High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/7061/1991disposed of

Chander Shekhar Sharma v. Additional Labour Commissioner

2023-08-23Mr. Justice Harsh Bunger37 pages

! ""

# #

"" $

% & '"

(

""#$""% & '

' ( ) *+ ,, - ."! /' 0 ' ' 1 ' ! /' /' 0 +

$ 2

4 5 ! + * ,,*

-.! /'0 "

' ' 1 '! '

+ * ,,* -.! /'0 "

'! /' ' ' 0 + $2

45 ! '

+6#7$. *8 *"

,)) "

9' ' /' $ 2

0 +!+* *7 ,)" ' **$. :/ * *"

,)) 0 + *7 ' *) "* '

+ &

' ' ' 1 ' ,%" ; ,%"<!

0 + $2

45 !

/ ' ' '

' 6 !

/! ,%"

> 2 3 ?

/'@

3AB :/ ' '/'0 + &

0 + ( / ' ,%" ' '

3 ' ' /' 0 + $2

45 !

C .

' ' 1 ' ! /' ' ' + * ,,* - .! 0 +

$ 2

4 5 ! '

+6#7$. *8 *"

,)) # 9 . + * ,,*

-.! /' 'D0 +

$ 2

4 5 ! /. %!

% ' 1 ' / 0

% ' 0 ! ) *+ ,, -."! /' 0 + $ 2

4 5 ! /' + * ,,* -.! ( ' ' ) & /.

/ , @ ' 7 *6 ,,) '-. * 5 /

) *+ ,, - ."! /' ' &/

' ' '/' : /' !" #$!$ !% &!'

!(($ )'"!* "!+

,-.

'/0

' ' 6 !

/! ,%"

5 /

-/' $B

4? '2!! : /' =E/ $3 4 5!

, -

&!'

7!+

1 ),.

8'2!3 '! 1 1 9 8 5 /

$ B

4 ? !

/' =E/ :%""

#$!$ 9 ;

9 &

' ' / 5 - /

/' / ' /' / * ' 1 ' :

/! ,%+D /'

' /' &

/' ' % ,%" ' / ( ' '

/ ' ' ' /' ' &

* '

% 6 & /

' '(

' /

' "

0 +

/' ' ' 0 +

' '

0 +

/' ' ' '

3 / /'

' / /' ) *+ ,, - ."! /' ' + * ,,* - .! /' ' '/ + &

/ / 6 ) *+ ,,

-."! /' '

' . '

!"#$ %

( )* + , -

. / 0 12 34

(6 -5 7) . 54 &. / 0 12% 894 %2: & 0

/0 1: 7 : /' '

' 6 !

/! ,%" /

/ /' !" #$!$ !%

&!' !(($ )'"!* "!+

,-.

'/0

&!* '0( <(( !

;!2!

-3

!(($ )'"!*+ 9 8-.

: !" #$!$ !% '2!! /' =E/ :%""= !

' ' 6 !

/! ,%" /

/ ' ' '/ / ' ' 6 !

/! ,%" # &:%""= !=E/-

;< = 3 & > 8 )0 12 ( 7 7 . 7 . 9 8

5 ? /0 1: @/@ && /

. 3 A

B 9 0 > ( & >)* + , ! )0 1%2 & +0 1:2

& 7

6*> 3 ( )0 1%20 68 0

: +0 > /

1: C @ +0 1:2 > 0

9 8

/7 & 0 . /

9 :/

62 6 & 62 0

9 8

/ 9 0

8% *> 0 6 @ &

8 B & . / 9 8D E&

& & &F0DE

0DE 0DE

3 & 0G

@ @ 9 DGE / @

@ & 9

& +0 1:2 &0

& . / 0 0

:2*> 6 @ &

6*>

/ /

/ // . /

3 7 .

/ % : . 0 7 . 9 8D E / . / /

DE 9 8D E 0

DE &

7&0. & 8D E /

& 6

0 0 && / 1D E . & .

G 6 & 0 & & . G

& 8D E

0 & &3 (

7. 0

& @

0 @G & 3 0 7 .

G & !

0 6 & G

/ 1D E . 0 & 9 8D E /0

HHH HHH HHH 8. & /0 /A

3 A 9I JK & / LDE&0 0 0 0 ' DE &

90 0 0 & ' DE

0 0 0 & 0 . ?& 0 0

L &

> DE 9 /3 L L

9 DGE L &

L9 D E L L L

0 & L HHH HHH HHH :3

( & /

& & &

0 0 > 0

0 0

& 0 & /

& & & / & / A 0

& / & A 0 &0

& > & / 3 & & &

9 & A D7

:/* (( -

;" 8 )/3!+ > 11

1 ?+

!@ )('3'3 !%

;"!

!%3+ > 1 8.

A"*

8 6!(+ > 8.

9E HHH HHH HHH / ) /05 B

/05& !

/0 , 9 3

& & & 0 0 F 0 0 0

0 (

/ 2G 9 & & 0 0 0

(

/1 9 0 0

0 0 F & G &

/ 6 . 9 && 0 0

& / 8 ( & (

/ 8 G 9 &

& 0

(

/ 8: G 9 &

& &

0 A

% /

A & 9 A

(

$!'+ "!!+ 7B + " "

2!7 !

2*3 $!'*

8 9>?

0 " ) ! " 33(

!7 @""

3' 0 3 7(0(

" 32(* @"$ " ( 2*

" 32(*!

0'! " "

2!7 ! !0( !! " !$"

" 32(*!

!!* " 0' @" "

3$ )!( >?

" '+ "

2!7 ! 0"

'0( 7(

< "

" <$"

'! " 0

, " !'(+ @ ((@ " 22(+ "

" <$"

'! '2"( " 7(*

8 9>?

0 " *3 4!'* )+

;" !2 2* " <M % C $3 4 5!

&!'

7!+

),.

8'2!3 '! 1 1 9

8 =E/ ;< ? 3 4 &

/ % . & I 80 1% + 0 1:8 9 0 1:0

*> 5 ? /0 1: 9

%0 1: B 8 /0

& >

/ 9 / A

% *>

& 0

/ &0 A

*> 0 0

9 85 ? /0

0 0 &

0 /

/ & ? 0 0

0 / C 0 G ? & /

9 5 ? /

*> 0 &

*> 9 & 5 9 8 9 & 9 8

0 / 0

& 0

9 /3 &0

) & ./" 8 . ;!2! !2! -

" 7+

;

=E/ . ;

3 0 1 7 . &

0 !

0 . &

(

&) !$"(* 2 ' 0* " (! '(

" !2+ 0 " *3

4!'* )+

2!7 " " $!'* "((

0 2*0( " !3 32(*3 !

*! '' !7 '"

@'( (' !$ @(( 3 &0 @

# &

& /3 # 0 9

, &

0 + * *"

,)) *7' *) "* ' ,%" 3 / : 6 !

/! ,%" '

"* :

' ' /' /' / /' * ' 1 '

/! ,%+/ 6 % ' 1 ',%" % * ' 1 ' :

/! ,%+ 6 % ' 1 ',%" .

*3 $!'*>

& 0>

N 5&

& &

N D5& 0 0 0 0

0 &

0 0

(E ,A >! 0

! & & A

A 0 @ N 5& > 0

& & 0 0 0 & N 5& D E0

& @ D,A >3 0 @ & > A G E

A D

. ?& E

8! 0

0 &

6# &

0 & & 0

0 0

D E>

& 0

& &&

!3 " 3' $!'*>

/ 0 0 0

0 0

/ 0 0

0 &

>/ 3

> 0 0 0

0 A . ?& > 0 ?& 0 N 5&

8 3

0 0 0 & 0

DOOOE

0 E

E 0

G & 0 0

0 0

0 E/

0 >

0 D 0 0

E &

6 !

> 80 & & . 0

. .&5

0 1 2 6

1 20 0 N>

A '

G &

& & & '

%/ G

(

1 20 1%03 5 . 86 2%

: / &

80 A 0 ?&

?& N 5& ?& 0 00

A 0 A A D5&

G G

> 80

2 ?& 0 0 0 & 0 0 &

% * ' 1 ' :

,%+ .

)22( !

4!'*>>

/0 F 0 0 0

0 0 ! "3$ N 5&

9 8 0 0 !"I$N 5& &

9 8 0 0 !"K$

/0 0

0 &

1 ) 22( !

2*3 $!'* ( !

" C2!* " 2! 2 " !'( "((

( 0 ! 0* " 32(*!+ " 22(

' ' ' !

" (* 2!!!$

" (3+ (3 !

$!'* '!

" )

"(( 0 7( 3!(* 0' " (3 (

2! " 22( @" " 2 2!

)* 2' " !$! "(( 0 !!! "

!(($ '"!* !

)22( !(($ '"!* !

3 P

( 0

& &

2 0 0 0 0

0 "#$

> 89 : A N !7 " " !(($ '"!* 3* 2

* 22( '!

" '0!'(+ '

' 0$ "@ 0* " 22(+ !

" C2!*

" 2 2!

" &

/- * ' 1 ' :

/! ,%+

* ' 1 '

! ,%"

( ' ' /' / /' * ' 1 '

! ,%" /' = '"'%'3! ,' ;"($*

./(%"3+

;

/ ;<

0 . /

9 :

8 /;" "3 " ) 2!

3 2!7 (!(* !7( " "!

2! (3 !!$ " !$" "

32(*

22(

!(($ )'"!* 8 &

7 @9 . 3 :"! :!!( !'3 $

- +

#8, !2 + >

8 ?E'!"!+

! (@ " " '0! ($( @""

" 2! 3 @'( 0

'(! 7! "7 * 63 & / 12:0

0 0 >/ 89 : / ) F' "!+ @'(

!(* ((@ " "'$"

" E! .2

" (* ($ " 22( !

2*3 $!'* !3 .'( " .'(+

!! " 2!'! @ '((* @!!

& .

&!3'"'

.$( -0'!

33!

00 N> L: 3 ,4 &

5 ? /0 &0

5 )+# :: : ,& 0 " '! " (!* "( " "!

'2 $!'*+ " @!%3 37 "

'"!* " 2!!2 (3 0*

!'( 0* " 2@!

!! "

!'( 3%$ '"!*L % B7. < D*!3 8"*

8$( :% - + >

--D

:3?

N> L6 / / 5 5

5 0&0

0 &&

% 8 5 ? /0

1:&

& 0

0 0 0 0 >

9 : & 0

0 0 > 0 &0 & &

0 0 & . / 9

/9 :

/ / 12:

12: 9 > & 9 > /

> 0

0 A . ?&

# 0&0

. /

5 &

. /

9 >

8 &

0 0 & 0

. /

9 > 8 &

8 0

. /

. / (

: & 5 ? /0 1:& = 9 8/0 0

( A &

> %

9 8

/ 12:0 & &

. /

2 & & 9 . <

4$"'3

6!% )$! ,'! !2

- + >

1?0. N L!& 9 :0 # &A &

9 A

9 . & 9 :0

& 7 . & 1 C 0 &0

5 ? /0

0 / / 128 12: 5 ? /0

1:0 0 &

. / 9 :

8 / /

0 9 :

: & A ?& . /

9 :

8 3 8!3

G$!"

),.

8'2!3 '!

0 9 . 9 @ . /& .

& / 9

. 9 6 4 / . A

3 4'!'"

&"( ;3

;C( !2! > ?

? . 0 " ($('!

" 7(* 2 * 2!'(!

37$

!(($ )'"!* '!

" *3

4!'* )+ B

. 0 &

5 ? /0 1: . B

7. & +7 . 0

G 6"! >

E-.

1E0

. /

5 ? /0 1: +7 . L" $!7 " 22((

37 " 2*3

$!'* ' " .2 @

'$ @!$ "! @ F'

* (* 22!"$ " !(($

)'"!* / 4 9 I

K7. G(%

6!( > ,, -.

99? & & 9 :/

0 &

L 0 & & 9 :

/L . / / 128 12: A2 " 33 8 + " @

'30$''(* 0 ( @ "

32(*!

" '* 2* $!'* @""!

22( (

;" *3

4!'* ) 2 0( ($(

(0!( !2! @'( "7 0

2 32(*+ @ "(+ 3*

3 0 @! " !$"

;" )

32 0($ " 32(*!

@'( 0 2 " 32(*!

!3 (* 3%$ 22( !

2*3 $!'* K 7 . 4!( 8!!*+ &%%($!

8$"+ :$(!

"!3'( >

,, -.

6 A

5 ? /0 1: &

60 &0 & A

( A 9 :

G . /

9 :

. 0

& 1 . /

. /

;" !'( @""

@! !3

0 ! 3!

@""

'!*

2!7

2!'(!(* !

" 33 " @!

!' 0* )3$ )

!3 )2!( 9 0* )3$

)

;" 2!7 8 32"

" " 0($ " " 32(*!

!3 3% !!$3 !

2*3 $!'* '2 " ('!

+ 2* ! " ! @""

'!(* 2!!0

#7 " 2! "

2!!0 " .'( %

!+ " .'( "3(7 (* @

" " (* " 2! " 32(*!+

*+ 0 ' '

) 0!"

" 32(*!

32(*

" 0($ '!

2!7

!'!!$ '' '

) 2 ( @(! ($(

" 32(*!

0 2!3 0* !

" @ '( 32(*$ @"

0($ " /' (3 "

32(*

E((*+ 3* 0 " "

32(*!

" !3 2* $!'*

@""!

22( ( "3

. /

: & &

2 " 3%$ 22(

" 32(*!

3!* '!

2!7 8

" '07

2!7 " + " (3 '!

.'( @""

!$$! '2 " ($ "

22( '!

.'( 07'(*

" (3 " 32(*L "+ & 6!( 8 2!7 :% -

'! 2'* -0'!

33!+

6-;

9> =

;2 % 0 ,A5

1 % 0 & & % >

&& 0

9 8 %/

& 9 8 % / 9 8 9 : /

5 ? .

0 1: 19 8/A

G 9 : 9 8 9 : /0 A & 0

5 /

& 9 :

/0 0 0 0 0 .'( !( 8 !

" ) (* '0! ($( 3 7

<M "6

' 1 ' ! /

- /' = '"'%'3! ,' ;"($*

'2!

> =

6!( 8 2!7 :% -

'2!

"7 C G!/ (( 7 .$( D -0'!

33!

/'> =

' ' '(

' /

' "# & '

/ /

/' /

' ' / : '

,%" ' #+ 'D ' : . '

"% &

' 1 ' $ ' D / ") & /

/ ./' 'D / 3 ) *+ ,,

- ."! /' ' '

(' + * ,,* -.! /' ' ", +* '

!)! *+ %(*,*+ - . )!

$ ?

$ F$0 ?

/ F$0