High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-A/1244/2014dismissed

Dhari Ram v. Partap Singh & ORS

2015-05-2110 pages

"# $%&$

$'( $()* +,, $-./ 00(11'

2* !.'0 3-'-(.* (*0 ('* +4#5 "

4#5 "

$" !.(*('+.67(*-86/.#-'3.&9 )'( .'-(001)'00(11'$-./ ::::::

#(3 33.(9(& '-( ) /01'$-. / -* 0.((..('-(0.(*('00(13*''-(/063(;63/(' '( ,)<6''3.(*0 ('!.'0 3-& .'-(

()(6(. ()' & =&

&=.(>'- ()' !1 3>'-'-(00(1001)' *((73) '

?*(1?13'-(00(1-*1* @((1($6('

'?0 3.0-)1/*'7('-(/063(;63/(' ()'

!-*@((/(' (* ()' =!>-1(- 13'-'

'-() /01'-1('

9('-( ()(6(. ()' =! #.()'* '-()*(&.(1(9' .()* '-* 00(1 .( '-' ) /01'00(11'$-. / 1( /01'3*''-(.(*0 ('!.'0 3-'> '-(.*

/(1?./1 3- 6.9(1 3-* * -(. 3- .(*('* 2113(! . ->&(-*1..&$*'.)'

/.'*.& .'-( ()(*6(. ()' *& =&

&= .(>'- ()' ! '>*11(3(@?'-() /01'

'-' ( *1( (( '(

'-.(( *1( ((* '(

>(.(11(3(1?(A()6'(@?-/9 6. '-())6*(.(*0()' -*1*'6'(9113(! . ->&(-*1..&$*''/.'*. -(*(>(.('-( .(*61' 6.(**'-.('&'360 '@? 67-(9 3- -@@&7 >'(..

.*' #@@.8-1*.(1/'(.1 6)1( ))6*(& >- )/( ' '-( *- 0)1) '-( /01'@?11(311?('3-/&3 '(A()6'('-( */(>'- 6'?) *(.' -(*6')-11(33'-(* *1(((*>*1* 0(3'-(91 6.'&>-)-'-( /01' - *6// ( '-( 1(.7 !6;@ ''(

1()'.)'?# .'

9('-''-((1()'.)'?) ()' @(.3 )) 6'6/@(. =*'

-*/()) .31?&/ 6(.&1(.7 '-(* 1()'.)'?# .00(.( 6.'

(0 *'('-(1( '-(*(1()'.)'?) ()' '* 0(.6*1& - >(9(.& '-( ) /01' )/( '

7 > '-' '-( .(* (1()'.)'? ) ()' )' - >.

31? @(( '.*(..( '-( /( .(*0 ('!.'0 3- '-( @** 1*(9'11(3(1?*3(@?-/&'- 63-&-( (9(. *3( ? *6)- )6/(' ()(& '-( .(* 9' >* .(*61' .6 )'& 11 '-( ))6*(

) 9)( >'- ()- '-(. 0.(0.( 1*( 9'& 7 >3611?>(11&'-(*/('

@(1*( ' 1?'-*&'-(?

1* 3 ' '-( .(* 9' ''(*'( @? 0.

6)3 * /(

'-(. 0(.* -* 01)(& @( .( '-( A()6'9( 3*'.'(& "-@181&$*'.)'/.'*.'-6*>(.(1@1(' @('.( 06*-( 6(. ()' & =&

= .( >'- ()' ! /01'00(11' *600 .' -* @ 9( /01'(A/(B27./$(93&1(.7'-( 6.' - .(>1& 91 "63( C .$9D /.'*.& 67-;(. 3-& >.'3 3(. !.' A0(.' * B -/*(1*B &-*0.(1/.?(9()( -(.('(.& '(. -(.3 1(.( ) 6*(1 . '-( /01'&'-(1(.("6)13*'.'(*'1**&/.'*.& */**('-() /01'3*'))6*( &/(1?

./1 3- 6.9(1 3-* * -(. 3-- 13 '-' 0./)()*(>*/( 6'3*' '-(/ >-1( *6// 3 1?.(*0 ('!.'0 3- .0./)(@(3 1@1( .'-( ()(*6(. ()' *& =&

&=!'

)('.16(. ()' *& =&

&=!9( .(.

'(,= ((13 33.(9(& '-( ) /01' 1( .(9* 3*' '-( * .(. '( ,=& */**3-*) /01'<6))6*(/(1?./1 3-

6.9(1 3-& @( .( '-( 6.' (** *& /.'*.& @6'

.(/(6*6))(**61&*''

&>**/**(@?'-(1(.( ' 1 (** *"63(&C- )D*'.)7 6.'&/.'*.

9( .(.'(, 0.()-.3( (9()(& '-( ) /01' (A/( 67-;(. 3-&>.'33(.!.' A0(.'*B -/*(1*B)1 *(-*0.()-.3((9()(@?

'((.3&3.

6* (361. () 00(1

0(3'-* 6.'*.7 , -(.('(.& '(.-(.31(.() 6*(1 .'-(00(11') /01'&'-( 1(.('.1 6.')-.3(*-(('('-(.(*0 ('!.'0 3- .) //''3 ()(*6(. ()' & =&

&=.( >'- ()' !9( .(.'( /01' ' 1( ?& .(*- (9()( '(.

)-.3()1 *('-(*/( ,= &9(-**(0.'( *''(/(' *(<6('1?& '-( *''(/(' '-( .(*0 (' ))6*( 6(. ()' .! >* .() .( &06''3'-(('.(/'(.1@.

63-'3*'-/@?

'-( ) /01' '

>-)- -( (( 01(( -* 1*( /01)' ( 0'('

1((9()(-*(()( -( .(*0 ('-*(()(/ 9(001)' .) /0.*

'-(*06'(*3'6.( '-() /01'>'--**'. *3'6.(&>-)->*11 >(@?'-(1(.('.1 6.'9(

.(. '( )) .31?& '-( .(*0 (' 3 '

/0.('-(*/(.

/. ;((9 -./&>.'3 3(.!.' A0(.'$B&>- 1(-*.(0 .' A$B'

'-(

, (()' '-' @*) >.'3 )-.)'(.*')* '-( *06'( *3'6.(**'.(*3'6.(>(.( '-(*/(0(.* ( ) /01'$-. / -( .(*0 ('))6*( 1* '((.( -* (()( (9()( '-( 91 6.' ;63/('

'( 0**(

!"## $%& !'$(& " #) #* &$$+,%- .

)!# / "$$ # 0""

/ %&!'$(& " #)# * &$$ 1(@?'-() /01'00(11'3*''-(* ;63/('().(('( A$&"63/(''( 0**( 1$ # $ 0""

1( @? '-( 00(11' /01'''1(*%&!'$(& " #)#* &$- 3*' '-( .(. 1(.( '.1 6.' '( , & */**3-*) '(/0'001)' 6(..(. 61( !* A$ ''(/(' '-(00(11') /01''-( *-0( -*9' A!B*!B'-( .(*91 6' ,'( =

=()( & A$ -* ).

**(A/' * A$, )1 *( -* (()( (9()( -(.('(.& '(. -(.3 1(.( ) 6*(1 . '-( 0.'(*&'-(1(.('.1 6.')<6''('-(.(*0 ('!.'0 3-@?*/**3'-() /01'9(/063( .(.'( ,

#(3 33.(9(& '-( 001)'00(11'$-. / -*0.((..('-(0.(*('00(13*''-(/063( .(.

'( ,&1 3>'-001)' .) ' ?*(1?13' B( -9( -(. 1(.( ) 6*(1 . '-( 001)' 00(11' /(.' * >(11 * 60 -* 001)' .

' (1?-9(3 ('-.

63-'-()*(1(9(.?

).(611? 5(.( ) 6*(1 . '-( 001)'00(11' .36( '-''-((1? ?*13 '-(0.(*('00(1* '

'(' 1 . (1@(.'(& .'-(. * @ (& @()6*( '-( .(* '-'-(@(3 10

.0(.* ) 61 '..3(& '-(()(**.?6*'

0?1(31((*'

1('&'/(**

*-() 61..3(6*&-(00.

)-(-*) 6*(13 '

'-(0.(*('00(11(>'- 6'?(1? '(.393 6.'- 63-'61) *(.' &>(/(.'

'-(001)' &@()6*(&@?'-*'/('*>(11*(''1('-'

( *- 61 @( ) (/(6-(. '()-)1 *(.' *'-(*'')*(&'-(.(*(313@1((1?

1? ?* -(.( .(& '-( 001)' *((73 ' (1?13'-(00(1*-(.(@?11 >( (1? ?*13'-(0.(*('00(1*) ( /(.'*&1(.() 6*(1 .'-(00(11'*6@/''( '-' '-( /063( ;63/(' * @*( ) ;()'6.(* *6./*(*&*'-(1(.('.1 6.' '00.()'('-()'

= '-'11'-( .(**1(((**'

@((A()6'(@?'-( 00(11') /01' >(.( '-( .(*61' 6.(** 66( 16()(60 -/@?7003-/-(1(.('.1 6.'& ' * *6@/''(& (..( ' 00.()'3 '-' *1( *(.' >*(9(.0**(&@()6*('-(.(*0 ('!.'0 3- '1(?(9()('-*.(*0()' -(1(.( '.1 6.' -*1* (..( ' .(1?360 '-(.(0 .' 67-;(. 3- !B->.'3 3(. 0.' (A0(.'& >-)-)1(.1?*- >*'-''-(*06'(9' .'.*(. '6@(>(11 ) ()' >* ' (A()6'( @? '-( 00(11' /01' '(. 393

6. '- 63-'61 ) *(.' '

'-( *6@/** *&*/(@ 9(@?'-(1(.() 6*(1 .'-( 00(11') /01'&>('-(0.(*('00(1) /01('(1?

(9 ?/(.'& .'-(.(* *'

>+ /''(1?'-() /01'00(11'&@( .(13'-( 0.(*(') /01''-(?(.&-/6)-(.1(.1(91 6' ,'(

= ''1(*$-./ 2*!.'0 3-'-(.* A$>'-'-(*/1.9(./('* '-' ( *1( (( '(

'-.(( *1( ((* '(

>(.( 3 ' (A()6'( .

/ -/ @? '-( .(*0 ('6(.6.(**'360 '>'-'-(-(10 ( 7 > '(..

.*' #@@. 8-1*& /(1? 67-(9 3- -@@6(.'-.(' 7113-/&6.3'-(0(7?* /1')?'-6*'-(*/(>(.(1@1('

@(*('*(

-(**6'>**/**(@?'-(1(.(91 6.'

9(;63/(''( A$&@(3@..(@?'-( 0.)01( ) *'.6)'9(.(*;6)'>'-'-( @*(.9' *'-'

00(11') /01'*- 61-9(.*(11'-(01(*'-( (.1(.*6'1(@?'-(.(*0 ('3*'-/ ' 1?'-*& -*00(1'

&>**/**(@?'-(.*'00(11'( 6.'9( ;63/('().(('( A$**)6**( @ 9(&'-(00(11') /01'1* .(/(6*6))(**61 -* 00(1 3*' '-( .(. '( , 0**( @?

1(.( 91 "63( C".$9* D& /.'*.& */**3 -* '(/0' 001)' 6(. .(. 61( ! 9( ;63/(''( A$ -(001)') /01'

-**0())11? /''(-*).

**(A/' @ 6''-( */**1 -*@ 9(00(1* 1'- 63-'-(3* '-(91 6.'/? '@( @360 )./1 6.'&'-(*/(-9(0.

@'9(916( (A0()11? >-( '-(*( .((. '

'-( */( *(' 11(3' * @('>(('-(*/(0.'(*-(00(11') /01'-93 *'-*)*( '-()91*( .'-(*/(.(1(&'-(*/( > 61-9(@(.3 '-(0.(*(') /01'*>(11&>-)- -* .3-'1? @(( */**( @? '-( 1(.( '.1 6.'& 9( /063(;63/(''( , .(* &'-(/) '(' '-(00(11') /01'

-*@(('-'-( '(A()6'('-(11(3(9''( ,

'.*(.-*'6@(>(11) ()' 9 6. '-(

.(*0 ('!.'0 3-**6)-&'-(*/(&?&>* '-(.(*61' .6/*.(0.(*('' >(9(.&-(-* ).

**(A/' /''('-'-(-1() /01'/.7 #

,3*'.(*0 ('!.'0 3- '-(.* @( .( ( . 60(.'((' !

1)(&'-*.(*0()' -( 1(.('.1 6.''(.0(.6*3'-(*/(-*.3-'1? @*(.9( '-'-***(.' -*@ 9() /01''-' 81*, .1* -*1>*3 ''.*(..(.

/-/

81* .1*

'1/(*6.3 , 81* .1 1 3>'- ('6@(>(11 ) ()' & .661('1?6(.'-(0.(**6.( 67-(9 3-&'(..

.*''

360 '&/('@6'1?)1(.'-''-(11 3>'- '-(*06'('6@(>(11>*'.*(..(@?-/9 6. '-( .(*0 ('& /? @( 6(. '-( 11(3(0.(**6.( 67-(9 3- -@@& >-)- -* '- 63- ' @(( 0.

9( '-( .() .-(00(11') /01' '(?'-() '('* -*@ 9() /01'.7#&.'-(.-*)'(3 .)11?/''( @ 6''*13@( .( ! '-(.31.3('6.('-(*'')*(*'-''-( *3'6.(* '-( 00(11') /01' '-( *06'( 9'*.(2 &!

3->-(.(*& '-(0.(*(') /01'&

-**''(/('*(')-(-**3( 31*-&>-)-0.

9(* -* /1( *- (*' '(' & @()6*(&- -(@(( - (*'& '-' (9('& -( > 61 -9( *3( -* 0.(*('

/01'-**''(/('&@( .('-(1(.('.1 6.'1*

6./67-&* *'

(@1('-( 6.''

) /0.(-*/''( *3'6.(*>'--**06'( (**@ 9() 6)' *33 -*) /01'*''(/(' 31*- ' 6./67- > 61>..''-(.>3 9(.*((.()(3*'-/& '-'-(-*'(' 11? (* &'

/*1('-( 6.' .

'-(.> .*'

*600.(**'-('.6'-.

/'-( 6.' 9(> '-(*)6** @ 9(&>( 11(31'? .

0(.9(.*'? '-( /063( ;63/(' )<6''3 '-( .(*0 ('-(0.(*('00(1*)) .31?*/**(&@(3 (9 ?/(.' C D C $"D "

,, 1