← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/7874/2024allowed

Dharmendra Singh Alias Dharmendra Singh Sandhu v. State Of Punjab

2024-03-20Mr. Justice Jasjit Singh Bedi13 pages





    

 !"#$%$ &'()( 

 

     

    '

 *+ ( ,,, 

   

!"

  # 

 !"    

 $% &



' 

 $  

!"   "  ((((( ,,- ( .

/

       

 !  "

#$##

%   &

% & ' ('

    !  )*

+ #  # # 

 ! 

 ,-  - ,.- ,- ,- -    / *$ &   $ '!   $ 0(  1- 2 ! +&- 2 ! 1 4&#

#  (% %!

%  !     !

1'   ##  5

(1

 6 && &! 5! 



 7  

    

             

    

  !  "   #   $%  %   %&'

(  !   )  * !&(' 

    !* !

&      !  "

+  !*  !

&  ,,-

./0/) !

!*1  !$& '!* , .

2/3334 % !*  !

!*6 , 3//) 3+!&#+!* 5 *(!*,

/.3)   %7



7 +!

8

'8 &9:

!!&#+!* + ;

<!* *1,  .002 

& 

 

 ** &** (

* 5 & 1& =>

 $ "

1*

*

?& ** *-51656  5 & &* !* & ?&   !&#+!*( ** * &    -51  56         

  %7 7   

  %7  7    +*  , @)

5;

..2%7

0))   +*    *    A    

   (  <  !

      5

  ;

& '

 ,   %77  &*1 !&#+  !*  ,  ,

/.3)   <  ?&    & ! 2/ 

 

(5- ;

& &( 0

.

1!&#+!*,/.3)   *  , )3  ?&   7 

<! &* & B $ 4

 = %+7 

+  +*)  *



%77     %7 :



 (<  

 < (*  &   & & *

&( 5-;

&   #  %7  

 &( *( 

   &     +



# <  ( +   

 

!*!

&,,  ./0/) !

!*1 ,  .

2/333    4   %   !*     ,

//) 3  +  !&#+  !*  , 

/.3)   * +  %7  

( +    & <

  



<  & :

  

  (



&

& #

& 

& >

 $ 1*  (

  

  *   &     

    (  &  #

&  + #



+  

*  %7< & +  >

 $ 1*

?& 

+  *+ 

 + &&   

&   +



< &  &  < '&       +  +  <

 *=>

 $ 1* &( 

  (&!

  

<6?&     ?& * +*   *  +  >

  *  *  (

  ( /  

 

 (

*  *



(

(*+*   <  ,  <*  

 

 *0   D?& & D  &  + &  $  1* $1 (

 

2  1& >

 $ 1* * 

 <5-;

&  * +  ( , =>  $ "

 *

 (<  + 

;

&

1& <5-)  

 %77    *+ 

 + & 5

 >

  *

(

  ?&  

 ( *

C

+  *     

     6& 

    

5

 2) 



+ & 5

&

  

2)

 

+ & 5

 

>

 * (  *

 (

?& ?& ( 

 (   *    2) /      

C 

+    &       *    

   (&

 

3 

 & ?& <  +(  

 *>

 * ( 

* & < + + *



.   ( +   ( *      

      &    <  & &  *-51, 56 



 

(*  *-51 , 56 &* * & 1!&#+!* # <* !&#+!*<    *'



 ?&   

&

2/         

 

             &( 5-;

&  %77   &*  1  !&#+  !*  ,  ,  

/ 3)   < ?&  &! 2/ 



5-;

& &( 0

.



!&#+!*,/.3)   , )3



    2/

 ?&  

 1!&#+!*  +            

&      &    * * & -51, 56    

     *          *    &* <    +





&

 &       & <   ( +     *    

   &   <        

            6      &        

( +    !&#+  !*     *    ;

    

&  >7 &      + &       

       ?&   & 2/



  < 5-&* * & ?&   !&#+ !*    ( (  &&

)





  $ 4

 = %+ 7

+ 

<) C!  %77 *( +  & * ( 

*:>

 * (  *

 & (+ & * (  * :

>

 *  *

 



(, & D, < +&

.

 

& *>

  * * 

& +   &  *< +  &*



 &  *< ?& 

+ 

     & 

 **   



&(  

<    & *

  71!&#+!*< ?&  

  &! 2/

 

(5- ;

& 0

.   0

<  ! )3

&  &

&%77  < &(*  ?&  

 &* &*    <



! 1!&#+!*< ((  

;

&  

2      &  '&   &   &    *+(1!&#+!*<* **   56 < < *    * <      ?&    

    

  

 &

&    &    ?&  

  &

 *     56   *    *      

< & &*  * '&   # 

 &*

  

 &  (( &*   

 < ?& =$1

( 

C

+ &!

  

 

& & =$1+ 

 6  <   ( *&

* ( + & +(

& (        

+  & # 

    <        (&

 

  &

&

#*

 /   &  

=$1 ( &* ( + *

     

  %7  7    <+    &

*+      *<  ( *&                +    

,



    

    & 

    &    &  *   

   

+ +* # &(  * &(         + *  <   < *     &  (    &    *  

   

   & ( (& # < 

56  (

 ?&&    56   0       ( +       

+   <  

        +   <  



 +

  & 

 

%77 (

* <

 (

 * 

  

    (  *    (

*

&  & >

 *  *

&( *

# <*<

5-;

&<& & 

&< * & *  +  

 < * & 

 

* &( 

+

 ' B*

  + (  && * 

  (   *    > 

 *   

&     (    *    

&   <    5-   +

 + +

 & (&    2)  //)    //3     

     < '&  &  75-5 '

 ;

&

2  &* 

 # < 

    & <

   & <  

& :

  

  (  

 &     

   *  

      

    + & 

   & 



<   &  ( 

(" 7  

  

+* * *    *  

&+  :

 4 (!&  & (& 

2

  

 , 

0

 E!&(



" 

 F !=" )& (?&  &       #     

    ( +

  # <*

#* *

&  *

( 5-<& &   

 +* <  & 

 & * ( (*   



%77    5-:1

    &&* 

  ( *( #

& 

%7:



    * 

 &+  4 D(!&  & 

2

 , 

0

 D!&( " 

 F!=" 3   

&       4 D(  !&    &     +    0 )

 

   :

:

*:* & :







:

 :     <%7 



 *:& < & 



  <+ 



 

  + +        *+  (   4 D( !&  &        

  <  .     *    &       &  &  

+!="<                ) )

3      

 %7<   

+ (    

+ (       (   & 

*  <&  (&(  !=""  

 & ( 

 &



<



  (

1 !&#+!* & ( <

  *       (

%7  **  

    (

(&*! 1  

 + # &   56  + & ( *&(

 &   

<

            *   

       





   (

  (  * *  * & 1!&#+!*  

+ 

+ * 

+ ( 

+ ( 

 %7 &*    * & 

 

G%7:$ &

 <&&* < "

  ( 

 *               

*     &       *  <       +(

   <

   

* 

  G     *+    #   

        < &  **    & &  <    &    "

      *  <   & & %7 &+ 

( + 

     ( +6      ( (   & +  + 

 

 & (  &     2)  //)    //0    

  -5156  <5- ( (& # ( &+  ( 

       *       (   

   ( &      

6     * < 

 (<

     <(

 *    :      

      + !

 

&          ( 

  

       *   (  ?&  

! 2/

 

 



   (* 

 (    + 

 

/9   & <

  <    

  

          

     +  +

 



*& * 

'

  

(  + :

&



  <    *  < *   &    

 +            

   #*   &

"

F5=,=5!= 41 (, .20

./ ) $ 4

 = %+7 +** 3 6 : !+ ' = + 6

) * 



H*



  %77I )     "   * +  %    "   ,- "   

  "  ./0 .1/ .02 .03 .04 .35 64.  51/7) -8 6    ""

    !

    

"  53691: 88       ""    ! ;"   7 <

'

!* , !* 66 <

'8 &<  !&#+!*  <



 66 <    

&8

'8 &J  

'!* & <

6 6 <  8

'  8 &           

 <  (  # & *(

6 6 <8

'8 &  

   * & <

 !

!*1  %7

 &    +

 > 

( *  I .

   ,-     "  53691: 88   !  "

 

     ""  7 - 

    =>  -   $   1* =-$1  6  %7

<  < (  

D* K 

 (

<!

   5

;

&5 '

 < 

* & <  < ( ( 6 

%7



* < 4  !*  !

!*1    !*!

&<

  <

9 >

  &*  +*   <   +  (   < 

 

 *

*

%77 ;

&5 '

  ++   &  * <   

  *+&  56 

   < < * *( !&#+!* %7< <  ;

& '

   8

'8 &<:

!&#+!*<  <

  =-$1<   +;

&   !

!*1  + < 

&

  &&

    1:%77 &  +  & 



<

D  > 



> *&< D(;& 5517  

?&  

 %7 <  ( 

& !

!*1          &      & 

  :  <

<:   + %7  

&  

'

  !*  <       66 < 

!&#+!* < 66 <:

66 <



** #=-$1  ** #

&   <         >  

  

+& :

 +* 

<%7 9           

'

  !* 

&> 

 

2 =  "     "    

  

  9 "  

!

   6/551/16   8 72060171/16 ; 75/:        "

    "   9

 :

 " !"  $% 

  9 "  

!

   54/51/1.   8 706.0071/16:    

 

  %!

     >     &   /5/51/11  



   + 

  9 :



   $ + 

  

      "   "7""      + & 

   

   $% 

      ""   

        

 ""         7    "+  " /2/?1/16    .0 " 

   ;      "     +  8 

 0 =  "        "      

   "7"" "   "  *    "        ""   

 $ ! ""   "7""  + & 

  



   $% 

      ""   

+   8 !

   11551/16 9 ; 7?: 6/551/16 ; 75/:  54/51/1. 9 ; 755: $   ""        7    "+  " /2/?1/16      .0 "     ;    3 =  "   "      "   

          "7""         

 - " 

            "    "   

 

 4 - !    "     ? =  8   "      

    

 !!"#$%%!

"$"&'()*%&$+"$""     7 <    (

   #*  &('       &    !  

 



+ +*    %    !       

   (  ( *       +*    

    :

     

(  &(>    &4 <+ < & + & 

* *( + 



 +*  

 <  I 5/

   "  "                 "  "       "    = !"

+     

  

 +   "     "   =    +       7    "+  " /2/?1/16     .0 "   !  ;    =  =

   "  

% +   ""

 +   = "7 ""      + & 

   

  $% 

  !  +    ""   

+   8 !

  ; 7?  755 " ! + ,        ; +        "   "    !

"   "   "     ""   

 -        

""    *     "     + 

 55 =  "        "      

      + 

 

         

   "    = 8+

 "" 51 =   

     +  !+    

"   "" 

 ""

       



  !

 "       ! !  + ""       56 - +  !   +       

+    ""   +       """  "  

 

+  !  

"   ""

   

 !

    5. -      9+     : 

  ,     2 // ///7        =

8 =    

         "   "      =

  "

 " ,,

   .#0- % @ %    AB @   AB