← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/4035/2022dismissed

Satnam Singh And ORS v. State Of Punjab And Others

2023-05-24Mr. Justice Anil Kshetarpal14 pages

!

"

#

 $%!

& $ '() ( *

(%+( (

(!

 ( *#(%



     



 



! 

 "

 %(

,)-"

%

'$.!"

( - /.

"!(%(-

 # $

%

& $  '(&)' 

 " * + $ ,

)'  $-.)'   " * +*/ 01 #2#+ $3

)'   " * +*/ 01 ## 01 #4# + $ -

&5)'   " * +*/ 01 #42#+ $ '&50  )'   " * +*/ 01 #4#)01 #4#) #22#)01 ##)01 #26#  #2#+  7 ()'   " * +*/ 01 #64#+ $-- & (&)'   " * +*/ 01 #4#+ $30')'   " 84 */ 01 #62#+ $95 &7)'  $: 

7 &&)'   " * +*/ 01 #426#+ $5

! $ $& 5

! )' 

 " * + $-"

&-55)'   " * + $

5 $ 7")' &' 7 &)

!) $8"0

!)

"% ' 7 &)

! ( - /.

"!(%(-0 '

 '!  

 ( "

* & (       +(  

 &  

& "

     "

 !

  

"     !%      )

&

 &

     9  

&"

 "     

 

  

&& ( "

&&;

""&         

 " 

!7 

#

&%) ( "

"

    )(

( !

< &%  !%    2'" )  ( "

&            4                 =& %,

, >(   ( "

&     

 ""& 

 &

"4  "  &9 !

 /

&&%         &    

  "

  

 ""&       & 5

!

=  0&

///*  % &0+ & )664 * 

 ? 664& @+) ""& ( 



%           & &

& "

   3()        

!       

!  0  &  *7 & 0 0

 +& )66 * 

 ? 66& @+) 66, &

(&      

   ""

  "!&  "

 

  (    )&66& (  (( 

  

&

 #!

 "

 !

< &%)   & ""& !&    (   

&%1      $  

!=  " ! )

!= 

*,

0.'+7"?0@ & )2(

   & 5 &6 66&  , "

 &&%"%

(

 $    

  " &; ""& 4 % %  , %    & 66&

!

% 



%3    

 "   0A /#6"  )       " (

  5" 

  

"   "

       & 

 " 

  

""

% "  "  &"  1

& &&





 ) " &? 664 & @)( 

""&    ( % , %   !   7 5  



 " &;  =  " )=  &  ) =7  &  )  '/=  &      " &  ,

    

* &  + 

 $) 

)&; (       &"&%

(5

 

!7 /

&      " '

 

 9 !

 0&& )      (



  "" & % , %& &%"   "



.1 /23 .3 45 . 6 278 99

 . 9:0 (;

/23 $11< 45 . 6 '332

/3=0 99:

 .

=> 2 6 *<= 45 *4= .3 =4=< (11< 5 

6  / 01 #2#)  &%!   

.

 

. 6

? 45 .28 

*)         )     &     

&)  (

& ""

 ( "

    &;

"" &  

! &   $) = 

" )=  &  )=7 &  )'/= &  " &  ,

      * &  +       &  "&%

 &

 & )  ) 





   &

 (    )

(  "      '

 

 ! )0&&0 , %& &%"   "



@= /23  45 . 6 278 0 

 .!

(

( "

&!%  

.

9 ' 2    & & ! "&    "0

$= 6 =  45

(2<3A= =2  

 . 9

 *5 (3= /23 .=2  45 . 6 278  

 .!

  '

)

""" 5 & '

 66& )(

;  # B         

           





  

   

   



               

  

 



       

  

                   



     

       !

" 

#    # 

   

           $  

 

         % "    

      

 

    

         " &  '          '       '  (  !

"       

           

      



)# 

   

 

   '   * +  (          

       

 

       " & $  ,

  $  -.+   * /  (              





         



        '   * 0(       1

2 # 

  

    

  

            



     ##    

     

   

    '    *  

        #



 

       3

 #      " &    ' 

  

  4  $ +55#  

    $       '    

 

         

  

  

       





     #

*6  &6 66&  !& 7 &;

% "

 & (

 # B        1     '      

 

       

   #   

   

    #   



    

!

" 

   

     

7  

   





 

*6  /%!   ! %) "" &       ( % (

(

  4% !%

"

&'

66&  4 , 

664& ""&        ( % ) ()

66&  (   % ! !

< &%

 4% /  )



 7

&"& %

)

(

" 



%& B )&&          

    &

(

( &&  ' & 0

 / ,    &"&% (

(5

!7 !   &;

(  "  (5 7 3 ) % 

 & " % !

 &



  ,  &  "&%  

    &

   &      "   &&%

  &

"

(

      '

   

     9 !

 *0&&  0+ !&%)  

     &% 

  &

      &     &  

    

!    ,  =& !

& %  ,   

( " &;

""& ) ()



( 5  " &      2 '

   &  

&"

" ) #

        0A /#6"  ) %!   &   ; &

&%



 =;  , 0 



 (   

  " 5" &"& %

/

&    & )    

 " <   

" %%

"!&

    3() 

& 

! 

 (  &;

;

 "(  

& ( =  

< ! 

" &       !&%)% ;"  

"



 0A /#6 "  3() 

" 

  !

 



!

 &"

 $)  

 0

& ,   0 & ! ( 

:

 "

 22)(

& &

"

 " "

&&%"

"

&  " 

 6 ,

0 &  &&%   "

!% "0

.1 /23C 

215/   ) 7  &;

<  

    ! &    "%"

 

& )(

( !   && 

0 , 

  

 &; ) () "0 &   7     

& &; ) (& !"""  0

 /

(;

/23 $11<C 

21)     

"            ( (  &;

<   "

     %"

       "       "     

   &  "

/  (  "     & ) 7   5    

      &;   ,   3  0 &&(     (   "  (      "  0         & 

"(&; &  



" &

 ( 

!   

&

!

(

;

 "(  

& (/

*4= .3C 

210 0 & # D4(    

 #  # 

      

 # 



  

    2  

     # 

   7   /3

*8   

      2  

  7      /3

     2    2  

         

    #       

          *8      7   /3

 +5- 

  

           

    92 *      

      7  /3



  *8            

 *2            

  7  

 

   92 

    

 

  *1  

   

 # 

   

 

 

  *6  3()& &%

*4= .3C 

210 " 0

;

  "( ' &   0

    /  

     !    %     &   



%)"  3 0)    )&&(  " % "

"



&

3 : & =;



*3:+,

   &%(

    7   &; ) 0

&

  "   

  % (&& (&&  "& % 7   ,   ;     &   "  !%     &   

& "

 "

  "



. 6

? 45 .28   

 .!

5 /

  ) ""& (  

!%   

 .

  (          " ""& !

 

(( ( !% 7 / " &      )  

.

 



   & 

&.

    )

@= /23C 

21  0(

&&%

"   "



$= 6 = 45



21 %= 

: .   &  0 

    7  &;  / (2<3A= =2C 

21 "0 &     "&%   &&!  

!&%&  

   %&&   5

(    &;         &    ,   &   

 ; 

 # D1  #      7   

/*8 

           #    

          #

           

 :+55.   ;-.!+55.<=/0.>*(  



          #  

              

    ,       # )  

   *8      #     #      #               *     

 



   #  7 # ) 

   #  

 

 #      

   ?6 #      

#     0 +55.

  8 

   2  

 



 

 

    



  #

               @    *  (  #            



                                    

       

       )  

    



  *



  &&%)

*5 (3= /23 .=2C 

21  0 &  &&; 

; &

 

 =;  !  

%  B 



)

   0)

        "& %  

) 

  ;"          7 " &"& %)

" &

 ,

" 

"& %

(&&5 (  0  ! 

!% "0

 " 



"& %   -"



 (    

)

 )&& ( "



  '&& "



&&  ""& 

)  %)&

"  

( - /.

"!(%(- 5

'$*#"

  "5

E  F E8  "!& F E8 8 0 8



 "

 ## *AG$+  !

- 

! 

 :  



.& 

! 

 9  

  

! 

  9  



! 

   

$



! 

  :  

 - .  

! 

4  9

3"





! 

2  :

- 

! 

6  9

'&5

& 

! 

    

$ "- 

! 

  9:  

 !







! 

  :  

70 " 

! 

    

 - 



! 

  :9  

8.& 



! 

  9  

7"





! 

    

$



! 

4    

"

- 



! 

2  :  

$   



! 

6    

 - 

! 

 

  

 

 

! 

 

  

7"

7% 



! 

  :

  

'

   

!      

3"





! 

 

  

( - 



! 

 

  

5 





! 

  ::  

  

 

!  4 : 9  

$ 





! 

2  : 9  

& ( 

! 

6 :   

 

- 



!   :   

5 "&-  

! 

 :

  

,

- 



! 

 9   

 

& 

! 

  9  

(

- 

! 

 9   

'

 7 

! 

 9  

"

"&- 

! 



 

 



! 

4  





 

! 

2     

:





! 

6     

3"





! 

    

 





! 

  :  

8





! 

 :   

:





! 

 :  

:

-  

!   :   

F(







! 

 :   

5  - 



! 

  :

 

.

.  

! 

4    

7- 



! 

2 

 

   

! 

6  :

-&!





! 

  :  

%&7 

! 

 : :  

$

5

 

! 

 :

:  

3"



! 

 9

 

.

( - 

! 

   9

7"- 

! 

   

5 "&





! 

  :

 







! 

4  9  

. - 

! 

2 

9  

  

!  6  

&!





! 

  ::

/  - 

! 

  9:9

5

- 

! 



     

C & 

! 



( - /.

"!(%(- 5

'$*#"