .
     '('(
  ,
 /4 
A4?
,
   
A4?