Universal Sompo General Insurance Company Ltd v. Banita And ORS
!"!
!""#$%
!&'('
)
*
!' +$,!$%'
# $% #! & # &!'!$% -
&
./% 0($, ,2+3#%!
# '!( %) 66&/!2!, &!$,!&!,
+%+&
33/,!$%'
"#/.'
&/8($#"1 :5#;;#&1 $'(&#$3!
&!4!&&!,
/$'%#$% # !#"
)&/!4"9 '%#%!,1 4#3%'
#&!
/$%!&2!$/$6
$/65% <= +$!
5
:#68/&
'/$3!
,!3!#'!, 3+./$6 4&+.
(&(6&#.
5/'
5+('!
/""#6!
55#&# 2/# )#5#,(&6#&5 5/'
3#& .#>!
?#6+$ 8!#&/$6 *@AA1 8!/$6 ,&/2!$ 5/.
.+,!&#%!
' !!,
?5!$ &!#35!, ($,!&89 #''
4"9+2!& $!#&
+""!6!1
)#5#,(&6#&51
&(3> 8!#&/$6 &!6/'%&#%/+$ *A= 1
8!/$6 ,&/2!$ &!' +$,!$% &#'5 $!6"/6!$% .#$$!&1 3#.!
4&+.
'/,!
)!&/ 5/% 3#& ,!3!#'!, :#68/&
'
&!'("%1 5/'
3#& 3#(65%
4/&!
:#68/& 5/.'!"4 3+(", $+% 3+.!
+(% 4&+.
3#& ,/!, ,(!
8(&$/$6
!' +$,!$% 4"!, #7#9 4&+.
' +% #4%!& "!#2/$6
+44!$,/$6
,!#, 8+,9 ,!3!#'!, :#68/& &!.+2!,
!$!&#"
*+' /%#"1 )#5#,(&6#&51 %5!&!#4%!& &!4!&&!, 1
+5%#>1 75!&!
+'%.+&%!.
!B#./$#%/+$ 3+$,(3%!,
33+&,/$6"91
= ($,!& !3%/+$'
A C
&!6/'%!&!, +"/3!
%#%/+$ #,#&1 )#5#,(&6#&5 '%#%!.!$% +$!
#%8/& <+ #.
0/'5#$
3"#/.
!%/%/+$ 3"#/./$6 '
"#>5 4/"!, 3"#/.#$%'
+$ $+%/3!1 &!' +$,!$%'
# !#&!, 4/"!, %5!/&
'! #&#%!
7&/%%!$ '%#%!.!$% ,!$9/$6 #33/,!$% 3#('!, ,(!
&#'5
$!6"/6!$% ,&/2/$6 *A=
% 4(&%5!& '(8./%%!,
/$'(&#$3!
3+. #$9 "/#8"!
#9 #.+($%
!' +$,!$% A$'(&#$3!
4/"!, '! #&#%!
7&/%%!$
'%#%!.!$% %#>/$6 &!"/./$#&9 +8;!3%/+$'
,!$/!, #33/,!$% 7!""
"!#,/$6'
!%/%/+$!&'
&+.
"!#,/$6'
#&%/!'1 4+""+7/$6 /''(!'
4&#.!,
+%+& 33/,!$%'
"#/.'
-
D
!" # $#
%$ % &'()
*
+,$- *$ ". %
+ /0&& ! 1 1 +
2 2
2/0&& -
/0& 3
+ 2
/0&$- .
!
% /0&$- 4 5
#&%/!'
"!, %5!/& !2/,!$3!
$ 8#'/'
!2/,!$3!
#,,(3!,
8+%5 #&%/!'1 ''(!'
,!3/,!, 4#2+(& !%/%/+$!&'
''(!
#&%"9 ,!3/,!, 4#2+(& !%/%/+$!&'
?/%5 &!6#&,
''(!'
1 /% 5!", 2/+"#%/+$ %!&.'
3+$,/%/+$'
$'(&#$3!
+"/39
33+&,/$6"91 2/,!
1
%+%#"
'
1A1@=<
#7#&,!, 3"#/.#$%'
&!' +$,!$%'
1 5!", ;+/$%"9 '!2!&#""9 "/#8"!
#9
#.+($% ,/&!3%!, 8!
/$,!.$/4/!, &!' +$,!$%
A$'(&#$3!
5#2!
5!#&, 3+($'!"
6+$!
%5&+(65
4/"!
@
#""+7!, 3"#/.
&!./'!,
4+""+7/$6 &!#'+$/$6 -
63 7
%
8
!"
)
*
1
)
1 91:;& 2 &! < * 2
;
2
2
2
,2
* 2 &- 7<1 = 2 1
0
2
%
* 2 ) 2
* % 2 % 2
)
,
%
8
* %
,
%
$;
2 $
* #
% 1 $ :;&>2
2
2
# #
=
% 7
%&-7<1 =
2 $ :;&>
+2
# #
7 %
+
8 2
% :;& . (
+
2 ;
+
! ;
%
* %
+:
%
<& == <,0&
< ) %# %
2
*
+-
2
% $
$
%* 4
2 2
%
*
2
2
+22
*
+,$- *$ ".
8
%
5
#.
($#8"!
!&'(#,!
.9'!"4 #&6(.!$%'
3+($'!"
7+&'% /% 3+$%&/8(%+&9
$!6"/6!$3!
#&% ,!3!#'!, 5/.'!"4 ,&/2!&
+44!$,/$6 2!5/3"!1 3+""/,!, 5!#,+$ ,!3!#'!, 2/3%/.
#$,1 %5!&!4+&!1 8!
3+$%&/8(%+&9
4#""#39
#&6(.!$% 7&/% "#&6!
4&+.
4#3% $!/%5!& #$9 3+$%&/8(%+&9
$!6"/6!$3!
!'%#8"/'5!, $+& 3#$ /% 8!
#''(.!, '(&./'!'
4#3%'
3/&3(.'%#$3!'
$ '5+&% &!./'!1 6&+($,'
/$%!&4!&!
=
(&%5!&.+&!1 /4 #&6(.!$% 3+($'!"
8!
#33! %!,1 /% 7+(", .!#$ !2!&9 5!#,+$ #33/,!$%
/$2+"2/$6 %7+ 2!5/3"!'1 "!6#"
&!'(. %/+$ 3#$ 8!
,$ 8+%5
,&/2!&'
4#("%
% 3#$$+% 8!
'+ !2!&9 /% 3#$$+% 8!
#"'+
,!%!&./$!, '%&#/%;#3>!% 4+&.("#1 8!!$ 3#$2#''!,
'
&!6#&,'
+%5!& #&6(.!$% !9!7/%$!''
1 '#.!
#"&!#,9 8!!$ ,!#"% /. (6$!,
4/$,/$6'
E(# '#.!
5#2!
8!!$ &!$,!&!,
#&!
8#'!, 3+&&+8+&#%/$6 7!""
+%5!& &/.#&9 !2/,!$3!
#,,(3!,
+%5!& 6&+($, 8!!$ (&6!,
/'./''!,
!$,/$6 # "/3#%/+$1 /4 #$91 '5#""
#"'+ '%#$, ,/' +'!,
#*+ ' ( # ) 6(& &!!%
?5!%5!& ' !#>/$6<&!#'+$!,-
!'<+
?5!%5!& &! +&%#8"!-
!'<+