High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/3879/2019dismissed

Suresh Kumar And ANR v. State Of Haryana And Others

2022-02-03The Chief Justice,Mr. Justice Arun Palli12 pages

CWP No. 3879 of 2019 1

!"#"$% &'( #)*'+ ( $,) (# - ""$ (# . (#'# & (/ $ $,) (# - #0$, $#

( # $%1 2(3#) /*'+ ("$, 45,6!

5() 0 ""$ (# 2( $3'( 2"

45 ,,4 ,6!

$ ( 45 (/ $ 7") 2(& '( 8)2 95##"# $,6!

$ ( 4 (/ $ 5 () ( #0$, $# :) ( # ",0( # $! "#8 "$9( !(, ,)('9)6", !$ ( $!"$9#"$! ) 0(! ,"$9#

( 8 "$9!$,'! ,"$6"('

4'(; <<<<

) !$(6 (#/"$646 ,"$) + ( ) $,( 646 # ('$,)

004"!

8"4"/& !"$=:; "9)

"(+0 $# "$ $,( $#0 ( $!/ "$> $,!?'"#""$5 ) 8"4"

"$ # 4 + $!5

$) !# ) !

# 7) ( "$) (,'$, (# !"$

) > $,!?'"#""$!

= 7 # $$'$! , $ " +( ) $ "6 / (# 0("( ) !++ $! + $ ) !

= # !$ $, , 8/ ) 0 ""$ (#5$ ") () 0## ##"$) 4 $,"# 3 $$(!+0 $# "$) #

CWP No. 3879 of 2019 2 8 $ 0 ",@, 0#" , ) ( ( 5 ) !?'"#""$ 0(! ,"$9# ?'

) 4 $, "$ ?' #"$) 6 4 0# ,"$6" 7& !"$=:;) !

) !$(6 (#/!(00 ,'0 ('$,"$ (0( "$& !"$=:; !

7 # 0' ( # 8/ ) $#"'"$ $!) ) $A84 &'0( + '($,"

"$!

) ( 8/4 /"$9,7$0("$!"04 #(, !4 ("$9)

!?'"#""$, + ,) 6 8 $4 0# ,'$, (# !"$=:;!

) 0 B'() #,"#!'## ,"$, "4 44) #0 !#$ ! ## (/ $,( 4 6 $ ( "$ (0( "$9 # !"$ =:; !

5 )7 6 ( ( ) 0'(0# , !","$9) + ( ) $,5) ( ( $! ) !$!4',"$90 9( 0)) C',9+ $7'4,8 #'"! $,# + "#( 0(,'! ,) ( "$8 47%1 D- !"

# $#$" %

" !"

! &' ! "(

) !"

! & " % ) % %% !! *"

( " ) ! " ' "(

# $#)$! "

! & "

! +

! ) & , % -. "

#$ ) %

)-.-. , ! "/ "("

#$ ! "

! & 0

" % "

! !! "

" ! "

' ! ) 0 "

) %'" ) 0'"

)

'!"

) ' ) 0

, * 1 1 ! "

#$ ! "

! & "

! "

" , "/" ! 2

#$ " ) % "

3 ! (

)!"# %$ ! !" ! "/ "

! "

! +

)

CWP No. 3879 of 2019 3 "

""" % ! "

! & " ) ( "

& ! 4 "/ "

! +

) ! !

' "

& ! "

" ) ( 52 ! "

# " $

! "/ "( " ! 2 % "

3 ! ( ! ! ' "

! & ) 6 %6

! !" ! "/ "

! "

! +

7 " )

& # $! "

! +

' "

"/ "

2 2 ! "

" , ) ( "

)

( "

& # $4%% ! ""

% ( !" ! ( "

' " "

"( "

#$! "

! & , "

#$! "

! & ) !"

#$ !"

# $#)$ 8 , ! 0( "

#$)%(! / 9 :" % )

0( "

! "

! +

' ( "

#$ ! "

! &'" ) 0

#$ + , ! "

#$ ( ! ! "(

") " ! "

0 "

!! )! "

! &" !"' "( ! "/ ( % ""

, !) "! ) " ) *"

#$! "

! & ( % " ! "

/ ( ! ""

"( ! "/ "

"( ( ! !" ! "

! &' '

2) "

% / ( ! ! 0(

"( ! !"

!" "/ .

CWP No. 3879 of 2019 4 ) B0#""$ 4 7 + , "$ ) ( # ", C',9+ $ !

$ 8 #'++ ("E , "$ ) 447"$9 + $$ ( ( +( !4 ("/ $ ) 0("$!"04 # 4 ", ,7$8/) $#"'"$ $!)%1 :

; $ 44)# !

# #7) ( "$) !?'"#""$0(! ##) ,8 $"$""

, 8') (,) #$8 $ $$'$! ,'$, (# !"$

) ! =5 $ ) , !++ $! + $ ) !

=5 ) ( "# $ 4 0# 0(! ,"$9# $, ) # + 7"44 !$"$' 5)7 6 (57")) (", () ) !+0 $# "$) #8 , (+"$ , '$, ( ) 0(6"#"$# !

44 )# !

# #

7) ( "$) (,'$, (# !"$

) ! =) #8 $

$$'$! , 0("( !++ $! + $ ) !

5 ) 0(6"#"$#) !

7'4,) 6 $8 ("$9( 004"!

$,) 0(! ,"$9#7"44!$"$' "$( #0 !)# ! # #5 #"5 ) ! =) #$8 $( 0 4 , :8; ) 7(,D(A'# ,"$8 7 $) 8)) !$"$9 $!" ## !"$ =:;) !

"#8 ( , #-.( #-.7)"!) + $#) # 34 0#"$9) !?'"#""$0(! ,"$9#8)) !$"$9 $!" # +'# 8 '4"44 , 2 $"$9 ) ( 8/5 ) " ) 0## ##"$) ,8 $ 3 $8') !+0 $# "$7 #$( ! "6 ,5 ) ( 7'4, 8 $ 4 0# &"+"4 (4/5 " !+0 $# "$ ) # 8 $

!! 0 ,8') 0## ##"$) #$8 $ 3 $5) ( 7'4,8 $ 0#"$9#!"

&&#$! 3( $ :!; # ( # ) #0 ! !+0 $# "$ ( ) 4 !?'"( , "# !$! ($ ,5 ) $A84 &'0( + '( $," ) # !

9("!

44/ 8# (6 ,) ) B0( ##"$0 ","$) + "$0 (# !"$=:;

CWP No. 3879 of 2019 5 ) !

, #$"$!4', , 0#"!+0 $# "$"$ !'( ) "# ( ?'"( , 8 0(6 , "# ) ) !+0 $# "$

+'$7 # $, ( ,7)"!)) #8 $ B04 "$ ,"$ &) ) $, ("$9 ) +'$ 7'4, + $ ) ) +'$ "# + ,

"4 84 ) 4 $,7$ ( $, ) 7'4, 8 ,"#!) (9 ) 84"9 "$ + 3 ) 0 /+ $ $, "$ ) 6 $ #'!) 0 (#$ !

$$8 0 $ 4"E ,() , '4"$+ 3"$9) 0 /+ $)"4 ( (("$9 # !"$ :

;5 :;5 = ) ! = !+0 ("$9) +7")) 0 + ("

0(6"#"$#" # !"$ ) !

5) $A84 0 B'() #!4 ("" ,) ) $4/!$# ?' $! $$10 /+ $!+0 $# "$"#+ 3 ) /+ $"$ ( # #0 (# !"$=) ! =6 $) $A84 & ) # '() ( !4 ("" , ) $! ) 0 /+ $ !+0 $# "$ ) # 8 $ ( ,@ $, ( , '$, ( # !"$ :

;5 )

!?'"("$9 ')("/ !

$$ 8 0 $ 4"E , ( $$10 /+ $ # )

+'$ ) # ( + "$ '$0 ", ,' ( '# 4 !! 0 8/ ) $,7$ ( !4 ("/ " '() (5 ) $A84 & ) # '() ( 8# (6 , ) " 4 $,7$ ( ) # "4 , ) ( ( $! ( )"9) ( !+0 $# "$) !

$$!4 "+) ) 7 #$0 ",) +'$ :,; )"4 ( ,"$9) 0(6"#& !"$=) !

8 ( # !"$ =:; ) !

5 ) $A84 &'0( + '( ) # !4 ("" , ) "$ !

# 5 ) ( ( 0 /+ $ ) # 8 $ + , 8'$, 0#" ,54"

8"4"/0 / +'$ 4$97")"$ ( # #'8#"# $,"$, 0#" ,(+ C("/)4,"$9#("6 / (# (+( 5!+0 $# "$'$, () !

) #8 0 ",)

CWP No. 3879 of 2019 6 $,7$ (# #$) , $""!

"$(4 !?'"#""$'$, ( # !"$ = ) ! = (,"$9 ) , 0#"5 " ) # 8 $ !4 ("" , "$ ) C',9+ $ ) ( ) )"9) ( !+0 $# "$4475) +$ /#)'4,$) 6 8 $, 0#" , 7") ) > $, !?'"#""$ 44 !( ( "$ ) ( #'(/ ( "$ ) '(7")( #0 !+ C("/4 $,)4,"$9#5+ $"$9) ( 8/" "7 #, 0#" ,"$ $/) )( +, #7")( #0 !+ C("/ )4,"$9#5) )"9) (!+0 $# "$7"44$44758'"$ ( # '$, (# !"$=) ! =7'4,8 ) !$# ?' $! : ; # ( 9 (,# ) +, 3"$9 0## ##"$5 ) $A84 &'0( + '( ) , !4 ("" , ) ,( 7"$9 "$?' # ( 0(@ + +( $,'+ 7'4,+ $) 0)/#"!

40## ##"$) #8 $ 3 $) 4 77") ( 9 (,6 #"$94 $,) #$! "$8 ( " ( ,)4,) $! ) 0## ##"$) #8 $ 3 $'$, (# !"$ F) !

=5) 4 $,6 #"$) & $,) ( !

$$8 $/,"6 #"$9( 0#"$9 :; )"4 !+0'"$9) 9 00 (","6 / (#8 7 $) ,

(, $, !++ $! + $ ) !

5 $/ "$ ("+ (, ( #'8#"#"$9"#8 B!4', ,7)"!)+ $#) ( B!4',"$9) "$ ("+(, (5) 0( 1( ?'"#" 9 00 (",G/ (#"#$) ( 5 ) 0(6"#"$## !"$=:;!

$$8 "$63 , :9; ) $A84 '( ) # '() ( !4 ("" , ) " ) !?'"#""$ $, ) , (4" ( 8 $ !) 44 $9 , $, ) !?'"#""$ 7 # '0) 4,5 7)"!) + $# ) 0(! ,"$9 #, !$!4', ,5 ) '+8( 44

CWP No. 3879 of 2019 7 0( !"$# !"$=:;) !

$$8 "$63 #" , #$( 6"6 # 4 $,"+ 8 (( ,!4 "+# :); $0 5) $A84 '() #+ , "!4 () ) 0(6"#"$ # !"$=:;) !

"#+ $8 "$63 ,8/) 8 $ "!"

(" #" 4 $,7$ (#7)7 ( ( !(, ,# ) "+ "##'

$! $""!

"$ '$, ( # !"$ = ) ! = $/ #'8# ?' $0'(!) # (5 )4, (() (7"# 5!

$$"$63 ) 0(6"#"$## !"$=:;) !

= # 0 ( ) !

# 0' () 8/ ) 0 ""$ (#5 ) / ( 7$ (# "$ 0## ##"$) 4 $,+ #'("$9"9) G"#7 !+0("# ,"$3) 7

G 5*) #( $F@@:1 G;#"'

,"$."44 9

" $# (5 )#"4

$,"#("!

$"0 ') ( # ",4 $,5) 4 $,+ #'("$9 "9) = "#7 "# # , ) 6 8 $ !?'"( , 8/ ) & (/ $ 6", $""!

"$# , , $, "##' , '$, ( # !"$ = # !"$ F ) > $, !?'"#""$ !5 =5 447 , 8/ (, , , () 0'84"!0'(0# $ + 4/5(, 6 40+ $ $,'"4"E "$ # #", $"

4 $,++ (!"

4& !( 1

$"0 "#) !

# ) 0 ""$ (# ) , #0" ) 6"$9 !?'"( , ) 4 $, "$ ?' #"$5 ) & ) # "4 , 3 0## ##"$) 4 $,"44, ) / ( "$ !'

40)/#"!

4 0## ##"$ ) 4 $, "$ ?' #"$ '() ( " ) # 8 $ !$ $, , ) ) 0 ""$ (#) 6 $( ! "6 ,!+0 $# "$ +'$ $,)'#5 ) !?'"#""$ 0(! ,"$9#) 6 4 0# ,"$6" 7& !"$=:;) !

#8) ) !$"$9 $!" #0( #!("8 ,"$# !"$=:;!

( '4"44 , G ( !$( 2( $3'( 2"

45 4 ($ , ,,""$ 4 ,6!

$ ( 4 (/ $ ("$9 ( ) & (/ $ #'8+"# ) )

CWP No. 3879 of 2019 8 !$ $"$) 0 ""$ (#8 "$9"$) 0## ##"$) 4 $,"$?' #"$ "#, 6",+ (" #) 0## ##"$) 4 $,7 # 3 $8/( !(,"$9

E$ +!) $G , , $, # + 7 # ) $, , 6 ( ) 8 $ "!"

(/ , 0 (+ $ ) +'

"$ = , , G

) # 4# 8 $# $!"$ ,"$ 6'() 8 $ "!"

(/, 0 (+ $ '() (5) !$ $,# ) ) !+0 $# "$(4 $,"$?' #"$7 #,'4/ $, ( ," 57 #+ ,

"4 84 ) 0 ""$ (#H)7 6 () /) 6 !)# $$( ! "6 ) # + $(, (#'8# $"

) # + 5) ( 4"

$! ) #8 $04 ! ,$) !) ) + C("/ !+0 $# "$ ) # 4( ,/ 8 $ ,"#8'(# ,) 4 $,7$ (# ) ( ( 5 " "# #'8+" , ) #"$! $$ ) !$"$9 $!" # + $"$ , "$ & !"$=:;) !

( '4"44 , #0## ##"$) 4 $,# $,# ,'4/ 3 $ $, ) 84"9 "$ ) & 0 / ) !+0 $# "$ # $,# ,"#!) (9 , 7") ) $, (@0 /+ $ !+0 $# "$H ) 0( # $ 0 ""$ + ("#,"#+"## 4 '() () ) # 3 $) 8C !"$$) + "$ "$ 8"4"/ ) "$# $ 0 ""$ 8/ 04 !"$9 ( 4"

$! $ 0 G $,( 6 40+ $ ')("/ :&'0( ; 7) ( "$ ) $A84 &'0( + '( $," ) # !

9("!

44/) 4,) !

# #7) ( "$) 4 $,7$ (:#;) #4#"$) (4" ( ('$,4""9 "$5& !"$=:; !

$$ 8 "$63 , ) "( "$# $! # ( #!

# ) $,"#!$! ($ ,5) 0 ""$ (#) ,!) 44 $9 ,)

!?'"#""$0(! ,"$9#8/"4"$9"6"4(" ""$= 7) ( "$ )"#!'() ,"(#4/# / ,) ,"#0## ##"$) 0 ""$ (# $,) ( ( ,"#+"## ,) 7("0 ""$6", (, (, , F

=7)"!)"+04" #) )

!?'"#""$0(! ,"$9#7 ( '0) 4,) ( () 0 ""$ ( 00( !) ,)"# '(8/"4"$9 $) (7("0 ""$8 ("$9"6"4(" ""$ G=

(, + (!

"$) 4 $,+ #'("$9="#7 #7)"!)7 #4 '(+

CWP No. 3879 of 2019 9 ) !?'"#""$ 0(! ,"$9# '$, ( # !"$ G1 ! =5 7)"!) 7 #

!!(,"$94/, + (!

, $,) # ",0 ""$7 # 4#,"#0# ,2(2"

4 ) # !$ $, , ) "$ 6" 7 ) ( + $"$ , !# ) !?'"#""$ 0(! ,"$9#) #

"$ ,"$ 4"/( 44"$ $# $,0'(0# # $,4 !?'"( , ) #6 # ,"$) & ( (+ 44 $!'+8( $! # F () 6"$90 ('# ,) 04 ,"$9#8)) !$ #"$90 (" #

$, ( !(,"$9 ) "( !$ $"$#5 7 ) 6 $ ) #"

"$ !$!4', ) ) + ( ) $,"##?'

( 4/!6 ( ,8/) 0("$!"04 #4 ",,7$8/) $A84 &'0( + '($,"

"$) !

# $,( 6 40+ $')("/:#'0( ;

$,) 0( / () 0 ""$ (#!4 "+"$94 0#"$9 !?'"#""$0(! ,"$9# , # (6 #,"#+"## 4"$6" 7) 447"$9( #$#%1

; )'9) ) 0 ""$ (# ) 6 !$ $, , ) ) / ( "$ !'

4 0)/#"!

4 0## ##"$ ) 4 $, "$ ?' #"$5 )7 6 (5 ) # ",

6 (+ $"#$ $ 84 "$6" 7) "$ (0( "$D

A + , 8/ ) $A84 0 B '( "$ $,( 6 40+ $ ')("/ :&'0( ; 7) ( "$ ) $A84 '( ) # !

9("!

44/ ) 4, ) ) 7(, 0## ##"$ '# , "$ ) !

= ) # # + + $"$9 # ) 0)/#"!

4 0## ##"$ '# , "$ & !"$ = :; !

) $ ) & 6 ($+ $

!?'"( # ) 4 $, ,( 7# + +( $,'+ 3"$90## ##"$ 7)"!)"$) 0( # $!

# "#8/( !(,"$9

E$ +!) $ G , , 0'(#'

$ 7)"!) 2'

"$ $ = , , G

7 # # $!"$ , "$ 6'( ) 8 $ "!"

(/ , 0 (+ $ ) 0 $!)$ + 7 # ,( 7$ 0("( ) (, ( ,"#0## ##"$ 7 # 0 ## , 8/ )"# '(5 ) ( ( 5 0)/#"!

CWP No. 3879 of 2019 10 0## ##"$ ) 4 $, # $,# 3 $ $, $! ) 0## ##"$ "#

3 $5) ( "# 8#4' 6 #"$9) 4 $,"$) & ) ( ( 6 $") 4 $,7$ (( "$#) 0## ##"$) 4 $,5) "# ( #0 ## (5 $,#'!)0## ##"$( #0 ## ( $'( #()"#8 $ "

$,$8 ) 4) 7$ (" & &"$! 0## ##"$) #8 $

3 $8/( !(,"$9

E$ +!) $G, , 5 ) 04 ) 0 ""$ (#) ) / ( "$0)/#"!

40## ##"$ ) 4 $, "# )'#5 ) ( 8/ ( C ! , 44 0## ##"$ ) # 8 $ "$ ,8/) +5""#$4/ #( #0 ## (# $,$ #7$ (## !$# ?' $! 5) ( $ ) ## $"

4#(!4 "+"$94 0#"$9

!?'"#""$0(! ,"$9#9 # 8; # ( # #0 !!+0 $# "$"#!$! ($ ,5""##0 !""!# ) ( #0$, $# ) ) !+0 $# "$ +'$ 7 # ,'4/ $, ( , $,7 #+ , "4 84 ) 4 $,7$ (#"$!4',"$9) 0 ""$ (#$(, (#'8# $"

# + ( ( $! ) #8 $+ , ) ! ) ' 4 !+0 $# "$ +'$ #

F5G55=@15 $ +'$ # 5==5G5F @1" + C("/ ) !+0 $# "$ ) # 8 $ ,"#8'(# , )"# ! "# #'"!" $ #)7 ) ) !+0 $# "$ 7 # ,'4/ $, ( ,5 $, ) 0 ""$ (#) 6 ) +# 46 #!)# $$( ! "6 ) # + 57)"!) ) / ( 4"8 (/ ( ! "6 $! " "# #5 ) # !$, !$"$9 $!/0( #!("8 ,"$# !"$=:;!

4#9 #

$,)'#5 #$$ ) !$"$9 $!" #0( #!("8 ,"$# !"$=:; !

"# '4"44 ,5 ) , +"$9 "!"$ 4 0#"$9 0(6", ,'$, (# !"$=:;!

$$8 "$63 ,

CWP No. 3879 of 2019 11 &"$! $$ ) !$"$9 $!" #+ $"$ ,"$# !"$=:;!

"#'4"44 , #0## ##"$) 4 $,# $,# 3 $ $,) !+0 $# "$ # $,# ,'4/ $, ( ,5 ) ( ( 5 $ , !4 "$ # ( 9 (,# 4 0#"$9 !?'"#""$ 0(! ,"$9# !

$ 8 + , "$ ) !

# ) $, !; 6 $) (7"# 57 ( "$!+04 9( + $7")2(2"

4 ) ) "$# $0 ""$"#$+ "$ "$ 84 ) "$# $! ) 0( # $0 ""$ (# #) /) 6 4( ,/4# (4" (!) 44 $9 ) !?'"#""$ 0(! ,"$9# + , 8/ "4"$9 =

7)"!)7 #,"#+"## ,6", (, (, ,= 4#5= "9) 4 $, # $,# 4( ,/ ( 4 # , (+ ) !?'"#""$ 0(! ,"$9#'$, (# !"$G1! =57)"!) 4## $,# , + (!

, )'#5 ( 44 "$ $# $, 0'(0# # ) !?'"#""$ 0(! ,"$9## $,#!$!4', , $,# + !

$$8 ( 0 $ ,'$, ( ) 9'"# # !"$=:;!

2( $3'( 2"

4 $ ) #( $9) ) !# 04 , , "$ ) 7(" $# + $) #6 ) + $4/!$ $, ,) ) & !?'"( ,) 4 $,( ) 0'84"! 0'(0# 0'84"! 0'(0# ( '"4"E "$ 4 $, ( #", $"

4 ++ (!"

4& !( 1

$"0 ) 4 $,"$?' #"$"#6 (/+'!) ## $"

4 !)" 6 ) 0'84"!0'(0# $," !#) 04 $$"$904 $$"$9+ (4 !

9(/045

+ (4 !

9(/04 +(7", ( , #0 () 4 /' $ ) 6 !$#", ( ,)"#0 ( (9'+ $( "# ,8/) ( #0$, $# 7 ( "$!+04 9( + $7")) # + #)"#"# $"+0( $ !(8 3 0"$+"$,7)"4 , 4"$97")) !

# ("#"$9') !?'"#""$4 !)" 6 ) 0'84"!0'(0# $,""#) # @"# ')("/7)"#"$) 8 #

CWP No. 3879 of 2019 12 0#""$, !", 8''"4"E "$) 4 !?'"( ,5 (") 6"$98 $ 6 # ,"$& # # ?' 4) 86 ,"#!'##"$ $,"$6" 74 7#'++ ("E , "$0 F$,( 6 40+ $')("/:#'0( ;5#0 !""!

44/ () 6"$9 ( !(, , ) "$ ) !

# "$ ) $,5 ) 0)/#"!

4 0## ##"$ ) 4 $, "$ ?' #"$) 6"$98 $ 3 $5) 84"9 "$(0 /+ $!+0 $# "$# $,# ,"#!) (9 ,5 (4" (!) 44 $9 !?'"#""$$+ ("#) 6"$98 $4# 4# !$#", ("$9 ) ) 4 $, "$ ?' #"$ "# 6 (/ +'!) ## $"

4 !)" 6 ) 0'84"!0'(0# 57 ) 6 $) #"

"$)4,) "$) "$# $!

# 5) # ) # '44/ ,"#!) (9 , "# 84"9 "$ ?'

8) ) !$"$9 $!" # !!'(("$9 "$ # !"$=:;

! $,"8 "$9#5) 0( # $0 ""$+ ("#,"#+"## 4

$,) $! 5) "$# $0 ""$"#,"#+"## , 6"$9,"#+"## ,) + "$7("0 ""$5 440 $,"$9 004"!

"$#5 " $/ 4#+ ) # + ) 7("0 ""$"#,"#+"## ,& '#?'5"

$/5# $,#6 !

, : .&* ; & :

>>;

6"$, ( ) ) (#0 3"$9@( #$ , #@ ) ) (( 0( 84 #@