← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/950/2002disposed of

Harbhajan Singh, Etc v. State Of Punjab

2015-03-10Mr. Justice Hemant Gupta,Mrs Justice Daya Chaudhary13 pages



      

!

"

#$%&'(%)%# **++ ,#- ' -&$  *.       

  

/%%# *##++**#01$++2.%&-.(03 !$###.% *###3  /%%#%&-.(0%-+.$#*#.%(3

# 4#+&5-#46.7)  4#0+ #*'(%6.76#%**++ 44&#%#-6..+6 -&$6 #%#*.    %*#**+*###.$1#$%&'(%( '(%6+$(%'(%) %%*+'(%6$%#$%&'(%. 4&.#5-#8%+.-(%##$%&'(%6(%&-.(0  7 . #.#   .. "

!

! *. $1 % ..+'-.(6-#.*-#62%#$1**++0+1 %%*+ '(%.4&.#5-#2#7.#%*-%$+-.# ' !   # % 0-#.#  4%.# '(% . +& '(% #*7+162%#+$(%'(%.#$%&'(%2#7.# *-%$+-.#' ! #.2% 9 *##0 %6 **++ 4&.# 5-# 8 %+ 2 7. #   *-%$+-.#' : 62%#%#**++2#7.

!

-.# ' :   #. 2% ' 9    ++% **++ 2# .-.#(0*#00.%#.# % *#-  2   0  % 0  0#; '(%   %# '(%6 0.  ' '-;%2.# '(%6 ' %<5<(#  =="   % 0 >?

@6 0#; '(% .% %%.2  .  .-(%#0+1 '-;%2.# 5-# 8 '-;%   .-(%# '-;%2.# 5-# 2 0##.  7#'(% #$%&'(%#.,++(5%1$- A1#(. % %%*+'(%8 -&.+$(%'(%6$#%#%<<+2B %+6#%<<+22++#&.#5-#.#$%&'(%6 0%#.%#%<<+26-.$%.-(%#<<+2 7# '(%6 2% 2 0*+1.  +% *#0 . % .-(%# '-;%2.#5-##.#.(+#.%-%12# ++2( % .-(%#  #  %# %-  ,++( 5%1  

=="6 % +(2% % - -* '(%   5## '(%6 % 1-(# $#%# 0+1 4%.# '(% . %  +& '(% 2  ,++(5%1#.#*#7+-*#$%&'(%.%0+1% %1%-+.%#%.-(%#.%%.1-+%++%0 $-C

462%%1#%.#%%-#$%&'(%6 %+(2%%$#%#4%.#'(%#.#%%-#0% -#.#62%#%+&'(%.%--*'(%2#++ -. (%0.%$#%#4%.#'(%#(%%-6

%%*+'(%8 -&$#-(%.-$+$##+#+#0.%%- .*.2#.%$#%#4%.#'(%-#6%#216 2%#%$#%#4%.#'(%#.##0%#%- 7%0+-#%#.%2%4%.#'(%%&-#%. #%.#%#06%#$%&'(%.%+$(%'(%6

2%2#*#%%-6-(%%$#%##0%%#.0.%0 ++%(#-./%+%$#%#2+1(%(#-.6 %%*+ '(%#.%2%%#+62%%%%$#%#4%.#'(%6 #-+2%%%..%*%##6 %%*+'(%#0.2% #+0-%%-2#.%0+&'(%#.#- 21  % 0#<1+6 2%% 2 *#;. #$1  27#6 #&.# 5-#60%# %%*+'(%.#%0#<1+62%# %+%.%#+#0%#$#%# %%*+'(%.#.% %+&'(%62%%%%#(%.%;/%%++ .2%(#-.6%+#.%#%62%%%%0%$;. %+%-+.##-+2%%%..

%*-#6% ;%+##2++62%#%$#%#-*'(%#0.#% ..$.1%+&'(% (%0#%2++6%+#. 2 % #0 % #+ 2#. -* '(%6 2%% ..  % %0 %##6%#21.+.%0+%%-(#'(%6 2%(%$-###$%&'(%#006%--* '(%0%%-(#'(%.#0.%0%++%*# #21#0%*+(2%#+-#%#.%#+7( -*'(%#%..$.162%%2((*++.( #*#6''-;%2.#'(%0%0+2+1<*.(##.. %0 %$-%06#-D>?

+'##(#  #-.= 4 #*#-D6

 >?

E!@2##..$1';%%'(% %##6''-;%2.#'(%+(2%*+*#12  % *  5%16 2%# .. $.  4%.# '(% . +& '(%2#+1(#0*+(%D-*#.(>? @6% % .. $.  4%.# '(% . +& '(% # * 0#0

?0++.$+..#%.%#0*1##.( 20*1##.( !$##+#0#%..$.1+&'(% .  0*1 ##.( #0 # % ..$.1  4%.# '(%6 . 7#.  *# +. *#+   + ;  *  0# 1+ 0; '-#& 7. 00 ?

F . *#*#. #-(%  *+ ?

4 %*<0#0?0%..$.4%.# '(% . +& '(% 2 .-. $1 /<! # #$%& '(%6 4.+ #6 6%-++ =="$- !

4.!

4 #*7+1-.%++2(&-#%..$.14%.# '(%  F#. *#( 2-.

0 ? G0 I 7+7( #(%%;6#(%%+$%-**#.+2#&2.$%. %(+#(%0.$+6*#%;+;(2 *#4#(2#7#..$+.(2*# .%&-# .6%0-+##*.(&-#1 2#+ #.60+#.*#0+#%-**#.+2#&2#(% %+2#0(#0%;.#(%0.$+#% (+ 2 #-#.    % %; 2 + $#; > #-#.@6#76$+.7+.0-+%*#; 7+7. 2# + +#.  %# 2 *# $+.  % 0-% .  % # ##*.(  &-#1     . *++   -0$# 2# #7#. #0 % &-#1.*-&2+% !'2++("0?90I7+7(%#(%%-+.#2% #.$#!? 0I# .6%-.#+1(#(%+7+$2#-#. '0% 2 %+%1 . . $-

   0 .(..0?.2%(#&-J

"

'0+#+16  % .. $.1  +& '(%6 % -. % ++2(&-# F#.*#(2-.C?!A0I%-**# %+  #(% .  ;6 0 .2 % (+  0.$+ 4#(2#7#.+.(2*#+;(2 *#  .6 -++ # #( &-#1   +#. % ;0-+.$+.7+##*.(&-#1 . #.%#-(%%$#0###-#(%$% ;-++%#2*#+#%$#0##0$ -*%+7++**#++$%$#0# % #+ #7 . $+. 7+  % $# 0# 2# .0( ++2#0$...

%$#0#+(% #-%&-#1%*++2#;-+(2%%# *#%$-+++1(0$...%*+*#++$ %$###*.(*+*#+$%+. %;-++2#-#.#+712-++$+. !+#.2-."? 0I%*##+#+ *%+%-+.#&%2-.20-+.* -*  0 .*%  +.( 2 *#  +;( 2 *#4#(7#. .  .  % + %-+.# &   $;6 %# 2 *##-#%.#+1(&+.(2*# %#*++0$...%2-.2##7#.    #..% $# ! ? A 0 I  % 0..+  % #%.J %*6%-.

%%4%.#'(% .+&'(%2%0##%(.%;#-+##0&-#1. %++%&-#2#0#0-#.2#-- .%%#.

 =="6''-;%2.#'(%##.+$(%'(%6 #$%&'(%.#&.#5-####((#$%&'(%6 %##(.+$(%'(%62%-#..+-#0?  %%%%.;*+. !$#.-$+$##+#+.-+1+.. 2%2+7##.(.2+7##.(%0-.#%% #%  % ;% 0 # % -$2++  -#-  -% .+-# 06%(#7#.%0%#+.%##.(2#;  * 7. 00 ?

  27#6 %%*+ '(% . %+ -##.#.%-#!9 ==" %$.+-#0 -#.$1 %%*+'(%.-#(##(6#0+%(-2 ;  * 7. 00 ?

'  %##6  0*+  #1#0+6#*#-.#' : # 2+.(% *#**++2++#&.#5-#  *#7  6 *# #0 ?0( /<! # #$%& '(%B /<: ' '-;%2.# '(% . /< ! *# #$ '(%6 2%.*.2%#(#.%7(##.-$1%02++ %# 2  #0+ -#6 % *#- ?0. /<  0#; '(%6 $#%#  % .. 4%.# '(% . %#  % .. +&'(%62%##.%#+#7#$   ++%#0(#-0**#(%*#- 7.2#*-%-.%#0##..-.#'

 #  %0 -. %%*+ '(%. %.16 +& '(% +(2% % #. #%*+ '(% . +; '(% %. +#2%%0+%(#-.%%2%.#(7( %#7#'(%6%$#%#%#2?%($-%#  % .1  -## =="6  $-C9" 462%% 2 2#;(  % +.  #  % %-6 4%.# '(%B +& '(%B

+;'(%B#'(%6'2.#-#.2#%+'%$6%(+5+ 2++ #%*+'(%.+$(%'(%6$%-*'(%%. 020#<1+.#2#.%0-#%#. %+;'(%2%7(#+62%#%#2#%+.(##. .%;1%1#.++;#;++%0 *%6%#.#. %%-++%*#++2.%0.#..%%-  0%# #&.# 5-# #.  7 %06 $- % 2 (7 &-# %%#.%#0.%-%.#6$-%*#$#;% .#.+;'(%#0.2%#+#.%0.#.;++%0 +#.#0%.#*#21%+2%%+.

#+ #-+2%%-#%+#216$-2%00+1 4%.#'(%.+&'(%2#%%*.%%%. #.6$%%...%#0*2-+.%7;++.%0. % 0%#  27#6 ++ %# -. *+.. + 0*+ . -**#.%.;$1 %**+'(%.6%1+?0. /<  #  ,#06 /<  #$%& '(%6 /<  '-#.# 4% F-%#6 /<9 50+ '%#06 /<" *# &$ '(% . /<C I#'(% #.#(%#7.##.6%+#.#+ -# D-. #&.# 5-# $1 ?.( $  .-$6 2%# 7...%*#**++60.$7 # % -#6 +#.

 -+ # % **++ % 7%0+1#(-.% /< 0#;'(%%1<26$-%% $#.-.$1%*#-+#..%%*#  0#; '(%  % *  .-$-+ 0-%  %#   # # 0#;'(%7%%-%.-(%#K<+262%%.-(%# .%#%-$.2##.

(#-*-#*#62*#2#0#<1+.22#6 #%#*#-.-$-+%0#;'(%.%#6 *#*#-#162%2#((##%7(0%%-% -.'++-#%#6%+61-(-0##..-(%##$%&'(% % $ ++1 0*+.6    -$+7$+ %  1-( (#+ 2-+. %  .-$+ $##+ #+ #0 %# $#%# . ;. % ++(. #.-#60#62% %%*+'(%2#01.2++#. %.+(  # #0    -#%# #(-. % % +  .  %7 #7#.%#0*#0%*+-##6$-2%%+..% +7##.(%.-$+$##+#+%0##.%##6 %*#-%0*+.

%%762%%01* -((#2#.%+ '0+#+16#$%&'(%2(.$-0#%:"1# %0++(.-##.+$(%'(%%$0*+. 7+7++%0+100$#%#+#$-.$%%0 *-++(%..4%.#'(%2%%%#%#1*#*-.. .0$*+-$+%#7#1#+#$-.% .+-# 0  +$(% '(% %-(%    +.

%%*+'(%'-%#7#1+.#+ %%*+'(%% $.+-#0+$(%'(%+0*+2% 720*+++%##+%0+1 +#(-.%%+#.#+-#%..#2.7# #%$**++.$%+#&.#5-#. %#%#-(%7#'(%6%<<+20#;'(%%7#0 0.  % **+ #  0*+ % -. 7 %-(% -% **+ 2 2%- 1 -%#1  % *#  % -.   **+?

+.$%+ %%*+'(%%-(%*#.$1

=

% 0 +21#6 2% *#.  **+ ? ,  $%+  7# '(%6 $- % 7#0 0.  -% **+  $ *#.  #7*#(%**++'++-#%#6%. %%*+ '(%%0-.#' # 62%%+; '(%#0.2%#+#.%06%##6#21%+6% #.2%%+.#+%.%#<?0.%*#- 2#*#+%#0.+B%##6%0#.+ .-%0#2+++.%#%%*#- %*#7.%%#((%**++ F#.-+#%**+++###.

%0  /<  #  ,#0  -**#  % #(-0 %6  6 % 0*+ *#1 2 % ((##   2 #(-. % #&.# 5-#6 2#$%&'(%2+.0-+*+&-# ==" %%#%.6%*#-%###.%.( ##.. $1 % +#. #+ -#  -**# % #.#  7 . &-.(0 / %7 %#. +#. -+ # % *# . 2% %# (%#-(%%##.#-++1/..10#% #(-0#%%*# /< 0#;'(%2.-$-+% 0-##0#;'(%K.-(%#20##.7#'(%  #$%& '(% . $#%#  +$(% '(% .

 %%*+ '(% %-(% % <<+2 7# '(% . .-(%# %7 #. #.( *#+1  +6 $- %  #0 % %1 2# ?+-.. #0 &10  % & *#*#1 2  -  # 2% /<  0#; '(%#0+.#%*#(#+%%.-(%#%-+.$ 0#$+.$D-++1*#*%%+.

%#%<<+27#'(%%0? 0.$1 /< 0#;'(%''-;%2.#'(%2##..$#= 462% % #-D 2   % *+  # #(#      % -## %. ; *+  $- C

4  %##6 % *#  0#;'(%%*$.-$.#%#%%0 >?

@6 % $   6 % $ ##..  # % -## 2%- (7( 1 0  % 0*+  0-7# +%. D-+162.%0#;'(%#-%-+.#+$+2 +(%1#<?06.-$-+.$#.$-%*# %*%##62%7##+1-*%0  #*  % #(-0 % 4&.# 5-# 8 %+6  1-(-0##..-(%##$%&'(%6%$++10*+.6 2.% /< 0#;'(%%0(#++1.*.% #%$1 %**+'(%#0%.-$+$##+#+64&.#5-# 8%+%.%.#+#0%$#%#.#.2%+& '(%41$%*#-%+.17.62%-*+.. ##.

(%..-$+$##+#+6$-%#0%#( ##.( #0 % %# $##+  #$-.  %+  .*. $1 /< 0#; '(%  0#; '(% % .*. % % . ##.( % % ..+&'(%%+.%;*# /<!6%&-#1 % ;  % -  .%  /<! # #$%& '(%  . -. % $-++ # #( &-#1   +#. % ; 0-+ . $+. 7+ ##*.(  &-#1   . #. %#-(% % $# 0# # #-#( % $  % ;-++  % #+ #7 . $+. 7+%$#0#2#.0( ++2#0$...%$# 0# +( % #-  % &-#1   *. $1 /<!

 # #$%& '(%6%.&-#1+#.2-."?

+#+*%+%-+.#&6.$-.$1%%#.$-++ ##.(#.#0%.-$+$##+#+76%$.-$ #( #.##.(#0%.-$+$##+#+6?..%+6% #0%%.##.(#.#0%.-$+$##+#+

%%*+'(%62%%%-.%+&'(%72% 1<2 - (7 $1 /<  0#; '(%6 ##$#. $1 % 0.+7..*.$1 /<!##$%&'(%62.###  % .( ##.. $1 % #+ -#  #*  #+  %+  -(.%+&'(%0#;'(% '0+#+16%#+ %%*+'(%%$+#+1?*+. $1 0#; '(%6 2%+ **#(  % 2<$?  /<    % .*.% %%*+'(%#.%#0%.-$+$##+#+62%% %..4%.#'(%%.&-#162%%-.%.% 4%.# '(%6  .*. $1 /<! # #$%& '(%   *# % 0  /<! # #$%& '(%  .

6 *++   -0$# 2# #7#. #0 % &-#1 6 2%% ##$# % *#-#1#(#0.-$+$##+#+$1 %%*+'(%% .;$1 %%*+'(%%0##..-.#' # +%%%#.+;'(%62%%0 %%-2%##0%% %%*+'(%%.0.%% #.+;'(%##$#%*#-#1%##62.  . 1 ###  % .( ##.. $1 % +#. #+ -# 7( %%*+'(%#-(.%4%.#'(% % #(-0  $%+  % **++ % #&.# 5-# -#.&-#%.62%%%**. =="$+ '%2?0.00.

+1#%-## =="6$- 2?0.!

=="+0#22;$1/< # 

!

,#0  ++ % ? &-# -. $1 % 4.+ #. (  # 4 4%&6 # +0 '%#. . /<  #  ,#06  % *##&.#5-#2#0*+-#.*#$$+.-#% &-#22%%#2;%#<?06/< #

,#0.0.%&-#1 C$-.$1#.+1%. . % *$+1  &-#1   ) ! $( -#. $1 ++   %#. -#  $ #-+. -  %  % #&.# 5-# %  $ 0.++1?0.#%-##%2%%&-#2# -.%0#++(.%-(%%#0#<?0% *#- 2 #(#.( -% &-#6 $- %#   *7 7.  -#( &-# $1 #&.# 5-#  '++ -#%#6 %#   #<?0 /<:''-;%2.#'(%6%7(( #6 #*&-#-#.$1#&.#5-##%%*+%+. 7(%-&-#-#.$1#&.

#5-#%##6% 0  /<  #  ,#0  $ ;   7.  #&.#5-#%7(-#.&-#%. ==" 27#6 2 . % % *#- % +.  *#7 % %#( +7+. ( #$%& '(% . +$(% '(% $1. 1 #$+ .-$  % +1 #+ *+. $1 $%  %0   *-++(  4%.#'(%2%%#+1%#(#+.10*+  01  #+  # *$+6 $- + %#   7.  ##$#%#*#.%#+#$-.%0-## %*#-%?0.-*'(%6.

0#;'(%%0-##%##6+1##$#% #+  +$(% '(%   #7#1  +. .-$+ $##+ #+ 

%%*+ '(%6  % .+-# 0  ' %%*+ '(% . +$(%'(%##+$#%#6+$(%'(%%$#$-.#7#1

+..-$+$##+#+%*#-2.%# $(1+;-$+7.#*7+70#$%& '(%.+$(%'(%%$1($+7(7. ( **++ #$%& '(% . +$(% '(%6 2 .0  **#*#?.$.-$$%%0 72%$7.-62%+.0(%**+D- **++ %%*+'(%.4&.#5-#8%+62D-**++ #$%&'(%.+$(%'(%%%#(+7+.(%0$1 (#( $  .-$  %1 %++ $   +$#1 #%2%6   #D-#.1%# >4

@   >F'FF@   

!

"   ,0+