Nahar Singh v. State Of Punjab And Others






    
  


  

  

 

 !

   
 




















!


 "#  "

  #$"

 %
 %  


$
%&
'#

()*
#+"
,"
)


&
%&
-))
"#*
##"
& &
'-&
%&
& &
#).*
#+"
/0(
#
"1
,"
 "#
"&


%&
& &
*
#+"

,"
 "#
"&
&
  %  & 
  

)




"
,"
23 "
,"3
,(
,#
"

4
",
'#(3
##
5&&556
#
-4
#
#
%(


7*
!)&

"
)
"
"##

)


"*
)
3

".#*

4#
,"&


#

  

The instant application (CRM-A-1316-MA-2014) has been filed under Section 378(4) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (for

short `the Cr.P.C.') for grant of leave to appeal against impugned judgment of acquittal dated 03.11.2009 passed by learned Judicial Magistrate Ist Class, Dhuri and judgment dated 26.05.2011 passed by learned Additional Sessions Judge, Sangrur, vide which, the appeal filed by the petitioner against said judgment dated 03.11.2009, has been dismissed. ,
,
",
)


)
)


8"3 
-3#

"3 
(
()
()
#
9) 
()
-4
(
)

)
4
55855:*
)
(+
)
:


",
#
"
 
-







;
&*<55=8



"
()
()
,"
.))

.(
.
2#
#
()
()*
(#
"
4
&*<*555=8
-,"
5>&&55*

)
3
",
)+(
"
",
##4
"

&

.
#

)
"3 
)
()
()*
##
"
9
)
."#
#
)
)
"3 
"

#
)3
,"3
)+(
)
##4
"

*
.) "*
)
 -
#
 )
9) 
()
+#
#
()
()
(#
"
4
)
.)"
3"
,
(
)
##4
"

&


#

)
"3 
)
#
 )
9) 
()
""9
)
(
(#(
)
43
#
#
)
 
?&&55*
)
."#
9
)
3"
,"3



















()
()
"(
.)
&?*555=8
#
."#
)#
"+
)
3
"
"3 8)
()
#
),*
)
"3 
."#
"
9
,"
3"4
,"3
#
()
()&

.(
.
(
#
"
)+
-
2#*
.))
.
(#
-4
 )
9) 
()
#
"
)
.&

.
#
)
 "
2 4
",
)
3
3*
)


8 "3 
@#
()
()
#
9) 
()
"
4
&**555=8A
)".+*
)4

",,
)
3
"
"
2
"
)
")
#

#

)

)4

."#

4

)

.)"

3"
"(
.)

#

(
2#
")
.(

)
(#&

.
#
)
-@4*
.)


8"3 
@#
-"
43
,"3

()
()
#
 )
9) 
()*
)4
-3
"(
#
,#
"
39
4
43
#
)
2##
)
"
)


8
"3 *
.) "*

"3 
.
-3#
"
)
"*
((
)
()
()
#
9) 
()*
-")
)#
"+#
.)
)
")
#
)#
)


8"3 
#
)#
38

"

#
)
3"
",
 
/1&
")
"3 
.
-3#
"
)
"
 #
",
"*
(
"
<&5?&55>&




)
"
)
-
",
)
"3 
-3#
-4
)


8"3 *



"&
##
5&5&55>

"
"
) 
#
"
:5
#
58
",
)
#

7"#*
.
(#
#
"#(4*
)
)(
.
"
,3#
#
)
#
"&


"#
"
"+
)
*
)
""
)#
23#
B8

 "
!
()*
B8
)
()
/

8"3 1*
B8
)'
()*
B8:
 #
()*
B?
.
()*
B8>
 
()
#
+"
#"3
.
-3#&
),*
3
",
)
#
#
"

",
)
7"#
",
73
"#*
.
"##
#

)
3(
3=+#
.

"
)
#*
.))
.
##
-4
)3&
()
()
""9


)
)
)#
9
)
#
",
)


8"3 
"
 
-
,"
"
4
#
)
.
"

#
-4
)
"3 
)3,
,"3
)+(
)
"

&

.
)
#
)
 )
9) 
()*
)#
+#
)
3"
,"3
)3
#
),*
)
"3 
)#
9
)
""
",
)



















#&
9) 

()

""9
)

)
)
)#
("
)
"3 "3
,,#

-.
)

#
)
)
"
"
"
"


)
"3 "3
#
)
34
 #

)
"3 "3
-(














"8+(&

,


(
)

+#
+-
"
)
"#*
)
#

7"*
+#

'#(3
##
5&&556*
@#
)
 "#8#
",
)
)(
,3#
(
)3
-4
(+(
)3
)
-,
",
#"-
#
)#

#
$8

    
    

 
 !

" "     #    $ 
      

    %"  &'
  #
   
                #       
   #
       (       
       #    # #  #  # %" &'

" )  &'        
    *       #  
  
   
 #  
 
   
 ' 
         (   #+ 
 , )
-"+8#
'#(3
##
5&&556
#
-4
#
#
%(

7*
!)*
.
3 (#
-4
)


8 "3 
-4
,(




-,"
)
"
#(*
(A
)".+*
)
3
.
#3#*
-(
"
3-
+#
'#(3

##
>&5?&5
#
-4
"
#(*
(*
-4
"-+(




#
$8

" 
#
#  -.
  '     &#  /"'     &#

 /"'# "0 '' &1232" 4 15  " 03   

 "" 0  6           



" 0      
  '   6          

  '    , ),*
)



"
#
"
C</:1
",
)
7"#
",
73
"#*
9(
+
"



(
)
-"+8#
'#(3
##
5&&556
#
-4
)
#
#
%(

7*
!)

.

'#(3
##
>&5?&5
#
-4
#
"
#(*
(*
"(
.)
)


*
)
-
,#
-4
)


8"3 &





"
"
"
)
)
-"+8#


"


/
   1
#
"
C</:1
",
)
7"#
",
73
"#*
)
-
,#
,
)
#4
",
C:
#4A
"#(4*



"
/
 1
#

"
?

",

)
03"
*
)

"

-

,#*
9(
"#""
",
#4&



)
+4
"*
#
"


(
,"
 "#
"&
#

)+
#

34
"-'"
-,"
)
7"
)
)
3 (#
'#(3
",
@
)
-
#
-4
)
#

7"
"
5&&556A
"@4*
)
"3 
)#
"
()
"
,





(
)
'#(3
",
@
#
-4
)
#
#
%(

7*
!)A
)".+

)


8"3 
,#




-,"
)
7"
",
"
#(*
(A
.))
.
#3#

"
3-
+#
'#(3
##
>&5?&5&
),*
)


8 "3 
 
"+
)
3
#
)



"
#
"
C</:1
7& &7&
,"
+
"



"(.)



)
-
,#
"3 #
-4



"
#
"
?
",
03"
*
9(
"#""
",
2 #
#4
",
C:
#4&
0#
"
,"
 "#
"&

#

)+
"
-3#
)
)
"+"
"
"






C
7& &7&*
.)-4
)
+3
)
-
(#
)
()
"
,




(
)
@
.
#
.&&,&
&&556
#
)
3


" +

&
7"@4*
)




"
3-
-,"
)
7"&
0#
"
,"
)
 "#
"
#

"
)
.
#
#".
-4

)
",
)
7"

     

  

  ! "  # !$   %& 
 %
'

'#&  (
)
'#(3
",
"D-
)
 3
7"

') * # +!,'

%-&

. # $ !

,$ , . #'   !/ + #) #

!$ (  0 % & 
 %
'

'#& 10
#
"
)
'#(3
##
-4












7"8"#
)
",
)
7"

)

",
E2'   *# #

!$ 3( % & 
 %
'

'#& 01
)
-3"
3#
-4
#
"
,"
 "#
"&

#

)+
-
"

"#
-4
#
"
,"
)



#

















)

"##

)


+.

",

)
"+"

"#


"
C</:1

7& &7&*
)



.
3-
-,"
)
7"&
7) 
FF F















",


7"#

",

73

"#

6C*

#

.)


)




&

"

C<
7& &7&
#

#$
8 10 .. '# " !/ "4 ' ) 71 3 #  #
)1"3
6 #
)1 3153) 138$ &
& '

     *  
  $
)
 
 9 1
3   :#       &
 &        - '      

    * 
'-' 7
     13;     * 
' #; 1"3*     
 #
  8 

  &  <
    8    &  <
 2 0%! 1"5 

0%!3 
        #      '  2    ' 7 '  :#  
6#
) 1 3  &
& ) 13' *  
$
 )
 
9 1
3   - '      

 * 
' -'7
 13;   *  
  '    #; 37= -';
)1 3 
) 1"3


  ( 

#-'

1%3*        - '    
 
     #        *    -' 153= 
)1%3   # * 



-'((  
# (# *  1!3 
)1%3   #  *           *  

   
) 1 3  
) 1"3

)+
)#
#
"
,"
)

#
)+
("
)"()
)
 
-""9

.

3 (#
'#(3
#
"
)
'#(3
#
 "
-4
"
,"
)
 "#&
,"
"#(
)
"-'"
#
-4
#
"
,"
 "#
"&

#
*

."#
-


"
"
,
"
)
"+"
"#

"
C
",
7& &7&*


""#
"
"
&&556*
.))
#

,"".$8
> 1 5!

.. !

'

# !$ 6' . !') =   

    6      '(#
'
  
> 
-


",
,"#

"+"
"#




















"
C
7& &7&
/

""#
"
"
&&5561
."#

3,
)

)
+3
##
"
)+
)
()
"
,



&
)
)
.4
-

"
+.
)
)

 
)
+3
",
)
3&
+4

3
",,
.
#
"
-

",,
(
)

#
)

"
)#
)
".
"
+(
#
"
)
&
)*
)
+3="3 




)#
"
()
"
,



(
)
'#(3
",
@&

)
()
"



.
+#
,"
)
,
3


D+3D
#
)
"+"
"
"
C
",
)
7"#
#
-4
)
7"#
",
73
"#
/3#3
1
55<&
"
/1
",
)
3#3

4
#
)
G' $ "!

 '#!

/! " !#  "$ 

 $
#  7! # #

8(

#!'/'"'!# '# $ !//'"' 79(

..!'#:

# '// # 

8

 ..!'# /!

'// # . !''!# !/

$' "G&

,)
"
6
",
)
3#3
*
55<
(
"
3#3
",
"
C
",
)
7"#

)
G'# "'!# 1 !/ $

 '#"'. "( $ /!!6'#, . !'!

$

 '# ( # 8;  !'

$ $ '"'

$ $  ',$ !

. / # .. ,'# #8 ! 

.

$
!

 "4 ''#, $ ""

 !

"!#'"'#, /!

 

!//#" !

'

.!'#, '#4  "!

.#'!#( #  "$ .. $ '

!

$
!

 !

6$'"$ # .. ! '# '8 ' ,'# $ !  !/

"!#'"'!# !/  "$
!

G&
)
7
"+3*
-4
","
"& &&/1*
##
5&&556*


"#
&&556*

)
#
,"
)

"&?
",
556
"
"3
"
,"*
.))
.
-)#

)
H
",
#*
2"#4*

/1
"
/1*
##
5&&556&
)*
)
()









",
)
+3*
"
,





3
",
)
#
"+"
"

















"

C
7& &7&*
-3
+-
"
)
+3/1
",



.))

"#
.
#
-4
4
3
7"
@(
)
#
"
"+(
)3
,"


",,
"
3 "(
#@
"3 "*
"
"
,
&&556&

)
3##
"+"
",
"
C
7& &7&
#
)$8
> /"=   #)=   

    6     ' '(#
'
  
? < !' $ $ '"'

$ $  ',$ !

. / #

.. ,'# #8 !  .

$
!



"4 ''#, $ ""

 !

"!#'"'#, /!

 

!//#" !

'

.!'#, '#4  "!

.#'!#( #

 "$ .. $ ' !

$
!

 !

6$'"$ # ..

! '# '8 ' ,'# $ !  !/ "!#'"'!# !/  "$

!

=

)*
)



(
'#(3
",
@

("+#
-4
)
"+"
",
"
C<
",
7& &7&


-
"
/1
",
C<
7& &7&*
"4
)
!
%(
"
)
*

)

34
-*

#
"
#
)
-
""
"
,



&
-
"
/1
",
"
C<
",
7& &7&
#
.)
)

+(#
#
)
!)


"
-)3
*
6:>
#

)"
*
)
7

"+3
34
"
#
)
-
""
"
,



&


-
"
/1
",
"
C<
7& &7&*
"



"
)
()
7"
)
#
-
"
/1
"
-
"
/1
)
-
#
2 
.)
)
+
",
)
7"&
-
"
/:1
#
.)
)



,#
-4
)
"3 


)
"#
",
@

#

4

#
 "

"3 
#
)
()
7"*
"



"
3#
"

-4
)
"3 

)
-),*
(
 
+
"



,"3
)
"#
",
@&

,)*
-"
/?1
"+#
,"
)
3"
,"
,(
)
"
,"
(
",
 
+
"




3
",
-"
/:1&
-"
/>1
"+#
)


)


"
,"
 
+
"



,#
-4

"3 
#
-"
/:1

,#
)
"




,"3
)
"#
",
@
)

#
-"
/1
"
#
-"
/1&


)



)
"
,

)



(
@

"#*
"#
",
3
"#
-

#"3
"
"
)
*
.)"
"
.
#
"
,





*
.))
.
)#
"
)
-
",


&
)
"4
2 "
"
)




"
-


"3 
*
.)
)
"3 
"#
,




#
"
C</:1
",
7& &7&
,
9(
 
+
"


*


)



4
"
)
()
7"&



.
#
)

()
"





-+
()
#

"
-
,#
-4
3 "

)

2 4
"+#
"&
)*
)
()
"



(+
"

+3
#
)
"+"
"
"












C
",
)
7"#
)
-
3#
,"-
.&&,&
&&556
#
)
3

" +

&

"D-
 3
7"
",
#

') * # + +!,'

%-& . # $ !

,$ , . #'   !/ + #)

# !$ (  0 % & 
 %
'

'#& 10
)
)#

,"".$8
>/%@# -'#  ##          #   /"   '&' 0/   #     #  # -'#   #

  # 
  #
#          *  
  ' ##    *        

8
" 0#

  *         (  

    * 
   

  #     

    * 

    #  * (            (   #>

B)
)
,
",
)


"##

)
()
",
)
(
""

##

,"("(
A
)
"3 

)


.
"
#
"
,
)
"3 4(



-
)
3 (#
'#(3
",
@
)
-
#
-4
)
#

7"
"
5&&556
.))

3)
"
"
&&556
.)
)
"+"
"
"
C
7& &7&
.
,"#
#
)
"+"
",
"
C<
/:1
7& &7&


+.
",
)
-"+
#"*

3
",
)
"##
+.
)

"3 4(



#
"
C</:1
7& &7&
,#
-4
)


8"3 
(
'#(3
#
"#
",
@
##
5&&556
#
-4
)
#
#
%(

7*
!)




"&

##
5&5&55>*
#
"
:5*
#
58
",

7*

"
3-
-,"
)
7"A
"#(4*

#"
"
,#
4
',"
"
".
)


"
#
"
C</:1
",
7& &7&
.))

4

)
-
,#
,
#4
",
C:
#4&

"
#"
"
,#
4

-
("#
,"
"#"(
)
#4

,(
)


"
#
"
C</:1
",
7& &7&
"(.)
)


&

7"@4*
)


"
/
 1
#
"
?
",
)
03"

9(
"#""
",
#4

,(
)


"
#
"
C</:1
",
7& &7&

#3#&

#(


"=*
,
4*
)
#
"#&
'()

&

      * %  + ( 
  B))
 9(="#$
I="
B))
 "-$
I="