High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/540/1988dismissed

(O&M) Kewal Singh Etc. v. Shri Guru Tej Bahadur Khalsa College, Etc.

2023-10-30Mr. Justice Aman Chaudhary6 pages

#$% &'&(

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

, 13 X-13+ B-22,221-3 *2 -:3,? ^0-2>*?,?2_ -. ;*3/ J,*2D?13= 6 U*3*;2 *3/ J*?;*2K -D+ -. 8 U*3*;2 ` J*?;*2 *2 B,? X*J*W*3/1 .-? +>, L,*? Y[`[[ 13 +>, *?,* -. C1;;*=, @*3:*3 *3/ /,.,3/*3+ S-7 <>?1 ED?D F,= G*>*/D? 9>*;2* H-;;,=, .-? I-J,3K )*2DL* >*2 =-+ 3- ?1=>+ +1+;, -? 13+,?,2+ :>*+2-,T,? 13 1+ *3/ /,.,3/*3+ 2>-D;/ W, ?,2+?*13,/ .-?,T,? .?-J 13+,?.,?13= 13 +>, 2*1/ X-13+ B-22,221-3 -. +>, B;*13+1..2 -3 +>, 2D1+ ;*3/ WL *3L:*L7 F>, 2*J, :*2 0-3+,2+,/a bcdefaa ghbga -3 +>, =?-D3/ +>*+ G12>*3 9*D?K :1/-: -. @*?+*B <13=> >*/ ,i,0D+,/ * T*;1/ I1;; 13 .*T-D? -. /,.,3/*3+ S-7 -3 5676[7YZ6K * /*L B?1-?

! !!

" # !

"$ !%"& '& ( "% $" !

%%! # !! !!

! !) $! *"& + ') * # , ( ,)

"$ - , $ %

!! !!! !!

. ! % "$ !

% !

$$& /"

) $! "! *"&0) "!! ! #1

" . ! %% "$ - ,) 3!

$ " "$ ! 4!

") #! ! ! % 5"! .!%1 !

$ " "$ !

% !

%%! #1 "% . ! %% 63&70 !" # $% $# ! "!& /"

) ! %"

%%! 5"!

".%1 ! ! $ .)

!"!

. ! $!

! .!

& 8! .) # "$ - , . .

%. !" #"!

%%!) :

! . ; < . # . ! .

! !" ! %% "$ #"! = . #1

%" ! !" !) "

%"%1 "! !" !& > !%1) ! %%

"! #1 .% #& 9"%1) / % . 720

!!%

.!!

. ! %%

$ " "$ $! *"&04!

" 72 -%?

" #

@ ! .)

" !!! ! ) #"! #%".

. !" %%. -%.) ) ! !!!" "! # !" 3! !

! $

%%& : %1) "%1 " "$ ! !!!

%" "! .

!& 81 $" %%"

%& B&

" . ! #" # ") % "%

. " #%$ "$ ! "!!

. "! *"&0) !! !! ! $!4!

") " "! ! ! %% 3! #1 = . 8! . .

. ! "$

!1 !" !

%%!& :

"%1 . . ! %% 3! #1 - ,

! $ " !!

. ! !" # % %1 3!

" " "

! 9!

" DE "$ ! 4 ;!) 0EE

!! "# $%&'# () !! !*! +,$ -./0 1 # !1 2!!! 200 .(+,& 304 1 5 /./.)

( 17 0

! () 3!

9 . ,00 0 ( 1 .1!. # 7.) :

)# 2! * .

. # 0 1 .1!. ;

< $5=>5$%?= 1! /0//00!5 02. //00 @ .

.1 0)

0 ,00 ( 1 # !# ! 1 .A .! ( .. 2 /.! //0( !*!! 5 '5 -.

0. !0 . ! /. ! ..

. . *!/5 B(0)# C./ 1 !( 3!

9 .# (1 !! 0!!#

: ,00# 7 . 6. 1 "*.D 1 # !!

! / 2 920 1 # 2. .7 &E.

! . /./.)# .! .*1$E.

() !23!

9 .5 >5 ( ! ,00 : () 3!

9 . (A 1 /./.)# .7 .*

!( C./ 1 # 7 . B5$.!/ ! 5 ?5 3. /. 1

# ! //! .. 1! 02.//00@ .#2 . !F GH- . . !!

! 3!

9 . I (1

* ! 2!!! ( ! ! 3!

9 . C./ 1 2. .! 1 !/.

! .*

! / /0! E .!/ !J ( C5K5 =5>5$%?=L

2! */ 2

! *.0 1. * . 9.. 9 .L 2! 3!

9 . :/.!!

!. : 200L .

10)#

2 .() 7001 301 00 304 1 !.( M!2 1 # !1 2!! ! 200 2

* (. 1 * 3!

9 .N

! ! 200 2! : 5

! . *!!# 200 8:5 C $

71 ( !.( /.! .1 0.

2..# . /.! !*

!" #"

$ % &

'( ) *(

+ ,) " ! #"

$ % '

)

." " (

) " '

/ " !

% " (

2 1" -% " !

- '

3%& !"." ( /

(% . "( %'

)+ 45+ (

-. ) % " !

+ 0 - %"

" .+ 3 . ) "

- .- -)

!+ 6 -

-. ) "' (

1"7

. ( .( " *.% " !

((

+ 8" " "%- 7 " - " " '&

" -

" ! %% -) " "%- 7 .

& -% %

$ %

"%"

-% '

%+ " ' " %& '

)

- % -) " :

1" -) (

1"&

! " !

2 1"& .- " !

& !% ' "

$ % %% ) %.+ 0! & " . "

" ." "

((

" -. ) " "

/ " .-

! " !

+ ;" !

*.%

" * ' "

) ' " ! + ;"% " "!

&""

- !"((%) 4<+ ;" %(.% ..%' .&

." " !

+ 3 - ( ' " '

2 1"

(

1" =8 -

) *.% .%'+ ;" "

.% " . ) .

- %(" +> ?+ 3 .& "

(.( !" " (

+ 0@- " 1%(' A% " .

BCDECF CG HIJ KLMCN O4PPQR S 1AA P " "

& T,1. U% -

( 1. 5V " 3 . W.& SV<4& .

- %

. % "

- .

" (%( ( *.%& " -

%-2. " (. " .%

( - .+ 3

& )"U%'1.5X"3 1%..W.&S?4Q,> SP+ )& " ..

% ! -) "

((

.- ' " .

$ % & " !

." " (9%.

3%& 1" ; %

! "#$! % &' (') * ) &$ % +' %'

! % % * % $! % (% ,'% -. / -0 ! %% * %

#& )! ,'* ' '% ' 1+ ' % ) ' ' )

,'* )'

) % ) % & #%'')! ' + * % '(' '% % % ) & % ' , 2 #& )3 +,4! , &$ ,$ %

' #& )! ) )$

*'() 5 + % % + + %$ &') &' '

*'+% % 6) 7' ! % & % #& ) ) &* , % % 1% % 89 / -8 ) ( %'

% , 7' ! +, 6) 7' ) : %+ 7' ! , ' 5' % +' , % % 1% % -; / ; ! #% % %% --< / -- = > '% ,#) & '

# %

% 5#) % ' ?@AB@C DEFG HIJ K@FLDIG DEFGM .<< 7 N O' :P> 88Q! , ' %' # % ) & () ) ) %% %

' & + () ' ** ) * ,'%

R#'

% 7*%' 0; S )' T(') * U*%! -;8.

) ,'% 7*%' 0Q2*4 % S )' 7#**' U*%! -9.! &$ % %% % ) &$ % %%%' ,'% ) 1*#)' *

%'(

% & '% %% % $ + % * % &

)) #+'*'# *'

*#% * ' %

* %

' )' %% % %%% &R#%) ' %% % % & '*' $ #% ('*

) ) &$ %! ,'% ,! '% , + ()

* ) %% % %%% , '(' % % %' ' )%= N *

' & + () ' ** ) * ,'% % %' ) + ('' !

'' + $ #+'*'# *'

*#% * ' % #) % +' %'

++ % , * ) % (')'%$ ) #' %

'= O'/,'! ' % * % )! % , ++% # %

# ) %% % 1*#%' %

' , )#$ + () &$ 1' ' - > + 7' ) .V5'% 7' ! % &$ %' $' %

R#'

% ,=

"# !# "# $% # %& "# '()*+,*- ./0 '-123 4544 677 8#9"# 67 54& :#;<%

6$ = 7$

& >?

=@&

A$"=# !=$% "# $< # "% A$ "# %B B # @& @ 6

"# C

D$#E< 7$

& A$"

#%@ $

""#

#" "# # %

$ = $

F"#

! %B

$ <%B

F !"%

="# = = "% "$ %B

$ = $

F"#

! %B !& " "= # " "%% >A$ "# %BH I#

B& # % " !$=

J="# " A$ "# !

% <@

G"% 7$ #

%% 7$ H <F

<# !$

!%%B "# KL.'ML N+(*-O-L/*/ ./0 P1,'Q'-L3 4544 6778#9"#674 4 " 7$ !"#

%B %% 7$ "

%@ F%$

$ "#

$ # $ B%% J="#

F"# "#

"F $

F <#& #%@

$# %$"<% # E$ !"#"#<@F"#

"%7$ &<"##$ R # $

# $% # %

F"# # A$ "# ! %B "#F%F %

<"# # "#!"="

@ "%%%"

@ "#

E$=# <@ %B %% 7$ & "

<@ "=" 7<E

"# # "#!$

$$"#F"B!

=# =<@%# $#%!

STUVWUX Y00ZZY [VWPN #\$ ]

\"#^#_ `^a ]

<%_ `^a