High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-A/554/2016dismissed

Kuljeet Singh v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2016-05-02Mr. Justice S.J. Vazifdar,Mrs Justice Daya Chaudhary9 pages

!"#$$%&'() *++"&, '% -$./!/ % %$01

'20%)$./ * $/+0'2$'%/ 34 5 5 55 64 5

.$/$'% .5 7$/) 7270, %$10.%)$ '%5

5 )$ &'/% '% %&0' ) / 8$$' 1&"$2 8 %)$

'% /$$9&'( "$ 7$ %0 1&"$ %)$ ,,0:+ &'( ++$ "

( &'/% ,;!&%% "01.$/+0'2$'%/0/5%0<7&2$&:+!('$2 #!2(:$'% 2 %$2 =55 + //$2 8 %)$ "$ .'$2 $//&0'/ !2($ $> .&5 ' 55

%$"$+)0'&, :$// ($ > .$,$&7$2 % 0"&,$ 0/% $,%0. ) .!)$.

.$( .2&'(

2:&//&0' 01 &' 0,9"

'2 0/+&% "5 ?)$.$!+0' )$'2$. &'() "0'( >&%) .$/) !:

. >$'% %0 %)$ )0/+&% "5)$20,%0.0+&'$2%) % > /'0%1&%%0:

%)$/% %$:$'%5)$1 :&"

:$:8$./01 "/0.$1!/$2%0 :

9$ %)$ /% %$:$'% !'"$// '2 !'%&" .$( &'$2 ,0'/,&0!/'$//5 '@55 '&'10.:

%&0'> /.$,$&7$2 &' %)$ 0"&,$ % %&0' >&%) .$( .2 %0 2$ %) 01 5 $. %)$. !"#$$%&'()"02($2%)$ %) %%)$:

..& ($01)&/ !()%$. >&%) .$/+0'2$'% 05

#8&. > / /0"$:'&A$2 0' 555 ' )$. :

..& ($ /!11&,&$'% 20>.

.%&,"$/ &',"!2&'( 7$)&,"$ )$'2.

B - (0"2 ,0&'/ %0"

(0"2 0.'

:$'%/ '2 (:/ /&"7$. 01 )&/ 0>' >&"" >$.$ (&7$' 8$/&2$/

" #

" (

) %

+ , -

/ 0

+ ,- .,1)),)1

+ , -

# #

,3)),)1

+ &

4 '

+ ,- # #

" +

- # 4 '

786

9 #

- + , 2

' %)$ 8 /&/ 01 10.$/ &2 ""$( %&0'/ 10.:

" !'2$. $,%&0'/ @C==C .$ 2 >&%) /$,%&0' = > / .$(&/%$.$25 ';!$/% +.0,$$2&'(/ >$.$ ,0'2,!%$25 1%$.,0'2!,%&'( !%0+/ /$ "$2+ .,$",0'% &'&'(7&/,$.

> /) '2$207$.%0%)$'7$/%&( %&'( 11&,$.5% %$:$'%/01 ."

'2 7$$'>$.$.$,0.2$25!++"$:$'% /% %$:$'% 01 '% !"#$$%> "/0.$,0.2$25 $/+0'2$'%0/5%0 < >$.$ ..$/%$25 $/+0'2$'% 05 /!11$.$2 2&/,"0/!.$ /% %$:$'%5 !./!

'% %)$.$%0 ,$"+)0/ +0!,) +&$,$/ 01 8.09$'8 '("$/70:&%01%)$2$,$ /$2 '2%)$+0&/0'>$.$ "&1%$2 1.0: %)$ +0&'%$2 +"

,$ >)&,) >$.$ ,0'7$.%$2 &'%0 /$ "$2 + .,$" >&%) /$ " 8$ .&'( &:+.$//&0' D35 "" %)$ 20>.

.%&,"$/>$.$.$,07$.$25 1%$./!++"

&'(%)$,0+&$/01,) ""

'%)$, /$;!

.$/+0'2$'% 0/5 %0 < > / ,0::&%%$2 %0 %)$ 0!.% 01 $//&0'/ '2 ,,0.2&'("

%)$ >$.$ ,) .($ /)$$%$2 !'2$. $,%&0'/==@C '25 ' 0.2$. %0 +.07$ &%/ , /$ %)$ +.0/$,!%&0' $E :&'$2 /:

/10!.%$$'>&%'$//$/5 )$ $'%&.$ &',.&:&'

%&'( $7&2$',$ > / +!% %0 %)$ .$/+0'2$'%0/5%0<5)$ +"$ 2$2%)$&.1 "/$&:+"&, %&0'5 '2$1$',$'&'$>&%'$//$/>$.$$E :&'$25 1%$. +$.!/&'( %)$ >)0"$ .$,0.2 /, ''&'( %)$ $7&2$',$01%)$+.0/$,!%&0' '2)$ .&'("$'(%) .(!:$'%/ 1.0:80%)%)$/&2$/%)$%.& "0!.%,0',"!2$2%) %%)$ 807$ ,) .($/ >$.$ '0% +.07$2 ( &'/% %)$ .$/+0'2$'%/ 8$ 0'2 20!8%5 ,,0.2&'("

%)$ .$/+0'2$'% 0/5 %0 < >$.$

,;!&%%$201%)$,) .($/5

4$ .'$2 ,0!'/$" ++$ .&'( 10. %)$ '% ) /%.$'!0!/"

.(!$2 %) % %)$ #!2(:$'% 01 %)$ %.& " 0!.% /!11$./1.0:"$( "&'1&.:&%&$/>)&,).$;!&.$/%08$/$% /&2$

'2 .$/+0'2$'% 0/5 %0 < .$ "& 8"$ %0 8$ ,0'7&,%$2 '2 /$'%$',$2 10. %)$ ,0::&//&0' 01 )$&'0!/ 011$',$ 01 20>. 2$ %)5 )$ #!2(:$'% 01 %)$ %.& " 0!.% &/ 8 /$2 !+0' /+$,!"

%&7$ "

/&/ >)&,) &/ 2$70&2 01 :$.&%5 "

,&'( .$"& ',$ !+0' %)$ +.07&/&0'/ 01 $,%&0' = 01 %)$ 7&2$',$ ,% %)$ "$ .'$2 ,0!'/$" ) .(!$2 %) % / %)$ 2$ %)01 ) 20,,!..$2>&%)&'/$7$' $ ./01:

..& ($

'2 %)$ +.0/$,!%&0' ) 2 $/% 8"&/)$2 )$. ) //:$'% 0'

,,0!'%012$:

'20120>.

"$( "+.$/!:+%&0'> /%08$ 2.

>' ( &'/%.$/+0'2$'%0/5%0<10.)0"2&'(%)$:(!&"%

'2/$'%$',&'(%)$:10.%)$011$',$/,0::&%%$25 ?$ ) 7$ %)0!()%1!""

,0'/&2$.$2 %)$ .(!:$'%/

',$28 "$ .'$2,0!'/$"10.%)$ '% '2 .$01%)$ 7&$>01%) %%)$ %&0'2$/$.7$/%08$2&/:&//$210.%)$ .$ /0'/%010""0>5 )$%.& "0!.%&' ,;!&%%&'(.$/+0'2$'%0/5%0< !'2$.$,%&0'=.$ 2>&%)$,%&0'= ) /% 9$'&'%0 ,0'/&2$.

%&0'%)$:$2&, "$7&2$',$5 ?.5!2)7&.&'() 2$+0/$2 %) % "!:&'!: +)0/+)&2$ $:&%/ +!'($'% /:$"" &% ,0!"2 '0% 8$ 2:&'&/%$.$2 8 2$,$&%1!" :$ '/5 ?= .5 '#$$% %) '2 ?@ .5:&% 7 , %$(0.&, ""

2$+0/$2%) %'0&'#!.

0./%.!(("$:

.90' + .%01%)$ 01 > / 10!'2 '2 %)$.$10.$ &% , ''0% 8$ &'1$..$2%) %%)$+0&/0'0!//!8/% ',$> 2:&'&/%$.$28 10.,$ 0. 2$,$&%1!" :$ '/5 )$ .$ /0'&'( 20+%$2 8 %)$ %.& " 0!.% &' ,;!&%%&'( !'2$. %)$ 10.$/ &2 ,) .($ , ''0% 8$)$"2%08$!'#!/%&1&$25 ' %)$ +.$/$'% , /$ %)$ :

..& ($ 01 2$,$ /$2

> / /0"$:'&A$2 0' 55 '2 %)$ 2$ %) ) 2 % 9$' +"

,$ 0' @55 :$ '&'( %)$.$8 /)$ 2&$2 >&%)&'/$7$' $ ./01:

..& ($5)!/%)&/0!.%&/%0/$$ %0 >)$%)$. %)$ +.07&/&0'/ 01 $,%&0' = .$

8"$5 $10.$.$ ,)&'(%0 "0(&, ",0',"!/&0'%)$1 ,%/ 01%)$, /$, ''0%8$07$."009$25% .0!'25 5:50' 55%)$.$> '&'%&:

%&0'.$( .2&'( 2:&//&0'01

&' %)$ 0/+&% "5 )$ +0"&,$ .$ ,)$2 %)$ 0/+&% " %

.0!'2 5 +5:5 0>$7$. %)$ :

%%$. "&'($.$2 0' 10. ,0'/!"% %&0'01%)$1 :&"

:$:8$./ "/010.%)$.$,07$.

01 51%)$.$> ,.!$"% >&%) 10.%)$20>.

2$:

'2 &' %) % $7$'%!

"&% %)$ '% >0!"2 '0% ) 7$ % 9$' 8.$ %) 10. :0:$'%&'"02(&'( %)$ .

%)$. )$ >0!"2) 7$&::$2& %$"

2$%)$/% %$:$'%%) %%)$2$ %) 01)&/2 !()%$. ) 20,,!..$20' ,,0!'%012$:

'201 20>.

5)$ '%:

2$%)$/% %$:$'% 1%$. 1$>)0!./

01%)$2$ %)01 5 )$ +.0/$,!%&0' >&%'$//$/ >)0 !'10"2 %)$ /%0.

.$ ? !"#$$% &'() ? ."

'2 ? 7$$' 7 %)$ + .$'%/ '2 8.0%)$. .$/+$,%&7$"

01 %)$ 2$,$ /$2 5

? !"#$$% &'() 2$+0/$2 %) % %)$ :

..& ($ > //0"$:'&A$2&',0.2& " %:0/+)$.$>)$.$ / ? ."

, :$0!%>&%)2&11$.$'%7$./&0'%) %0'%)$0,, /&0'01F0 2 ) &3 .$/+0'2$'% 05

:(&.& ) 2 .

&/$2 2$:

'2/5 ,,0.2&'( %0 %)$ ,0'%$'%/ 01 %)$.$ > / 2$:

'2 01 %

!):

!))' !),+; + 3

+ <'

+ 1 -

# #+

!)) '

0 )

, &

? ."

'2 ? 7$$' 7 2$+0/$2 %) % 0' %)$ "

/% 0,, /&0' >)$' 2$,$ /$2 7&/&%$2 )$. + .$'% " )0:$ /)$ >

,,0:+ '&$2 8 .$/+0'2$'% 05

#8&. '2 )$ /%

$2 10. 1&7$2

/>&%)%)$: '2%)$'%0092$,$ /$2 >&%))&:5 ,,0.2&'(%0%)&/>&%'$//$//)$) 2%0"2%) %%)$ ,,!/$2 +$./0'/ >$.$ ) //&'( '2 8$ %&'( )$. 10. 2$:

'2 01 20>.

5 )&/ $7&2$',$ 20$/ '0% &'/+&.$ ,0'1&2$',$ 01 %)$ 0!.% / %0 >) %)$ 2&2 '0% 2&/,!// %)$ :

%%$. >&%) .$/+0'2$'% 05 '2 >) 2$,$ /$2 > / /$'% >&%) )&: $/+$,& ""

,,0.2&'( %0 ? 7$$' 7 % %) % +0&'% 01 %&:$ .$/+0'2$'% 05

#8&. .

&/$2 2$:

'2 01 %

+ , -

1>?& <19

<178

+ , 1

+ ,1

"" %)$ 1 ,%/ '2 ,&.,!:/% ',$/ 2&/,.$+ ',&$/ "/$ &:+"&, %&0' 01 %)$ .$/+0'2$'%/ 0/5 %0 < '2 08/$.7 %&0'/&'%) %.$( .2:

2$8 %)$%.& "0!.%"$ 2%0 %)$&'1$.$',$%) %%)$+.0/$,!%&0', /$&' ""+.08 8&"&%&$/&/ "/$5

' 7&$> 01 %)$ 10.$/ &2 2&/,!//&0' >$ 1&'2 '0 :$.&%&'%)$+.$/$'% %&0' '2%)$.$10.$%)$/ :$&/ )$.$8 2&/:&//$254$ 7$%0 ++$ "&/2$,"&'$25 G5 55H H