← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/846/1988dismissed

(O&M) Rajinder Lal v. Prem Mohni Etc.

2016-01-08Mr. Justice Ajay Kumar Mittal20 pages



            !""#$%&'($$  

  ! )*$+,  -./*& 

    



         /      !""#$$0'($$      

   

    



   1

 231 #

 433  

      !

     "  



  #$%& " '($$    #'

  #'$$) " '($$

  *    !

 +, -    "   #.  %  / 

433. -1 !1 "   ! 

  2  !    2  "

!



/  3 

 

     '&4%'($&  '('4'($5 

 /1  

 / *      +  *      1    

   #$%& "

 '($$ "    "  

 /1  "

  #'45(678   9    1 

      #'   #$%& " '($$   

   #'$$) " '($$  ,  : ; +1   / "

  #.  %  / 

    9 9 3<  + -,   

 "

  "      

      "  .54='(5= 

 /1   >"" /  +     "  "      <   "   #.  % 3 

 

 1      #'

  /     "    !    <? /      1      #.  % "   !     1 /     "    ? " 

1   3  

        

 !   

 " 1  "  1      1 /    "  # ! !        # !

!     1    /1 

 >""  )'4''(&) "  $%'.6? 1/   <

      #  "       

" /  <    !  /1 : ;

  #)  4='.'(&$ "   "  # 3  

    @

  )''4'(&5   /1  

  

  "   >""     "  1  "  "  

      /  "  @

3 @

  "   

    >""  "  /    @

 3     ""   / "  /1  ,  +1         @

 

      /"   >""     3  "" "     1     !  /        >    "      ; "  "

! 



?

  

    

         

          

    

 

     

    !    " #    

  $      

  %                 ! $



  

   "      $  



   

   !  #  %   

      & " '   

(  )*+,   "- $      " )  ./

 0  &   

    " +  

     2  3(  /   " 1



   " *  

$      ,  

 

4      

    "    / ( "  ( &   -   

         /          & !            -   

    

  "      )*+,   -

  

        5    

   

 "       

 "- 6          !             #     

   

   7      " %     

          

    ! '  8 "         

;    " 

 " =6'%  /1 !1

 "   

    "  "      3  ;      @

  /   /   ,  +1      ! !      1  "  ""  /"   >""   @

 1    2      1    3   

      

 /1   >""  /     ! "  ""   3  ; 

      

       /1        "        

"

"     

  "   @

3 "  

 ; 

!   "  /1      

   "  /1  ""  "    @

  /        ""   /     2  "   3 "  

 ; 

      

 /1   ;       !   < " '65  /  "      "  #   3 "  

 ; !  ""   "  " 

 ; "  



/         @

     /1 3 @

A<@(6'  /   /1   1 "  @

"  "" "   >""  /1    "    !

 3

      /1  ; / !      ""     @

 3   "!      >"" "  /  +   " "  @

  1   /1 !

      "  1    8  /  " 1    1  "

 "1  1        ; / !       @

 3 "    @

  /    1 ! !  /1    /  /

  ,      @(    !

  

     < "  @

 3 "  

 ;  ! 1    ""  A<@''6'%  A<@''6'& "  /1  ,     +1     /     "    !

  /1   ;  

  ,      +1       !

/<  1     ""  3"  !   "  

    

 < "   ""  /1  ,      +1  ; "  

 " /  

 >""   ""  "  /1  ,      +1     1 "

 @

  2        1  

   ""   1 "  @

  "  1        ,      +1    @

     "!  1  ""     "

 @

     ""     2  "

  1   /1   ; 3 "  

 ;  ! 1     ""     /     

     "  # !   /1 



 ; "  

 

    .5  )& "  +    

;   /   '(=% " "   B C /  ;  ; "  

   

    3 "  

 ;    ;           

 /1   >""   / ; "  

      "  +  D ;     "       

   

  !

  ; "  

 /   "

! /  2  "

!  "  ?

' @  ! "  /  /1  .5  )& "  +    

;   /   '(=%  ;  ;      " 

 /1  /  +   +      '(=%E . @ 

 /1  " "

 < "  @

   /"   >"" <  !   +        "  1      "      "  @

   /1  ;  ;E ; "   #.  %     /   " " "  /1 ; / !   @

  /     

" "   "    

  @

    "   3 

 @

!  1 !      !  /1    /      3  @

! !

    / "!   >""   /  3 

 @

A<@(6'  /"   ;   1    / 1 /

  , 3         ! 

    ! !  /1   

 

 /   @

; "   #.  % " /   2    !  ,      +1      "!  1  ""  / !  

     @

 3 

   "      @

  ""    @

    3  "     2         1 "  

     @

3  ""     2    "

 @

   

  "      @

    2  "  2  3 "  

 ;   1       "       ''= "  8 A   '$5.    1   @

 /"  /1 2    /1 



 8     "                3           !  " 1 #'45(678   9    3 

     @

 )''4'(&5     454('(54 

 /1 

 >""  "  "  

    #' !   #'  %   





3 1    !

   # " "          " ,  "  $%'.6?  )'4''(&)  # 

 !1  4'4('(&$   /    

  ?  #'  , ?

  #. : ;?  #) +1 ?

  #% D 9        ! !     " -"    # 

    <  @

 "!     >""

     "  1     "  "

    3  >""    454('(54  "  1    "     /1  1   @

 ""  "  /1  , ?  #. +1 ?

  #%          1     1   @

 1  

"  #    1 "     !      !  "   3  ;   "                 "    #    

      !  ! "  1     "    <    @

/ "   < 

 @

A<@(6' 3 @

!

  /   /1

   "  /  +  /1 < 9  @(    !

9      @

!

/     "

 #  '(5(   #  

 !1  4'4('(&$ 3 1 1 /       3  ;  !     @

    

 @

A<@(6'     " 

 

   +  ??

 >""

 3! *   ,  1   " !  "  1  "  "  

  

 3  ; 

    

 @

! !      !  /1   /  /   /    " "" "   >""  

 A<@(6'  / 1       "  "   ; 

          @

! !    1 A<@(6' /

  , 3  ;    "   !  /1    /        "

!

!   /   ,     3  ; 

    "  !

   <  "  

 @

          /   

 3  ; 

       "  

    "  1 "  @

!

 /1    /1       +  ??

 >"" *  /  

   / /       3  ;        1  "      ! !        @

       @

3     ,  +1      "  ""  A<@''6'% @''6'=  @''6'& /"   >""   @

!   /1   ; !       !        "

 

 /  / /   ,  +1            !

/<  1    "" 

   3  ;  !        ""     2  "     1 

 >"" !  "  

   "  "  "  

      < " =6'%

    "  " : ;  D 9 

  < " '65   3  ;     

 ! " =6'%  3      " ;  ;  /   .5 "   !

  /1    ;  ;   / " <   1 "  2  "   3  ;    "  "  /1     !  "   1    /1      

    #.  % "   

3 

"  /1   #.  % ! 

! /1   +  *   !  

"  /1  

 !  

 3 "  

 ; ""  "   @

    /     "  ""  A<@''6'% @''6'=  @''6'&   /     /     /1     1 "         "   ! 1  /    !       ""  !     / "   "  <  @

 "  "  

     ""         /    2  "    @

  /   3 "  

 ;    

    !   < " '65   / ""   "  "    

 3 "  /  2  "

!  !

  .5  )& "   /  ;  ; "      1 "   " 

 /1  /  +   E   !   2     !

" /1  +    

;   /   '(=%   "    

 !  "   ; :    ""   !   1  1  6 "1   "     

   /   /1 "  1       "  !    / 2  "  # 3  <  !     "" 63/

"

   " ! !   2   "

     1      "   !   2  "   /     /   ; 

;  .5 "   

 " 1   

 /1       )& /  ; 

; "  1      "

1  !  ; :   1 ""  1      ! /1       3  !    ! /1 1 "     /1  " 1 !   ; :   1 ""  1         /   2 

 "   8  /  " 1       " !    / 2  "     

 /1  "" !  /  ;  ;       "  ;  ;    2  "   3

 ; / !   "  1      "  ;  ;   / 3 "  / 

2  "

!   !    

   /   3  /  2  "

!     

 

   ""  A<@''6'% @''6'&  @''6'= "  /1  ,  +1      /"   >""   

"  

 @

     1    / "  1   "    "

 

    3  ;       ""   /        1      !

/<  1 

      1    2      1 3 "  

 ;  "    ""           "

!

?

 6 

  

  

    

        

     

      9     $ 

   

 

 

$     

  5

   

         

        9

            /  :;<#(  "  <'    &  :;<%( 

  9 ;      

       9   $          

      $             $ 

;    ;        9    

  

   3      / ( "   &       

:;<#( :;<%  :;<'

  "- 

   "    

   

          

   $         -     

 



     =6 *+ &3   ,+%>   "  ? & @  6  6   $    0 

 

> A

(      $      $              

    (       

    



     $   ;      $    

                9    $

     

  $       

          

  $           



8   

  $ 



  

  5

   



 

  9

                

    ;             0 : $

 



  



/             $   

       ;   $       !      6    :;<%  :;<'

 

         $   $

         

 

            5

   (  (      

 

 6  

 

   

   

  

 6 $

  

   =6 *%* &3    % 9 & 9;   B   @  1  0 -/  0 &( $    0 

  &

  3    

>    

   

 

 

    

 

     $  

   

   /    (  

     



    ! 5     

   

 $     ( 

 

   (     

 

/  $   

        :



 



 $      

    /                $ 



     

 

      

 

   

       :  



      $     

     

  $( 

 

 

 $ 

/  $

        9  

 $  

  $        5

  

           

      

     $   5

       $         9  ( $( 5

  

      

 $ 

   





  $ $                8         =6 *'% &

  3  + &-

 C D  

 

     

 @  3    > $   $

     

  &

  3  > 9 $   

     

    

  & %      

  

&  

   / $

 5

   

8    : 

    9 

  &  % 

          9   

  $ /$    

 C+ )D =  :6 #'* 9     



       

 $   

           3 5  $    / 

             $             

      /$   

   

  5   





 

    (     

  

     

$  



 $                ( $

     

   

   /   8  6  $     

(   !  #    

         

     

8   "  "  "  

  "  

 ;   

     " "

       "   3 "  

 ; 

   " "    "     ''= "  A          "  ""        /1  

 !     @

/  1 

  /1  ,  +1        /  "  "          3 "    1         "" " 1  "

!  "

"  "  "   ""  !      ! " "  <           !

/<  1      "  ""    "  

 ;   1     2  "

   2  !              /    < @

  / "  /  3 ! "

    ''= " ; " ; 

     "    "  " "    2          /    /  8"     "  /         /     " " 

 " ""    "  /           

     2  !   /     ,    "

   2  3 ""  ! /        @



    -  

;  !

 "  

 ;     

 A<@(6'      1 < @

 3 

   ""  A<@''6'%  @''6'& "  / 

        "

     "  2   1 ! /        "  <   @

      / "  /  ; 2 1   /  2  "

! 

  !    

   "  "

     /    3 

  1  

 !       5 4336    4$ *1 .4'&   1