Bhajan Singh v. State Of Punjab & ANR
" # $% & '
"( *++,(-
/01232 ".
.0 '
4
.&012 * .2 # 56 " " 76 "
.# 1 102&839 1
-&
% :- .01.&0
.
% "3(-(0 . - 320 & 2 400 2&;
. - 0 .&0 0, $ ( (,( ) .&0 --9+
$( 1 ,0 :0 .
++0 , --1 ( ),$%.&0 (2 ,,;0 &0 0, $ ! $2( ++,$( )1,0 :0. ++0 ,(2- 0 &0( 2.
3 01"0-.( !<=>?@1 & 2 400 (,0 4$
. & '
)&% 200A( ) ,0 :0 . (,0 .&0 --9+
$( ++0 , 2. -B3(..
, .&0 . 2 . = :( 0 (9+3) 0 '3 )90 .0 =+ 220 4$.&0,0 0 (.(
,"022( 23 )0%
01C0+31
--1 ( ) . .&0
.% .&0$ ;010 .; 11(0 41.&012
31 ;(0102+ . 2& )(,,(-(.10, 2;(.&&(9 023,.
.,$%.;$0 12 -A%2&0;
2)(:0 40 )24$&01&324
.&322&0 2 102( ( ) ( &01 + .
, &90 . :(,, )0 -&&(;
9'(. 8 31 320 . - ,, &(9( .&0 ()&. . 900. &01 .&03.012( 0.&00,0-.1(-9.1.010 '$( ).&010% .&0$ 320 . ) 4 -A . .&0(1 102+0-.(:0 &902 <?%
31- ,,0 .&0
..900. ..&0 90 +, -0 43. &0 0-,( 0 . 900. &01 3:0 (,0(19 , "( )& ;
10 .&0 4:0 -.% ;&% 1-0 &(9 94(,0.900.&01 20B30 .,$% 13 D+9%
, );(.&2 ( (19 ,"( )&10 -&0 .&010
.
,A0 94(,0 ;(.&
9'(. 8 31 E&(,0 .&0$ ;010 +1-00 ( ) .;
1 2 .&0 2 ( 9.1% .&0
. &0 1 290 (20 .&0.1-&,()&.%&02 ;.& .102+ .
190 ;(.& 8(1+
102+ . < ;(.& A ++ , ;(.& ?D +012 190 ;(.&
)2% A ++
A(1+
-9( ) .&010 . 1 (20 , ,A . .0 -& ,022 ..&0
.1,(1.( ) .<) :0 ++ 4,; &(2&0 E&0103+
311 (20
, 19. ..40 ..&0
.;0:01%2.(,,102+ ) :0 A(1+
4,; &(2 &0 023,.
.,$% .&0
. 0,, ;
. 2
< ) :0
A(1+
A ++ 4,;2 1 01.+1.0-.19+3 -0 4,;2%.&0
.1 (20 &(2 19
10-0(:0 ( '31(02 &(2 ;1(2. '( . &0 3 .((0 +012 2 & ,2 )(:0 A(1+
A ++ 4,;2 &(21()&.
,0. 192
,0. 1&0102+ .2 ,2-& 20
31;0:01% 2&02A(++0 .&01&320&0
.;
2.&1;
.&010 .01 290 990 .% .&0
. - 90 .&0 1
3 .& .(19 ,"( )&& ,0 $19.&02+. &(2 9.1 -$-,0 &0 102+ .2 & ,2 2A(++0 ;(.& .&0(1 102+0-.(:0 ;0 + 2 &(2 ( -( 0 . & .
A0 +, -0 .&0 19 ,0 A0 4$(19 ,"( )&.102+ .
.&012 &0
. ;
2 .
A0 . .&0 (:(, 2+(.
,%
01C0+311.10 .90 .
.&0 4 2(2 4:0 ( 19 ;
10)(2.010 :02.() )0 -$ 2;3 .
-.( ".
.090 .2 ;(.
02202 ;010 10-1 0 &0 102+ .2 ;010 1102.0 &0$ ;010 +3. .1( , 3 01 :
1(32 "0-.( 2.&0
, 0 31( ).&0+0 -$+1-00 ( )2%(19 ,"( 2 0-, 10 '3:0 (,0%.&01010%20+ .0+1-00 ( )2;010 3-.0 2. &(9 4010 .&0 3:0 (,0 32.(-0 1
.2.=;010-& 1)02&00.0 3 01"0-.( !<%! %!?%!!%?=%?
++1 (2 , 0:( 0 -0% .&0 .1( , 31. ( . ( (.20, - -0 ;(.& .&0 +120-3.( 0:( 0
.&32% -B3(..0 102+ . 2 . = :( 0 (9+3) 0 '3 )90 .0 = 0 -3 20,1.&0
1)30 .& ..&0 (9+3) 0 '3 )90 . (2 4 20 2319(202
- '0-.3102 &0( '31(0223010 4$.&0
.;010 3,$-1141 .0 4$.&090 (- ,0:( 0 -0&0+1020
+ 1.(-(+ .&0 +1(:
.0 102+ .2 ( .&0 -99(22( -1(90 ;
-,0 1,$02.
4,(2&0 %.&01010%.&0.1( ,31.3)&..& :0 :(-.0 .&09 .01 )(:( ) 31 .&3)&.3, - 2( 01 . .&0 2349(22( 2,0 0 -3 20,1.&0
.%;0( .&0 +1020 -9+,0.0,$901(. ,0221.&010 2 2. ,,; >(@ 9(..0 ,$%
& (,,(-(. 10, 2 ;(.&
9'(. 8 31 ;(0 102+ A&
)& .&0 .03, $ (0 <??% ;&(,0 .&0$ ;010 +1-00 ( 1 '$90 2 323 ,% .&0
. ;
2 234'0-.0 .40 )24$102+ .2
<
290 .((0 +012 2 &0 - 320 3,. 4$ .2.=;
2(,,(-(.10, 2
;0:01% .&0 4:0 :012( .&0
43.- 320 3,., -A2-10 0 -0%40320&0 -3, . +1:0 &(2 ,,0)0 (,,(-(. 10, 2 ;(.& .=
31;(0102+ A&
"( )&% 1%2&0- 90;(.&.&0 4:0 :012( .& . 2&0 ;
2 & ) 23-& 10, 2 ;(.&
. :0 &01 &324
A&
0:01 9 0
$ -9+, 2. .&0
1& )23-&10, ;(.&&(2;(0&32%.&0 +120-3.( 2.1$ 23012 19 +2(.(:0 0:( 0
.&010 2 1.&0 3,.;
.+1:0 >((@ .02. ( 0 .((- + 0 ;
2 - 3-.0 . ( 3. 2 . ;& ;010 .&0 3 .((0
(,
.2 20B30 .,$%(.-
2 0,$40( 0110 .& ..&03 .((0 +012 2;0101+0 ,20,$( .&0- 20 >(((@ &0 90 (- , 0:( 0 -0 02 . -1141 .0 .&0 '31(02 ,,0)0 ,$10-0(:0 4$.&0
.&0
..02.((0 .& . ,,.&0 --320 & )(:0 (:0( '31(020 -& &(2+012 .1 1$.(.% +01 .02.(9 $ E? 1
'( 01
-&
% .&010 ;010 ..
, 0()&. ( '31(02 .&0 +012
..&0 ,,0)0 ( '31(02.&0
1093,.(+,(0 %.&0 .&0$;3, 40-90910.&
.&100 .(902 0 -0% .&0 -3, 1 :012( (2 0 .(10,$ .1 (-.1$ . .&0 90 (- , 0:( 0 -0 10 2% .&010(23 0F+, 0 0, $31 $2( , )( &0 0:( 0 ++10-( .0 4$ .&0 .1( , 31. (2 20 .&13)&
00+ 0F 9(
.&0 ;(.
02202
.&32%(2 .,( 4,0.40 (2.3140 :(0; .&0 102 ( (2-322( % ;0 ( 901(.( .&0+1020
%.&01010%.&02 90(2 &0104$ (29(220 60 :0. ++0 ,(2 0-,( 0 "@ > @ $% 8