M/S R S Enterprises v. M/S Srubhi Traders

 
   

     







      

    ! "  #$%

 &

   ! " #  #$ '

   "($&) *$+&)   !(

, *$+&) +  %&'())%*+,%&-"

*%.

 %$ $  &$  "&  - ./0
'
 *

  )  * $,"*& & &/ 

&#1 

&2"&  *

3 
+ '

 +4$ #1+$ 
"

5"&$ & "& , "& 

$6* # 7 ",+

  89#  ,
"

 /(" '.'(012314%451%.6(""

4%4%('7%*%4  05"- 

8    

*1314%.


-   &

#  &" &,

)

   - & - ./0 '
+ "&&$ $),$ *$  "&  -
'
# $
"

  ) 

$ & :"&*, "&  ;- %$  #)&



  & # #

&  4 3  1+$),  ,,"$ # "

*$  4$$ # ", #& #1 1& &7$  + ), "& 

$++ 1 $$ &

 $5"  4$$ " &$,  $,,&#1  4$$

*&$ + , 1+$ "&+4$$5"$ # &$"

&

& 1+$ *$ ),  ,,"#



&

4$$ *$ "&4$$  " & )+4$+ ,   *$ 

"&  -/$
'
  )&  ,$ $ *$ 

"&  -/ ,   *$ &#* "#:&  1  & ,

1+   ),   ,+  4$ )  #  $   "

    $   ,+ "& 1,"$ *$   %$ & 1+ $ $ $'

, $"*$ $ )"# - 4$"  , & *  1  &  &    # "  &#1$), +4$$< 

   "&  $  *  )     & & ),4$   =$

1+ *    5" + $ +$ "*$$'"# '

"   

)$,  &  "$ 

+$"*$"

"$ 4$$  ) $"

84) + 1

1 $

 ,    >"4$ ,     ),?  *$       +  $ (*   )  ,$ 8*$
"

"&  - ./0$
'
4" &# 

14$ #&&#1$'

,#1  $ )  -$
'
 3"

$ 1+$'

,$  ,&&  -  ", #$),? *$ 

:" $ 4$ *

& ,     * =$$ $ &+$'

,$   &$ )  - ) * "  *$ $),   

$* "&,&$  ,

&

,   3$ 1+$) ),$  

"& 

$"" #1 #%$# "$,  &"&

$  )$ "

 ) ,   $
'
 &  / $ #1 < 

$ )$ '
$,   "$ &,& &  , %$  +$,  + 4$$), &$"

$5","#  "&#), ,$ )  - &4$$&),"&  .4 0$
'
@   3"

$ +   1*  $  &     )  )

" *+ 89#  ,
"

 1*'509*%0'9:'6'42'40'..1;'45'6("%&

  <23%**9*%14 *1314%.=='%.9"> :
,10) *1314%.

=='%.9"
?
9:
+'51+'+94?""

8- 4$ 

1*$ :"&*,$ # #   ) 1+$ $ & "&  ; %$&

  "& *4$"# )

*$+#1$ * "

+& &# )"      <  1    #1  

1  ,    , &    $ )

 )

%$ * , <,A6) 
" 3""

3 , 7,  #+6'

 A& * $  4 4"*$ *"

4$  4 &$

+

4$ ", )1 &$

",*

1 &

" $

1 $4  #1    <   )    $   "      $

 )1    $ 4  & #   $ "*$  

,    %$    # "  "$   "  4" &  $ )  $ 5" *)& *$+,4#"

&

,  <*  # *   84) +  4$   &

& *  *

&$

  

)"#5" 1)

" &#1$&

*

#$+$5"$)

" *

( 1& 

&#1& " +  ))1(1(@'5%2('101(('00.'+.%, 0)%00)'.%,+'5.%*'+@A0)1( 92*01(*'0*9(='5016'%4+1( 49*3%..A%((23'+09@'0)'.%,:*930)'145'=0194 %$

 4 1 & " " ,"# "&  4$  $       :"&*,   &2+;3'40  9* +'51(194  ,)15)  140'*=*'0(  %  (0%020'  9*  =*961(194  0)'*'9: +'5.%*'(0)'3'%414;9:0)'(0%020'%(10()92.+@'594(0*2'+ :*93  0)'  +%0'  9:  10(  '4%503'40"  4  90)'*  ,9*+(-  0)' &2+;3'40+'5.%*'(,)%00)'.';1(.%02*')%+(%1+%00)'013' ,)'4  0)'  .%,  ,%(  =*932.;%0'+  %4+  0)'*':9*'-  10  )%( *'0*9(='5016''::'50"=$

1+$ " "  4$$ ",&# )" <  1,

 )B$  4 ,$ ,+$  &

/ :"&*," *   4 # 

 

)$ *&1# &   ",4$ #" &$, *$

44$$<& ,$$ & " )B$ #&

&#$ 4$ & ,"#$ &$ 1#$ 4$ &%$  " , ,$

 $ $&"1$ "

A " 4 4#",   & <"&$ &A.,$  &&&0 / %$  +)4$:"&*, & &#1$89# 

, 
"

    '.'(0123  14%451%. ."

0  & 1*'509*%0'  9:

'6'42'40'..1;'45'."

0+ 

& 2"&*+'

 +& &  $   )  &"&  - '
 & "$ ,$


"

 &  ,   * 1& &&$,  #( &$

 &$  

& 2"&*+'

 + $4$ 

&+  &* 1'&* + 1+   &&&

 #$

>""

8 

$

, B$$ (* &  C6 B$$  #   C6