High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/921/2014dismissed

Chhotu Ram v. Ut Of Chandigarh

2018-05-30Mr. Justice Mahavir Singh Chauhan23 pages

""# $

%%&& '(# )*+ ,("

% -(

(. /0&+ 1 %%&&

(#2 3#%+ &-- )*+ ,("

(*(4"#1

"5+ 16 $# #( 1$ %( %%& 4

& , 8#,$ ((

% & /#,+ ,("

1 #%%&& & ,0"

"( 0( 1 #

- & # (, (,(# $%(

5( %5 +

#& %5$ + #("( # (, (,(# $%( 5

4( %(#

%( <

$%#, 8#,$ % &( (& # =

+ &%" $, (1 -&

( :

%(#(> " 4

31 & &&, .%&+ (

+ ,("

(1 ($ ( (( + ;

)5 -& ,"

& ,0"

"( %& & (" "(

*"( %(#(>+ &&5 (( ,(&+ ( "(5 .$ &&5 (( &&0 (

9+ ,("

& ,0"

-(, - 5 & & ?(2( "(5 .$ $ "$ & 0(2( , (( "( $ + ( &&0 =*" " 0(2 & & ?(2(

"(5 .$ &&5 "&& ,

(

9+ ,("

"(5+ &&5 (( $ ( $ " # &2 ( "$

+ &&5 (( ,(&

%(#(> ($ <( <2 ( :+ ("

"(5

:+ " ( 1$

+ "( %(, 5 #

#( %

( #+ # %1

" ($ "( 1 ( ' $

" 2 4# ($ %(#(> " & "( %(

$ "#%

<( <2 0" " $$ 0( "( :9 $ " & & "( " 4 2

"#% &5

$ "( @$& ( @$&"A

4 $ B>-+ ( $2 ($ B>- + (#C "(#,"

4& 85 (,(

4 D;

B>- (( 1 ($ B>-

*"((+ ;

)5 -& $1 %%&

, # $ &,& >$

%(#(>

( $ &,& >$ %(#(> # %(, !

$ 5+ "#% (( 1 $$ B>-

. 1$ 1

$$ B>- # & , $&&5 >$ . 4& $%& & 4

D#("( #( 1,

+ 1, ( && (&1 #$ ($ <( <2 ( :+ ,("

0&& ($ "(5+ (

9+ ,("

$ 0 0( ((

+ 0" &#( 4 " ($ ( ($ "&( "$+ #

4#& <( <2

& $

*" DE "$& >$

D#("( #( 1, + (( #(5 ,#( "( (&1 #$ 4"

" # 0( 2

D#("( %( %(#

"&% 2"+ 0" $ %(#(> 0&& & "&% ( -($&

@#(+ -5"( 3.+ (

+ ,("+

-(#(> ((,

" & 4 "#% (+ "( "( %(

"1 4& " # "1 %& & # $$ 0( "( &5

$ @$& # 2 "(F 0"( "( &5

$&5 5 # # ( 0"

4 "( %(#(> "0

%",(%" #%

$+ " 0 %( /$ @#$( 4& " "1 %& "( %",(%"

"#% " & & @$& 5 "$

D#("( %( %(# #( 1, %(#(> 1

"0 4"

($+ 0"( $$ "(

%& " %& 0( , %(%(

D#("( #( 1, + %& 1,

*$ # 1,

" 1( - @#&0 ,"+ 0" $ % #"

"& #%%( ) + ( 9+ ,("

. (( @$&

1 $$ B>-

# /$ @#$( ((

1 $$ B>-

# 5 ((

1 $$ B>- !

( (( #+ "5 0( , $&&5 >$ 0&& "( 4& $%& 0( 2

D#("( %( %(#

4& $%& && $%&5 0(2

<( <2

0&& "(5 0( 2

" 0( DE &5 %#(%+ %& "1 #%

&& "$

. & 2 %

(

(,(+ 5 # $

(,( (#& %( ,(& <( <2

D#("( #( 1, + " , %(%( & %& " 4"

($+ 0"( $$ & 2 %

(&1 (( (,( % , $%&5

" # % %",(%" 0&& 1,(%"

&&5 "&&

%( &5 , "#%

,"+ @$&+ /$ @#$( 5

%( %(# %(#(> &&5

(( ,(&+ ($ $ $+ " ((,

$ + ((

$ "% ,"+ @$&+ /$ @#$( 5

"( $

(( " "0

%",(%" #%+ " 8 " %( 0" & # 0( "(

($ "&( "$

"( $ ((

+ " ""# $+ 0" #(5 3#( "(5 & # 4 "(

($ $$ " " %",(%"

&%%

"( #%%&$ (5 $ ((

+ :

+ " 1 ,"+ ",0

0&& <("

@#$( 0"

%",(%" 0( "0

&%%" " %( & $$ 0( "( 0"

" "(5 1 ,"

",0

0( $%&5 "(5F 0"( <("

$%&5 31( # &&5 ( "&( (

+ ,("+ " # $ &1( "(5

D#("( %( %(# %(#(> ,1 4("

$& "&

4& $%&

0&5 4(

"& "( 0&& "( 0

4& $%& 0( < (%( 4& $%& && #% 0( &(5 2

%(#

#( 1,

0( DE &5 %#(% < (%( 4

(1 ""# $ 4&,& "( "& %(#(>

%%&& ""# $ & ,0"

"( # 0( "(, " %# "4& #

, ;-+ "5 %&

,#&5 &$ (& * #%%( 1( %(#

>$ &&0 0

-?+ -(, - 5 $%&

-? (-($&

@#(+ -(( 3.+ (

+ ,("

$$4( $$ # & # 1$ -? %(#(> -?

' 1 (+ "(5+ (

9+ ,("

-? (- $ 3&+

$4( $& 4(+ 0" # $&,&&5 >$

%(#(> -?:

( "( 3& 3.+ (

+ ,("

-?9+ 2"

<#( "(5 -?!

E5 4& )" - 3#( #5

<( <2 ( :+ ,("

-? 3

& ?&( %($ + ,("+ 0" %(1 %% $ &( @$&+ 5+ @$&"+ /$ @#$( "#% ,"

(1 @#(+ 3.+ (

+ ,("

$4( ( # $&,& >$

%(#(> -? . " ,"+ -",(%"( . %(1 %",(%" B>-

B>- B>- B>-

,1 B>-

B>-:

-?+ ('%

@#"&+ + 3.+ (

+ ,("

. " 1( (( B>-:

B>-9 1,

-?+ -(, - 5 $%&

#(2" "($+ ( + B4&"$ + 3.+ (

+ ,("

" %(1 %% $ &( B>-!

%% $ &( -(, - 5 "( (,

B>- -? ;

" @#$( $4( 1,

$ -? ;

@#&4( @#( -?:+ (8 "

+ & (+ 3.+ ( :+ ,("

. %(1 4& $%& #"

($ %%&& -?9 81

3("(+ /# ( (+ DE+ (

:+ ,("

. %(1 < &5 (%( B>-

( ""# $ 4&,& "( $& "& %(#(> -?!

(%2 2" . # $&,& >$

/$ @#$( %(1 " E B>-!:

-?+ (-(8 . >$ ",0

G1 %(1 " E B>-!9 -?

( 2 " ,( " %(1 4& #"

($ B>- - -9 -?+ (%2 "($

. # $&,& >$

8 (+ <("

-& 1 %(1 "( E B>-!!+ -

- B>-! %

0"(45 " % "(

" #,, "5 0( %4& %(($ >#& (#(

-? . G"%&+ ($

. %(%( & %& <( <2 ( :+ ,("

"(5 # &&5 ( "&(

(

+ " ,("

-? 4& $ +

. # 1,(%"5 %& #(( %(1 B>- -

4& /,(%+ -",(%"(

. %(1 %",(%"

,1 "(5 B>- -

-?+ -(, - 5 $%&

-? + 4& 8 -&+ -",(%"( . %(1 %",(%" 31 # &&5 ( "&( (

+ ,("

,1 B>- -

-?:+ %( )5 -& ,"

. %(&5 1, -?9+ ;

"# ,"+ ?$

&&+ ( 9+ ,("

. %(1 B>- !

- -?!+

. " ,"

. %(1 B>-

- -?+ # ?(

"(5 .$

" " 1( (( "(5 - @#&0 ,"

%(1 B>- B>-

2 " " #%( <( <2 ( :+ ,("

(&1 $ " " 1( #5 (( 1,

$ -? - @#&0 ,"

1, (

-? (< "#"(5 " $&,&&5 >$ ""# $ %(1 " E B>- :9 -?

( %

@#$( @#"&+ & #%( + 3.+ (

+ ,("

. %(1 %%& ($+ 4 %% $ &(

B>- :!

B>-

$ %%&& (( #

(-+

&& ($ (#$ %%(

%(#

1 0( %# "$+ " %& & $%&

>$ ? % + #%( + <( <2 ( :+ ,("+ ? ( ( #%(( ( "(5+ ( ,("+ ?

/%& "($

0( ,&5 ? ($ , & #

&&5 . %% "&( (

+ ,("

(1 @#(+ + "(5+ (

9+ ,("

"( 1

( %%(& 1 + (& 1 $%#, 8#,$ (( + 1 # %%&&

(( 41 # "#% ,"

%%&& 0( & 1 1 8#,$ (( 1

,,(1 , 8#,$ (( + % (& #(+ " & %%& # "#% ,"

"( "1 & %((( %( %%&+ "1 4

$ 1 8#,$

! 9 !

! 9 (. /0&+ 1 %%&& " $ (C# 0"(0& %( %%& .01(+ %(5( $ &&0

"#,"

&( # & %%&&

%( " %%&

$(+ "01(+

5 #(+ ( 1

(( 4

(

(%1 (&

# "#% ,"+ @$&+ 5+ <("

@#$(+ 1

,"+ /$ @#$( + 8 ,"

",0

G1 "1 &(5 4

8#,$

! 9 %

+ (%1 %%& & "$ "1 &(5 4

$ #%%&& ""# $ % #(5 ,#(

"(5+ (

9+ ,("+ 0"( %(#(> " ($ <( <2

"( >$ "+ %(#(> % "(5+ ""# $ "( # $$ >#& (#( "( " & % ""# $ % , "(5 " $$ >#& (#( "(

4"($ $A

81 3("( -?9+ /# ( ( (& D( E4((5+ (

:+ ,("

& 1 (%( B>-

""# $ 4&,& "( "& 4(

%(#(> C# "1 4

(%&5 (% "$

(< "#"(5 -?

+ %(1 $ &,& (%( ""# $+ 4&" " 4&,& "( %(#(> "(

" #,, " %4& %(($ >#& (#(

10 %1 ("(," $ %(#(> ((4(1 1 + &( (& (,"&5 1 &# %%&& ""# $ .01(+ ( %

""# $+ 0" 4

$&&5 %(1 4&,& "( "& &1( %(#(>+ #," "1 4

0( ( >$%&(5 + 0"& $#((( (5 %"5& ($ 1$+ (% ,( & #& "&%& $&

. H4& #%($

!! "

# $%&$ ''( )*%'+,-./0,1 0%21,--

# 3#$ ''( )%4 .55-6!%(7( 6%'..88

(#$ + " % &&0 ((

! 9 =*" %( %%& ( , 8#,$ 1

(( % &( (& #(+ 1 %%&& & ,0"

"( # %(

5( (,(# $%( "

- & %5

6 "

#& %5$ #("( # (, ;

D( ($

%( < !

+ (,( #

- & -&

( :+ ,("

E( # & %%&& 2 0"(0 %( %%& $( "( & ,0"

"( 4"

%%& ( "( &( # & %( "1 , "(#,"

((+ %(1 & 10 %(#

" & # 1 $2 # $

(( ( ,&5+ %%&& # "0 # 0"5 0( "$

$6 " %%&&

& /&+ ,("

,(5 ( $$# (( "(#,"

#%( + & /&+ ,("

10 41+ %( %%& (( ,(, ($ 4"

%%& + )*+ $ (

& %%&6 (1

& 8#,$ 6 (( +

(#$ + (*(4"#0

"5+

1+ 0" %(

#(+ %% $# #(

4"& 1$ - ,

9A . H4& #%($

!! "

# $%& 9 (0 6!%1

# =

? 0#& ( & (C# %%&& %($ "$ 0"(0 %%& ? "1

5 ( "( %( "1 4

%($ 1 + # "0 #

%%&& " $

42(%+ 0

%($ %%&& 0"(0 %%& ? 5 4# "0 #

# %%&&

($ (( !"

%$4(+ :+ 0&& "1 2

&,& 4 #4 1 %( , (44& 8#(

%%&& #

( (

($ & -(#( + 9

(- +

+ %& (5 8#(

#%($ "0 #

" $ $# %(

%( %& # (&5 >%

*#( 6 #'

% : ''(

) #% .5/-0,1 ;<-

+ $%& #( % 5 %%& , C#& 4( .,"

"((+ #(, %%& " 4 *" (8 %& #+ "1 # %%& 4 &5

4(1

%%& , C#& ( .,"

#(+ 4$ #5 .,"

$ ((%1 %%&&

%(# ( # 4& %(# (

( "( %%&5 $ &,5 # $# "0 #

" $ # ( "( 4"

+ 0&& #5 $ ((%1

0 %(# " %%& , 1

; $5 %% & ((

( % 2$''( )

,--;0;1 0% 21..8,--;0/1,</ %<1

%(,(%"

(%( %

" $ # 4# %(%(

&0 #( "#& "(

$( & 1

"#,"

%( " %%&

$( 4( .,"

+ " %((( %%& , (# 1

4( ; 0&& 4&" %

&0 #( "(

" $ + "&

' # !%: #(''(

) 74.5<<0,1 5;

/#,+ 0&& "1 (," & "0 # , " 1

"0 # 0"5 " "#&

# 3# 9 ( 0 6!%1+ . H4& %> 4(1 # =<0+

%( %%& & #

1 , (( % & /#, < %%& & #

, 0( (& #( #

6 ;-

,(#

C#5 <( .,"

>( # $# (1 & %0( #

9 (

; .,"

$ " %(%( #( >( # $# %0( #

9 (

" $ " 1

C#5 ?"# &&0 #"

%(#(

.,"

%%& & 1 " " A

10 &0 & 0

( #"(+ >( (1 & %0( (( #

9 (

(- %%&& "0 #

0"5 0( "$

$6 " 1 ((

! 9

(% "+

"( %%&& 0&& " # & 0( # !

41+ "1

4"& 1$ (*(4"#1

"5+ 1 %% $# #( ,("

$ (

& %%&

$( " $ 0( %%&&

4"& %%&& + 4

#4$ %%&& + 0" & (% 4&5 ( "( $ ( #,"(+ &(5 # (, %%(>$&5

5( $%(

%#(# 8#,$ 0( "$ C# %#(% "$ &(5 "1

. #("( #("( $%" (($1

%(,$ %%("+ ( $&5 %%&& %

"( " + &( $# #( #4$ #& , (% ( ,(15 + $

( >#

(%(#

1$+ (#$ && " $ $% 1$ %( 5

, (& E( # &

%%( )*+ $ (

& 1"$ &5 %(5 " $

0( %%&& "1 "( &( # & %( %(# ((

. H4& #%($

#47% $ ''(0

)(2# 10,-.=1/// 4(1 #

-( &5+ 0 "&& %( & 8#

E( # & %%&& + 0#& #4$ "#,"

%(1

(,(# $%( &+ 5 $ $#$

5( %#&+ "#& (# %# "$

5( (,(# $%( ; #(, "$ %%&& "( #( "&(

"( &1 0#& (# $%( & ($ ( -( @#"+ ( '

&($ + # & + #4$ ($ 4 " #+ $%

4&#&5 8#

0(( (( ; & 1 "$ (#

0#&

"$ % 8# %# "$ -($(&5 4(

$ & ,& $% (,( 4 "

#( $

(

$$ # $ & %#(% $%

%( %& $# (& ($ $$ "$

&5 (

" & 4# & 15

& 4( %#(% 8# %# "$ , 1#&

5 #&$&5 # &&1

#( $ ,

($ ; (1 (( *(# +

(

+ %%(# $5 ,( 1 (($ "$& 4# C#&&5 (# %( %& %(%( &5 40

$$ % &5 $% ( 2%

10 ?"& ((5 # $%&> >(+ 4&,(5

%( $%

5 0"& ($

$$ &&1 0&& (%(#

>+ 0 $5 (( %( %( # $

7((2 $''( ) ''% % ( # 0,-.-1.,<=,+ 0"(

#(+ %2 4# % + & 0

#5 1(5 #( 0( %(%( "1 (,(

#( $

(

># ( $$ #( ( >% ( && (&1 (#$ 4(

%( $% $$ #( ,(15

# 2( # $'# '#(%$''( ) 6&%' '#(% 0,-->1,=<5+ 4(1 "#

=D($

" E0

, 5

= ($ & &0 # "#& 1 (&

& # 5A *"((+

%( 5$+ &0 "#& % ((1 $" (5 ( (( 4

#& $(> $#& %( (

0"( "#& 4+ $%( $(5 0"( 0(( ,1

(#$

#( ($+ $

(

$$+ $1 $$

($+ # #+

#( 0% # && "( (#$ ( (&1 0#& ( ( (

''( ) $6220,--81.,=;+ 0 &( /#,+ 0"& & 4# C#5 + "1 >%( "#

= -# "$

( ,$ &0 $$ "$ %(

( $$

# ,#&5 $% #(+ #5 #( $%

"$ #"

%((4 &0 0( C# &

& 1

1, %(

4 1

0"#

4 $% "((

48 %# "$ 4

# &5

2 6%4? @ )32

'&;;

! "#

=*" $ %# "$ (

0 ( ((4# 8#+ (( + (($

%&5 (& $4

1(& ( && " $ ((4#1 &$ "0 %#4& (1#&

%# "

" 0( # % 8#

$ %# "$ $ 4"

%# "$ "#& & &2 "#& (1 $&( %# "$

( ,&5 $%( % %# "$ (( ( $ ((

&5 #& ($ #("( 4# & % & ( ($ 4(2 &0 $%( (($

,(0 $%" & #%

$#"

&,& 4# 8#& %

0( %(#&( $ 1( ("4&

0&&

##&&5 ( %( 1( (( $

$ %# "$

8#& "#,"+ "01(+ && %(

5 "( 48 (C# &5 (1 &5 (5 (

( 4 A $%" #%%&A

!2 3#$''( ) ''%+# 0,-.=1/ <;<+ 0"& & %"&%"5 8# %# "$ &&1 (5 5+ 0/#, "

8# %# "$ 0#&

( & 8#& (

<"( %( & %(%

/#,

( & "( $(& 1

( "5%"& %%(" "#& &&0 "1 %&5 D( 1(5 + ( $#(

"#," $&(&5+

&&0 ( & 5 &&5

,(# (

(& (C# 0,"

(#$

($ 4

$$ "( $ ( :

( #"( &

, (& 1(# %+

$&5+ ,(15 + $

( ># $%

5+ (%(#

1$ %(%( &5 %# "$ "1 4

$%"I #%

" + 0 ( ( 8#

& $%(

(% $$

," 5( & ,(&+ "&%& 1#& (4& +

05+ "%& 1$ 4"

%"5&&5 %5"&,&&5 1#& (4& ; 0("5

2 >#& #& &05 4

10 (# 15 9

!2 *++ $ $2 6(4

'#(%0.55,1=,-;+ 4

4(1 &&0 = "#,"

&& >#& #&

$& "&(

(

(%(

$ &," 5 "(

&($ "2 ( >#& $$

"&(

*" # ( "&(

( , ( (% (

4& ( ( 4$ 5 %(5 &#5 4(# 0" %&5

# (#%#&#+ #& # ( &#( $& "&(

5# ,(& *"((+ #"

( 0" ( 1&I 5 "#& $(&&5 >(4&5 %# "

1( ($A

&# %(,(%"+ . H4& %>

#("( "& # =; $&5

&,&#(+ 0"& %((4 $ $#$ ($ "&&

& "

5(+ & %(1 $5 > #% & &,&#(+

0$+ & (

&$ & "( + 4

>%( , ( %( ( ( ($ , 0$

," 5( & ,(&+ 0" #%% % $

"(#& + & $& %

"( , 5 %#(5 %"5& ($ "( %&," "& "2 #( "(

0&& 1#& ($

"& % &5 (( % C# $5 1&I 5 , & 0 5 ="& , %(1 A ( (&$ 4#(5 5# ,(&+ &#> $+ 0#& ,(0 (#$ >%( +

# (,4& "$ " "&& &05 "# $$(5 (%& "15 (#"

( &5 " "&& ( % ( "(

,"$("

$& "& " $5

4& ( " #( 0$

#& "( % (%#

5 "0 4 1&5 1& 5 < $$4( 5

( 1 "

( "&&0

" #( 0$

" 2

&5 &$ 4& 4# & %&(4& ; 0#&

>,,(

5 "#," #&&5 %"5& ($ 0$

% 1&I

($+ + =%"5& $(&5A

%"(+ $%#5

($ 5#"#& >$

%& ; "#& %($#

1(5 J $ "+

" + 5 0"&

%("

($ %#&% 4# &+ $ %&& C#&5 > +

"(+ $ %(1( $$4( $ 5 "#$ I 0$

2 "( 45 (# "( "5 ;

1#&5 "( , 5 0$

$ " "#& &, &5 (1&

% $ (# 4#(& "( , 5

(2 ; ($ , "&5 45 0$

#& 5 #"

($ ,,(1 $

(

$$ ? "1 $%"

( 4#+

%( + 1$

," 5( & ,(& 0" %4&5 0#& %(1 ($ =%( EA $," %5"&,&&5 $%&& ($

=*($ ? (A ?"

" #(+ &&1 &(, & #( #"

,#&( ($ (

$%"( ( "(&&5 4"(( 5 ; $ 8# %# "$ ($ #( #"

$ + #( &0 ( 4# (% 0"

&,& %($( ; $ 8# 0( %# "$

&,&1 $$ (

#(A

& ," %(#(> &&5 ($ # "& & ,

! 5( &+ 0" %#

( #5 && 0"$ 4(5 (# (%

"$ "( %(( ,#( (%&5 #48 "( , (% # (# &5+ & "( %(, 5 "( &1( "&

%( "2 >$%& %(( #( %(( (# #( ($ ( &&5 ($ ,(& =# 4& &2 ( "(&A =# 4& "(& & "( 0

1A %( $& %

B> -

?-!9:

.( & , ( 5( =-K:

#,,1 $& & ((

$& 4( #

(

( 0( %

(,( ($

%(, 5 1$ C# (%

%( $$ "#$ 4(4( #%

"( #5

(#$ + 0( %%&&

$$ #( # ($ *"((+ & (( 0"( " $ 0( %%&& 0(( $%& 8# (% ( 1$ C# &5+ 0( %%&& "(45 " ($

5( & $%(

6 $% &( (& #& %#&

"&& ($

# &(

E( -#4& -(#( % # #( % 5 %%&+ 1$ 4

$%&5 "(5 .$+ ,("

)* ,("

$ (

"&& # &2 ( 1$ "( "& && " $8(5 9 *" %&

(( %%(

( (

&( $# #( !

(( %&#(

((

-#4& -(#( 4( (& $ "1 4

C#&5 #4C# &5 (

E,& $$4( (+ )*+ ,("

%5 8#,$ (( -(# )* ,("

15 %

,#"

" (+ 1

"5 "1 #%(

0 1 ,1

A#('#(% !(+ 3B%( ( ( B

A#('#(%%(!

%'2(C (