Naveen Aggarwal v. Union Of India And ANR
! "# $%&
'
"%(%) $%& *
'
+# % ,,+"-+.
/0/0% "
1 "!(!
%0% %$0++%$+%/2 "
!3%$ %/!
&4 566 6 " ! %/
!
" # # $
%&'
"()* 6 6 7+) , & "
" "
- "
+, ./01202.
3
! $ $ 4.56202. 67 +,
" "
" + 48 9:6/62020,
.00/202. 4. +, " "7 "
2 "
" " 4.56202 "
;
* )"" 8 ) " " <;*)= & "
$"
3
+ $ 20.9, !
" " < $= & >
"
>
?9@+2, ?9/+.,+, + , 2.2+/, 2.2+.?,"$ 20.9
/2.+.,"$ .@:/ 9
;*)
2.. " $ 20.9
"" "11$ "!
"" " >
< 3 = <3 A! =
<# AA= < = <4'$ & = <B
= <
=& " " " > ! " "
!
<8 = < 8 = <C - $ 8 = < ; 8 = < D 8 =
":21" '6"
"' " ! .:@/@? * " " ! " " "
"
"
" " "B "'6" ? & " > "
;*) E' $
$ $ 1.
./01202.
" " """ ??1"$ & E ' 3
>""
" " 6> "" " " " " "
" : * 7 " $ " " <A $ = 20.0 " <!=" " " 8 - D8
7 " "
0.0/20.0 250:20..
" 7 " & "
> $ ;
" 8
20.0>20..
210?20..
20..>20.2 900:20.2 D8 20.0>20..
2?0120..
/ & "
0.0120.1 $
! "$ "" 4.
F " 2.2+.?,"$ 20.9 " " <20.9 =
;*) "" "<8 = ;*) 202.
.00/202.
48 >9:6/62020 " " < =
""
" ""
"
" "
E' 3
! $ $
" ./01202.
' E 225
* 299 /21"$ .@:/
" " < = 5 & " ./..202.
0@..202. " F &
" " 1 & 4.
*
"
>
4.""" .@:/ ".@:/
" ?/:+2,+ ,"20.9 "
;*) 2.2 " 20.9 "" .@:/ ;*)G .4 20.1
.4 20.1 ' 4.
""" .@:/ * ) "" 20.9
* + "2 .9:.
, ".12 2?1 4.: 3202.
'
"" ) .03202.
" """7 @ & "
7
?/:+.,"$ 20.9 $ .@:/ ?/:+2,+ ,"20.9 .@:/
$ 20.9 "
20.9
""
"
" " *" " " " "
"F
+"
"
,
+ " " " , .0
B "
.. & "7 "
C
0.0120.1
"$ "" "" "8 F " 2.2+.,+,"20.9 11 ! 0:0/202. "
.00/202.
"$ "" F " 2.2+.?,"20.9 ""
"
" "
" "
E > '
$
./01202. .2
"" " 8 > , ! " " G G G> , 8
8
C - $ 8
; 8
D 8
C #B8
& $ 8
- *"+#B, " " ..?9 +".20@20.9,-" :21 +" .20@20.9," '6" & ' ! " " "
$
.:@/@?$ , " "8 " ! $ " " "
" " " "
#- "
" " " " '6" *
> "" "
" "$ B "B
" $
> '" "$
, "
"$(*
""" "/5.?1$
" /?:1/$"!"$ "6 ; "
" $ "
"
! " >"" " " !"$ "2...
$" ..0@20.9
, " $ "
- "
" " '
" " ' "
" .9 & "
"
" ;*) "
:
> "" "
> , ; 6' " "
H)"" ' 6 >??1"$ 20.9 6 /21"$ .@:/I , ; " ' " " H)"" ' '
" G " "
6 > 9/+,"$ 20.9I ,
" " " '6" H)"" '
>??5" $ 20.9I
, > " "
H)"" ' >.?96.?5 ??1"$
20.9 62256299 /21"$ .@:/I
, ;-" " -
-" """ " "
G ' ' " H)"" ' >
> "" " " $ >20@ 2..
2.5 "
.@:/ .21 .2@ .9?"$
20.9I
, 4> " G G ; H)"" ' $ -
6.11+:,"$ 20.9-62@5 6/2@ "$ .@:/I
, 4>"
" " H)"" '
$ -
6
6"" " >@2+:,-.95+9,"
$ 20.9I .? * "
"" " "
.: J
"
"
"
"
"
J '
" " ?/:"20.9
" >/"! $ ./ C
.5 * " " " "
" "
" "F
+ "
"
,
+" " " , " .1
"
" " " 7
$ ./01202.7
7 .@ & " " 4."
;*)
" " 4.
" 2.2+.?, " 20.9
"$ ! F ;*) 2.2+.2,"20.9
" 2.2+.?,"20.9 $ ! " F +"'
'" ,
; * )"" "" "
"" " 20 & " 2.2+.?,
" " " '
" 2.2+.?, "
" F " "
" 2.2+/, 2.
"
" "$ ! *"
" " "
C= $"* "<"
#B *7 = +200@,.5$$@2 22 * " " > """ "
.@:/ " " "
"
0...20.1
" " " 29 *" " " " C= $"* "<4A!B
DF "* = 2020$$) B2:00 <A # 8 - ) " $ = <
A '( "* = +200@,2$$. 2? &
# $ " *
# $ "
F
# " " " "
"$ "" ' ;*) ;*) "11 "! # $ " " " 11 " E "
&
# $ " " " 6
;*)
"
"
2: J # $ " "
" "
" " " "" "" ' # $
" "B
C= $"
* < " " = < " " = "" & # $ " " "
"
"
" " 7 " 6 "
J " " C= $"* "< A$
"* = 20.2+.,$+$ ,.00 $ "< ( "* = +$J#>2.@5.>20.@,
2/0120.@ # $
* "
" B
"
$* " # $ " 7 "
" 2/ J ' $ " "
" !
" F "" ?9@+2, ?9/+.,+, + ,
2.2+/, 2.2+.?,"$
20.9 /2.+.,"$ .@:/ > # $ " " "> " "" " "" " " 25 * # $
" ?59"$#$ " $ " " "
'
F "B
$ ' E""" "F " "
# $ "
" ' >> B " " ' E
"F # $ " $ ' E 21 J E'
"
# $ " "
?/:+9,"20.9 /"! $ E " " "
" 2@ & "
90 * " '
"" "
> , ' "
.00/202. , $ '
E " , 7
"
, " "
?/:"20.9 .@:/ 0%/ & 9.
" " " "
6
" "
"
" " " "B
B " "" & " .00/202. 92 & " 4.
" " 0%/ & 99 J ' ,
"
" "
""
!" & " " "
6 6 4.
F '" "
" " " & "
"
, "
""" ! " " != 9? )
" ?59$#$
< " " $ $ ' E" """F " " " " " " F
"B 9: ;'" " """ E' " " ?59$#$ F F
" "
"
:
" 9/ & " 42
' "
" " 0%/ & 95
"
& "
" * C= $"* "< *7
+,=
!
"
#
$
"
%& 91 J " C= $"* "< A+,= &C= $"* " 7
" " *
" " 9@ J "<#'
"#B =2005+.,$+$ ,.
C= $ K "
"> "
C= $"* "7
7
" ?0 & $ " < +,=
""<" =
<
" = "
F
" L
?. &' " "
" F " 7 " " " ?2 & 7
" C= $"
* "< A+,= <#' +,= $ "< +,=&" "
' "
?9
7 "
49
" " $ "
0%/& ??
"
.00/202. >
K* "B " " " ; $ 4 4" '
.
"
" #
;*) 6 "
"
; - "
"
& - ; " "" " 1
"
' "
B (6 ??5 " $
20.9 (620@ 2..
2.5
/21 "
$
.@:/ 6.21
.2@ .9?
??16 ??5"$
20.9 #
;*) 6 "
"
; - "
"
& - ; " "" " (620@ 2..
2.5
/21 "
$
.@:/ 6.21
.2@ .9?
??16 ??5"$
20.9 #
;*) 6 "
"
; " ' "
(6 9/+, 6 ??5" $
20.9 #
;*) 6 "
"
" ?
4>
"
(6 .11 " $
20.9 #
;*) 6 "
"
:
4>"
"
"
(6@2 .95"
$
20.9 #
;*) 6 "
"
/ ;
& - ; " "" " "
(6 225 6 299
$
/21 " .@:/ .?9
.?5 ??1 " $
20.9 #
;*) 6 "
"
;
;*)
D)J
;
D
$ * "$ $ & $D*
* "$ "* 64;
* *#" '
" ";*)
6 !$)
;*) E 2?.
2?2 2?/699@"$ 20.9 "4$8& ' ""E " '6 '
B
' " ""
""E
' ??5"$
20.9;*) " " & .: L ?: J "
"'
" ""
"
" "
" " " " 7 ?/ *" " " C= $"* "<4A!B+,=
< "$ """ " ?/:"$ 20.9
"M M """900.20.@
* ?/: " " $ "
" 900.20.@ J ' " ?/:"$ 20.9 $
D * " " B " " "#*** *" $ .@:/ & = ?5 *"<A # 8 )+,= C= $"* <$ .@:/ $ 20.9) ""20.9
20.9 C
20.5 "
= ?1 *"< A '+,=
C= $"*
< " $
' "
/"! $ .1@5
" " F
/" ! $ '
"" J F
""" "
'
# '
"" " "
F & """ "
FF" *"# "
F
"
""
" " "
"
" = ?@ & $ 20.9 "
'
?/:"$ 20.9 & F" > < " >+.,& $ .@:/+.".@:/, "$ + '' , .@/.+ '' 1".@/.,+" " ,
#
FFFFF
FFFFF 2+, FFFFF 2+, FFFFF 2+, FFFFF 2+ , FFFFF 2+, FFFFF 2+", FFFFF 2+ , FFFFF 2+, FFFFF
2+ ,
""
" $
B "
" $ 2+B, 7 $ .@:/+.".@:/,
" 7 " :0 J "
$ .@:/ ?/:+9,"$ 20.9 *
K " > +2,
B " /"! $ .1@5 +.0".1@5, """ " "
"$ + '' , .@/.+ '' 1".@/., $ L :. & 6""" 20.9
" F ?/:+.,-?/:+2,"20.9 " >/"!
$ :2 * " ' >/"<! $ = /"<! $
=> ' () *+
,, -. "
$ / -.
/ -. 0
/ - .
/ - .
/
+
& :9 & " /+,
""
""
"
"" " :? & " " " ?/:"20.9
"" :: "'" "
:
>/"! $ "" ?/:"20.9
"" " ?/:+2,+B,"$ :/ C
" .+9,"
20.9
" "
" $ ! " )"" !E
"" " "" " " "
" "" :5 & ?/:"20.9 " """ " " " 900.20.@
):/0+D, 900.20.@ ) ?/: 900.20.@ " "
* " "$ 4.
.50?20.1 0.0120.1 4. F " 2.2+., +,"20.9 ;*) "" "8
:1 & 0.0120.1 " " " ?/:"20.9 0.0120.1 "
F " "
" ) ""
?/:"20.9 900.20.@ " "
" "$
.@:/ ?/:+2, +B,"20.9 :@ * "< A '+,=K " " ?/:+9,"
20.9
" > +2,
B " /" ! $ .1@5+.0".1@5, """ "
/0 *" """ ' " "
" C= $ "
<4A!B+,= <A # 8 )+,=
""" F /. *
..0/202. " .00/202. 0.0120.1 ""
"20.9 "
" /2 & " 4?
/9 * "" " " " 7 " >>
.00/202.
C "
"
.00/202.
/? * " 3+"/.;+..- $ "" " "
"
.00/202. ;" #
+, "
" 6 6 *
'
1 2 J' 6 %64 J %64