High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/852/2014disposed of

Dalip Singh v. Miyan Singh & ANR

2025-07-22Mrs. Justice Manjari Nehru Kaul5 pages

!"#$!%&'&"()*+, ($-

+&.&(/0

..+&%( 1..!++( 2!3'*' 4&,(&(/0($(" 0!3

!'."($!( ' 4) 4) 4) 4) 5 64 476 5 64 476 5 64 476 5 64 476 3!'!( ) 8!'0*. -$9"% ! #"3 0!..+&%( 1..!++( Mr. Vipul Sherwal, Assistant Advocate General, Haryana. 476-

476-

0!..+&%( 0'#&+!$ 0!.3!'!( ..+&% &"('!!8&(//3( "#+!9! "..!+/&(' 0!:*$/;!( "#%<*& +.''!$&(%";.+&( %'!&(' & * !$*($!3!% &"( "# 0!!/" &=+!(' 3*;!( '% - >0!3!&(# !33!#!33!$ "'-?% @A-B0!3!=, 0!%";.+&( #&+!$=, 0! ..+&%( B'$&';&''!$($ 0!%%*'!$B'%<*& !$

0!+&;& !$<*!' &"(3&'&(/#"3%"('&$!3 &"(&( 0!.3!'!( .3"%!!$&(/'&'B0! 0!3(..!+/&(' ("3$!3"#%<*& +.''!$&( %";.+&( %'!*($!3!% &"( "# 0!% %(=!!( !3 &(!$*($!3 0! .3"9&'" " !% &"( "# 0! 3 0! &(' (%! "# 0! %";.+&(( C

0! &''*! &' (" +"(/!3 3!' &( !/3 ( ?41' !+!' &*; ?41' !+!' &*; ?41' !+!' &*; ?41' !+!' &*; &((%&+ 2'

(('!83( %

) >A &((%&+ 2'

(('!83( %

) >A &((%&+ 2'

(('!83( %

) >A &((%&+ 2'

(('!83( %

) >A >3&;&(+A @ >3&;&(+A @ >3&;&(+A @ >3&;&(+A @- 0!"(5=+!*.3!;!"*3 * 0"3& &9!+,0!+$ 0 %";.+&(( &(.3"'!%* &"(*($!3!% &"( "# 0!% -<*+&#&!' '?9&% &;@*($!3!% &"( >BA"# 0!3 -=!&(/ 0!.!3'"(B0" '*##!3'#&((%&++"''$*! " 0!$&'0"("*3"#%0!<*! "('!<*!( +,- '*%0%";.+&(( &'!( & +!$ ".*3'*!(..!+/&(' %<*& +*($!3 0! .3"9&'" " !% &"( "# 0! 3 - B& 0"* 0! 3!<*&3!;!( "# '!!8&(/'.!%&++!9!*($!3!% &"( A"# 0!3

B"*+$ =! .."'& ! " 3!.3"$*%! 0! 3!+!9( !D 3% "# 0! #"3!;!( &"(!$:*$/;!( -B0&%0&''! "* =!+"B)

DDDDDDD !%"($+,- 0!3&/0 "#9&% &;"#%3&;!;*' =!.+%!$"( .3 B& 0 0! 3&/0 "# ( %%*'!$ B0" 0' '*##!3!$ %"(9&% &"(-B0"-'; !3"#3&/0 %(.3!#!3(..!+ *($!3 !% &"(

"# 0! 3 .!3'"( %"(9&% !$ "# %3&;!0' 0!3&/0 ".3!#!3(..!+*($!3!% &"(

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

A "# 0! 3 B"*+$ =! %"( 33, " B0 0' =!!( &( !($!$ =, 0! 3+&;!( =, &('!3 &"( "# 0! .3"9&'" " !% &"( "# 0!3 "*3 0+,- 0! 3+&;!( 0' (" ;!($!$ !% &"( " %&3%*;'%3&=! 0!9&% &;5'3&/0 ".3!#!3(..!+:*' '& 0'B& 03!/3$ "%";.+&(( "3 0! !#&+&(/(..!+ ( 0!" 0!30($- 0!3+&;!( 0'&('!3 !$ 0!.3"9&'" " !% &"( '"' "!(9&'/!'*.!3&"33&/0 #"3 0!9&% &; "#("##!(%! ".3!#!3(..!+"( 0!/3"*($';!( &"(!$ 0!3!&('%";.3!$ "%";.+&(( &# 0+,- 0!&(9"+9!;!( "# 0! !&(3!'.!% "#("##!(%! *($!3!% &"( "# 0!% &'%"('.&%*"*'=,& '='!(%!

0&'&'=!%*'! 0!%";.+&( #&+!$*($!3 0 .3"9&'&"(&'&( 0!( *3!"#.3&9 !%";.+&( '.!3!% &"(

"# 0! 3 ($!% &"(

"# 0!% =,(!D.3!''&( !( &"( &(%"3."3 !' 0!.3"9&'&"('"# 0!3 &( 0!; !3"# 3&+"#'*%0$!!;!$"##!(%! 3&!$'%3&;&(+"##!(%! 0!3!#"3!- 0!%";.+&(( -B0"&' 0!9&% &;"#$&'0"("*3 "#%0!<*!;*' =!%"(' 3*!$ "=!9&% &;&( !3;'"# 0! .3"9&'" " !% &"( 3!$ B& 0 0! $!#&(& &"( "# 9&% &; *($!3!% &"( >BA"# 0!3 DDDDDDDDD

' +3!$, (" !$- 0! .3"9&'" " !% &"( "# 0! 3 B'&('!3 !$&( 0!' * !=""8"(+,B& 0!##!% #3";

0!"=:!% ($3!'"(#"3'*%0&('!3 &"(;*' =!3!+&'!$($;*' =!/&9!(& '#*++!##!% "=,%"*3 ( 9&!B"# 0!#"3!'&$$&'%*''&"(-B!0"+$ 0 0!9&% &;"# ("##!(%!0' 0!3&/0 ".3!#!3(..!+*($!3 0!.3"9&'" "!% &"( "# 0!3 -&33!'.!% &9!"#B0! 0!30!&' %";.+&(( "3("

9!(&# 0!9&% &;"#("##!(%!&' %";.+&(( - 0! %( ' &++ .3"%!!$ *($!3 0! .3"9&'" " !% &"( ($(!!$(" $9!3 "'*='!% &"(> A"#!% &"( "# 0!3 G 0*'-B0 #+"B'#3"; 0!="9!"='!39 &"('&' 0 0! "(5=+!*.3!;!"*3 -# !3(!D0*' &9!!D;&( &"("# 0!' * "3, #3;!B"38($.3!9&"*':*$&%&+.3"("*(%!;!( '&(%+*$&(/?4++&83:*( ?4++&83:*( ?4++&83:*( ?4++&83:*( 7"$/+&2'

!"#73( 8" 0!3'@

F> A 7"$/+&2'

!"#73( 8" 0!3'@

F> A 7"$/+&2'

!"#73( 8" 0!3'@

F> A 7"$/+&2'

!"#73( 8" 0!3'@

F> A -%+3&#&!$ 0 0!3&/0 "#..!+%"(#!33!$*."( 0!?9&% &;@*($!3 0!.3"9&'" "

!% &"( "# 0!3 &'&($!.!($!( ($'*=' ( &9!&(( *3!-(" %"( 3"++!$ =, 0! .3"%!$*3+ 3!/&' 3 &"( *($!3 !% &"( A "# 0! 3 $". &(/ .3/; &% ($ :*' &%!"3&!( !$ ..3"%0 ($ /*&$!$=, 0!.3&(%&.+! 0 .3"%!$*3+3*+!;*' '!39!($(" "=' 3*% 0!%"*3'!"#:*' &%!- 0&'"*3 $!!;'& ..3".3& ! "$&3!% 0 0! .3!'!( ..!+ =! 3! !$ ' "(! * 0"3& &9!+, &(' & * !$ *($!3 0! .3"9&'" "!% &"( "# 0!3

( 9&!B "# 0! * 0"3& &9! .3"("*(%!;!( &( 41'!+!' &*;&((%&+5'%'!>'*.3A 41'!+!' &*;&((%&+5'%'!>'*.3A 41'!+!' &*;&((%&+5'%'!>'*.3A 41'!+!' &*;&((%&+5'%'!>'*.3A($ 0!9&!B 8!(=, 0&'"*3 +'"&( .+&(/09 !"#*(:=(3 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4

H $&'."'!$"##"(

- 0!.3!'!( ..+&% &"(&'$&'."'!$"#B& 0 $&3!% &"( 0 0!+!3(!$!''&"('*$/!%"(%!3(!$'0++ 3! 0!.3!'!( ..!+'(..!+#&+!$*($!3 0!.3"9&'" "!% &"( "# 0!3 ($''&/( 0!';! "(..3".3& !"*3 #"3$&'."'+"(;!3& '-&( %%"3$(%!B& 0+B 0!%"(%!3(!$..!++ !"*3 '0++.3"%!!$ "$!%&$! 0! ..!+!D.!$& &"*'+,-B& 0"* =!&(/&;.!$!$=,(,$!+,&(#&+&(/ 0! ..!+- &( 9&!B "# 0! +!/+ ."'& &"( ("B %+3&#&!$ =, 0! "(5=+! .!D"*3 0!!/&' 3,&'$&3!% !$ " 3(';& 0&'"3$!3+"(/B& 0 %"., "# 0! %";.+! ! ..!3 =""8 ($ 3! *3( 0! 3&+ "*3 3!%"3$- &#3!%!&9!$- " 0!+!3(!$!''&"('*$/!

&'."'!$"#%%"3$&(/+,

"., "# 0&' "3$!3 =! .+%!$ "( 0! #&+! "# !%0 "# 0! %"((!% !$%'!'

*+, *+, *+, *+, ($ ($ ($ ($- - - - >476 476 476 476A *(!! I0! 0!3'.!8&(/13!'"(!$ ) !' I0! 0!33!."3 =+! ) !'