Sher Singh v. State Of Haryana And Another
2
IN TH HE HIGH COURT FOR THE E STATES OF PUNJAB AND HANDIGARH HARYANA AT CH $$% &'
,
- .
* / / $ '(
$$%
)
*+* *
*1-
"
!"
" ! . .')#( & Mr. Neeraj Poswal, AAG, Ha aryana. !#
%!'#% #& 5 5
'%'&%
## 0 # #& 56 7#8 6 7
'& 9%9":"
!!& &'( !
!# ' ! !
#
$ # %
! $ &
" ' '
## % & " ' ;# < # '' %(# + #$ $ "#1)
2//
'' & )&#"*
)! + " = (## "' #"(" & & ## #!
",
0 # #"
" , 3 4 $( $ # "
%'
& # #'#"
(# "! " -
$
! & "
' #" # # ' ""#
& " ' )! ! ( &# $ $ # > > & ! ( $ + # (
# $ '# '& %'
> #&'
# )"
" # #&# " $
&&#> > !$
$( '( (#&%&" #( # !!&
!!
#& &&#$ " $
$ $ # % # #
# %&& # # ##
("
3 2 % " $ "# & # $ #
> #"#
( '(" %+&&"# & (#"
5 3 4 ' # &'
# "
, ? $ ( < "' & #( $ "
? $( & :
'
)!& "
' !&(
#'!
"'& '' $ # 9 # ' '
$ & && # !& '!
!
# !! & % !'# % ## # & ' # %!''" '&# & 4 "# &!& '' "
"
4 % "# & % #&'
" !!# % !
# & && # $ & #"%' (#& "
$
'$ !!&
! > 4 $ !
"
!!&' # &
3
&&#> > "
% !# %&& && !"' ""% % & ( ! )/. 9# # ! &&# ##"
3 $!& '#
"
&& # # )" $
" $ ( '' $ # $'# '&%'
( & %& "
'##& '' %!'# # 9 &' !''' " & #&
!' $
'# %(# % & & #"
4& # #( %''
$#
'# ) )#( & :' 4
# '' 4'
$ $ &&# # # & # & " ' $ "
! "
& (
!"
5 3 $
& $ &# !&" $ !!&#! " "
' & ( '(# "'& ' # # ! '# # %' & %& # #'"'
!!& !
# '%' %#"# , ( #'#& '!
& #%'' # ( ' "' '
'&# & #&!'' ) '' & " ' $ #&# +
- !
!# (" & 2 # @ $& (&# $
"
, 3 3 % ( $% ' 4 $( ' # ' $ "
"# &( # $ "
(# ! " - - " !
/
#
# !&# #&'
" ! !
&&# #$ '' # # %!
% && # # ( "
3 %A '& ( !"
5 3 %!!&# '' A 4 %( '(#'
'
$ &
&&## & ##"
@ !%' " (
" &$ '&( !!
'# # '# & &( ' & "" ! % %+& &" 4 ( '(# "
&
!"' @ # % '# & ' ! @## %! ! %' "
"%& # #'"'
' !!&&' % # %!
# ## < ($ !
#!&#&&"& ' %# &"' &## #!& # &&" & &" &
##
# # #( % '# %'
' 4& #"#
"#&' % ( "# % (
' !#&# # " '' ( % " & % (MANISHA BATRA) JUDGE / / $$%
Whet ther speaking/reasoned Yes/No Whet ther reportable Yes/No