High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/685/2014allowed

Binder @ Balwinder Singh v. State Of Punjab

2023-02-10Mr. Justice Vikram Aggarwal20 pages

!"!#"$%&!"'

(

)'* +)(,-).+ ///

!"# $%

& '

& ( ()*+( (,-. % /!"#

& ( (0*-+( (,-0 %

1 !"#

& ( (.0*( (,-0 !23"# 1

! ( /// ,-).+ 0 4

# " #

# #"# .-,-0! 3 5!

" #

#"# #0-)6& #" !

# -.

!---7( #! #! -, #

##(

! ((

((

$ 8'%

!((

$ 8'

, 9-:-:,--! %

16!& !

3#3=: 6#

2 3=*

" ! 5#

6 ! %

; +3 #4# #/ !

;3(

5 "

(

! > +()## !

?"3 #/ < "! .(+ #!

5 4 ##

3 %

3 ((

9-)-:,--! %

5 # #/< ((

!((

((

6 %

" #

#/ # #/ 3 < /

< "!3 "!

" %

#/"

-:-:,-- # % # <

" ## "(

" ## #/

; 0 9 %

!@6

" #

# %

! "!A--:,--

##3 9# " !

#:0&&

# . 4 # A

## A

# + ##

#"# #

) "3#

" : 6 " # #!

& * % # "#

& " 3#"#

#0-)6& 6

# #

" #-: 0-)6&6 #

# #/

#-)-:,--

#-:-:,-- !!# #

# %

% # " A

3# "# ##

B 6 ##

# > B-C " " % # "# ">

#6 # "# %

B+C !!# "A

## #!

3 #

?A=*76 # "A=,2

1! ! 2 @# #! 16?

/ 3 %

# - 6

# %

# / # "3 " 6 # %

,--+ #

! # %

2=0

!& /!

35 3!,--+ %

+ # "

! %

! 3 A %

# # 6

& 3# 3" 2=

=0 /

#(A

# "

# % # "

3=+

! ## "

# % # "

!! >

3 3 , 6#! #

# # <8 &

" # " $ %# &! %%

' !! " # " $ %# (D & ) $

+ "# " $ %# ,(D

) $ *

+ ( "# " $ %# ,,(D % *

- ( " # " $ %# (&D

+ "# " $ %# ,!

- .

% /+%

"# " $ %# !D

<& 0 +

+ /

' !! "(# " $ %# ( 0 9 ! #

)

3 3 #"# #% #

&! A

3# # #3##

6 # # ## # !!

&" . 6A 3

3# !

# 3/

;E3# 3 # %

" A 3 /8 3 / 3

; " # < "!> %

; ## 3

# " # %

4 ! "A

# # " / # # # + 4 !! ### " # %

# # "/

# # #-:6&

3 (

1(2%34%"3!5637 "8(( !

( @(6 3 D

# 3(?

3# #3 ! #

# # # #3! D 4 3(6

!3 #

( ! 3

# ## !

" 3# #! # #!

! ?A

,(="! #

#! 3 # #

! #G ) E #

# ! # # "

# 6# - 976"8

)6"86:8

!9;64 ,9(363%!5#<6 630

"6:

= 1!<8

#"#

#0-) .B*6&6 # !

#3 <

" #

## " > 3@ ! #

# 4 ##

#"# 3

& #"#

3<8 <&1 4<8

&! "!" #> ##6

3<8 & ( FB " "

6# # #3

" "

## #3

#" ## # > # #

# #0-)6

& -6

/ % 2 %% 3%4 "(# " $ %# & " # A 3# # ## # ## "# #

# 3 "# ## 3#

#6 & "#

3" 3

#! # # # >#

#3 #"#

## # A##

3## #"

"#3#

#! ###&

### ## 3 #-:6

& 4#

##"# # ! $' 3 D$,' 3# #3 D$0'

!3 #

! 4

# # 4

H H

"/!#! 3 34

33 !# #3

! "#

#-: #-B " # #

#># " # ! "

#88

#-B ### 4!#

# #

/ "# ,6#

# # # ## #

#4 # # ( # 3I

4 ", '. 1 ,&!#5G : 6# 7 3 %97-#46 7!> 6,9(363% !?3(!5!5 %:7

!<8 &6

# #0-)6& 6 # ! ## # 4 ##

! #

#4 ##

"#3! 3 / !# #

# 4<8

& ( F, #! # " ! ! 3! 3 D# 3!

3# #3 !

# # # #3! D 3!

!3 3 #

! ?A

#-: 3

# # # !

# #H H6

! # " " ###

# #0-)6

& 04!>#

## " ! # 3 #-:6

&J .#

3 #! # " ! H H 3 4 H H6

# 3& $ ) $

4 !!"# " $ %# ,(& " !!# /(5 #! &% !5$ <%

' !

! "/! # # H #H 4 3 > H H!# 3 #

# # H H # 3

3"#>#K # 3# #># #

#># #

!# +4!#H H! "/!#!# #33H H H

H4# 3 H HH

# "/ # #H$ &# 9A? 2# ;3'DH/ 3 3 #H$ 9A"

#% 82# 3(:?'

HH "3 3

/ " >#/ #

#!#

3##4! H H H

"/! # # #3

8# $ '! ##3 #3 ##### ### # #

A# #

#! H H

36 ! " ## #

#3 ! $' ##/ 3# 3

! ## #

3" # # ### 3! ##

/# "

>#/

#D $' ## "/! # # #

# #

" L 3! # # 3 ## )6 #/

"# 4> # # 3 # #

# A # 2"

# " 3#

3 #"! ##"

" 3#?

8# 3 #"A#

! (#?

# # ##

A # # "

8 " 3 !

:6# !#

##H ##

$# ' #

#3 #

> ! # / " 4# ## # ##

# / A 6 # ! #!A # "! #3 ##" ! ## # ##!#

! ##

## #

# #

A# !!#

3 #-:6

# 3

#! #

# "

H6# "# "# 9 #

3 & &

3 # # # #

- # 3

-C9 ## &

3 3 & # "#

,+C ##-C=

" 5 "

# & / 3

3 #

"#3 3 / # #

# 4"# > # #

3 #

# 6 # "# #

# 3 " # #

# 3#

3 ## H * 6 ((77%%"6 ,% 9#9 , <6@ -#46 )676<6"0

"6:

!<8 &" ( F)6 3# #

#0-)6

&! #

# # 0-)6

&4 ## ( ! ((6 3#

#! " #

##!

# #

3A3 !

H :4 H#H

&! "

/ >A

H H H H H#H H/

H! 3 # (/

# #

3 !#" 33 #"#/

,-6#3! # #!# ## 3 #

! # # # 0-)6

&,H H

#-:&= # #-:! #

H-:! (( ! (( " ((6 3 D # ((? 3 # #3 ! #

# # # #3! D $ ((6

!3 3 #

! H ?A

, #

#-:

% &((="! #

#! 3 # #

3 # #

! #H ,,4 #

# # &

4 , 77 "(# &( 6

$ &&:0! '

H3 ((

((

$ 8 8 ' 43 3

3 # <

###

3((

# 6

3H ,04&

## 3# # # ##

!#"#

# 0-) 6

& 3

,.4 #

# # & $ ) $

4 !!"# " $ %# ,(& " !!# 6# ! (5#& ##

H3 "3

"3 /H4 !

#4& ,- A

H H ,- $ &&),B'

H,-6 !

!"/!## 8 #84 3> # 3 #

# # # 3 ##

3 " #>#K # 3##># # 4 # ## 3 # 3 ##### ### # #

A# #

# ##

3 "

#># #

# H ,+6# !##

## "#

# #

( ## " #

3# 3

,)6

/ % 2 %% 3%4 "(#

" $ %# "# &(!& # # A 3# # ## # ## "# #

# 3 "# ## 3#

#6 # "# #

3" 3

#!# # # >#

#3 #"# #

#!# #

A##

3## #"

" #3#

#!#### ### ## 3 ,:4& ) $ 7 "8

:% # !!"# " $ %# !!",# ' & " !!# !,! ##

# 4&

# 3

H H H H4& "/!## #3

#8# 3 ?

# ( (#4!

3 #/

## ?

## ; # ## # ,* " "

= " #

## #

#!#"## 4

# ; 3& # #"# #0-)6

& # #

> #" #

, # # # # #

# #

"# # #

#G B 6# 46:%"&#6:6:

6976"3#,% 9#9363%!5.%93 %"86:0

"6:

! "3<8

& ( F04

#0-)6

& #

# 3 3&#

+4 !!"# " $ %# &!

!!"(# '7< $ % ( " !!#(

, 0 H, " "

6# # #3

" "

## #3 #" ## # > # #

# #0-)6

& 06

1/ 2 %% 3%& " # A 3 # # ## # ## "# #

# 3 "# # # 3#

#6 # "# #

3" 3

#!# # # >#

#3 #"# #

#!# # A# #

3 ## # "

"#3#

#!### # ### ## 3H +4!& # 3 /"

## 3 # # 0-) 6

&!&

# 3A

# ## ##

"# # # 3 "# "#

" 6

# ## ## #

# 3

3" #A

###

## # #

#!#"# #0-)6

& )6 # " #0-)6

& # # #

" #

# "

3 #" 3 # 3# # # #

#4! # 3#

# " 3# # #"# #0-)6

&G ,- 6# 6"8#:6)!76"%&&@,% 9#9363%!5"&7 6 6&%970

"6:

!<8 &

#0-)(6

&! #-: # ( F6#"# #0-)6

& # #

#(6

> #" ##

# # # #

# # "# # #

# , " "

(= " #

## #

#!#"## 04 "/!## # 3

#8# 3 ( ?

# #(4!

3 3 ( #/

## ( ?

## # # ## # ,--B$.' & $& 'B)$ &' G , 6#

= ' * .7;

% ;

'. " 7$

;-*-B,--+6,--:!

9-+,-.! "#

"4 # ?# "

34 A

## 3A A

# #/ / ! #

3 # 6

!# " # M 3 ! ?"

# ,--:!

; " ## ?A #

# ,, 4

& #"#

# -03 # :!"8;

375 "%

#.B*(6& -:3 #6:!"8;

375 "% #0-)6&4 > <8 &

# # A

# # # # !<8 &

& <&#"#

# = #

!<8 &6 ( .,6

&A 3#

# ## # ## "#

# 3

"# ## 3 #

# #

(5#&

" & $,--'B &&)*! &( #"# ### #0-)6& #0-)6& # 3"6

" ( H,-6 !

!"/!# # H #H 4 3 > # 3 #

# # # ##

3"#># K # 3##># # 4 #

## 3 # 3

##### ### # #

A##

# ##

3 " #># #

# ,6 =

$BB.'

&&:0!& # & A 3# # ## # # # "# #

+ # 3 "#

## 3#

# 6 & "# #

3" 3

#! # # # >#

#"# #

#!# # A# #

## # "

" #3 #

#!###& ### ## 3H $ '

.0## 3! # "## # ">

334

<&#

( 4#

/ # ,4 "# ##

#.B*6& # 3

# B3

. 4 " "

(

E # 3

/# #

" # # @!

# !

E 3H

H +4#

3#@! #

3 /!

4 # #

)44

<& / "# =(B! 3# #

) #"#

#0-) .B* 6& :4#"#

"# # ! *4 "# +,.!# 3A A

# ,0

"# !

" ##

3<8 &6 # 4 # 6" #

# %

4" #

.(+ ##!

# "

5 %

6 " %

$?A=*7' 4

;< ?A=*7 "

6A 3

;

# "

# #6

" #

! %

" +()/

! 2=!

3 %

3 6

# "# 5

$2=' / "

/ ,. 4 & 3 # ?A=*7 # 3 #

/3 %

/ # " 4

#3=*

" !

3 A =*

"# %

4 # " 3 # ## 5#

9# A 3

## & " 3/# ##

?" !>

4 # # %

/ 4

6!!

6 %

4 #/ A

# # !/

" 3

3 # " 3 A

##! #

L ## #! # ?A=*7

# ,+ 4 3> #

# " # %

6& # ## #

3<8 A&! > "@

! "#

6 "

4# #/

#-)-:,-- (

3 "

* %

< "!

# #

#3 %

4 =

N=0 / ! # %

=.1

!?A( #

#> "

# 3 6#(A

! # ## #

# "

#6&!

& " 3

# # 2=

# #

# # # ## #3 "

E3 "

3 8 ##4& 2=

#6 & 3 3 2=

< # ##3 2=0

!& /!

! 4#!

2=0

## #2=07 #

3!2=07 #

# %

2=07&

#3 2=07" E. + "3 "

4 # %

23 6

! 6 3

3 6#

B # # # 6

"!" ! /

# !# "

!/#

! # ! / # 4 # 2=

# 6

# ,--+ #/

#,-- < "! 2=

#?A2=07 3#

# #4 # # #!

## ,) 6!!#

6 # " 3! #

# !

" !

! 3

; @!

# 43# " ##

3 "

03 # ,: 6 " 3 #

" #

## ### ,* "

3 # ## #

#!&#

3 "#

#4 #"# # 4

4 #"#

,- # 3

#>#

4 3 # ,-).+

(

= /7 K7E = K7E