Gurpal Singh v. Jasdeep Singh & ORS

  
 

      
 

 
#
$ %&'( )%* +#, .**+,&

01%2)2  211*#,

/'1%2  .

12* /2 $  34  #
 #  54  #
  


%121 /$ % %2' (6& /1%/'1

/

 
(    #),&,1 / & )21 '

2 711  2'8  / &  1 /'1 1+ 9, ,+, -/'1 &&:*

9,   '1 ,2(/'1%1%1( &&1*/1'11+  ;

! 92 ,  ,+, - /'1 &&:*

9,  ) 1% #1&/, ;<=;>% ,2&  1
  '1 , 2/

 '

2 711  ,+1 79 /'1

/( 211?, - +1 61 / ,+1 /'1 &&:*

9, **1

2/ &@),// +%12* /2

(6,1,:*)- A)-:1

/1 "" * 221 79 /'1 +1 ,/,

+#122, 2)-1(





%,1+9 2/ /1( %)  ;"     ;!!!( /'1

&&:*

,1 79 ',2 :

/1%

+ ) &+132 2 (

:1+9(  %&'

 #,

 

A B):

%( %,61%  /'1 '

%612/, -&:7, 1(81%1'

%612/, -/'1:)2/ %&%*, ',2 +

?

8 25:78 + 51

8',+1(%12* /2

(

:1+9(  211* #,

  +A,/ #, + - 8,/'  

:, 1% #, -'( %1 &'1 /'1%1 ,  8',/1  /122  & % %, - %1-,2/%    !  !! %: /'1 2,1  

 12* /   8 2 %:1 8,/'  7%1 +,&1 &1 4) (8'1%1 2( %12* /  8 2 1:*/9 '



:, 1% #, -' =2, &1 1&1 21> 8 2 %:1 8,/'B,%*

/1%&:, -8 %:/'1& %(%12* % ,21 5+ +?

5/'

//'1

/71 / ++81/ - 2&/ %11 12* /   ,%1  2'/ %: ',2

%12 ,  4 -)  /8 %2 /'1

/( 8',+1 

:, 1% #, -' %

 /8 %2 /'1 &:*+

/ * %/9 7%

,2', -/'1B,%*

 % ,2, + %:79 %&'

#, -'( %12* /2

 + -8,/'

:, 1%#, -'+1

9%:/'12*/ + -8,/'/'1,%%12*1&/,6181 * 2'1 :/,61 71',  /'1 &&)%%1 &1 8 2 /'

/ +,/,-  %1- %, /'1 +

 8 2 *1 - ,  71/811  7/' /'1 * %/,12

%12* /2

8

/1/2/*/'1

/%: '

%612/, -/'1&%*

 /'121 ++12( %:

 8 2 %1-,2/1%1

12* /2  

  81%1 %%12/1   /'1 2 :1 9

1  4 )  8 2 %1&61%1 %: %12* /   )  + 1 8,/'  1 +,61 & %/%,-1  /'1 2 :1 7%1

 11:*/98 2 +2) , /'1/'1%7 %%1+/'1-)  :%1+,61& %/%,-127%181%1 +2%1&61%1+9, -,

 -+ C1 * *1% 7 - ,  /'1 %1 % 21 /  & % '1 & % + 8,/' %1-,2/%  &1%/,,& /1 8 2 +2 / ?1 , /*22122,  

:, 1% #, -' 8 2 %%12/1   !!!

  28% 8 2 +2 %1&61%1 %: ',2 *22122,  4 /1%  ( #1&/, ;
8 2 1 " !!!( /'17 2,2 2*1&, +%1*%/D ;6,1 /1%&:*+1/,  612/,- ( ,

+ %1*%/ ) 1% #1&/,  ; %  8 2 ,+1, /'1)%/+1 1
++ @  -,2/% /1

 &::,/:1 /  /'1 & 21 / /'1 )%/  #122, 2( /'1 +1 1 ,/,

+ #122, 2 )-1( 

% :1 &'

%-12 ) 1% #1&/, 2 ;

 "  %1  8,/' #1&/,  ;


 #1&/, 2 

 ;  /'1 %:2 &/(

2/%12* /2

(/8',&'/'19*+1 / -),+/9

&+ ,:1/%, +
/,2*1%/, //:1 '1%1/'

& &&)21 

:, 1% #, -' '

 ,1 71%1 % :, -  &'

%-12

( /'1%1%1( *%&11, -2 2/ ',: 81%1 %**1  '1 *%21&)/, , 2)**%/ ,/2 & 21 1D :,



2:

28,/ 12212  /1% &+2)%1  /'1 *%21&)/,  16,1 &1( /'1 2/ /1:1 /2  %12* /2  

  ) 1% #1&/,  ;; % 81%1%1&%1(*)//, -1 /,%1, &%,:,

/, -16,1 &1 7%)-'/   %1&% 2/ /'1: / 8',&'( /'19 1 ,1

*+1 1/'1,%,

&1 &1
',211 &1(%12* /  +A,/ #, -' ',:21+ **1 %1 2 E  712,12 /'1 1D :,

E 

A,/#,

+2/1 1%1&1%/ &):1 /2 /1% '1 %, - +1 1 &) 21+ % /'1 * %/,12

-, -/'%)-'/'116,1 &17%)-'/ %1&%(/'1+1 /%, + )%/ &@),//1 %12* /2  

  6,1 /'1 ,:*)- 1A)-:1 /79-,6, -/'1:/'171 1,/)7/ 1&) 21+%/'1

/2)7:,/2/'

//'1 /%, + )%/ '

2 8% -+9 &@),//1 %12* / 2

  8,/')/ **%1&, /, - /'1 )++9 &%%7% /1 1*2,/, 2  /'1&:*+

/'1%8,/ 12212 /1% -,6, - )% /')-'/)+ & 2,1%  / /'1

%-):1 /2

&1 79 +1 1 &) 21+ % /'1

/( 81 ,  /'1 *%121 **1 + &:*+1/1+9 16, 

9 :1%,/ %/'1%1 2 2/++8 '1 16,1 &1 ,+ 7+1   %1&% 2)--12/2 /'

/

&&)21 211*#, -'32:

/1%

+) &+1)%16#, -''

*)%&'

21 F;% 2'

%1  /'1 +

 :1 2)%, -  ?

+2 



:

%+  2,/) /1 ,  6,++ -1 '*)%

:

( 8',+1 /'1 %1:

- F;% 2'

%1 8 2 *)%&'

21 79 /'1  /'1%  /'1

/(

:1+9( 

 #, -' ,  /'1

:1  ',2 2,2/1% B,2'

A11/ B )%    8161%( /'1 %12 , 

 #,

++81 )%16 #, -' / &)+/,6 /1 7)/   ?

+2  +

 )/   +

 :1 2)%, - ; ?

+2    '1 1 /%,12 ,  /',2 %1- %81%1, &%*% /1, /'1%161 )1%1&%2)%, -',2 +,1 /,:1( )%16 #, -' 1D1&)/1  E,++ %1- %, - /'1

%12 ,F;%2'

%1,  6)%%12* / 211* #, -'  /1% /'1 1 /'  )%16 #, -' ,  !<<( /'1

%12 ,+

8 2:)/ /1, ',2 6)%

2, &1/'1 ('1 2 &)+/,6 /, - /'1 %12 , +

  +/')-' E )*% #, -' =&:*+

/> :,//1 /'

/  /'1 1 /%,12 ,  /'1 %161 )1%1&%81%1, &%*% /1, /'1

:1%12* (7)/1*21/'

//'11 /%,1281%18%

 +21 8161%(',2/',2/12/,: 9,2 /8%/'%1+,

&1, /'1+,-'/  &):1 / %9 16,1 &1 D ,2 /'1 &*9  ?'

2% -,% %,%/'1&%*# ) ,!</ %,;%1- %, -/'1 +

 2,/) /1 ,  /'1 %1   6,++ -1 '*)%

:

 8',&' 2'82/'

/%12* / 211*#,

B%,2'

A11/ )% 81%1 /'1 & 8 1%2 ,  *22122,   F;% 2'

%1

F;% 2'

%1( %12*1&/,61+9( 2, &1  !!  %2  ')2(  -,2 ** %1 / /'1 &1,//'

/%12* /



B%,2'

A11/ B )% 81%1 & 8 1%2 ,  *22122,   /'1,% %12*1&/,612'

%12 '1 ++1-1 &&)%%1 &1 '

 / ?1  *+ &1   ;!!!
/'1*%121 /& 21(/'1

/8,2'1/2 ,+   /8 7 /2  ,%2/+9( '1 & :1 8,/' /'1 61%2,  /'

/ /'1 %161 )11 /%,1281%18%

8'1 '1&)+ /2)&&11( '1/?/'1%*+1 /'

/'1'

711 * 9, -/'1+1 21: 19 /#:/B%,2'

A11/B )%%&)+/,6 /, -/'1+

8161%( /',2 61%2,   /'1

/ 8 2 / 2)**%/1 79

16,1 &1')2(/'116,1 &1 ,+ 7+1 %1&%2)--12/2 /'

//'1

/'

/', -/8,/'/'1*22122,  +

:1 2)%, -;?

+2

E"'

4 +(#
=
612/,- /, - ,&1%>1*21 /'

/'1'

/:

91 @),%9 2/8'8 2/'18 1% /'1:)2/ %&%*( %

9%161 )1%1&%8 2&++1&/1 / 2&1%/  /'1 8 1%2',*  /'1 +

  ',2 :,22,   /'1
612/,- /, -  ,&1% 2)--12/2 /'

/ /'1 , 612/,- & )&/1 8 2 11&/,61  '1 +-,&  - 21&/,  ; )1/7A1&/, /'1 )7+,& %21&)/%/'

/%12* '

,%1/'1-) 2'//8 %2/'1 **1++

/( /1% *1%,  /'%11 : /'2( ,2 / ++ +1- ++9 /1

7+1(

2:)&' 2( 16,1 &1 ,+ 7+1 %1&%2)--12/2/'

21&/, ;8 2 2&%,71%&::,22, 

9&%,:1'1

**%1&, 16,1 &179/'1/%, +)%/, %1 &', -//'1



& &+)2, /'

//'1*%21&)/, '

2 ,+1/*%61/'1-),+/ %12* /2

,2(/')2( /,++1- +(%1@),%,

/1%1%1 &179/',2)%/  6,18  /'1 %12 , ,2&)22, ( 81 ,  %&1, /'1*% 91%:

1, /'1 ;<=;>% % -%

/  +1 61 / **1 2/ /'1 A)-:1 /  &@),//

/1 )+9 "( " * 221 79 /'1 +1 1 ,/,

#122, 2 )-1( 

&&%, -+9( ,/ ,2 %1A1&/1 61/ **1 +,21&+, 1 = #>  =  
>      %&'(