Ashok Kumar v. Sardara Singh And Others
!!"#$%&'$()!"%#&%&'*+(,-)%.+%**(-/+'0(./.%&'(0 !1$#%" 1%21'(!!1%"-&31.1$'#(&45678(0 .
%/%#&*''+1(.31.(0 %$9-#''%"3%'135 5!%**13:;'+1-3#$#%" %/#*'.%'1*' "%**1.% %**##&%$()!"%#&'$%*1-&31.1$'#(&*74774<=75.1%3>#'+ 1$'#(&7?
*!1.'+1$()!"%#&%&'+1>%*#&!(**1**#(&(0<*9 ;%.3* (0"%&3#&2#""%/1%!!%.2#31 1*("-'#(&( =(0 .%)%&$+%;%'%!!%.
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
-&"%>0-""; #&'( '+1 *%#3 !#1$1 (0 "%&3 %&3 $%-*13 31*'.-$'#(& '( '+1 :(-&3%.; >%"" %* >1"" %* ('+1. 2%"-%:"1 %.'#$"1* %&3 '+.1%'1&13 '+1 $()!"%#&%&'%&3+#*0%)#";)1):1.*(03#.1$(&*19-1&$1* &< '+1)%''1.>%*.1!(.'13'(("#$1:-'&(%$'#(&>%*'%,1&:;'+1) 1&$1 '+1!.1*1&'$()!"%#&'>%*0#"13
+1 '.#%" (-.' %0'1. %!!.1$#%'#&/ '+1 !.1"#)#&%.; 12#31&$1 %33-$13:;'+1$()!"%#&%&'*-))(&13'+1%$$-*13!1.*(&*%&3$+%./13 '+1)0(.'+1(001&$1!-&#*+%:"1-&31.1$'#(&*74774<=75.1%3>#'+ 1$'#(&7? '(>+#$+'+1;%$$-*13!"1%313&('/-#"';%&3$"%#)13'.#%"
'%'1)1&'* (0 '+1 %$$-*13 -&31. 1$'#(& .
>1.1 .1$(.313>+1.1#&'+1;31
%""'+1$+%./1*%&3!"1%313#&&($1&$1 +1 %$$-*131B%)#&13>#'&1**1*#&'+1#.3101&$1
+1'.#%" (-.'0#&3#&/)%'1.#%"$(&'.%3#$'#(&*#&'+1'1*'#)(&; (0'+1$()!"%#&%&'!.($11313'(%$9-#''+1%$$-*13(0'+1$+%./1*"121""13 %/%#&*''+1)
1&$1'+1!.1*1&'%!!"#$%'#(&
1%.3"1%.&13$(-&*1"0(.'+1%!!"#$%&'%&3!1.-*13'+1$%*1 0#"1$%.10-"";
+#* (-.'0#&3*'+%''+1'.#%" (-.'+%*$%.10-"";1B%)#&13'+1 12#31&$1(&.1$(.3>+#"1%$9-#''#&/'+1%$$-*13!1.*(&* (*'#)!(.'%&'"; '+1 12#31&$1 (0 '+1 $()!"%#&%&' #'*1"0 .1&31.* '+1 %""1/13 ($$-..1&$1 *1.#(-*"; 3(-:'0-" %* &('#$13 :; '+1 '.#%" (-.' >+#"1 1B%)#&#&/ '+1 *'%'1)1&'(0$()!"%#&%&'*+(,-)%..1$(.313#&$#2#"*-#'(&? 7 %0'1.'+1%""1/13($$-..1&$1 +1*%#3*'%'1)1&'6B 8$(-!"13>#'+'+1
*'%'1)1&'*(0'+1('+1.>#'&1**1*3(&('1*'%:"#*+0(.$#:"13#*!(**1**#(&(0 '+1$()!"%#&%&'
+#* (-.'0#&3*'+%''+1'.#%" (-.'+%*%3(!'13%!(**#:"1 2#1>:%*13(&$(..1$'%!!.1$#%'#(&(012#31&$1(&.1$(.3%&3'+1.10(.1#' 3(1*&('>%..%&'#&'1.01.1&$1
& 2#1> (0 '+1 %:(21 !1$#%" 1%21 '( 0#"1 %& %!!1%" #* 31$"#&13
%&-%.; -"%'# !" C+1'+1. 1!(.'%:"1 1*A( C+1'+1.!1%,#&/A 1%*(&13 1*A(