Sanjiv Kumar & ANR v. State Of Punjab

 



    




!""#

$"

(

))** +& ,&$

)     
 

 .& -/# 

 %

0"( 1 !



(" 0"( 1 !



0&) (&1 !



$

*"4 *1 01 ,&$

 

 

))**  "* )

))

$&.'

)!"

3&.6661 78)&1 "

!"!

! 6

/ 

/ " 

&* /' " &( &. 6

)"

/ 

!

!"'" ".

76

1

!1 ,*"! 1  ""!

78)&

-"

!

1 /  ,:;

6 0&'

"*

))(

$"

'$"

< ''

  "** . % (.

(

;

)&!( ".



-* ,"*"

"$!" >/!" ! )*/( $" /".

 )&!( ".



-* ,"*"

"$!" >/!" )

! " 4

'

"".

-&*?

* ! " 4 )

 !( )*/( ) '$"

< ''

;

)&!( ! "".



-* '*"

(

)&!( ! "".



-* "!*"

!

 )&!( ".



-* '*"

 )&!( ".



-* "!*"

)

! " 4

'

"".

-&*?

! " 4 )

** ')*

! "".

-&*?

* '*/ ,:;

6 0&'

"* ".

"')" 0

) ')* "')"

*

"> 7'



? " )" " ''

". A
?(

A
'

$"

*

 &   A
?(

 &B

,1 " 76 ,C ."

(



!')*" )!".

)* ! !/1

*.

6DA -" ".(1

 " /".

!

)) "')" 3

( )" *?(



; *!?

&)

 > / "

1

*.

&-

""" 3&"!"

 ." 1 :

*.

B&

 ." !! !(!?

 !

')*

*.

7'

 

*/" ,&$ -1
( ".

(

 !") ) 7E1 ) **

;

 "".1

)"'

!" 1 .

'

)*   .&"*/

!* "' "

6 ) " 1 > '" ,:;

6 0&'

"* &))".

) .

".

!/ '"!

">"!

)" $"

'$"

< ''

 !

A ) !/ ''

 '' ,



A

* ) ! ''

4(-/

) ! "! ("'

)'" 4"  !

(" ) !(

A

* ) 7'

 ".

')* "')" ,=

6 ?( !- ' 4"

 !"

A

* ) &B

,

76 ,C

6 -" )

A1 ,*"! 1

/1 ,:;

("'

*.

"')" 0

A " "

!

!(!?

(

"> 3 "!*&".

7'



 > /1

 

*.

 ."

))*"!

"

* '1  ." 

9(

&-B&*/1 ')*

*.

7'

 ')* "')" 



*/"1  " )

D

A

* ) )!"

)  (".(  "!"

* 

A

*4 

"

D .

".

& )"

')*  "!

7" **/1 )&-*"!

)!& !* "!

(

> '" ;

;



"!"'" "! )& ('1 -& (/ " '

)* 

* "')*"!

"!!

> '"

:

%4 %"( 1
*?

*( ) ' &'' !

) 7'



7'

 .

".

*"!! "& D &( "!

** &

!('" ()  *" &) ;



!)" (





)!"*/

A

))*"!

4 *"!! )".

!')

&("/

  !&* "1 *  "

!"!

!

! !1

- "*

-

!&*

/".

**. "')&. $&.'

&-'"

'" -*/

"* ) "

 ')*/ &( "!

**1 ".

)) *"!! &
('" ()1

"





*"!! )

:

 "!"

,&$ A *(

) '1 * ! "  "!

( ".

(

!&*

&( &-'"

)

**. !"  ! "* / )"" 

- &(

.&

)) )!&

)"   **4 )) "/ '"!

">"!

**. ! )

- &( &-'"

**. !/  !

4(  ("

*/"

"* ".

"&!"1

) B&"  4"("

(& !/

 ( 1 !&* &))".

$&.'

)!"

3&.6661 78)& !

(  "**.

*"/ )"/ $&.'

- &(

.&

!/ )   ! )

&!(1 )"" 



))*"!

-*

- &( &-'"

(  "!"

* ".

 )"& '"/

(&1 (   ('

**/ "')*"!

)

- &( !

,:;

!" '

) !/ ''

F 4(-/ '"!

">"!

! )"

? " )"

 )

*

)

- &( !

& "1

!! A '*/

6 -" ".(1 " "

!

))

 > / "

1 "/ " " 6**

 ."

!! !

&-B&*/1 * ')* !(  "! !!1 !""

*/"1 & ! "".

")(>/* A/!(*"1 )" &*)(

>/!"

))  )

D

- &( &-'"

)

))  "'" " '"

 !" &-'"" !&* "

6 ) 1 !"  ! /

 * "'1 >/!" !(&*A &.

!

&.

'"!

"

C 2" "!

" 2 F@

=C1 

=@

==;



;@

F

"& 0' 6"

)"

**4# "Eithyl 1 (3 Cyano 3, 3 Diphenylpropy) 4- Phenylpiperidine

Carboxylic acid ethyl este,(the international non proprietary name of which is Diphenoxylate) and its salts and preparations, admixture, extracts or other substances containing any of these drugs except preparations of Diphenoxylate calculated as base, and a quantity of Atropine Sulphate equivalent to at least one percent of the dose of Diphenoxylate."

 !*

!" *

"$!" -*

>/!"

 ) )

D1

 . B& "/

)" &*)(

-* *

;

&

'.1 ;

'.

'.

)!"*/

")(>/* A/!(*"

-* *

;

&

'.1

;

'.

'.

)!"*/

!" B&"  ! )*/( . "

1 )"" 



!

;

7'

)& ! !&)*

 ." .

 "/ ))/1 "

"

1 "!*&".

 ." !!

* &

A41 "

!*



 & -&*?

) )!  ." !!



 ." " 

)) ("D(

7'



9(&1 "

 )

 ) -&*?

)!

 ." 1 !')*"

! / )"" 

AG-* &)'
 

  4("* *".

!)  (*

(  )""



?".

"' "8&

AG-* &' &( -

**4# "Sub section (3) of Section 52 A requires that the Magistrate shall as

C soon as may be allow the application. This implies that no sooner the seizure is effected and the contraband forwarded to the officer in charge of the Police Station or the officer empowered, the officer concerned is in law duty bound to approach the Magistrate for the purposes mentioned above including grant of permission to draw representative samples in his presence, which samples will then be enlisted and the correctness of the list of samples so drawn certified by the Magistrate. In other words, the process of drawing of samples has to be in the presence and under the supervision of the Magistrate and the entire exercise has to be certified by him to be correct."

!*/1 AG-* &)' 

  

 !

"# $%!  * )* ! *"

! " *" !"" 

 !"#$#% &) 

!B&"

!!& ?".

**4".

- "# "10. Hence, the act of PW 7 of drawing samples from all the packets at the time of seizure is not inconformity with the law laid down by this Court in the case of      This creates a serious doubt about the prosecution's case that substance recovered was a contraband.

11. Hence, the case of the prosecution is not free from suspicion and the same has not been establish beyond a reasonable doubt. Accordingly, we set aside the impugned judgments in so far as, the present appellant is concerned and quash his conviction and sentence."

7'

)& !1 "

)) 

! '"!

">"!



/ &'-1 & !& >)"/

1 "

 )&!( ! "".



-* ,"*"1

"$!" >/!"1  )&!( ! "".



-* '*"

 )&!( ! "".



-* "!*"

!&*  !"

) " ! ! )"

 ) !/ ''1

 &".

"')" 0   ' !/ 4" '*/

6 ?(

A41

)) 4" -> 4(

 &   ("'

7'

)& !1 "

!&* "*/ &

!/ ''

 ". &

!/ 4"

9("

*

'" ! > '"

"  > '" ! !/ 4" '*/ A
'

$"

".(1 4( ". &

( !/ ''

6

-!

/ ") !- "1

 "!) !"

= 1 !  &(  /

6 *".(

(

"* / )""  !&)* ( "!) !"D "!"!"

"!&

-1 "4

"* ) " -/ ( 4 &-

B&*/1 )

))

**4

$&.' !"!"

!

)!"

3&.6661 78)&

"

))** $"

'$"

< ''

!B&" . '

('

9( "* -D&/ - "!( .

&'(()&)'

 



Yogesh   %+ %,#-%./ 01,%# %23 %#1

%+ %,,%- ,+4!%3 %#1