M/S Ishika Automobiles v. State Of Haryana And ANR.
! "#$% &&% '(" )*(+, ( &,
-( (&). / ,'( (0( ). / ,'( &&% ( 1+ " / ,'( (2) ,%! / ,'((&,3 44444 !"#$ $ %&' !(
)% *+ 5 &&% %, &(&&%",() 7(-(.(%'%&&%. #&"., (,(,,7
&,$+%(,8",%.(9(%/ :#"3.(/2 ($+/ (% "( ;", (&,
",#&%",()6 (,2 )7 3.$%("# /
( (/< =
( 1+ " / ,'((2) ,%! / ",&&($ %(&,3 , %,-2(
(+/2 !((, 6 *=$%)"&(#"( ,#
"*"#-./0 .1 12. * 3#
1 1 #"4 % 1 -2 ( 5) + )%.0.1 *+ 6( ( ,($%
,",#&('(&()6 ,6 7 (-/%",, '# (. %&&%",() (-$( "() %'&( , 1",.#",(
> 5 (( $',(( ,$%$(,%%2 9(%+/ '#(##" '$%" (. &((&&%2 $("#($, $++,&(, /'# ",()6 //&+( %,( ;"&(2 "(, #& ##,$+&(2 (., /#%+/ ",/2 ;" $ , "(, ),%+/ (. '#(##"$ &%,&(2 (. ",2 "(,'/2 /#((. &(( &&%",()67 (- &( ',(# (. &((&&% ",()67#((. ,$.
"$1, + , )#%(%+/ '# (#/ 2 '( $ "( (#/ ",%%+#" '(. &((&&% 5 (,%+/( ( -(%# ".
2 "#,.+,&(,$"%%%, $+ '# / 2 ?&( % %", %.%(&(',,'# 2 &((&&% ((+/.(,(;"%/
6 )/ (". -"$%-("(&(( &&%' #&%,&((" &&%/ ". "(" &&%2 %' "(*2'(/%2+(+( )(#&%&((&&%@"2 # '#A (. &(( &&%/ !.&%%'&&%(# *. "(",()6 7 (-2"%,$ ((+2 $,,$+ -(%#$+ ( &(')6 (- 9"( %+/ -(%# #,,) ("#($ '#A(. &((&&% 1" 2 (.(,#&%( ) %.
&&% ( ,/ -(%# (, &(')6 '. "&(((. ( '#&(( &&% .
(-,)76 $+?&((&( &(' (- #((%" ,#, (,(#%5 ((/ #&%/ 2 '#, "( ;"#"$ (",$'#(# &(') (,2 ,'#",()
2 (-B 7 9"( (/ &&%+. ,( &(&' '(("%./
7 *=$%)"&(#"( .%"2-7% -"
"3"1/"
1-"**.9"12"
3#
!
:/0 % %7% .1 %.0.1 * ;;" *
< 8
'.-$ %.0.1 * ;;" *
= &"2.&"& = 5( 2 %%(+. 1",.# %%$&&%$%((&'%+/ %,",( >5 ,%(",%.2 "$' (. /$+ %.%"(/,(,$&(&'"% ?&(%+ ( $+ (+ #&% #, ' ((&'&(5 %.%#?#C3'" 9""(9(##&($/3-((C,. 2%2". (."%2 %%2, &/((2 &("#&&(&'+, &("#&.(%%+,&("% ((+ 2 $+ ?&( &(' " ( ((&'+ (2 ,($% (".
(+ #&% 5 $" " " 2"%, ' ;".',(. /#&2$"(,( #&( ?. $%. *2'(/ 2 , (,(.&(.(, (&(&% &('"$;"%+'(("%,$+ ,%(.( $ / ;" '(("%.(!%+,( ,$+,"%/((&'$.# .
.- .# #"--*"& * '
-$ - -$"
* '
&"2* %"& >?
-$.# 7/%- .# %"-%7#;"2-.3"
1& .# 17%0 **?
##/0"& -7 >"
-$"
* '
8%70 -$"
.12";-.71 5 &(2%+,"(("%#"$ ", 2 1",.# !/&90"1- 7% &"2.#.71 '$.2$ .1-"%;%"-#
#- -/-"
7% ;%73.#.71 -$"%"78 &"2* %"# -$"
0" 1.19 -$"
#- -/-"
# .- #$7/*& >"
271#-%/"& 8%70 -$"
& -"
.-# "1 2-0"1-
7-$"% '7%&#( -$"
!/&90"1- &"2* %"# '$ - -$"
*"9.#* -/%"
$ & # .& - -$"
-.0"
'$"1 -$"
* '
' # ;%70/*9 -"& 1& -$"%"87%"( .- $ #
%"-%7#;"2-.3"
"88"2- ((+/ "( ("% 2 &("#,$&(&'"%?&(%+#, ((&'D %%2(# #/ ,( 1",.#".&(&%%2&&%$%%% ((&' .&,+$(,( ("#2 $", #. %22 ?,(# & (," (&('D $,%(,$ %2 %, #"$ %, '%2+$ %2 %,5 %"%#(# (% ,"+ "(C&("2%2$"#, ?&", %,C#& ,,,
5 ((/'2 1",.#(,(,$+ *=$% )"&(# "( "*"#-./0 .1 12. * "&( , .%"2-7% -"
"3"1/"
1-"**.9"12" "&(/ %(, ) 8",./ (,/ ,(,( &(%'&&%&&%%,",() (-,(" # &&(&("((,&% #( E .(+,(,, #&%&&($!, ((, %(,)8",./(,/( 2 &,/(,.%+-,.&&%/+/% ,,&, ) + < 6 5
D ()&!.
, : 3 D ( &($% : 3