High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-A/217/2016dismissed

Pratik Aggarwal v. Abhishek Jain And ORS

2016-03-02Mr. Justice S.J. Vazifdar,Mrs Justice Daya Chaudhary8 pages

!"#"$%&'&

(

")** (+ , &&&&&&&&&--,"!

$

.& /0"#0) "$ $ 0(# &&&&&& #-$ $ # % 12 & 3& &3& 12 & 3

!"# $

# % !"

&" '&!# (" ) * + ", +

&"

4& &!

"&.

& " / " % 0 1

+, " "" " 0, &

&&"

&! &" & "& &" &"",

&"!

, & & & (&"-

" , !&+"

&"! "

" &" " / "

% 2+ &, " "

"

"

& "

(&"-,

&" +&"

-

, "

&"!&"! &"

&&"

3" &+&"! &"

& "

& (&"- ! " & " " + 2&"!, &"" " 1&"! $ 1 & "

& & &"!

4 &"!

1 && " & &

& " &

& " "

"

"

& "

3"

& "

&" &"" "

2& " % 056%0 7( !& 7"8 &"! "

9&"&

!

2"

+"

&" " &

&"+&!& ", &" "

2& " % ( " &" !&" " 3" &"

2& ", "

&& " 2& " :

!, ! " "

2& " 0;<, % 05

& 2& " %0 7(,

& ! & & & $ " &"

& , 9&" "

&"! &" ) ( ' 2 5 !

+& =9( & 0, "!

& ' 2 & "

' & "

(&"- 4 &"!

,

+, "

9" -

&"

1 +& "

& 9&"& " > &

&" "

+&

"

& !& 9&"& " 3"

"&"!

&" +&,

&

"? "

-&"! 1

+, " &" && !& "? &! &" "

+&

%

"

-&"! $ & &&

& 7"

& &"& ",

! "

- & !"" &"! & 9&"& =9( "

& !& =9(<, & +& & &"& " =9(;,

! "

- "

& " & & &"! &"

& !"", & &" &"

" "

&" & " +&, & " - "

( ' /&&- !

+& =9(

" 9&"&

+&

(&"-, ? &+, ", -& ", , +&9 & & &" "

+&, =9(< "

&!" "

" ' 2 5, &

&, *" 1 &, " (% ' ' ( & &

"

&" &" & && ! & &"& & 1&"! $ 1 & " 0 (0 ' @

" 0 " &"

& " =9( 213, ( & 2& ", 5 + /!, (&"- ! &" & & ( A + 2&"! " ( &"" (- !! ,

& +& " ( 1 / @ & &" & &" &"+&!&

& & 7"+&!&"!

& 27 2&"! 2

&

- &" & & " ! &"!

(&"- "

+&&&"!

& 7"+&!&"!

& & "

&"!

&"! "

2& " 0 ( 2 &

" "

+

&"!

0 !&& " / 1 1 ;; "!

& +& + =9( 2

&" !&

% 7"+&!&"!

& "

&

"

& " =9( " , "& &&

!

&+ & "!&"! &" & & " (< 2& @

&+ & 78 !& "

&! &

& (; 27 5- 2&"!

47 =9(% " &

"

&"" =9(0 "!

& & &"! =9( 1 &

"

&"!

& "" && "

&

,

"+ ,

&" && "

9&"&

" 0, "!

& 9&"& " $& &" &" &

& &"+&!&

& & 7"+&!&"! 3

& 27 2 " 2&"!,

0 + &"+&& " &! !

" ( 1 2" & "

" =9(; ( 2 "& @ ! &

+& =9(%

&&"!

&" 5(2 * +"" & !, @" @", 2 " &"! "

+ & 1 B&- 2&"! " 0 ( 1 B&- 2&"! ! &

+& (% &

&&"!

&" -" 7"+&!&"! 3

& 27 2&"! "

"

&"!

+&

(&"- 1

( !& '", (*7, - "

5(2 & ! ! 2& @ (% 27 2&"! & 7"+&!&"! 3

&

1

A

-"

& &"!

&"+&!& " (0 27 2 " 2&"! &" &

& 7"+&!&"! 3

& 27 2&"! &"! &"+&!&

& "

& " (A 7" "& C + &

&" 1 &

"

2& " % ( &

&"+&!& " ( :&"

& ! !

"!!" "

&! "

& =9(0

(0 ( 2 "& * & &"

(&"- 2 &

&

! =9 (0 (&"- "

&" & "& &"

"

" +& ", "

"6 2& " %% ( &"! "& &"&&"&"! +& " ! "

" !&" ,

& "& & &&& " 1

+, " +& " &" & " &"! " "

& "

""&"! +& " " , " & 8 & " +& & !"

!" < A &"! " &

+ & !&"

"

5&"! !!&+ , &" &"" & " && " -&"! +

& "&"! " "

&" ! & !"

!"

" & &

" & "

" $ " & & & "

,

!

-

' "& 5 ", *

&"

/!, ", & &&" "

& 5 "

, &"

-&"! (&"- &

8 &

, -" !& & && " " ' ' (,

& !&+&"! " & &

1&"! $ 1 &, ,

&,

" $

+

"

-&"!

(&"- ' "& 5 ", 8 & !" !&, + & &""& " " !&+

"" "

", !

& " &&" +"

&! &" &" D 4 "

(A, (

(, & +& " " "

, "

"

"

&"!&"!

&&"

1", 8 &

"

" & & "! "

&! + !&+"

! "& & "

&& " & , "

9" -

&"

"

(&"- &

9&"& ( ' 2 5, "

" & &" +&

1", & & +& " (&"-

"& & "&"! "

" "

&"! !

" ' 2 5 &" 9&"& "

! "

- "

& " 2 & &"

&

!"", & &" &"

" "

&" & " +& & " - "

2 !

& &

8 & " 7" +&

&&

' , " & &!

+ &" " " & (&"-

& ",

, " ""

"

& " &&" & && "

2& " % 05 7( (A + 2&"! & & +" &" $ , & & " &! "

&

" & !

! =9( "

" =9(0 + &!

" &!"

" & &" +&

&&

( 2 "& * +& - && " "

" &"" 7 & & "

+

" &

& ! &! + "

& "

&

(&"-

&"

&"" +& & =9( ! &"!

"

&"!

+

& " & $ " & -" &" "& & " +&

& "

& "

,

8 &&"! " & ! =9'E 'F

& &- &" "

! 0 &

" &

&"

& &"!

&"

&

" & "

& $ &

&" " " 4

& & ", " &&& " & & "

" & (&"-

" " "

< & && " /

&" !

7" +&

& & ", &"" && &"!

+

" & & && &&

+ &

&" 6 5& &3&6 &'&