High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/191/2003allowed

Mithu Ram And ORS. v. State Of Haryana

2015-07-17Mr. Justice Sanjay Kishan Kaul,Mr. Justice Naresh Kumar Sanghi19 pages

!"

#$ %&# ' ('

'('# %&# ' (#) (' #

$ !

" %

% %& "

'

'('#*'

' %

()( *+, -

.

!

(/.0 .0 % 0

1 0 % !

-3#4 (

+1 ( (

5 0

' 4 6 & & 7 0 % ! - 0 ! -* 3#4 (

*+1

( (

5

0 % ! -

0 ! -*3#4 (

(

+1 ( (

8

0 % ! --

0 ! -*3#4 (

(

5

0

' .. .

( 0 . (

'

999 1 0 # ! ! /. ( .

7.

!

(! " : 0 % (" ) 0 $ 0 ;

( .

"0 . 7;! .

(& 7 0 ( ( (

! .

( (<

0 ; ' 4 6&

( . (

( !

( 3

"

0 (

0 (

0 . 999 /.4

=%

( ( . # / 0 0

( / 999 . > - 0

1 (0 ! # ! 7 0 /0 (

;

(.

0 ( ' 4 6&

( & 7 (

0;

'0

0

(

!

(0 ( 0 ! .0 ! 0

&(% .0 ; #0 & 7 (% .0 ( ! 7 ?

0

( % 0

! .

% ( 7

(

+ 4

< /3 @ *, 999 A=5 #2 0

( # ! ! /.

( % ( 3

7.

!

( ( ( ( "

< .! & " /. 1 ( 1

=5 #'

0 7 0 :

( 00 % 1(

0 0 & " /. 3 % ( ( : 0 # ! 7 0

" .# ! 7

! 3 % ( ( : & 7 & (

(

# !

(6# :

- 999!3!')!

(0 % (" ) 0 $ 0 !

(! % (

& 7 &. 00

& 7 ( % 0 &(

%

. :

* 999 1

4 /. ( (

4

7.

!

(

;

, .

( ( ( (

(0 0 ( 0 . 3 % ( (:

B % (

0. 1 0 (

. ! - 3#40 & & 7 0 (

. ! - 0 ! -*3#4 0 (

.

! - 0 ! -*3#4 ! -- 0 ! -*3#40 (

5

0

#?4

. )# % ! 3<(

#? ! C #( % (

=5

## (0 ( % =5

#,#0 ; ( (

#?-@ !

(4 ; : "

%

#?*

% !

(0 1 . ! 0

- D ' 0 0 5 ( E .0 %

0

( 0 % :

.

(0 0

( ( . < 0 0 0 0

0 F 5 .; E

(

0 0 %

( 0 0 % :

.0

.

/

.

% ( 0

( ( 0

( % 0 . - % .

0

0

(

% !

( 0

( ; % (

' 0 1 0

4 1 #? # #?, . .

0

;

#?70 !

( % 1 =5 #$

#?>

) !

( : &

. " /. 1(5 # 999 0 (

D

0 0 .-5 0

G1

0 % 0

(

# ( ( @5

0

' @ . 0

@ 0 ; .

%

'

0 0 *

.. 0

'

1(5 ! 7

0 (

D

0 -G 0

. ( 5 (

0 ( G * 0

( 5 (

-

G ( 0 - G1 0

%

*

0 ( 5 *

5

/ .G1 0 % @ 0 0 @ - *0 ; .

% G1 :

' 0 0 *

.. 0

#?9 !33 0 !

( ( ( 0 . 1 . 3 % ( (:

#? !3 ! ') !

(

% ( "

& 7 &

%

#?4

. .

;

.! 1

#? ) $ 4 4 ! 0 !

( !. % ( /. .

( /3 @ * , 99>

!

>+--+-* 0 ! -*3#4 D!

E

( ! & 7 (

$ !

(! ;

#?-3

7.

!

(#?*"4).

!

( #?4

.) !

( .%

; .

( % (

7

( %

#. # % =5

#B # /!C

? 5 ! -- 4

#

' 999 # (0 ! 7 ! 0 0 (

' 0; ; % ( ' (& & 7 (( ? # ( ! (%( .00 ; 0 .0 ;.

(

%( %

! 7 (%( .0& 7 0 ( % #(% .00 1& 7& & 7 .

;.

0 ! 7 # 3 0 1 0 .

(

(

" % 0 0 ! 0

( .0& .

5 ?

!

7)):

! ( & " /. 0 %G1 =5 7&=5 4 & 7 =5

?

@ 4;

0 : & " /. 1( 5 1 999 0 (

D

' 0 0

(9G -0

) ( ( .% ? 0 0 (

(

%

. 0 4.0 . (0 G1 0 %

' 0 ( % 0 ; .

% :

! (

' 0

0 0 0

' .

.. 0 ;(

@ 4;

0 1(5 & 0

D

C 0 > G

( 0

(

? 0 0 . (

.0 G1 0 %

' 0 ; G1

0 0 . . 0

E " 1(5 & 7 0 (

D

0 -HGH 0 0 (

' 0 0 0 . 0

. ( 0 ' 0

0 ( G1 0 %

' 0 ; .

%

' 0 0 .

( 0

'

.

. (0 ;(

.

. E

(

( ( % 4

( %

.% "

C

. 0 ( (/30

5

'% . 0 0 (

(

3 .

0 0 ((

5 ( ! . .

%

' 0 0

& 7 0 . % . #? #?,#00

% 5 ( (

:

#? .

0 ;

(0

C

!

.

( % (%

0

"% (

( ( (% 0 .

4

; 999. > - 0 1 (0 ! # ! 7 0

" ;

(.

( 0;

(

'

( . (! .0

0 & & 7 (% .0 %# ! 7

%.! .

! 1 # ! ! /.0 0 . ;

( .

7.

!

( ! (#?4

. )#0 %. 3<( .

( . 0

15

(4

. )# ' 0 0 % ( ( (

(

(

< (

. #? #?,#% < %

; 0 0 7

;

( 999 3

+ 5 .

% ; .0 > - 9 999

' . % .5

4 0 % %

(

/ ?

@ 4;

0 : & " /.

1(5 & & 7 999

0

) 0 ( 1& 0 & 7

0 % (

(

%

. 0 0 %

' 0 .

' 0 ; .

% G1

?

7)) :

! ( & " /. 1( 5 & . . " 1( 5 & 7 0

" 1( 5

A20

& (.

,

?

@ 4;

0

(%.

. . > 999 3

15 ( 0 0 ( %

.

"

( 0

.

"0% 0 ( 0 ( (( 0 .0)

/ .% %

0

. 0 . 3 0 5 .

0 %

#? #?,#

( %5 1 .

(

5 #? 0 0 0 ;

(0 "

" "

-

( #?-3

7.

!

( 4

. $ . 1( 0 & " /.

( & " /.

.

#&3;

' 0 & 7 & 0 ; "0% 0 (

999 & & 7 .

(

.

#?,#

:

5 .

. 0 00 (

( .

. 0 ( ( . 1& 7 (

1 !

0 <

.0 &

( . (

1 ( ( . 0 0 5 999

( 4 3..;(

.

. . ; %

;

(

( ( 0 & 7

& 3

. 0 ((

;

. .0 .

( . )( " I. ! 4

0 0 J3 5 . .

% 0 4 00 (

A2 '

(

%

A2 ' 0

0 %

(

%

.8 A-2 ' %

0 5

.. 0.

'

/ 5

( 0 %

0

0 ( % %

0 .. 0

3

0 .

!

( %

0 % . 5 .

0 . 4

% # ?

* , 0 0

% . (

' !

( " (4

%( %

( ?

. 4 !&)

7 / 4 @ , 9 99A 39 !4 *>2 . 0 5 . '

0 .% 0 . 0 % (

..

1 0 0 (

5

' 0% " ( 4 0

.

(

% (

J % 0 .%

.

. . % . . .

( )( % 1 < ( (

' . 7 .

. ( ' . .

0'

'('#1 0#) (' 1

)1