Sant Ram & ORS v. Commissioner Gurgaon & ORS






    
   


   

    

    





 


 

    

      ! " 


 #

  ! " 
# ! 

          
! " !#  $ %    " #   &

''''



 #

"

)   #        #    *     #   +##,$& # ) *!- # & (.+/ , 01 # 2#!   #

3  3   # ! 4  &

.

(.(! -(4 #(5# ) *#  3  3#!-  $!   ##-)  3 %3 # !6 - #  3  

 # *!  -       # !    7 ##
!  3 *!  * # -   6  !*(89 )   #! !6 -


# 3  *!   -#  "  0-1) %  ##-+!! / 0
-# 1 (85( 0  9

(1 3 *!:  





    





   

 !"

     !# $ 

  " % %  

 !"

 

   !%!% !!

&!! ' !' !

' '!"

! (! &!"""&)% !

&! '&* '% +

       !    ! ,  !   (   '  (

  !&!-.* 

!'% /#

(  (, 

!&!-.* 

!'% /%'  !'

! ! ,&! ! ! !' &!"  !! "  !!* "

 ! !' ( #$  & !& !! " +

!!( !! 0 " %1 !

&% %  %  1  # !,!( !!&!&&( , ""

'! !!&!&!"" ! &( ,# $ (      ,  , !% !

%"

 ! %  !&! , !'%"" '&!"""& )#

( 

(   " %   !(    (

 ( , & !!,&!

! ( !  " !&!-.* 

!'% /#!

$   ,     &! !&! ! % !(!% "" '&!"""&)#2  %3 # +##  !6 -  #     - ! #   # *#



    7 ##
! * -- *# * - -  -#01*3# #       #!

 #  3    * #  # - )  



    *#  -

 * - #3#   #-#  7 !  - 01 #!

7  ##
! # - # -  #  (89   -  *!    &  #     +##      #  # 3 *#

 * - #3#    #-#  *7 ##
! .    - 7 ##
!    ! ;  *-  # 2#  !6 - 3  

 # *!! -   (9 ( (88 )  #  :<( --   !            #  - * # ## 

)  # *!- #& (.+/ ) # ##   -  3    (( ( (889  #  :<    -3  3 #*  # +##    !6 !#   #01 ) *  # !# --  -    3 * + =     #  *  #  #  3      - 

*  !  #!   # -   # )     ) **#        3 3#    #    - * *  #  *#3    - #   !  # * -    -   #   #3#  7 ##
! . 


* -    -    - 

7 # #
!* -   ! > ,  *-*!    # -*!  # ) # # -    ! 7 ##
!3     #  .*#  7 ##
!3   !  ) # - - ( # - 3 :  

+1 3   !  4   %& !&  &&  ( ,

,!  !  !,5 6+ 5 6+  ! ,78

6+ -99-9"  !,8  ."

!  !,* "

 :/ 

     !(     &  ( ,  1   1+  6 !

  &!"  &!& !+ -+1 4    3   !& !&  && ' !&   &!   &&,"

  ! !  ( , & " !

6+&      !!0 " ;  &  &&!   

("!  /' !   "!   !&  &&0 " ;     && !! &   & <!

"  '

! ! &  +

+1 !&!  "&& <!

"  '

!!,%,   , ! & +1   (! &!

&&( ,""

' "&&!"&0 " =     (  '

 
  ) !  8,!! !(& "  "

 "&  '

   &&    ! "&<!

"  '

 ! !,  

! !

  ,  &&+2 # 3 ! # -  #  01# - (    3    ! )        - (  01 *! !*   3 -  <   #  3 ! #-   # #   


 #   --   # 3    !  7 ##
!3   #  #-  3 ! *!   -  # #    #!    *7 ##
!3   #  )    *3  ! 7 ##
!3   !  *#

*#    7 ##
!3  #3#   #  ( %3     *  !    !   !##

#6 -  )    #  * !*

*  #  *#3  3      # * - #3#  7 ##
! * !#  # !   7  ##
!3 !    3  !     * -*  #  -  7 ##
!  !  ! * # ##  *6 -    - # #!#

3 -  ?*!##   (( ) **   *#3  -    *  -               3   3  !##

--     7   #  # 
!  3       :       #3# # -   #    # -# -     # (89 )   *  -#  #    #  -#01*  ? #?#  #  :  #3##  # -  7 ##
!    *!    !  !         '

  ;       


  ! 7 ##
!   *!3 #- #    #   !




, ?# # #* 3    # * #  :  # -        7 ##
!

! 

( ) !- #   :<(<

 <   !-   # ! 3##    !  *      3 !  )     ##3  !-  01?  * # 3  ** 

& $

 #

%   &'"&'"(&('

$# ! 

%
)*+,-*   
*,)*,.-/,012345.,0-63,7 ,-56 *,)*,..,/6.)08+, ,-56