Ram Mehar And ANR. v. State Of Haryana
!"# $% &'(
! " #$% & #
'
!(!
)* &
) $
!"# *% &'( +,
'
!(!
)* &
'+ ,-'
- -- + "
( -(
% .
-( + #% .
!# 01(% .
!&
-#/ % .
& 2$ & !#1( 3.
% -%)* - -- .
5#!6( 7 !# !
! & & 2$!3
!!
6( 7
822 & #!3
3*
!9 & # ( & 2$ #! 3
3*+,
# 77 6( 7
2
!!
3* !! !:( 7 %: %/# 3*
! #.
3
.
! (!#3 (
2$ / #
2;+'
22%
!#.
!
( 7 7 (! !
!
* ! 3 ! ! * %8
(!#3 (
2$82;+ (
( 7 7 (! !
#
!
%
/!
.
+ :( # !
5 &% /# 3 # #! !!
/ #3#
*3/ 33*#77# !
;!
& !# 7#+< #
!
39#(!3
/!
#
# )!/
(#
* / *! # !# /!
( !# (
(!
(
#!
39+<!
=# 7/ ##!/
!
07 !5# # !
7
)!3
9( #! # ! !
(!
+< 3!
3
># ( #!/ !!7 #
) ?( #!
%/# 3#
7 5# /! 7#
3/
#!/ (
* ( # #77 / #
!# ) #!* 3 !;
!( !
#!/
!( (
!# ! ( +<!
/! #
#
/!#
0 7!
* ;?(
7!/
&
/!
. /
#(!3
% */! ( % % /!3 7 0 ;?(
7!/ (*!7 3*+< !
3 /!!
+#
7 #!/ 0 ;
! .
% #!!
7 % @;&
2
A (!#3 (
!2$>%2$$%2=$ 7 % >$% 2 ;+ /! 7!
!
!(3
3*
A !
7 ! ! B
#! !
!# /!
+< #
#
! / 0;
!( .
!# 7/ ## # #(!3 / !
7 # (!
= /#
!9& # (
# (!
3
2 7# 5# * ( 3 ! !!(7#
.
# (!
5# *!
0 7 !.
! # # (!
!
!#
!
% */ ( 0# #(!3 # !
!
%
! 9 & # (
0
B
C .)
% ## *%-D3 %/# !#
/! 0
82 *! 3
# / # #
(
# 3* 5#
%
# */ 7 !!(!
3*
.7 ! %# % */ ( #.
7
+
:( !# /! !!(!
!( !
.
(
& #
!3
.7 !
!# # 7 # / !
*/ ( 3 0 ;
!( .
B/! 0
+ :( ; 3*& #%(
==# /!
0 !
.
( & #
!3* * 3 ! & #%/# /
7 !
;
!.
# * 3 !% B!( !
.
(
(!
!
!# /!
(7# ## #(!3
& # #! ! 3*0
#(!3
;
!
9& # #! !7
0#
D( %
# /# !# /!0
3 > *! !(36
5#
%
& #!
#.
0 # 3*
+ #3) #+ !#@ ! & #(!
# 7.
# * /
! + #3 & # *(!
0
#! ! * 3 !
* *
)
*
0# # * 3 !)! !!
(!
# ;
!
& #
(
# * *#
*& ## 7 !# 7
# #(!3 3* !07 7#3 ( # 5# B
#(!3 %/# 7/ #!
.7 !% # + #3
> /#
07 # & # * (7#
0 3( #(!3 !
/7
!.
( AA;
!!
!& #%( % * 3 ! !/ (37 #!!7# !/ !# * 3 !/ #
0 E 7 /!% #(!% * 7!
! #.7
(
#
7
0# # *@;&
2(
!2=$%2$>%2$$%>$%2;+/!
7!
B ( (
* !!
/* =8%# #(!3
*
/!
3 # # #
0* 7!
* ;?(
7!/ ) %!(3!
?( *
FB+ /!
;? 7!
@;&
2
A (
!2=$%2$>%2$$%>$%2;+% 7!
+ :( ( .
7 /# /! (!
(!
!!(!
.
*8
*
# / 7!
# (!
!
% *(!
0# !/ !# * 3 ! ;
/!
3* :%:
( .
7
!(
/!!
!
/
# / 7FB+ @;&
2
# 3*# #(!3 !
@E%!7
!(
%
* /# #!FB+
$ 7FB+ @;&
2
! .
*/
!7 !5#
%
@;&FB+&8 (
2$ ;+ /! 7!
!
!(
%
!!/ ! (!! & 1(
!3 35#
!/
#! !
(!! &1(/
(
5# (!
# #! !
/!
!
#*B
#77 +< 9 '0! +# 7 % # 7/ # &7#(3 +
/* +3# (
+
FB+G /! 3*# !
@E
FB+H
!
/!
.!
7 7 (!
#/! !FB+C8 @
(
=2+/!
.
7 7!
! #7
(
2$ / #
2;+/! 7!
A%
/# # *
7( *
5# B !*! !!
! !
(
FB!+
+I5#
!
! (
22 + 7
.
5# *
!
5#
/ !!
! / B 3 ! !
7
( !FB!
FB ! 7 !
= (!
! !
( # !( !!(* ! !
* 3 (3 7!
! .
(!#3 (
!2$ / #
2;+ !
!
3 7 77 . !
%
!#.
! !
(!
! .
* 7( ! !
#7
7(
! #! !
5# !
. (( ( 3 * 5# (7# !( (
. #
3(
! !
#7
* .
8 ! 7
7!
@;&
2%/# # !! (!#3 (
2$ ;+?(
!5# # #!
!
7! #!/ #
& # # / #.7 !/ ##%
%
; % #(!3
#!
#! !
!
!3 #!/ 5# !
(7
.
7
7!
@;&
2 A ( (
!
J!/
( 3 (!
! 7( * !! #7 ;
!7(
(7#!
!7
0 +(63
0%-
/ .3
% ! !
/#*!7 !8/ 7
!(
FB+ /! # *
/ 7# 3*
#(!3
%
% !7( % !(
3 7! 7!(
/!
7
@;&
2;
!
*
!(
/# ##!3
#! !
5#
7 7
!7 !.3
! !
7
@;&
2 /!
7!5# % (
%* !
%#.
. !
;
! !(3
+<2 )!#. #% !!!
% @ ! E3
*% #(3%1%#!
#!
!(3
*
;
!(
+<;!
& !# 7# (7##! B # !
(
!(
FB+ /# # !
%
!! B !
!(
/! (
#(!3 B /!
+< !!
#!7 7 7 .3 *
!(
/#
/!
7
7 #!
3 */ 0 ;
!.
(!*(7 !
%
*
!(
!!(!
% !
#7
!
/ 7!
/3*
5#! ! !
* !
. / !!
#(!3
!# /!
% !
/#
!
/#* +< ;&37##
0 !
!7 ! 7 +(63 0%-
%/#
# ( /#* !
!(
/!
! 3*
%@ ! E3
*% #(33( # *
/ 7 !
# 3* #(!3
5# !
% !
%
0
# / 7
;
!7( ! 3 3 (
3*
!!
(
# # /! *#.7
# % % !#7#* 33 !# / ( #.
(
.
(!
3**
!%
7/ # .(3 ! 6 *
#.7!
*#( * !# /!(
* 3 (7# 3 0 + #33*# #(!3
% !
#7
!! (!#3 (
2$;+ (!
(
!(77
+<
!!
%/# /!
3
+<
!!
# !
( /* # /!
(
+<!
0 //#
@;&
>
/! 7!
7!
(
(
!2%2$>%2=$7 %>$;+ (!
/
?(
!
/ !!
! !
!
07# !
( ! /! *!
7!
3 0 5# !(77
# !
7
+ #3 # /
//! +< #!%# %
*/ # (
=% >+3*
+ #3;
!
3*+<
!/ . FB
!
!3
#!/ ;
!% #(!%7( 7
(!#3 (
2$;+ !
( (!3* 3!
;
9+,
% ! * 7( #!
!
*
#(!3 B !
#!!
9 + ,
/! !
(7#
3
(
!
7 * .
#! *;
!% #(!% *
!3 ; (7 6( 7
$2
223
!
!3 ?(
#7 7!
+ % (!
7( !
.
7(
! 5# . % #! !
%/!!
!(36
77
3 7 3* 3 (
5# . /! !
/ 3 (7# 3 0 3* # #(!3 #
! 7# # 3( (
!# 5# %!#
!( ;
!
7(
! @;& @;&
2
! * / % % !
% 7
3* @E #!
#! !
%
*3
!
!
!
; (7 6( 7
$2!/ 7 6( 7 % 3!
.
%
% ! 6( 7 ! / ! !
223 ( ;#.
(!
! 7 # #.
(*7 (7#
/ 3 !!!
#!!
7 % !(!
(
2$;+% /# # !!( " K
!( L;*
!
!!( % /#
3
!! !( #!( %!#3
(!# # !
!
/# #*
* !% !#!
3
M 5# ) J3 (
#! 3!
.
!( " K
.
.
!
!! !
7 7
!
* 7
!
7 #7 <
! .
(!
!
7
7!( % .
!(!
5#
7!
3* #! !
.
!
( !
2$;+ #!
!
;
!
?( ! .
/# #
!( !
7
#! (!
#.
3
(!#
!( #
!
!( M ; !
" #$
%&&% ) J3 (
3!
.
!( " K ;
! #(! (!#3 !
3
!! !( 3**
!
%
7 B!
.
0 B(!3
%3
7
7 (! .
5#
3! 7 #! .! !( #
3
5 !
3
%
.
.
(!
!
7
!! !( !
.
* !
3!
* #! !
!/ (
7!
#! &
!! ( 3 !
!! !
(!
(D
!( / ( !# ! / 3
!!
( .
2$;+ 7( *% ( *% ( 3 *
* 3 ! !!
3
2$;+% #(!
!
!(!
!( M (
(! .
!
#!
! #7 3( .7 ! !
7!
! 3 * !# / 3 (3 (! (3 ! !
.
! (
. (! !
/# # ! (!!
/7 ! ;
!
!
#(!3 .
2
!
!3 #!/ ) !
!(3
#! . FB
#!
(3!
?( *%
AFB+
7!( @;&
2%( .
7 /!
@;& (
2$;+/!
*7!
! (!#3 (
2$;+ )(!3
+<!
7# =%#!/ /! 3* 0 /*3*
!& # ( /#
7# % !
%# !
* */ ( 0#+<!
/! 3*
! ) !
/# #
#! 7#3 (%/#
! (!
# !
0 /*7 !.
!3 ! ! !# ( %8 (3
# 7/ /
+ :() %
3 0/ # !!(
0 7!
(!
3(
!/ 0 ==%
! + :( 7/ # #! / 5#
/! !
;
/!
#!/ / ( ! ## #
(!(
*( ) % /# +< 7/ ##! / /
(7#
==%
& # 3*
0 /*#!/ #!
* +< (!# 3 0
3( /! 0 +<0
#7 #!/ 3 > *!)
.
#!/ ) #+ !#+< 7/
=8
/
+ #3 ) # + !# 5# *!/
& # #!
#5# * #
# (!
!
#!/ . *7
!
! (! !
5# * !
0 /
# # 7
! (! !! /# *!0
*
.7 %!# * (!
(
& # /# 7 / ( 3 0# + ( !
+ #3
0+<%#!/ !/ !& #
5# */ * +<!
3
(%#!/
/!7 ( !!7 7 # (
* ( # #77
(!
*73(
!+<!
!(
/!
) 7.
!
# / 7 #!/ %
* /# #!FB+5# ! !(
/!
/
# / 77.
3*+<
#!
% ! .
#!!
$@;&
2%+<# 7.
.
!
#.
0 =+< !
7!!
7/ ##!
# / !
7 # (!
=) / (
7 ( #!/ 7/ #.(3 !!!7 # ) !/* (!
07/*#!/ = 5#
7
@;&
2/! (*!( +</!
(*
##! !
;#! !! B
%+<#!
#! !
FB
> ;
! .
#!!
7 +<#!
7!(
!=%>+ + #37!
#!/ !
9& #5# FB ! (*
3*+<;
!!
*!
!
/!?( (
! / +</ #& # B
/ +< 7/
!/! (
0 6(* *!7
B
/ +</!
5# !
!
;
!
!
+<3 (7# 3 0#!/ + #3 AA ;
!
% #!!
7 % . 6( 7
! #.
3
?(
(!#3 (
!2=$ 7 %2$>%>$%2;+
77 (!
#! !
! 7 7
!(
* 3*
; %
!(
%
* /# # !!(!
/!
.3 @;&
25#
!
B !!
.3 @;&
2;
%
*
FB+ /!
%/# #/!
7 ( !!3 * +<2 )!#. #% !!!
@E% #(3#!!
*
#!
7.
*
! *
(!
!
!(
/# !
!!( " K & #%( %+%(!!%&61(#.
$
* !# ( 3 (!#
; *7 !# M 5#
! ( 5#
# / 7! !
% #N
7
05# ! !
! /73
!%/# #
0 *!
!
5# !
!
/#*
!7 !.3 30%/#
# # ( /# #/ (*!
@E%
+< #! !
* !
(!
# !7 !/# 7.
! *
/! !
! ;
!
# / 7FB+
!
!7
+<!
# *
*
7
!
# / 7 FB + ;
!
+< ;!
& !#% +< ! #!!
/!
3*
*
!(
FB+
* * !#/!
*
! +<6 7# ;%#! !! B %!
!(
/!
/#
3/!
+< !# 01(% #7 %+(63 0%-
(
/!
! 30
!7
FB+@
.
( # FB+- / #
( !
= ;
#! 3
# 3* ) J3 ( '
" "'
((&
% K . # / 7
#7!(!
* * (3 % *% 7 ( !!
8
# / 7 (!
# / 7
!
% 3
3 !!/# . !
BBB BBB BBB ;
!/ !
. 7 7 *
( * ( 3
3*
B7
!
/# ! .
! /
# / 7 !( #
!
(7#
*
/# !?(
0
!
!
/ 7
/ 7 ! 3!! 3* 7
!
(
;
% #!
3* *7 . # / 7
+< ( ! ! # / 7 3* !
!
3 %
( ! 7 !( #
!# ( 3 (*! ! 3 ( !#
/ 7! /# # ! !
3!!
!
!# ( !
(*! !
3
3 * # / 7
M ; % !!
(! (3 7 7
( !#
0 !
/ 7
*
5# % 7.
(!
! / (
(!
! !(
.
(!#3 (
2$;+ 5#
.
! !
!#0* 5# !
#7
* % !
7 3
3* *
! 7
J!/
7!( ;
#!/ 7*3
(
3*
7 !( 3* / +</! ( !
3*
! !
!. 6( 7
#.
?(
#7 !(
!2=$ 7 %2$>% 2$$%>$%2;+/# 7 3 (3 +<#!
*3 #! *
#! ! ) /! (*
##!!
> 2A FB 8
/# # #!
#!/ # !/ #& # # ##;* ! %
(
3!! .
! 7( *
* 7%3
7 !
7 7 J!/
7!(
% !(3!
73 (3 ! !
.
! 5# .
!
( 7*
7(
!5# #!
. 7
! (!#3 (
2$ ;+ 3!! .
5#
!
A
(3 ! (!
7*% 3
#
! /#
7 (3
! !
?( *% (7 6( 7
$2
22
!!
3* !! !:( 7 %:
! 5#
!& #%( 7#&
+ ,
&
2 $
?(
#7 ! 7!
5#
! 3
#/ # !
?( *
!
%-/( #$% 012 <#
!
078 "
!8
<#
3
"
!8