High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/7521/2025allowed

Kulwant Singh v. State Of Punjab

2025-02-14Mr. Justice Sandeep Moudgil14 pages

!"#$%$

! "

$$$ '( ) %

#*+"# &

'() * +,+) - - ./ * %, ,% ,' +,+'

'%0 '+, '12 '13 '1( '3% +,% )' %+,4 /5

* / 566 6 ! 6 57

! " #$ %& '%$()% * # # +,-.

% ! (* ! +% & / 0 "

#$()%/*!() ,&1( * 2 # #3 &# #2 + #

*4( *** ,-56 + ! 7+ ! 86 &)+ ( +# # + ! 86 ! ! #$+*!86. !( * 896 (+ ! !*

'% . * . . !% 1( *

! #$+*! #7+ !$(

'%.* ..% *

#0 (( * + 0 *# 7+ ! +* (2*5 #* /(* '0 *# 07+ !*+ .

*(* + ! (86#

* %&)+ ( ( %! !

(* + !*# + * # *# 7+ !

(2 + *# 7+ ! #

( + -(**(*. ! ( ** (+ ! #* #2 + # + + !*&)+ ((* # +

*# (# *(* * ( #+*4* #

++ % +

( # . ( + + +* *# 7+ !* * # * % *+ (** # *#2 + # * *5:;:;#

(

+ !%+ ( *# 7+ ! + # * * * (

* #$ + # * (*. ! **< (+ ! #

+ * *(*=+ !7+ !# 0 + (* ( *

+* *# <*+ /(* +=(

*#2 + # * *5::; * -% 2 +* # * * # #2 +

* # *# > #

* + + !4( * + ** #*; 50#

( #+#&)+ (* *5::;* ** #?* 50#

( # (*! !* *5:;:;* * ( (#2 + # * * + ( ** .*+ . !* (+ ! 2 + + # #2* (.

*# 7+ ! 4( * + # #

(

+ !

% ** 2*

# @0 * ** (

+ # A + *# + %* #* (*# ( ##(

2 (* * .# % 1( * *( * * #2 + * *5::; * *(* ( + ** ( (*

#( 4( *** * (* (* # *#(* ( * )( * * (' *!*:-% ! # $+* ! # 7+ ! $( B /(* +.* .%* #0 ( ( C55;5; 5;2 (D * 5:;5:;%

* *# ## #**

"$ & '!!$()" *>##? 55: * 2-5 * ;5 ; >## #

" #$ & ' * *# " #$ %& ' % 2* 7!>##

# " #$ %& ' ( % + ! #7+ ! * ..#*

;* * ;555; ## #** "$ & '% !!% * # ## #**

" #$ & '!!$()% : * 2-5 & '* *;55; * >## #

" $ & ' # . " #$ %& '% % 2*

* 7!%>## #

" #$ %& # %+ + 5 ( 1( # % +# (* !& #( %+ *# 7+ ! #" ! #&!* /(* +%* ..+

+% +$(%* ..%7 *

;5-;5% + 59* ( 9% ( 5::98-56* ( 9% ( ::;:5:58- ;6%::58-;6%::58-;6%::58-;6::598-;6%::5:58-56% :5:58-56::5:58-56* ( 9% ( 5::5:58-6%5:::8-565:::5:85-6%::55:585-6%::8-;6% ::9:589-56* ( 99% ( :::85-56%::9

8-;6* ( 9% ( ::5;:85-6%:58-;6* * ( 9% ( 5::58-565::5:8-;65::; 8-;6%5::58-;6%5:::58-6%::55:58-5;6* ( 9%

( ::58-;6* ( 9 :58-;6% :58-;6%:::58-6%::5;:585-56%:::58-5;6* ( ;% ( ::5:8-6%::5:5:585-6%::5:589-56%::; 8-;6% ::5 8-;6% :::5 89-56% ::59::8-6% ::5: 89-56% ::9:89-56 ;5 0<5;5: ( 50*(* +* + * + 7+ !. 7+ ! +

% * $+*!8# # 6*

( + !&-5 * # %7+ !< + !&-5* #

+ !&-5+ +*( * *( =( #+7+ !4* + !&-5* # #

( (

*+ + # + 5-;-;%

+ !&-5 ( # (

"(! #E!%* "*2 %

.. ## 7+ ! ## #!(- & - ( #2*/**

#7+ !% 4( * #2 + # 5 #

(%* * ( 50 ( *

+ 7+ !#

(*. !( * #*+ * * # (7+ ! 1(* *

* + # ++ 5-;-;* * 5-;-; ## # !(-& -96 ( 1( %

* + # 54( *# !(- & %

* # ** *

# (7+ ! #4( # + # +

*# ## # !(-& -%* # + *( *# +% $( ..%E! ! 0(2 ! ( * 7 * ! * # "(*

!% (+*! !*0 ! "(* !' * 7+ ! #" ! * # %( * + # ** *( 9;59%( + *#2 7+ ! * # 0+% * # #

##27+ !* #*

*9;59 *# # !(-& !+ * # "*2 % . .%!0*!*( * ! !% + * * " + # * **( 9;59%( *#2 7+ ! "(!&- #E!%* 7+ ! #" ! * #

( 1( # % # * "(!&-+ *%+ #* *

* */* 9;59 #7+ ! % ( *

2*( + # 5 (* * #

"$ + # 5 * *5;;% #"$ + # 5* * 5-;-;% + ! #7+ !* /(* + ** ..8&-564( * ** #

** #7+ !% (;25 ** 9#

( #&)+ (&-* * (25 ** #

( # +! !8 # 6>

***% ( ( ;;%* *-;-; #

( #&)+ (8&-6*0( ;;%* *-;-; #

( #! !8 # 68&-6 *% *. !&- #=( !*

+* ..* (+ !&-9

!* +%* .. + ** ( +# (* +7+ !%*# # ! 2 +

25 *+1(* + !8&-56*( -- + &)+ ( 8&-6 +# + ! * * ! ! 8&6 # $+* ! #(*(

#* * + % *7+ !#*/ !( /!--; # E <** / 7(*%..* +

# #**# *"$ + # 5* * 5-;-;* ( ***4( *

#"$ + # %+*# !$2)B % ** / 7(*8! 6* 4 * # ;;;. # *@ * + #F * # ?*/ ( 5; ( % +

(* 5;; + #

+ # * **%<( *. !&-% #=( !%*

+%* ..%* ;;;%7+ !%*# # ! *+ /

#* # *+ 55. # * #

7+ !%

* ((* $+*!%*+% ** *;5;; !$2)B ** / 7(*8! 64* + 5 # %

;* * ;555;( * + !&-5 $+*!* &* % + !&-5%$+*! #7+ !* !/-5 */ ( & ,

# **( 1( # #% # (* *# # ! 7+ ! #" ! #&!*

+% .. +*25 * B/(* +%($(% ..% + ! 8&-56 +

. !( *8&-6* (+ !8&-96

!*"(!8&-6 #E!%*

"2%* ..%+ *#(* # 7+ !8*# # 6% %"( !8&-67+ !* #7+ !<#2 **9;59% 4( * #2 + 5 5-;-;** #7+ ! ( 25 % ( * +* . .% #!(- - "$ +

# 5* *5-;-;% (+ !*. ! ( * #*+ * #* #27+ !.# % # *#2"$ + #

5* *5-;-;% + !8&-56%#2

*%4( **** *5;; * 2 9 #

( #&)+ (*4( * ** # * ( 5 * 2(#

( # +! ! ( # * ( #; 5 0 # 7+ !%( +% #

***% ( ( ;;* *-;-; *

#&)+ (8&-6*0( ( ;;* *- ;-;@ * #

( #! !8 < 6 8&-6( *. !&- #=( !*

/(* +% * . . * (+ ! 8&-96

!* +%* .. +

***> +% #% ##(*! 5%;%9%%%5% $/ +# (* * ( * + !8&-56 #7+ !* + ** . .% . !( *( * 8&-6 * # /(* + ** ..% (+ !8&-96

!* B/(* +.* . .*"(!8&-6 #E!* "*2 ..%. !( *8&-6 #=( !* /(* +% ..** 5- ;-;* # +% (#* * &)+ (8&-6+# + !* /(* +%.* . *! !8&- 6 #$+*!* #B/(* +.* * ..%++ ***( #

% + ! &-5

; * * ;555;+ * $+* !! # *

* ( 1( % ( * + ! $+*!* + !/-5%* * *5;5;%+#* !/-5 + !&-5 * % *% * + !&-5

;

* + !&-5 #**#59& * , ** * + !8&-56 #7+ !* /(* +%. * . . (+ ! 8&-96 !

# !% * #B/(* +.* ..* "(!8&-6 #E!%* "*2%

..(* 5%;%9%%%5% $/#

? # * $ ! & #

# * *( % *

** :**( * (*:& ( * !*:- 7!>## # "$ % & ' %

* + 1( ## # " #$ <& ' # % " #$ & '

++ 1( % 1(

+ ** " #$ & ' !! * ## ( -9$% * * 5;;# *B* ## ;5 *

2-5& '* *;; #** "$ & '!!$()%

?* %& '!!%+ + + !() & *

(

!* #* ..% * ( ( ; + ! ( -55:

:& * * :;:; #

!* () ":& ': * *5;;* * * (* * . ! (* 56 + ! # 4( **# #2 + # & * # ##% ":& ': + * *5;; **

* 56 + !6

(+ !6"(! :5%;%9%%5 $/ # * *( > # # ":& ': * # *% * * + *#(* # 8*# # 67+ !%*(# % *"(!7+ ! 5;; #7+ !<#2**9;59 **# *"$ + # 5* 5 0 * 7+ ! /(* +% . . # !(-& - #

( (+ !*. ! * + + # 5 * * #27+ !.# % # *#2 "$ + # 5* *5-;-;% + !% #2 *%4( **** *5;; *

2 9#

( #&)+ (*4( * ** * ( 5 * 2( #

( # +! ! ( # * ( #;

50 # 7+ !%( +% #

***% ( ( ;;* *-;- ; * #&)+ (*0( ( ;; * *-;-; * #

( #! !8 <

6( *. ! #=( !* /(* +%* ..* (+ ! !* +%* .. 7 +

***? > - * # # ":&

': * # % # ## 56

+ !6 (+ !6"(!(:! 5%;%9%%%5% # $/ * # #

*( % (* * *:*(* * # * !E> $ ! & % * * # %

( ; + !# (* *#% * 1(* * ## + % * 2

(+#* !*:-

& '% +** "$ % & '!!%$()# &

'% *& ? ;9 * 2-5& * *;; * % # # ?+ >## * !

5* * 5;5;%** "$ & '!! * * #@& 3 &* +@* + !

;* *;555;% * ## % # 3 &(* 5%;%9%%%5 $/ * 56 + ! #7+ ! * B/(* +%.* ..6 (+ ! !* +.*

..6"(! #E!%* B "2% . .% % + 1( * #3 &**

B) ( : # #( ! ##*

+# * (+/ #3 & 1 0 # # / ( 5 * * ;5;;@ ) ,-."-./,-$

-0"1*23,3.1"4"././,-"# 8

# 7 6

+ 7 --

./ 6 -

- #9

- - 6

%, ,% +,+2 - # 6 ,2 ,+ +,+2

+3 : # ;

6 9 9 < - 6

4 67

# -

7 # - - ,' ,+ +,+2

#7 5 5 442'0%4 +,+2

;

7 ./ 6 - #7

7 - -

-0"1*23,3.1".*."

= 5

# 4

9 < - 9

# ) 6

++ 7 8 5 6 /- - =

7 - -

#6 #7

-*2+$/$

7 6

7 ) 6

++ 7

+ 7 --

7 # -

6 "

- 7 -

#7 # # 9

%, ,% +,+2 - # 6 ,2 ,+ +,+2

+3 : # ;

7 9 5 <7 < # 6

-6 ;

5 >

! 9 # -

;

-6

4 G #(* ( # )((* ( # % * ( # (*( E + % ( ++ ( * (*+ * # ##( ** * # #(* ( ##H #

( )((* # (*( ) 8+ 4 + (64

# ( % # #+ ( * **# *.* *

( )((* ( . * ( * # * # )(* *( % 4

#)(** ( * ( * ** / ( * E/ ( ( H % +

* (* * # * ( # ' % # * ** + (* + * *( + (

+ * #( + # ##* #* (* *( % (* * ( #

)(*( * # #* ! % + (*+ # # ##*+ * +1(* ##!( %#(* *# ## **( (*4*# # *% + (* # )(*+ (** *

# )(* *+ (* # - ##* (* ##*# % ( #( ##* *( .

* ** ( #(* 4 # * $ 2

# A4 # / * / $ *(% 5 1( #

2 $ / * #/ $ *(%5 9.

( %( (*1(* * *

)(*%+*+ # *(

(* ( * )(*( * . # (* * # (* % +

% 1( # 5 # / ( * #

(

+* %* *

* / ( &- ( / * 5$ %;586&/&8/ 65,;5896 & 47(* 8&76;,8;565;!//9

. 2 (* #

# *(* 4* * * * 2.*! *%;5856!/?A; 2 * # 0/ * % #+ * "(2!! ! #$()% 85;6!//99+ * +*+ 2 * -A % &5/( + *( &#+ *

A E( % &55*9+ +

* # (*#( 4 .

# # - * *

# ( *% 2 * E + %+ (* (*

* (* * . #( #

+ * # )(* * ( * (# *% ( 4*)(* ( * ( * % * # # ( % 2 #(

I & 5 6

- 7

+% 5 /

& -

;

$% "

& ' ()

) 9

# < - 9

- #

- 9 9

"2/"3

/ 9

- -

7 # 5 ?!

7 - 9

7- #

;

6 &

9 ( ) (* ' 2: * H:

' H: