High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-A/207/2016dismissed

Narinder Singh Deceased Th His Son Sudhir v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2017-01-30Bench- 4,Mr. Justice Jaspal Singh4 pages

SUMIT GULATI 2017.02.13 10:58

%%&'()(*+,-.(/0*%(1(2-345670'--5895::(*+,-.(599(885-(

30&-705&(:932*(2-:3 52*;'2-.(599(589&(4(&&(*+,-.(15%5'2:- 632)'6-'3252*-.(/0*%(1(2-346324'&15-'32345670'--58&(63&*(*+,-.(-&'58

30&-7053%'2*(&'2%.+,-.(599(885-( 30&--.(9&(:(2-599(58

! !34<52*6&'1'258&()':'32

3 ;=34<&(:9(6-')(8,.5)( +((29&(4(&&(*+,-.(:323485-(5&'2*(&'2%.>.3>5:-.(631985'252-

-':-.(65:(34-.(9&3:(60-'32-.5-631985'252-5&'2*(&'2%. 90&6.5:(*5.30:('2#5&25802*(&&(%':-(&(*:58(*((**5-(* 52*.5:

+((2'293::(::'3252*(2/3,1(2-34-.(:51( 4-(&631'2%-3?23>-.5-:31( +5*(8(1(2-:.5*'2-(2*(*-3-5?(93::(::'3234.':.30:(54-(&+&(5?'2%0932 -.(836?:32 @.(9&36((*(*-3-.(.30:(52*4302*-.5-;1':6&(52-: .5*(2-(&(*-.(.30:(54-(&+&(5?'2%39(2-.(836? 2'-'588,565:(02*(& (6-'32;@52*@< >5:&(%':-(&(*5-38'6(-5-'32 '-,#5&258

5-(&32'->5:&()(58(*-.5-5660:(*5-958#50&A.52-'()'(B(60-(* (2(&583>(&34--3&2(,'245)30&345>52#015&32 = 52*32-.5- +5:':5>52#015&:38*-.(5+3)(.30:(-3-.(631985'252-02*(&-.(5+3)( &(%':-(&(*:58(*((* 0+:(70(2-8,5-958#50&A.52-'()':38*-.(:5'* .30:()'*(&(%':-(&(*:58(*((**5-(* @'245)30&345660:(*':.52 '2%.5?.>'2*(&'2%.5&:.52'2%.52* .5:.51958'2%.5'2.5)'2% .5-6.(*5632:9'&56,>'-.(56.3-.(&'23&*(&-36.(5--.(631985'252- .( 344(26(902':.5+8(02*(&(6-'32;;<;<=;&(5*>'-.(6-'32 >(&(5**(*32@ < @

"( .(5&* -.( :0+1'::'32: 15*( +, 8(5&2(* 6302:(8 43& -.( 5998'652- ;

"(4'2*-.5-631985'252-.5*90&6.5:(*-.(:0+/(6-9&39(&-,4&31 32(5>52#015&>.3>5:-.(588(%(* (2(&583>(&34--3&2(,345660:(* 5-958 #50& A .52-' ()' 32 = (:932*(2-: 3 -3 ; .5)( 90&6.5:(* -.(:0+/(6-9&39(&-,32 @*'&(6-8,4&315-958#50&A .52-'()'

-':4302*-.5--.(:5'*3>(&34--3&2(,5>52#015&>5:23- ()(25::36'5-(**0&'2%-.(630&:(34'2)(:-'%5-'32 -':328,-.( ')'8 30&- >.'6.652*(6'*(>.(-.(&-.(:58(*((*3+-5'2(*+,-.(631985'252-4&31 5>52#015&>.3>5:588(%(*8,-.(3>(&34--3&2(,':)58'*3&-.(*'&(6-

:58(*((*(B(60-(*+,5-958#50&A.52-'()'+('2%-.(3>2(&34-.( 9&39(&-,':)58'* 660:(*5-958#50&A.52-'()'>.3&(:'*(*'2.5'852* .5*631(588-.(>5,-32*'552*%3--.(:58(*((*(B(60-(*'245)30&34 &(:932*(2-:3 -3;

.(9.3-3%&59.:B -3>308**(132:-&5-(-.5- 5-958 #50& A .52-' ()' >5: 5 .52*'6599(* 85*, .( .5* *(8')(&(* 93::(::'32-3&(:932*(2-:3 -3;32 @>.(&(5:-.( >5:83*%(* +,-.(631985'252-328,32 @ .(93::(::'3234&(:932*(2-:3 -3;

4&31 @-3 @>5:23-5-5886.588(2%(*+,-.(631985'252- 3 32(4&31-.(83658'-,.5*58:3631(43&>5&*-3:0993&--.(685'134-.( 631985'252--.5-.(>5:'293::(::'3234-.(.30:('270(:-'32 3(8(6-&'6'-, 3&>5-(&+'88:>(&(58:39&3*06(*+,-.(631985'252--3*(132:-&5-(-.5-.(>5: '293::(::'3234-.(:0'-9&39(&-, -599(5&:-.5-&(:932*(2-:3 -3;>(&( 90&6.5:(&:4&31-.(&(583>2(&34-.(9&39(&-, .(&(>5:23-.'2%32 &(63&*-3*(132:-&5-(-.5--.(,.5*90&6.5:(*-.(9&39(&-,:0+:(70(2-8,4&31 -.(&(583>2(&'23&*(&-36.(5-52**(4&50*-.(631985'252->.390&6.5:(*-.( :51(9&39(&-,(5&8'(&'293'2-34-'1(-.&30%.3>(&34--3&2(,34-.(&(58 3>2(&34-.(9&39(&-, .(&(':58:323()'*(26(-3(:-5+8':.-.5-&(:932*(2-: 3 -3;.5-6.(*5632:9'&56,-36.(5-52**(4&50*-.

(631985'252- 5>52 #015&-.( (2(&583>(&34--3&2(,34-.(&(583>2(&34-.(9&39(&-,>5: 23- (B51'2(* -3 *(132:-&5-( -.5- .( *(8')(&(* )5652- 93::(::'32 -3 -.( 631985'252-'11(*'5-(8,32(B(60-'3234-.(:58(*((* .(631985'252-.5* 631(30->'-.565:(-.5-.': .3>?'*5&32(5&0 51'243&1(*.'1-.5-32 @:31(9(&:32:-&(:95::(*0932-.(:0+/(6-9&39(&-,+,+&(5?'2%39(2 -.(836?

0-0243&-025-(8,-.(:5'*5&0 51>5:23-(B51'2(*-3(:-5+8':.

; -.(6.5&%(34-&(:95::8()(88(*5%5'2:-&(:932*(2-:3 -3;

31'2%-3-.(&38(345660:(*3%'2*(&'2%.'-':4302*-.5--.( 9&3:(60-'321':(&5+8,45'8(*-3(:-5+8':..':'*(2-'-, -':-.(5*1'--(*65:(34 -.(631985'252--.5-.(.5*2()(&1(2-'32(*'2-.(631985'2--.(251(34 5660:(*3%'2*(&'2%.52*-.5--.(588(%5-'32344&50*.5*+((25--&'+0-(*328, -3-.(3-.(&5660:(* .(9&3:(60-'3258:345'8(*-39&3)(+(,32*&(5:325+8( *30+--.5-32 @5660:(*3%'2*(&'2%.>5:9&(:(2-5832%>'-.-.( 3-.(&5660:(*52*-&(:95::(*0932-.(:0+/(6-9&39(&-, .(&(43&('230& 632:'*(&(*)'(>-.(599(885-( 30&-.5:&'%.-8,5883>(*-.(599(589&(4(&&(*+, &(:932*(2-:3 -3;09:(--'2%-.(/0*%(1(2-34-.(-&'58 30&-52*-.( 599(885-( 30&-.5:&'%.-8,6324'&1(*-.(5670'--58345660:(*3%'2*(&'2%.

.(&(43&(-.(6&'1'258599(585:>(885:6&'1'258&()':'32:-52**':1'::(*

" # $ 5205&, "

# 085-'

$ ".(-.(&9(5?'2%$ (5:32(* (:

".(-.(& (93&-5+8( 3