High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-A/623/2016dismissed

Mohinder Singh (Since Deceased) Through Lrs v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2017-03-02Bench- 4,Mr. Justice Jaspal Singh4 pages

SUMIT GULATI 2017.03.14 16:32

!!"#$%$&'()*$+,-.#))+/ 01"$203&$3)0 +3&410")*$ 011$3,$.3&$"$,)#03565565675+3&8 )*$/$!+/ "$2"$$3)+)#%$01 +)$0*#3&$"#3!**+%$1#/$&)*$2"$$3)+22/#,+)#0310" 2$,#+//$+%$)02"$1$"+3+22$+/

*$,+$01)*$,092/+#3+3)#)*+)+92."+3#3!*1+)*$"01 0*#3&$"#3!*:+)*$0"#!#3+/0:3$"01+3+!"#,./)."+//+3&#).+)$&#3 %#//+!$+*+"2."

+92."+3#3!*&#$&03 5 0:$%$"/+)$"03+3 $3-.#"(#):+"$%$+/$&)*+)*$:+9."&$"$& ,"#9#3+/,+$:+/+.3,*$& +!+#3)"$203&$3)0 +3&4+3&03$ +<#3&$"#3!*.3&$"$,)#03465+3& 4"$+&:#)*$,)#0345 10")*$9."&$"01+92."+3#3!* .)!#%#3!

'$3$1#)01&0.'))*$(:$"$+,-.#))$&'()*$)"#+/0.") $203&$3)0 '( *+),*#3!+,"#9#3+/,032#"+,(:#)*"$203&$3)0 410"!$&+3&1+'"#,+)$&)*$ +!"$$9$3))0$//&+)$& 4+)*0.!*#):+$=$,.)$&'(/+)$+92."+3 #3!*)*$1+)*$"010*#3&$"#3!* 3 5+,,.$&./>+"#3!*

$3)$"$&#3)0+3+!"$$9$3))0$//*#/+3&:#)*)*$,092/+#3+3)+3&*#'"0)*$"

+&)*$"$'$$3+3(+!"$$9$3))0$//$=$,.)$&'(+92."+3#3!*#31+%0."01 "$203&$3)0 )*$/+))$":0./&*+%$2$,#1#,+//("$1$""$&:#)*"$2$,))*$"$)0 #3)*$+'0%$+!"$$9$3)&+)$& 5 0*#3&$"#3!*,+9$)0?30:01)*$ +//$!$&+!"$$9$3)$=$,.)$&'(+92."+3#3!*#31+%0."01"$203&$3)0 03/(.203$"%#,$01)*$/$!+/30)#,$ $203&$3)0 ./>+"#3!*1#/$&+ .#)10"2$,#1#,2$"10"9+3,$ 092/+#3+3)0*#3&$"#3!*0')+#3$&2*0)0,02( 01)*$+//$!$&+!"$$9$3)$3)$"$&#3)0'$):$$3*#1+)*$"+92."+3#3!*+3& ./>+"#3!*+3&,092+"$&)*$#!3+)."$01+92."+3#3!*:#)*)+3&+"& #!3+)."$ $203&$3)0 +3&4*+%#3!*+),*$&+,"#9#3+/,032#"+,( 10"!$&+3&1+'"#,+)$&)*$+!"$$9$3)10"+/$#30"&$")0!"+')*$/+3&01)*$ ,092/+#3+3):#)*0.)+3(+/$,03#&$"+)#03

3)*$#&$)*$,092/+#3+3)@8)0@85:$"$$=+9#3$& @ +!&#*A.9+":+)*$)+92%$3&0":*0*+&$20$&)*+)*$.22/#$&)+92 2+2$"#3)*$3+9$01+92."+3#3!*+2$")*$$3)"(9+&$#3*#"$!#)$"

@ +*#2+/#3!*+33)+)$&)*+)03 5+,,.$&./>+"#3!* $3)$"$&#3)0+3+!"$$9$3)10"+/$01*#/+3&:#)*,092/+#3+3)0*#3&$" #3!* $+/0+&9#))$&)*$1+,))*+))*$,#%#/.#)10"2$,#1#,2$"10"9+3,$ 1#/$&'(./>+"#3!*03)*$'+#01)*$+!"$$9$3)10"+/$&+)$& 4 $=$,.)$&'(+92."+3#3!*:+&$,"$$&#31+%0."01+,,.$&./>+"#3!* +3&+3+22$+/2"$1$""$&'()*$,092/+#3+3):+&#9#$&'()*$+22$//+)$ 0.") @4"

+(3+3&:*0:++*+3&:"#)#3!$=2$")&$20$&)*+)*$ *+&+30,,+#03)0,092+"$)*$)+3&+"&#!3+)."$01+92."+3#3!*03/(:#)* )*$ #!3+)."$ 10.3& #3 )*$ 2*0)0,02( 01 )*$ +!"$$9$3) 10" +/$ &+)$& 4 @5 .?*:#3&$" #3!* :+ 303$ 0)*$" )*+3 )*$ 03 01

,092/+#3+3) 0*#3&$" #3!* :*0 *+& 30) $%$3 "$+& )*$ ,03)$3) 01 )*$ ,092/+#3)/0&!$&'(*#1+)*$"0*#3&$"#3!* *$0"#!#3+/+!"$$9$3)10"

+/$$=$,.)$&'(*#!"+3&1+)*$"+92."+3#3!*:+30)2/+,$&#3)*$0.") 1#/$*$*+&$20$&

@$ *$+"& )*$ $/+'0"+)$ .'9##03 9+&$ '( /$+"3$& ,0.3$/ +22$+"#3!10")*$+22/#,+3)

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

3)*$2"$$3),+$)*$,092/+#3+3)2+")(9+&$+3+))$92))0 $)+'/#*)*$+//$!+)#0310"10"!$"(+3&1+'"#,+)#0301)*$+!"$$9$3)10"+/$ &+)$& 4'+$&03)*$$%#&$3,$01@4"

+(3+3&+3&:"#)#3!

=2$") .).310").3+)$/(@4*+&+30,,+#03)0,092+"$)*$)+3&+"& #!3+)."$01+92."+3#3!*03/(:#)*)*$#!3+)."$10.3&#3)*$2*0)0,02(01

)*$+!"$$9$3)10"+/$ 30)*$":0"&)*$0"#!#3+/+!"$$9$3)$=$,.)$&'( +92."+3#3!*:+30).'<$,)$&)0,#$3)#1#,,".)#3(01@4 3&$".,* ,#",.9)+3,$)*$$=2$")C$%#&$3,$/0$#),"$&#'#/#)( *+)+2+"))*$"$#30 +,,$2)+'/$$%#&$3,$)0'"#3!*09$)*$,*+"!$011+'"#,+)#03+3&10"!$"()0)*$ +,,.$&

*$/+)$"+!"$$9$3)10"+/$&+)$& 5$=$,.)$&'(+,,.$& ./>+"#3!*#31+%0."01,092/+#3+3)0*#3&$"#3!*:0./&30)$)+'/#*)*$ ,*+"!$0110"!$"(+3&1+'"#,+)#03+//$!$&+!+#3))*$+,,.$&

1,0."$)*$,0.3$/+22$+"#3!10")*$+22/#,+3).'9#))*+) $,03&+22$+/*+'$$32"$1$""$&++!+#3))*$,03,.""$3)%$"&#,)2+$&'()*$ )"#+/0.")+:$//+)*$1#")+22$//+)$0."),*+//$3!#3!)*$&$,"$$012$,#1#, 2$"10"9+3,$2+$&#31+%0."01./>+"#3!* *$2$3&$3,(01)*$+22$+/ &0$30)#3+3(:+()"$3!)*$3)*$,+$01)*$,092/+#3+3)#3+9.,*+)*$ ,092/+#3+3) 2+")( 1+#/$& )0 2"0%$ '$(03& "$+03+'/$ &0.') )*$ ,*+"!$ 01 10"!$"(+3&1+'"#,+)#03/$%$//$&+!+#3)"$203&$3)0 +3&4

3 %#$: 01 )*$ +'0%$ 1+,) +3& ,#",.9)+3,$ :$ +"$ 01 )*$ ,03#&$"$&%#$:)*+))*$)"#+/0.")*+"#!*)/("$,0"&$&+%$"&#,)01+,-.#))+/

*$"$#309$"#)#3)*$2"$$3)+22/#,+)#03$$?#3!2$,#+//$+%$)01#/$+3 +22$+/ *$"$10"$)*$+22/#,+)#03)+3&&#9#$&

! "

# +",* ! "

./+)# # @*$)*$"2$+?#3!D $+03$& $ @*$)*$" $20")+'/$ 0