High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-A/120/2015dismissed

Swami Sadanand Ji v. Arvind Mehta & ORS

2015-07-1612 pages

!"!

#$ %& & & &

# !

**+!

,**

**+!

,**

**+!

,**

**+!

,**

- ."/"

.0!#

"* "* "* "* $ 34 ' '

$ 34 ' '

+ * ." ) 7 8

9/:) ;

. #

;

9/:) "1 /+ 8

;

$ . ' = 0

**+!

, >>> '

= '

= ?45 ?45 ?45 ?45 1

**+!

# 1

. '

# <&@?A5

1 '

# A@

. :.

'* + +

!)*/:# 9/:)

&B * 87 +

/! !

+ ""= /.

"*/. (1

**+!

. '

,<A

# +

!")!""

# .

"* " 1

) .!

**+!

. '

,<A

# +

:!#:

,*.

1= "!

!# .= 1"!+ # !"

"*/. 1

. /

#" '(

# !

" .

1= !#

. '( # ! '

! (

# 1

#+7

'( )!

# ! '

+! 6!++ !#

# 1 0!#: "

/# !"* "!#: "

)!#= /+7

'/8 .= !# .

1 8

1 **+!

.D!#: *.

+ !#"

" ) 87

1 ?./"

5 87 '( # ! '

! !# 1!" +!

**+!

!" 8 !#: ( ."1!**

/./ +7 '

# 1!"

." 1

**+!

./##!#: #

1 1 .) 7= (1

7/.0 ! ) ! !#

7 *

" /"

!" 1 0!#: !#!)!

+ .

#" (!

" 1

" .

1 /"

/#9 8 F # :8 #!

"*/. (1!+

< !"

! #

!# . /"

A= !"

/#9 8 F .! # :8 #!

.= #1 . 1

++7 # (!++ /++7 :

*/8+!"1

)" !# /#9 8 F .!

BA%

# !# /.

"*/. F +/)# /#

!#: (!

1 *1

" G'(

# D 9!D ( 1!"1D . D!7

H 8 ! # (" ( " */8+!"1

87 " 2 < !. #

! # ("

.!0

#" (

(" 1

(# 1!" .

# 87 + ++!#:

#" !#

BA% :

/#9 8 F ".! # :8 #! .=

*/8+!"1

.7 #

G #

D1!. '

# 1 /#H D /. 6 "1!

!H # #

1!D

)+ .)7 H

++7 (!++ /++7 )

. /#.

(!++

# ! !#

. * # ++

*/8+!"1

<&< !# /#9 8 F .! . #1

G #

1 '

1! !"D "1!

H 1

*/8+!"1

. !# 1

#"D.!

-!7 +7

1!. ) ..!

# 1!" (!

!" 1

.+ ""

#:+7 "

!" 1 0!#: !++! !

#" (!

1 "!"

!# "1 F/) . ., 1

1!" # (" */8+!"1

" (!

+7 !. /+

+7 !#9/.

" ( "

1 1

)8 ..

1 *

*+ !#:

!#:

. */8+!

(" 87

!. # . 1

# 1 .)

*/8+! 1

))!

*/#!"1 8+ . + ( 1

# "!"

+!)!# "* "

"/))

))!""!

" */#!"1 8+ . '

,<A

# *.

**+!

)!# 1!)"

" 6

)!# 6 !# "1 '1

!"1 # # 6< +8!. '

# "!"

= .

"* "

))!""!

" /# . '

(1! 1= *+

:/!+ # + !)

"* " . '

# << . (

7 *+

!##

!)*+!

# 1

**.

!#:

"* "

)= !)*/:# 9/:)

&B 1!"

**+!

. +

/#"

**+!

# :

/:1 !)*/:# 9/:) 1

**.

!#:

# .

" /# .$

#" +

)!#

" 6 !"

*/8+!"1 (" !# /#9 8 F

BA% !# /.

"*/. F .! +/)# /#

!#: (!

" G'( )! # F 9!D - "1!"D . F!7

H 1 */8+!"1

*1"=

.!:!# + # #: (!

*/8+!"1

+/)# !" E # A%

. !" E 1 (" E !" /#

1 F D1!. '

# 1 D F /#;

1!" #

) !

" */8+!"1

!# 1!"

/. 87 '( )!

.( # ! (

# !

" "

. 6!++

BA (1! 1 !" /#.

87 '( )! '

.( # ! !#

'1 D1 1 . 1

*/8+!"1 1!" #

)!":/!

+ */8+!

# + (# 1!" .

"!)!+ . #

)" ( " */8+!"1

. :8 #!

" E <

. <=

*/8+!"1

/#9 8 F .! /#

-!1 1! !"D "1!

(1! 1 !" ) .D

1!" #

# 1!" 1

. ( " +

# !# !) 7 (!

1!"

. !# 0!++ 1 #:! 1

87 */8+!"1!#:

1!" .

# !# + */8+!

# !# 1!"

# 1 (" */8+!"1 " 1 0!#: (!

+7 !. /+

# !. /+

6 !# "1 '1 # 6< +8!. '

+!#

# < #

. 1 # !#

= 6 -!# /*

1!)"

"" 8

) E # E

# */8+!"1 . /*

. 0

#= 1

) 1

# (.!

# 87 @A% !# 1!" *.

(!#: !#:.

C/!.

)/"

D!#:

. */8+!

!!5 1

!" )

. */8+!"1 )/"

!!!5

!" )

. */8+!"1 )/"

G!)*/

#H= !05 )/"

1 !#

.) . (!

D# (+

(!++ 1 .) */

. . !++(!++ # . ) +!

# !#:.

# (

.= # #

# /#*.

9/"

#= !# 9/! !

)!#

::.!

+7 ."!"

!#: !# +!8 /" 1

#7 "/

! !

#= ) 7 8

# !#

#"!

" #

1 1

. !++(!++

+ !#

0!+!

"/ 1 #

" )

(!++ /++7 . */.* +7

#7 + /+ E /"

. 9/"

# %

!" #

!#!#:

# "1 /+ "1

++7 "/

#7 .) !# .

# *.

*.!)

!" #

!#!

!)*/

# )

"1 /+ 1 = !#

#7 1 .)

.3" .

. !

" .!)!# + .

"* #"!8!+!

#= D# (+

# 8 +!

!)*/

" !# (1! 1 /#!"1

. 1 " "

( !" "1

= #

!+"

& ( +

/" .

= #

# !""/

.0!#

*/8+!"1

.7 )

BA% # A% !# # . /#9 8 F ".!

# :8 #!= -!# /*

< 1 # 4 + 8 !#: .

! *

A -!9 7 /*

!#:

*.!#

.= */8+!"1

! * ))!

*/#!"1 8+

. '

.7 #

BA% '

# ! '

9!D - "1!"1D . F!7

=H (1 !#= !

!" )

" .

.!#: 1!"

" 87 (.!

!#:

.!)!# " 8

#: (!

1 &

. )

/# . '

# <&& 1

# .

# 1 " 8

# 1 "1

!#" )

"1 /+ 8

#7 #C/!.7 .

.!#:

6!++ (1! 1

!# 1!"

# ! (1

# /# . '

<B ,A ,<&B,<&,<% 1 " 8

# .

#:(!

1 &

. * #"

= !

/#"

" 9/"

*/8+!"1 (" !

:!0 # 87 .0!#

# #

1!#:

" 8

"/8)!

. 0 7!#:

!#: 1

# :!0 # 87 .0!#

"/**

1!"

#" 87 *+ !#:

# .

. G1 !

+= #:

-" .

' 9/ ?<5 B% ?F .#

!" #

9/#

/* .= !

+ ) # "

. (1

!" */8+!"1 !" !#

*/8+! !#

*/8+! :

# !" 8

+ .

= !

/+ 8

+7 !

! /+

# "/ 1 */8+!

# )

!# :

. '

# ABB

/:1 9/! !

= (1! 1 "1

A 1 */8+!"1 ,*.!#

"!"

"" #

:!0 # 87 .0!#

(1! 1 !" E 6, 1 0!#:

"!:#

.0!#

= E 6, E 6,= E 6,= E 6,

. *.

"" #

" :!0

# <

.0!#

# .

. E I ! /.+ "/!

.!#:

'1 D1 . 1 . -" '(

# (1! 1 !"

"/!

.!#:

!" #

# 1 , , .

1= !# .= /* # "/!

"!"

8.!

6!++

(1! 1 1 . 8

87 '( )!

# ! E < "1 .!)!#

87 .0!#

# E A "1

# 1

!0!+ "/!

# -" '' - /8+! ' 1

!#:

1 .!7

1= !# " *

7 (1! 1

E!"

# B@< !#

!#/ /" +!

!) .

7 /"

/:1

# .

# E

. '

<<, %,A&,A@,AB

#: (!

)+ "1 '1 .)

#: (!

+7 (

/:1

# .

. E %= = (1! 1 !"

# /# . '

<&&

9!# . " "/ 1= E

# E */8+!

+ .

# !" )

!# :

1 /.

. !#

G-!.

#:10! -" '

% ?5 ?.!)!# +5 H= !

!" 1

# (

+7 */8+!"1

# (1

. #

#7 )*+! !

." 8 1!# */8+!

!"*/

(1! 1 # 8

9/!

**.

87 8

" '

= !

!" / 7 *.

# .

" E

# E % 1

# +

.!#: (1! 1 */8+!

# 1

# )

# E

# .

# ! ( " 1 "1

. '

# <&&

# .

" !"*/

6!++ 8

# '1 D1 . 1 '1 .!= .

.!#: (1! 1 "/!

# E I 1

87 '1 D1 . 1 . '1 .!

)! '

# ! 1

"/!

!" 8 !#: 1 .!7

1 !"

!#/ /" +!

!) .

/+ #

) 1!" *

7= (1! 1 !"

'' - /8+!

' 1

/:1 .0!#

" "

.7 B = !# /)/+

!. /)"

*!#!

# E # E

# (

+7 */8+!"1

# "

/* "" #

:!0 # 87 1

" #

)*+! !

A 8 1!#

*/8+!

!#"

!" #

. "/8"

.:/)

87 +

/#"

!#" ) " !#

.:/) 87 +

/#"

# )!"

!0 = 8

A "

) /# . '

#" +

*!#!

" /# . '

!" )

+7 #

) E # E 1

# */8+!"1

.7 !#

) )!

+7 !0!+ # .!)!# " 1 " 8

# +

. *

.0!#

.!)!#

. '

E ,<= .

.!#: (1! 1 "/)) #!#:

. 1 +.

7 8

# *

# @ .!)!#

# A@<

# < % )!

+7= !0!+ .!)!# + +!

# 1 " .

#!#: 8

. 8+

.!)!# E < .= !

*/8+!

# !" 8

+ .

# !" )

!# :

1 " "/ 1= #

.!#: !" )

2 A

. '

H 1 #38+ '/*.

!# /.

+!1 . J !

2 #. /.

+!1 . J !

2 #. /.

+!1 . J !

2 #. /.

+!1 . J !

2 #. 0" '

0" '

A?5 ?.!)!# +5 & 1 " 1 " /# .$ G 4 . /""

++ !# . /""

++ !# '1

./* 0" F!#: )* . K '1

./* 0" F!#: )* . K B<A .!07 /# !+ &L B<A .!07 /# !+ &L B<A .!07 /# !+ &L B<A .!07 /# !+ &L 1!:1+!:1

**.

!:1

.!#:

+ 4 . /""

++ "

!= G !:1

"1 /+ # (!++ +( 7" :!0 . ( !:1

#"!

"/ 1 )

" ?5

!8!+!

"M ?5

"/)*

!##

"/)*

!#+7 #

" 8

1!"

+M ?<5 .!:1

#7 /8 M # ?A5 "+ (#

!# !"

/.8!#:

!#!#:

..!0

!#:

"H 1

*!#!

. /""

++ 1 " 8

." "

.+7 " !# B = 1!" !# '/.

9* + '!#:1 0

M N B ' L= (1!+

+!#: (!

!:1

+ /#

# A&

.!)!# + .

!:1 /++ *

/* # (1! 1

+ (

= 8/

C/ ++7 ( ++ "

"/)*

!##

. .

87 1!"

+ 87

!#!#:"

(1! 1 1

!#:

# 1

.!#:

# 8

#+7

. 0 .7 "/8"

)* ++!#: .

#"H 1

**.

+ 1

1 87 1!" /+"!.

) F #/ 0 '

M K B A ' L= /+"!.

) F #/ 0 '

M K B A ' L= /+"!.

) F #/ 0 '

M K B A ' L= /+"!.

) F #/ 0 '

M K B A ' L=

# '!#:1 0 '

M K B A ' %<&L= 7 0 '

'!#:1 0 '

M K B A ' %<&L= 7 0 '

'!#:1 0 '

M K B A ' %<&L= 7 0 '

'!#:1 0 '

M K B A ' %<&L= 7 0 '

M K B

' @&L= 1 . F1!) 0 '

M K B

' @&L= 1 . F1!) 0 '

M K B

' @&L= 1 . F1!) 0 '

M K B

' @&L= 1 . F1!) 0 '

"1 M K B % ' &L= +8!. '!#:1 0 '

/#9 8M K B & ' %L= :

.( + 0 '

/#9 8M K B & ' %L= :

.( + 0 '

/#9 8M K B & ' %L= :

.( + 0 '

/#9 8M K B & ' %L= :

.( + 0 '

"1 M K B%< ' L=

. F1 # 0 '

"1 M K B%< ' L=

. F1 # 0 '

"1 M K B%< ' L=

. F1 # 0 '

"1 M K B%< ' L=

. F1 # 0 '

#M K B%A ' @%L= F1 /

# 0 '

#M K B%A ' @%L= F1 /

# 0 '

#M K B%A ' @%L= F1 /

# 0 '

#M K B%A ' @%L= F1 /

# 0 '

!1 .M K?B&5 ' A L= '1!0 9! '

0 !1 .M K?B&5 ' A L= '1!0 9! '

"1 M K?B&<5 ' &B<L= 4 D1

0 '

!1 .M K?B&<5 ' AAL= F1 ) F # 0 0 '

!1 .M K?B&<5 ' AAL= F1 ) F # 0

M K?B&A5 A ' %<L= !"1 # '!#:1 0 '

/#9 8M K?B&A5 < ' @@L= ) !

! 0

/#9 8M K?B&A5 < ' @@L= ) !

! 0

/#9 8M K?B&A5 < ' @@L= ) !

! 0

/#9 8M K?B&A5 < ' @@L= ) !

! 0

M K?B&@5 ' @L= F + 7 0

M K?B&B5 ' <

'!#:1 0 '

M K?B&B5 ' <

'!#:1 0 '

M K?B&B5 ' <

'!#:1 0 '

M K?B&B5 ' <

'!#:1 0 '

/#9 8 KB@&?5 ?.!)!# +5 < $ ?B@&5 ' BL= /#9 8 KB@&?5 ?.!)!# +5 < $ ?B@&5 ' BL= /#9 8 KB@&?5 ?.!)!# +5 < $ ?B@&5 ' BL= /#9 8 KB@&?5 ?.!)!# +5 < $ ?B@&5 ' BL= ) F/) . 0 '

M KBBA?<5 ) F/) . 0 '

M KBBA?<5 ?.!)!# +5 %< $ BB '/** ?5 ' A@L=

# 4 + 0 ?.!)!# +5 %< $ BB '/** ?5 ' A@L=

# 4 + 0

2FM KBB&?A5 ?.!)!# +5 @B$ ?BB&5 & '

2FM KBB&?A5 ?.!)!# +5 @B$ ?BB&5 & ' %&&L= '

)8 "!0 # 0 '

M KBB@?5 %&&L= '

)8 "!0 # 0 '

M KBB@?5 %&&L= '

)8 "!0 # 0 '

M KBB@?5 %&&L= '

)8 "!0 # 0 '

M KBB@?5 ?.!)!# +5 %B< $ ?BB@5 ' AL= 1 :( # '!#:1 0 ?.!)!# +5 %B< $ ?BB@5 ' AL= 1 :( # '!#:1 0 ?.!)!# +5 %B< $ ?BB@5 ' AL= 1 :( # '!#:1 0 ?.!)!# +5 %B< $ ?BB@5 ' AL= 1 :( # '!#:1 0

M K?5 ?.!)!# +5 B< $ ?5 A

M K?5 ?.!)!# +5 B< $ ?5 A ' @ L= .!9 1!./* 0 /8+! .

.= !:1 ' @ L= .!9 1!./* 0 /8+! .

.= !:1

M K ?<5 ?.!)!# +5 @% $ ?5 %

M K ?<5 ?.!)!# +5 @% $ ?5 % ' A&L= #

#7 0 F :1 # !.M K?A5 ' A&L= #

#7 0 F :1 # !.M K?A5 ?.!)!# +5 & $ ?<5 ' L= '

?.!)!# +5 & $ ?<5 ' L= '

0 F D.!"1# M K ?5 ?.!)!# +5 .#

0 F D.!"1# M K ?5 ?.!)!# +5 $ ? 5 B ' BL= '

0 '

#9 7 1 D.

#M $ ? 5 B ' BL= '

0 '

#9 7 1 D.

#M $ ? 5 B ' BL= '

0 '

#9 7 1 D.

#M $ ? 5 B ' BL= '

0 '

#9 7 1 D.

#M K&?5 ?.!)!# +5 A @ $ ?&5 < ' &

L K&?5 ?.!)!# +5 A @ $ ?&5 < ' &

L 1 #.

0 '

M K&?5 1 #.

0 '

M K&?5 1 #.

0 '

M K&?5 1 #.

0 '

M K&?5 ?.!)!# +5 B$ &?5

* E /:) " ?5 ?.!)!# +5 B$ &?5

* E /:) " ?5 @A$ ?&5 A ' A L @A$ ?&5 A ' A L @A$ ?&5 A ' A L @A$ ?&5 A ' A L

!" #

+ (!

" !#!0!/ ++7 '/

1!"

#"!"

+7 1

+!#: (!

)/"

. !# )!#

(!#:$ ?!5 1 !" *.

"/)*

!##

# "/ 1 *.

"/)* # !"

+ * !# 1!"

/. 87

= ?!!5 1

# !"

/8 # !

+= ?!!!5 1 /:1=

#"!

.!#:

#"!0

" !

." !#

#0!

#" 8/

!" :

++7 +

1 !# !"

/.8!#:

!#!#:

!" "

!#:

= !#

9/:)

+ !" #

9/"

#+ ""=

# +/"!

#" .

+* 8+7 (.

. 8

/" 0!

. !

"/ 1

# +/"!

#= +!D +7

"/+

!# :.

!#9/"

!# !#

.!#: (!

1 "/ 1 # +/"!

#" !"

/++7 9/"

# ?!05 +7 8

# .

**.

# .

!# +!#

(= !#

9/:)

+ !" #

9/"

# 87

""!8+ ( 1

#+7 8

)/"

"/+

9/:)

/#"

**+!

"1 #7

. !# +

"!"

(1! 1 !#

# 8

1!" 9/:) . 1 #:

&% 7" !# !+!#:

**+!

#" 1

**+!

#!#:

7 " "/ 1= **+!

. +

+ !" !")!""

" (

7 /+7 %= /+7 %= /+7 %= /+7 %= ? '

5 ? '

5 # 1