Bharat Bhushan v. Dilbag Singh And ANR
!"#$"#%$"#&'()#*#+$,"-'.(/#%#0-%$#(1+$"#(1)#,$2 #,3-
!
"
++#4'%#,$-56%#+-$"1+)/'$$"#(#0-,1$1-+,-7! $-!5#46*1+#(/#7-%#$"#$%16. -'%$6+(++#4'%#,$-6%#$"# %#8-9#%:*#*-8%1*#,8#+#%#0-%$6+(%#0-%$%#,0#8$19#.:#4"1/1$#( /#7-%#$"#$%16. -'%$
"#%#7-%# 0#%*1,,1-+ 6, ,-')"$ 7-% 1, )%6+$#( 6+( $"# 600.186$1-+1,6..-;#(
"#$%16. -'%$%#8-%(#(68<'1$$6.-7688',#(1./6)1+)"1+ $#%*,-7$"#&'()#*#+$06,,#(/:1$-+= = "#0%#,#+$600.186$1-+ "6,/##+71.#(1+9->1+)$"#0%-91,1-+'+(#%#8$1-+?@ABC-7 -(#-7
%1*1+6. %-8#('%# ,##>1+) ,0#816. .#69# $- 600#6. 6)61+,$ $"# 6/-9# 9#%(18$
$1,$"#86,#-7$"#0%-,#8'$1-+$"6$688',#(1./6)1+)";"- ;6,1+$"#0%-8#,,-78"6$$1+);1$"$"#8-*0.61+6+$"6%6$"',"6+-+ @ @6$6/-'$?
0 * 6$$"#$'/#;#..-7$"#8-*0.61+6+$-0#+#(71%# $;18#7%-*$"#8-'+$%:*6(#01,$-.6+(*6(#6+6$$#*0$$-*'%(#%$"# 8-*0.61+6+$ =
"#$%16. -'%$"691+)$"-%-')".:6+6.:D#($"##91(#+8#-+ %#8-%(8-*0.#$#.:(1,/#.1#9#($"#86,#0%-$#(/:$"#8-*0.61+6+$
#6%+#( 8-'+,#. 600#6%1+) 7-% 600#..6+$ "6%6$ "',"6+ ,'/*1$$#($"6$!% 6,6+$E'*6%#+1-%81#+$1718 7718#%"6(+-$#( (-;+6"-.#-+$"#;6..-7$"#$'/#;#..-7$"#600#..6+$ "##*0$:;6, %#8-9#%#('+(#%%#8-9#%:*#*-4 1+$"#0%#,#+8#-7$"#8-*0.61+6+$ 6+(60-.18#8-+,$6/.# #7#%%1+)$-$"##91(#+8#-7!=6+(!
"# ,'/*1$$#($"6$$"#:"6()19#+$"#+6$'%6.,#<'#+8#-7#9#+$, '%$"#%$"# #91(#+8#-78-*0.61+6+$6.,-1+,01%#,8-+71(#+8#1$;6,,'/*1$$#( ?
1%,$.:;#71+($"6$$"#;#60-+6..#)#(.:',#(/:$"#688',#( ;6,+-$6$6..%#8-9#%#( "##*0$:;6,%#8-9#%#('+(#%4 !B3-+.:1+ $"#0%#,#+8#-71+$#%#,$#(;1$+#,,#,+6*#.:$"#8-*0.61+6+$6+(60-.18#
-+,$6/.# + -$"#% ;-%(, +- 1+(#0#+(#+$ ;1$+#,, ;6, #46*1+#( $- ,'/,$6+$16$#$"#%#8-9#%:-7#*0$:7%-*$"#,8#+#-78%1*# '%$"#%$"# -88'%%#+8#"6($6>#+0.68#1+691..6)#,#$$1+)-+ @ @6$6/-'$?
* '$$"#%#8-9#%:"6(/##+6..#)#(.:*6(#-+B @ @ "#91..6)#%, ;-'.("69#$"%-+)#($-$"#,8#+#-78%1*#"691+)8-*#$->+-;-7$"# -88'%%#+8#$"6$6..#)#(.:$-->0.68#6$$"#$'/#;#..6+(8-..#8$#($"##*0$: 176$6..1$;6,7-'+(6$$"#,8#+#-78%1*# '%$"#%$"##*0$:;6,+-$6$6..
8-++#8$#(;1$"$"#;#60-+6..#)#(.:',#(6,$"#;#60-+1$,#.7;6,+-$ %#8-9#%#( "#%#7-%##9#+17$"#%#8-9#%:-7#*0$:1,/#.1#9#(1$(-#,+-$ 1+(186$#$"#8'.06/1.1$:-7$"#688',#(6,$"#8-++#8$1-+;1$"$"#;#60-+ ',#(/:$"#688',#(;6,+-$#,$6/.1,"#(
@
!=6+(!
;#%#+-$$"##:#;1$+#,,#,$-$"#-88'%%#+8#
"#%#7-%#$"#1%$#,$1*-+:(-#,+-$1+6+:;6:1*0%-9#$"#86,#-7$"# 0%-,#8'$1-+ -$-01$6..+-*-$19#"6,/##+6$$%1/'$#(6)61+,$$"#688',#( 7-%-0#+1+)71%#6..-76,'((#+#9#+;"#+"#;6,#+)6)#(1+1+$#%68$1-+ ;1$"$"#8-*0.61+6+$
7 6$ 6.. $"# 688',#( ;"- ;6, 6%*#( ;1$" 671%# 6%* "6( 1+$#+(#($->1..$"#8-*0.61+6+$"#;-'.(+-$"69#,$-00#(71%1+);"#+$"# 8-*0.61+6+$;6,7.##1+)1+$"#71#.(7%-*$"#$'/#;#.. +-'%8-+,1(#%#( 91#;$"#$%16. -'%$"6,%1)"$.:8-*#$-68-+8.',1-+$"6$$"#8-*0.61+6+$ "6,+-$#,$6/.1,"#(;1$"8%#(1/.#6+($%',$;-%$":#91(#+8#$"#8"6%)#, 7%6*#(6,6)61+,$$"#688',#(
!#(-+-$71+(6+:)%-'+(7-%)%6+$1+).#69#$-0%#7#%6+ 600#6.
"#%#7-%#$"#600.186$1-+,$6+(,(1,*1,,#(
# 6:
'.6$1 #