High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/12916/2001disposed of

Amrik Singh And ORS v. State Of Punjab And ORS

2023-11-285 pages

!" #$%

%&'('

)*+ , -.'/0')12#)3 $2%.( 4%$'$'

)%.( 5%.(6( 2%0$#$%

6)7#8#)3 $2%.( %(9

! !

.%(%)$* !.

#:;0%)'

.35 &#$%<'$2 !.

=#>-#)2#632#.?;35 &#$%;

.$2%9%$'$'

)%.( Mr. Charanpreet Singh, Assistant Advocate General, Punjab. !.

#7'5$-##-;0%)'

.35 &#$%<'$2 !.

.'7%(2@2 (:#;35 &#$%#)3 !.

#.#-5'.0')12;35 &#$%;

..%(9 )3%)$ A$ +; ;, A BBB

"#$$%&"'"

"&"()*&"+, ?<#?

$2'(<.'$9%$'$'

);$2%9%$'$'

)%.(&2#::%)1%'($ $2% 5#:'3'$?

$2%3%&'('

)$#/%)8?$2%#8')%$$ .%#99 ')$$2 (%6)(6&&%(( 6: &#)3'3#$%( )9 ($(

&/%5%:

9-%)$ #)&2#?#$

'&%.(;<2 <%.%%#.:'%.#99 ')$%386$<%.%:#$%.

6)36)(6&&%(( 6:')5'%<

$2% (%:%&$'

)&.'$%.'##3 9$%3')$%.-(

$2%3'.%&$'

)('((6%38?$2%069.%-% 6.$')

0 C .'% #&$(<2'&2)%%3$ 8%) $'&%3#.%$2#$#(%:%&$'

)9.

&%(( <#(& )36&$%3;<2'&2<#() $#99.

5%38?$2%069.%-% 6.$')

D(&#(%(69.#"#)3$2%069.%-% 6.$3'.%&$%3$2#$-#./(')<.'$$%) %>#-')#$'

) (2#:: #:( 8% $#/%) ')$ &

. #((%((')1 5%.#:: -%.'$ && .3')1:?#.%5'(%3-%.'$:'($<#(9.%9#.%3#)3&#)3'3#$%(<2 2#38%%)%#.:'%.(%:%&$%3<%.% 6($%3 %<&#)3'3#$%(;<2 <%.%(%:%&$%3;

<%.%

%.%3 #99 ')$-%)$ #)3 $2%? 7 ')%3 <2':% $2% (%.5'&%(

.%(9 )3%)$( .%(9 )3%)$( ) A $ A" <%.% $%.-')#$%3 2%.%# $%.; .%(9 )3%)$( (68-'$$%3 # .%9.%(%)$#$'

) $ $2% 5%.)-%)$ #:

)1<'$2

9')'

-0%)'

.35 &#$%

.#::

<')1$2%-$ & )$')6% )$2%9 ($( 2% 0$#$% 5%.)-%)$ $

/ # 3%&'('

) $ .%:#> $2% .6:%( #)3 '::%3 #33'$'

)#:9 ($(#5#':#8:%6)3%.3'.%&$.%&.6'$-%)$E6 $#8?#99 ')$')1 .%(9 )3%)$(#( )%$'-%-%#(6.% 2%3%&'('

)<#($#/%) )& $2#$$2%.%<#() #6:$ )$2%9#.$

)3%)$(#)3$2%?2#3) .

:%$ 9:#?<'$2.%1#.3$ $2%-%$2 3

(%:%&$'

)& )36&$%38?$2%6)7#868:'& 0%.5'&% --'(('

); <2'&2 2#3 6:$'-#$%:? )

6)3 #5 6. <'$2 $2% 069.%-% 6.$ , =%#.)%3 & 6)(%:

. $2% 9%$'$'

)%.( (68-'$( $2#$ )&% .6:% 9.

5'3%(

. '::')169

9 ($(')#9#.$'&6:#.-%$2 3;$2%(#-%2#($ 8% )%')$2%-%$2 3#(9.%(&.'8%3#)3#3'

%.%)$-%$2 3&#)) $8%#3 9$%3 2% #&$'

$2% 0$#$% 5%.)-%)$ '( & )$.#.? $ :#< #)3 $2% 3'.%&$ .%&.6'$-%)$ 9 ($( & 6:3 ) $ 8%

%.%3 $ 9%.( )( <2 2#3 8%%) 3%&:#.%3 6)(6&&%(( 6: ') # (%:%&$'

) 9.

&%(( % 6.$2%. (68-'$( $2#$ %>%.&'(%

<%.

.%:#>#$'

) 6)3%. 6:%

$2% 6)7#8 %5%:

9-%)$ #)3 #)&2#?#$:#((

"0%.5'&%6:%(;FA;'(8#(%3 )<2'-( .&#9.'&%

$2%#8')%$ %. & )$.#; :%#.)%3 0%)'

. 6)(%: #99%#.')1

. 9.'5#$% .%(9 )3%)$( 2#( ')

.-%3 $2#$ %>&%9$ .%(9 )3%)$ )

; #:: $2%. 9.'5#$% .%(9 )3%)$( 2#5% .%$'.%3 $ '( #:( ($#$%3 $2#$ $2% 9%$'$'

)%.( 2#5% #:( #35#)&%3')(%.5'&%#)32#5%8%%) 6.$2%.9.

- $%3#(?

0 #)3#$$#')( (69%.#))6#$'

)') #)3) .%:'% &#)8%1.#)$%3$ $2%9%$'$'

)%.( 0 #. #(.%(9 )3%)$)

'(& )&%.)%3;'$'(($#$%3$2#$# $%.2#5')1& )$')6%3#( ; 2% <#( (%:%&$%3 ') $2% 6)7#8 '5': 0%.5'&% >%&6$'5% .#)&2";

, <2%.%2%'(9.%(%)$:?< ./')1 2%6)7#868:'&0%.5'&% --'(('

)2#(#:( ':%3'$(.%9:? #)3 9:%#3%3 $2#$ $2% 3%&'('

) $#/%) 8? $2% 5%.)-%)$ <#( <'$2 6$ & )(6:$#$'

)<'$2$2% --'(('

=%#.)%30%)'

. 6)(%:

..%(9 6.$2%.(68-'$($2#$ ')$2%:'12$

7631-%)$(

9%> 6.$')G

#)3 G

) 5%($%3.'12$

$2%9%$'$'

)%.(&#)8%(#'3$ 2#5%8%%)$#/%)#<#?#)3$2% #99 ')$-%)$

612$$ 8%9.

$%&$%3 =%#.)%3& 6)(%:#99%#.')1

.$2%9%$'$'

)%.(2#(#:( .%:'%3

)7631-%)$($ 86$$.%((2'((68-'(('

)$2#$(?-9#$2%$'&& )( &#)) $ 8% $2% #(9%&$(

. 3%&'3')1 -#$$%.( #)3 %(9%&'#::? .%:#$')1 $ #99 ')$-%)$( %.%:'%( )7631-%)$(G

;G !

D; G " #$

D(&#(%(69.#"

+ 2'( 6.$ ')3( ') G

%( &#(% (69.#"; $2% #99 ')$-%)$( -#3% 8? $2% 68:'& 0%.5'&% --'(('

) $2% 9 ($

(<%.%(%$#('3%#)3$2%6)7#868:'&0%.5'&% --'(('

)<#( 3'.%&$%3$ & -9:%$%$2%9.

&%((

(%:%&$'

)')$%.-(

$2%%>'($')1.6:%( $2#$8 $2<.'$$%)#)35'5#5 &%$%($8%$#/%)')$ &

.$2% 96.9 (%

%&$')1#99 ')$-%)$(;<2%.%')$2'( 6.$2%:3#(6)3%.*

!" #$ %& !" '% !" % %& !" ()*" %! !

! )

% + !,- !" ..%) !/ ! ,% ! ) " 0',)1 )1

%//))% ) )1! !%1%/.,!!".%1%&,1!)%

A !/%&!"2)!) *,%!"!'%!"!"#)!!

!" )%1!!'!$ ) !%1% ) !)% &%!"..%%& &&1!) * ..%) !/ ! ! ) / 1, !"! % &!" !)/ ! % 2/) !)% ",, !$ .,1 '! 1% ) !)% %& !" !) .%1 ' &&1! .% !" ,) 1% !"#)!! #,,)%1!!

".%1 ' 1%/.,! #)!") .)% %& /% !" &%/ !" ! !"%& ! ) &!" / 1, !"! !" ..%) !/ ! )& -, -/ ",,1% !) '!",,''31!!%!" &!",!#")1"/-' 1, '-!"0',)1 )1

%//))% ) * !% &),,) * . %& !" .%! %& 4,%1$ 5,%./ !

0 1"-! &&)1 " .., !" !

,,%#

" #),, "%# ' % % !% 1%! 6

)& -9:'#)&%

$2% .3%.(9#((%38?$2% )D8:%069.%-% 6.$;$2%#99 ')$-%)$

$2%.%(9 )3%)$(;<2 <%.%) $(6&&%(( 6:') $2% ')#: -%.'$ :'($ 9.%9#.%3 8? $2% 0 <%.% &#)&%::%3 #)3 $2%'. (%.5'&%( <%.% $%.-')#$%3 )

2%.%# $%.; $2% 0$#$% 5%.)-%)$2#(& )('3%.%3$2%'.&#(%(#)3'$#99%#.($2#$8#(%3 )( -% :%1#: 9')'

) #)3 (?-9#$2%$'& & )( .%:#$')1 $ $2%'. 2#5')1 .%('1)%3 - $2%'. 9.%5'

6( (%.5'&%( #)3 $2% $%.-')#$'

) %

%&$')1 $2% (%.5'&%&#.%%.

$2%.%(9 )3%)$(;$2%0$#$% 5%.)-%)$2#($#/%)# 3%&'('

)$ .%:#>6:%#)3#99 ')$$2%-# .%(2

2%& 6.(%#3 9$%38?$2%0$#$% 5%.)-%)$'(#)#)#$2%-#$ $2% 9.')&'9:%( :#'3 3 <) 6)3%. .$'&:% A

$2% )($'$6$'

)3'# 9%.( );<2 (%#99 ')$-%)$<#((%$#('3%8?$2%069.%-% 6.$;& 6:3) 2#5% 8%%) .%#99 ')$%3 8? $2% %(9 )3%)$0$#$%

#)? 9.

$%&$'

) <#( .%E6'.%3$ 8%1'5%)$ )3%)$(;$2%(#-%& 6:3 ):?8%1'5%)8?$2% 069.%-% 6.$ <%5%.; #( $2% 069.%-% 6.$ 3'3 ) $ 1'5% $2%- $2% 8%)% '$; $2%3%&'('

) $ 1'5%$2%- #99 ')$-%)$ ) #33'$'

)#: 9 ($(; <2'&2

C <%.%) $9#.$

$2%#35%.$'(%-%)$;'(6):#< 6:#)36)76($'

'%3 2% & 6.(% #3 9$%3 8? $2% .%(9 )3%)$0$#$% (6

%.( - #.8'$.#.')%(( 06&2#& 6.(%'

'(#::

<%3$ 9.%5#':< 6:3.%(6:$')6:%

26-8')($%#3

6:%

=#< $& 6:3%)& 6.#1% #5 6.$'(-<2'&2&#)) 8%#::

<%3')968:'&(%.5'&%( <%5%.;$2'( 6.$ ')3($2#$.%(9 2#5%& )$')6%3

.- .%$2#) ?%#.(#)3#::

$2%-2#5%.%$'.%3;%>&%9$

)% %(9 )3%)$)

2#(8%%)#8:%$ #&2'%5%%>&%::%)&%')(%.5'&%#)3'( (%:%&$%3 ') $2% &'5': (%.5'&%

$2% 0$#$% 5%.)-%)$; )#-%:?; 0 >%&6$'5%.#)&2"

%<#((%:%&$%3%#.:'%. )$2%8#('(

-#./( 8$#')%3 ') $2% ')$%.5'%< ) $2% 9 ($

2% 069.%-% 6.$ ')

% &#(% (69.#"; ):?

.- $2% 9.

&%36.%

(%:%&$'

) 8? ')$%.5'%< #:

)% #( 6)76($'

'%3 <%5%.; '$ 3'3 ) $ -#/% #)? 8(%.5#$'

)(

#.8'$.#.')%((')')$%.5'%<

) $2% &'.&6-($#)&%( #( #

.%-%)$'

)%3; 9 (('8':'$?

.%(9 )3%)$(8%')1(%:%&$%3#1#')'

$2%.%16:#.(%:%&$'

)< 6:32#5%8%%) & )36&$%3

.$2%9 ($(8?$2%0;&#)) $8%.6:%3 6$ ,

)5'%<

$2%#8 5%;$2'( 6.$

<')1$2%9.')&'9:%(#(:#'3 <)8?$2%9%> 6.$')

D(&#(%(69.#"3 %( $$2')/'$9.

9%.$ 3'($6.8(#'3#99 ')$-%)$(# $%.#9%.'

- .%$2#) ?%#.(#)3- .%( #($2%9%$'$'

)%.(2#5%#:( .%$'.%3 A && .3')1:?; $2% <.'$9%$'$'

) '(2%:3 $ 2#5%8%& -% E6'%$6( #)3') .6&$6 6(8?#

:6>

$'-% C ::9%)3')1#99:'&#$'

)(($#)33'(9 (%3

- "#$$%&"'"

"&"/ #7)%%(2H5( 012$ 7"!".$) *8% 9 : 8;% 7"!".%!', 9 : 8;%