High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-A/1440/2017disposed of

Gurbachan Singh v. Ram Raj

2025-12-09Mr. Justice Rajesh Bhardwaj5 pages

! ! " " #

$ " #%!& $$

" %!& ! #$%&'

'#()*#$+

(#, '

()*+,-.". &

! !! ()

! / ! !!

. 0!

% " 1% 2/% . 3 ! ! 4 !

(*#

%**+ %6 7- 8 .

-& %,%&./01 /2#23/#, 4& 2#2#&%5#(#2 .3 + 6 7

(/1/2#, 8+

! &

() !()*+,- .".%

!!&

()."..

9)'

! !

/%& & 2

/ / ! 5

(* % %/ 3

2 ! !/ 2

! % /% !%2 3

! /% & ! 2 !2

! %2% (),.".

(), !

! /

/% & % 2& %

/ & ' !

4 () !

/ !

/ & % 2 ;

! & ! !&

2 < /%

! 3 % %"

( 82&%

=2 & > %

& . ()*+,-.".2 ! /2

!!/"

().". : /%"

()* & >

< !%"

()

& &

/ '

! &

.". ! ,( / ;

.".

!! !

% 2

& !

()! 2 !

& !

+2-.".?

( :% /

& &

% 8 .

/(%3.9(#.% %4%20% 2.%,,/;%23% 4& #$ <01#( (9(# /2 (/1/2#, ==%#, 9 7>

7 */.'

(/1/2#,

, ==%#, 9

)%3/)%) 6+ 2

& /% ! 4 9'! !

2 & %/

!! &

;

/ /

! & & ' ;

@#&.

: 5 %# "

2 2 2

2 ! % / !

/ !

2 / ;

2 ! &

& ! % 2!

;

82&% 2 !

3 /& !/!

3 &

1 /!

!/! % &'/& /& ?%3#0&% /.

/& &%..,%) ,#* .'#.

.'% ,#* )%3,#(%) ?@ .'/& 90(.

/& (%.(9&=%3./4% #2) /& 29(1#,,@ #&&01%) .9 ?% .'% ,#* :(91 .'% /23%=./92 ' 2 / ! ! 2 ! $0);1%2.

9( )%3/&/92 *'/3'

/2.%(=(%.& # &.#.0.% 9( =(94/&/92 .'%(%9:

)%3,#(%& .'% 1%#2/2;

.'% &.#.0.% #& /.

&'90,) ?% 392&.(0%) :(91 .'% )#.% /.& %2#3.1%2.

2 9.'%( *9()&+ .'% $0);1%2.

)%3,#(%& *'#.

.'% ,%;/&,#.0(% '#) &#/) #.

.'% ./1% *'%2 .'% ,#* *#& =(910,;#.%) #2) .'%(%:9(%+ /.

'#& (%.(9&=%3./4% %::%3. < /%

! &

;

/! &A

2 %

& ! /!

22 ;

! &

A ! ! 2 !& 2/ 2 !'

@ 2 2

; ! ! @+

!!!- , '%

& 2 ! !!/8 .

%,%&./01 /2#23/#, + - ! /(%3.9(#.% %4%20% 2.%,,/;%23% + -% !

0!% !%

! &

().". ! . !

! ! 1 ! ! !

0!% !%2 B

!% !

% /%

! " > 6

C D C# A D C#