← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/384/2019allowed

Shashi Sharma And Others v. State Of Haryana And Others

2024-02-15Mr. Justice Sanjeev Prakash Sharma,Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma9 pages

LPA No. 384 of 2019 2024:PHHC:022187-DB -1- 

        

   

 

  !  

    !"  

     " #  $$%

&$$    # $ $$  $  #  $ % & '  (" $ $ $ # "'$ )# "'$ ! *+  $ , -# ' '

  $ !# '   % '!"  $  .

$,'  (" $  - +' '     /        0"+"1# 

'

 , 

   3   ("  -* - +("+  &4#3 5    6   7+ + -( +   ("!" - 8

2  (  +  +   9+  +   :;  '+ (

    +  7 

       +   (  &  ( - &4# 3  5     + + +   6       ; -   &4#3 2858

<          

  +      !*7

=>&

7 -

LPA No. 384 of 2019 2024:PHHC:022187-DB -2- * -     +     ?        +  - 1#  

9= > ; - (  (" &  76    &4#3 5  ("   -* -+ - 1# 3 22 2<" 

   #  $  $!

 %!          1#  3  22   2 <       01# +++ +("+ 

 

 7+

 +(" $ - - & = > ( -   3  6      7  + ++ 

  1#=&>3 2  +- + 71#+ ("  &  5

 7 

'+

 +(" !" ( - 3   ++-- -+ 3 65   7 3 65 + ("  - * - (+ 7   3     &4#3 5   ( -   ; -   1      

         

  3    &4#3 5  + '    "  3 65  &4#3  88   #    !  ---(" '   1#( & "( - 1#=&>3 6    

LPA No. 384 of 2019 2024:PHHC:022187-DB -3- +  2

  +  "   -  &4#3 5  +(" &  @ 

' 1#+++ +(""1 # 

 7  +-     +,   1#      7'    1#  +  ("  

  

     +-  - ("& 

1      

     (      !" + - "+   &  1# ("$ - -& 

 7+  -  ++ -"  +

   &4# 3 5  + ; -  ?  ++  +

      ; -    & 4 #  3  52    ! &          8

2  7 '  +     (+        +  

 (   -0   -0  -   9+ 

             + +        +  - 7 '+; -   ( AB +("  !  (  +  -      ,   (    +   +     (  1             (   +     9 -( ++    -  ' (     !" -- , -+   

LPA No. 384 of 2019 2024:PHHC:022187-DB -4-

 

 ("  -0 6   !   (

 + +, -- - A A  4  ( 

4, -     '&  +           -  + +  C   ( ;  ("      - 0     (    ( ( ?++   ( (( - , -++ -(+ 

  !+'   

       

     (  ((++ -+    +

 ("!" +-    "(" !-& 

7 &       +    ("    !" +( ? '(  8 " 0" (( -++  'C  - - +   +("  -0   7&   ( -+  '1#  (   ("  $ - - &  +  ("    !"   - -     

  01#  ++(" 

 +     ("    0 '  + 

  +  ("  $ - -& + 1#+-   (    & ' + +    

  7  '!"   "+

   1#(" & '+

 +

LPA No. 384 of 2019 2024:PHHC:022187-DB -5-  ?    !

=8>&&2 '1- 0     &  + D  -    @6   &#&   A   

               

   !"  ## #    !"     

#

     ##  $       #    %  

   # &

' #

   %         

   #

   

  (  

       $   &

 '     #' &

'    

% 



##

  #  &

' #

    '   )* + ,  



 

   ' 

 

#   -      *.

/ 

   

 #   #      

$

  '    

 

     

!

"0

    '   % !

"      % !

" *(

%  !

"

 

# 

 '  

    1 0 #   2    #

    ## $  (  34#% $( !

"  $  %  !

"     

 # %!

"  #  



  #  %!

" 

 #      $    $' %!

" 5   $#     $ '        

  

$ #4    $4# #$$  '   # 

#  *  %

LPA No. 384 of 2019 2024:PHHC:022187-DB -6-  %  $ 6$        ##  #$ ##     

          $   #    '  $##$        #   #$2   ##

#  $$   

$# 4* #% %  ## #$-$ %       $*#2       

         $  #'    ## #

   #   7        %$       #

   #   $ -   #       0

  '      

   8     4

  

 (  

 

 $       ''  $   $ #

 



# 4

    #

$(  

 &

' !

#

#

$   

        ''   

 "  $

   4

          #

    ##  # #  # #6(  #

  #  2 $(  

   %          (    #    #

    

         4

  

 (  

  4 ,(    #2  %  %      

 $   ' (  #  #

     (  #$   ###    $

 

  ##(  

   ' &     ##$/        $   '        ##

  $0

  '   

 $ '   4#  (

 !4#$$  $ #

 "  #         2  $  (  

 $  %    $4#$

LPA No. 384 of 2019 2024:PHHC:022187-DB -7- #   



 # 

2$  '    #           

  (

 

#           '  &   

 $    9 2

-   1- 0      &  + D  -    ("+     #!!'()&)

  * '+     ) & &&

& ' !!! ( ',+- %   ', =>&&268'+  -      -  -   .= >    +    .= > -  A :;: ,       

)!< $ :===!;"''>1"''+ ?!

"0  #

 ##$* #2 #2 -        0  #

 ##       #        0    '    4

      ##   !

" -         ##   #2  %

%

    %   #

 3 $%    

        $   # ' 

     0

  '    $%    %       $ # ' 

      #     

 %    $ $#   5 $

$(

 

# % #'  0#4'    $/ %  $ 

 %    $      # '  (    #

   #     

LPA No. 384 of 2019 2024:PHHC:022187-DB -8-  #'  $  (



 5 #   #  !

"     ##     ## (  

  #'  2#  ##           @   $    % 

 $   !

" ##

##  2     ## 

      ##   # '   (  

   &

'      

 #       #

 $  *  ! "     ''9 :;

          < $     % 

2$   

#  

   #

 #       #

 #  

        #< $ 9  7 '+  ("!"  1# +   A$ - -&+ ((   (  ! -'& ''     -  ("& + -  &4#3 5   (   ( D  +  7   &4#3 5   ; -     6   +     -      +   "--+ -  - ; -  8

 -"'  

  3     &4#3 5  C   ?+

 (-  ( ( " 

LPA No. 384 of 2019 2024:PHHC:022187-DB -9- ("  0  +  7C    (;  6

&   

'   ("& ((  5 7

+ -"

  -

   

3        

$%

&$$ !             ''       $  $ ! %$           4 , -B  EB3 4 ( EB3