Dr Neha Bansal v. State Of Haryana And Others
!
"#$
"% # &'( ) '$*'
'
) !'$
) ) ) "
+,,
)$,
('
-'.
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$-
,,,,,$ -"
)
- ,
0') # / $0'
) "
$-
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
- , 1
)# '
) "
$-
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
- ,
/ ) '$2'- ) "
$-
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
-
,
$ *'
2'
- '$0'
) "
$-
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
- 1,
&*"
) "
$
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
- ,
2"0'.
) "
$-
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
- ,
'0
!'$!
) "
$-
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
- ,
""&'
) "
$-
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
-
,
#.-
) "
$-
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
- ,
*"!
) $ -
!
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
- ,
/ 2'- ) "
$-
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
- , 1
'0
(#) $'&'
) "
$-
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
- , 1
'$ - 2#0'$ ) "
$-
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
-
,
.'0 ) "$-
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
- 1,
-' ) "
$-
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
- ,
''$
/'- - ) "
$-
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
- ,
-#2 ) / -
!
) "$-
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
- , 1
-#
2#0'$
) "
$-
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
-
,
0#
) /
) "
$-
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
- , 1 1
( '/ - 2#0'$ ) "
$-
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
- , 1
0"
) "
$-
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
- , 1
&*"
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
- , 1
'03') 2 '
) "
$-
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
-
1 , 1
-#
)
/ $0'
) "$-
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
$"#!
'))
"
'.
% - $ '$*
"
!"/ $
"% '$*'
) "$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
- 1, 1
0'
&# 2#0'$
) "
$
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
- , 1
'- # 2#0'$ ) "
$-
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
- , 1
'$2 - ) "
$-
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
- , 11
0#- '2 ' 0 )
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
-
, 11
!#$$
-
!
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
$"#!
- '))
"
'.
%
- $ '$*4 %
) '$
,,,,,$ -"
)
- , 1 1
$ *'
2'
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
- , 11
/ &'* ) $ ) "
$
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
- , 11
'..'/
- '$0'
) "
$- ,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
- , 1
0'0
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
-
,
'/'
2#0'$ ) "
$-
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
- 1,
$ *'
"")'
) "
$
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
- , 1
/ & ) $ 2#0'$ ) "
$-
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
- ,
!
$'
) "
$-
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
- ,
$
$'
) "
$-
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
-
,
""
'0 ) "
$-
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
- , 1
-'
"- $'
) "
$-
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
- ,
-#0'
!#
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
- ,
- '
) "
$- ,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
- ,
-'
&'* 2#0'$ ) "
$-
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
-
,
#.
2#0'$ !
&'
) "
$-
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
- 1, 1
'$ ) $ ( '$)'& ) "
$-
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
- ,
-'
"- *')'/ ) "
$-
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
- ,
/'$- '
) "$- ,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
- , 1
!"/
) '
'$ ) "
$-
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
-
,
('.'
)"$'
) "
$-
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
-
,
) 2'
) "
$-
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
-
,
'/
$'
*')'/ ) "
$-
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
-
, 1
'$"$'
) "
$-
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
-
, 1
$ # ('.'
) "
$-
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
-
,
$'&'
2#0'$ '
) * ) "$-
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
-
1,
'/) )'
!
) "
$-
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
-
,
$
# ) "
$- ,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
-
,
2'0'.
2'
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
-
, 1
/ 2'- / $0'
) "
$-
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
-
1 ,
&'
$'2'-
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
- 1, 1
0'
$
2'#$ ) "
$
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
- 1,
0'&"$ -
!
) "
$-
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
- 1,
0"
2#0'$
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
- 1,
'$
) "
$-
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
-
,
/ / 2 &
)'.
) "
$-
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
- 11,
)$ '*'.
2 '
) .'.
) "
$-
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
- 1, 1 1
-#$ *'
) "
$
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
- 1, 11
) "
$
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
- 1, 1
0'
*')'/ ) "
$-
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
-
,
-'
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
- ,
-' ) "
$-
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
- ,
0'
&# $'
) "
$-
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
- ,
'0
0'.
) "
$-
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
- ,
-'
&'* 2#0'$ ) "
$-
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
-
1 ,
-#$ ) $ -
!
) "
$- ,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
- 1,
$ # ) "
$-
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
- , 1
""&'
) "
$-
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
- ,
&*"
) /
,,,,,
"
$- / $-#-
-
"% '$*'
) "
$- ,,,,,$ -"
)
- "$'0+ "
5(.
0$, &#-
-'
) 0"#)!
.
!" #$
% & ' & ( & ) !
" (%
!* +
"
'"
$
# !
&!"
)
)
! " )%
& ,)
* # &
$
%#
!
#
&
+
!
&
"
)
#)
, ' &
& & "
%
&
- #
# !.' *
) "
.
///// -'
) 0"#)!
.4 & "$'.
(
'1 &&
+
'! &4156731
( % ' 33:;337 -
2
! ; 37 8:
3836 100 ' 3' & !
' & '! '
&
!
% 3 < ' &' . )1 380= ' .
''
>
' ' !
37 8:
3836 !;1 >! &
!
37 > 105 8?
3839 07 3839 > 106 109 ' ;. '
'1 ; 37 8:
3839' )1 380= ' '
' !
37 8:
3836 ''
'
(
& !
! ;# . .
)1 380=
'"!) @ ' !
> : &&
'% &@ *
&
'2 @ *
&
&& ! <! '
> & '
!
''
:
( ! ! )1
' '
&
! ' % !!
(& &' !2
! &
! ' ! =
$ . .
1
& '! .
! !
3803 -"!)
A> && '
!
@ && B
.
! ' ! !
& "&
?
- ' !
! # . #.
&
*! & !)! & ! & & #.
$ !
&
!')1 380= ' . !
' "!) C
'"!) . ' )1 '!
& (
& > )1 ' !&&
& & ( ' ! )1 & &
!
'
&
$ & < @ *
&
# 3
)1 !! ! & ! !
-
! ' : && )1 380= & ! ! :8
'
!
@ *
&
-! '& @ *
&
' ! ! '
!
$ &
! ! ! ' '2
' %' )1 380=
-
!
&
% !&' > D
!"!" #$%" " && '( ) !"!*+,- )' *./0 !
!& >
1
0:
$ '&
& ' !
# 3
"& .
@ *
& & !
& !
> > % -
# . #. && &%' "& - "& >
1 !
E %1
1& & ( & !!
<
"&&
&>
>1& '
&
& & & & !
!& & !&1
- '& )1 380=& & '#. ' !
&
&
! E
$!
&&' *
& '@ *
& ( @ *
& ! ! !
& ;
1 : &&
'
& & & !
2 '2 <! ' )1 ' @ *
& F # 0;6?;38331 0@*--;0=057 37 8:
3836 % &
0=
-
'& #. ' !
.
! !
3803 "& "! )
&
A ' ! )1 ' ! &
&
"&& )1 & '
! & &!
0?
!! @ *
& E & ! !> ' > & E
(
! !
1&
' ! >2 &'!'
' ' @<!' )1 ' & !&
!
'' &
-
!
&
% !& > 6 ' & & '
2 2002(3) ALL MR 932, !
2
2
& !'
&
30
(
& ;@ *
& ! )1 380=
' &#.
& : && ' ! < ' )1 !'
' 1 "!)
!& >
C
'& &
)1 380= > 19
'"!) . ' "& .
C& "!)
)1
& )1
'!!
& '
@
. !
& &' "&& &)1
& ! >
! : &&' ( @ *
&& & & '
! & ' ! & :8
> 15 ( & @ *
&
' ! ! ' <' !
& & &
' ( <!' &
! ; 37 8:
3836 < 100
'
- & '
'
& &!'
)1
' &
C & && & ' && '2 & &
& '
'! <
@ !
& @ *
&1 # 3'! ' ' ' "!' .
!
&
' !>
. (
!
! C "!) # 6 )1 @ *
& !
!
! &
1 !'
1 ! & &
& &!&
3:
( E
' !& >
& & )1 '!& '
& >
(
&
&+
- !& >
'
!
> & '
% ' & ' !06 -
& && +
-
>
'
& !
& > ' !
!!& !
( #. & &
"& &
& & 2
' (
& ' ! & &
#. & & &
06 % ' ( !&
E! &
'
'
3=
( ! !
< G & ! & )1
A
!!
& & ' '
! & &
& '
3?
* '
& (
!"44 +.- /4,0
22. As already noticed, fairness in State action is the essence of proper governance. Where the authorities exercise their powers under the rules, they are expected to exercise the discretion vested in them fairly and with the intention to attain a balance between exercise of discretionary power and the larger public interest sought to be achieved by such discretion. Arbitrariness or irresponsible exercise of the power vested in the authorities, has been a matter of great concern before the courts.
( E '
+
- D2
2
H
& !& !
"&& G
!
)1 ( % ' ! &
!! & ' ! ! '
>
'1 380= !!& !
@ !
' ! 1 (
& ! 2 !'!!'
'2 '
2 ' &
- 5 & 6 +!""#- * ./,
& '
37
27. This Court, in a catena of decisions, has granted relief against recovery of excess payment of emoluments/allowances if (a) the excess amount was not paid on account of any misrepresentation or fraud on the part of the employee and (b) if such excess payment was made by the employer by applying a wrong principle for calculating the pay/allowance or on the basis of a particular interpretation of rule/order, which is subsequently found to be erroneous. The relief against recovery is granted by courts not because of any right in the employees, but in equity, exercising judicial discretion to relieve the employees from the hardship that will be caused if recovery is ordered. But, if in a given case, it is proved that the employee had knowledge that the payment received was in excess of what was due or wrongly paid, or in cases where the error is detected or corrected within a short time of wrong payment, the matter being in the realm of judicial discretion, courts may, on the facts and circumstances of any particular case, order for recovery of the amount paid in excess.
$ > ' D 7 8 & ) !" 9: .#%0 "13. In State of Punjab and Others v. Rafiq Masih (White Washer) and Others, (2015) 4 SCC 334 wherein this court examined the validity of an order passed by the State to recover the monetary gains wrongly extended to the beneficiary employees in excess of their entitlements without any fault or misrepresentation at the behest of the recipient. This Court considered situations of hardship caused to an employee, if recovery is directed to reimburse the employer and disallowed the same, exempting the beneficiary employees from such recovery. It was held thus: "8.
As between two parties, if a determination is rendered in favour of the party, which is the weaker of the two, without any serious detriment to the other (which is truly a welfare State), the issue resolved would be in consonance with the concept of justice, which is assured to the citizens of India, even in the Preamble of the Constitution of India. The right to recover being pursued by the employer, will have to be compared, with the effect of the recovery on the employee concerned. If the effect of the recovery from the employee concerned would be, more unfair, more wrongful, more improper, and more unwarranted, than the corresponding right of the employer to recover the amount, then it would be iniquitous and arbitrary, to effect the recovery.
In such a situation, the employee's right would outbalance, and therefore eclipse, the right of the employer to recover.
xxx xxx xxx
18. It is not possible to postulate all situations of hardship which would govern employees on the issue of recovery, where payments have mistakenly been made by the employer, in excess of their entitlement.
Be that as it may, based on the decisions referred to hereinabove, we may, as a ready reference, summarise the following few situations, wherein recoveries by the employers, would be impermissible in law: (i) Recovery from the employees belonging to Class III and Class IV service (or Group C and Group D service).
(ii) Recovery from the retired employees, or the employees who are due to retire within one year, of the order of recovery. (iii) Recovery from the employees, when the excess payment has been made for a period in excess of five years, before the order of recovery is issued.
(iv) Recovery in cases where an employee has wrongfully been required to discharge duties of a higher post, and has been paid accordingly, even though he should have rightfully been required to work against an inferior post.
(v) In any other case, where the court arrives at the conclusion, that recovery if made from the employee, would be iniquitous or harsh or arbitrary to such an extent, as would far outweigh the equitable balance of the employer's right to recover."
14. Coming to the facts of the present case, it is not contended before us that on account of the misrepresentation or fraud played by the appellant, the excess amounts have been paid. The appellant has retired on 31.03.1999. In fact, the case of the respondents is that excess payment was made due to a mistake in interpreting Kerala Service Rules which was subsequently pointed out by the Accountant General."
(
&
>
&
! '& ' ' !
06
( '1 &
& !& & ! '
&
5:
C
> '1 380=2 & ( '
! ' ( '
&
& '
789
) ! I <! ! ' &
!; 37 8:
3836 > 100 ' !
' 5=
! 2 ' '!
!& >
1 ' 06 - & & '
! :J & &
<
5?
!'
'
!
-'
) 0"#)!
. ,,
&#)!
Anuradha/Meenu Whether speaking/reasoned :Yes/No Whether reportable :Yes/No