← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-A/657/2016dismissed

Harpreet Kaur v. State Of Punjab And Another

2022-09-30Mr. Justice Sandeep Moudgil25 pages



        

 !

"#$#%&'( 

)

      *++,#"

%  - .$/$ 0  1     *

$+%!

% $ &  23  00  3  

       

 

 !

 " # $ 44444 0  356 .

,7 % !       &     '

 "  ""

 $( %$ $)%*  & +"  ,

" & '# $   -    " "

    (   ,    !  .  /  %010   23# $*1 %% )0 $)%$  ,&

" 

"       "" 

     4 ./ 5 %% )0 $)%$         

  

" "    

 ,&

""   

   "       $$ )6 $)%)    & ., / "7              ,  , "

-&  ./ 8"-& ., /  " 7        )9 %$ $)%)   "   , ,

 , "

 &           ,    , "

       & , :

;

 $6 )$ $)%%   ,

  ./ "    ., /7    $1 )< $)%%         ., /   , "

  "

         "      ./ !  ., / "7 

"

        ./ ,    &, :

;

    ,

       )< )9 $))0      &   7

"  !      &    

 7 

    

7  ,&    &       " "

   ./

',   

        & :, +"

" :, ;  ;   :, +  " & "   =  ./ :,+"

" "          &  "

  &   > ;

      ./

 "

     



" -&  &

5.:/

" .?/ 3   -& :, +"

"       &  > ;

  "

                   .?/ "   &          ,  ,

 , "

            ., /  " 7         & ,       "

          





" "   ( ,  

! ./%010 "





.?/ 5



"23 "  ( ,   !  .  /  %010 "

   & , > ;

 .?/ "

 & &    "



 &

  "  :,+"

" :, ;  ;   7 & ,  :

 ;

 

   "

         .?/ 5                

 " $)9,  , .?/   "               """ ,+ 

"       

       (    ,  

! ./%010  ?&   &    ,  "&     

   ,  

"   )9 )* $)%( 6897 2"  

       (    ,    !  .  /  %010 "

 "

  " 

 "&    

.?/ 3      "      ,   &        ?  ! 

     ' 3#$  :# % $$ $&  

:   :00 )% @'% 3  " )$ @'$   ": ,=5A5



" )( @'(

  " )< @'< 3; ;  )* @'* :,+"

" )6 @'6 &:,:

;

 )9 @'9

  "

3"7  )1 @'1 3  ;

 )0 @'0

;

 &  ,  & 7   %) @'%) 3   " 3#$  "/;

% $8<#=#

!&   >

  3 0   0 )% B?@%A

   3  " )$ B?@%A> 23-& .:C/

" )( B?@%A,

3-& .:C/

" )< B?@$A 7 %% )0 $)%$



" )* B?@$A> 7 %$ )( $)%(



" )6 B?@(A      '>  ;

 )9 B?@(A>   ' '3

 )1 B?@(A,

&> )0 B?@(A +



%) B?@(AB , , ,    %% B?@(A2 ,&

# $9 %$ )< $)%$ %$ B?@(A 7 %% )0 $)%$ ""  



" %(

= !,    %<  =>    %* B?@(A: ,&23

.?/ ! ' #  $     "                 .?/ 3   ?

 7 ,  ;     @'% ,

"

 "  @'$   "   B?

'%B?

'%*  =D E   .??/ 8      ,

     '

    " "

  &          "& - 

'# $ "

 "

 (  ""

  & ,  ,    '

   & "    "

   & , & '

 

    :          3 ;  ; A@'< :,+"

"A@'*   =   :         &"

 & , 7             &   &     < 3           A    ""     * ! "    "      '

* % 3      @'< @'*  @'6               "

" -    ' * $ 3; ; A@'< :,+"

"A@'*                7 & :, :

 ;

A@'6        >  ;

    @A* 

= "

    "

 * ( 3?

 ''      

 $A( &     

  " "

 "

= "

     $A(  &   "

 "

      :"

"    @A6    &       &    &   &    & * < !    3 ;  ; A@'<     = " '?

       " &      & .:/      "

& "

        2        " &  "

&  "

          :  &"

&  = &      : 

        

     &  

                ""

& * * !  &  :, +"

"A@'*    =     '?

                     

                       

                     

       

    

                      ! * 6 !               

              * 9 B"

"

    :, +"

"A@'*    " &     



   "       #    

     "   $      %     &       

      &  

  

'( ') *''+! * 1 B    '7 & :, :

 ;

A@'6 

 

" 

 

      & "

"   " 

" &  "

  

" 33 0 

30?

3  !

  &,   "   "

 -   ! :F    ,   

, - .

/ ,  .0" 1+23&*''  ?  4 

             



  



   

   

  

  

 

 

 

 ! "

    

         

   

   

 

  

     

 

  

#

 #



  $

  % 





  &

  

   



 

  

  

!"

   

!"



  

    

       $

    





 

  

  

! '



 

   #  $

  

 

&

&





 

   



 

 

     

 &

  

        

 

       

 #      





 





  

&

 $

  

 

  &

  ! (        $

    





       #

  





 

 

   

         

 &

  

 



!$   &       4                 5              

   

 

                



 &

&#  

      & ) #  

 

#   



  

  







 

 & ) #

 & *

    &

&

&! +     

   

 & 

 

     $

  &  







 

#



  



  



 

 



      

     



   !" 

      ,  



    ! " -

 .&  

 / && !.& ('123,3! 4 &   

    # #

& )

 &  



 

  







 

#

  

 &



  

         



 # 

        







 

 

  25!1!!(!26!(!'!1! 23,!!3# 



&



78

 9

 :! "   ! &  

 (9& 

 !   , 9#

   

    $

 

 

   

  9



    



&



 !7'

 &



#

 

    

  

  





 

 

7    

 

7! '



    

#

 &   &&   



 

  



*      

 

 $

 



 

!"  

    



   

     

! (   





& )     

 $

  



 

    

  



 

 

 5 1 

  

# &





 

   

 

 ;        

  !7" #   

    *

 

 

&

 

7  



  & 



  

  !"    

     #  

#

    

 !    19  

$ 

!"  , 9%

 #

     

9

&  

#  $

    &        

 

!" #  

   

 ; 

     

&  

      

# $

     9



  





   23 !!1! 2# <!  23 !!1! 6  2  !!1! <!  2 ! '!!!1! <#   

 

    





 #

 

   ;      # 

! '

  

 

#    #

 #

    

       





      &     





 $

  !+ 

(

    

    

 

  

    $

  

 











!

 ! :F    ,  &  .

  /  -  " # *''*6(7"

& "

6&   7)8'   ' ! "  

 &               

    

 

     

  

#

 *

    

   

#  

 # 

 

 &



 



 

 



  

   

  

   

#

 & *



9

&  

    



9

 !'

 

             &  

&

        







 

  * 

 &





;      

#

    





     

   



 #     

  

    !+ &

1

!   0  24  4 

 =&  

 > ?!!"  + 24<! GB  H @ 2:F   , 

 #  $ 

6*'*178&&*1* 4 3! + 





&

# 

  

  

 

   

 &

 

46 !,!! 



     $

  

  

 

   



 !3!!'

   + !  -# << 2  62#     

 



  

 

  

 

 

 46 !,!! 24 '

 

2#

 

 

@A

! "  

&





 



   $

 



 9

& 

  

      !"    

   

9

&  



 

  #          &  &  

!B  



9

&

  

#      

  





 # 

  



 

         

   

! "     



  

 

    

  #       

;



  &   

 

  ;





  



 

! &  #



 

 &  9 A&

  

     ! :

+;1&!  D!,2432#&

 !  + 22<4# 

, !    D!, <<   4# /

 

 !    0!,<<<22#+ 

!  D!,<<2 4#  D!,!!1&:

<<4<# !1&:!1& 1

<<6333#(!  <<2<<#, &;1

!  (!, <<2   26 

 1& 

 !    $!, <<  3! ! '

 !-

.& ('12,4#  ,    

    

@ '( ! < E  $

       

    

   

  



   &

        F



 

 

 

8 &





     #&

 

 

;       

  8  

   

 



 8



       







    F

    



!7 ! "  

 

   

           !" &- ! ('123 #+ 

!  , 9('1234#0!G! (  !    0  ('1 2  <<# -  

 !    +  24<   3<# &  !   -2263#+  

!   0!,<<   63 

    G  !  9  "; <<4433! 3! '



!  - ;<<43#

   

  



,!# @  (         

  #   

 

  

 

   

  

  

!  " 

   &

 , # 24 

 &

#



*    

   



 

&  



#





 

!  :

 *

#   # H

 

&

 

%# H

 

 



%# H 

 & %# H



%# H 

& ;%# !

  *       

    

  

!    

  & 

   H    

 %

&       



 

 

       

  



&



!  (     #  # &  

 &



   

# 

&

 

    ! I   #  &



  

 &

 

& 

   &

 9       

   &

 

            &   ! 

 #     

       

#  &



  

   # &

 

      ! 3 ' 





  

   



 #     

 

 

      !7 ! '

G 5!  D!,<<6<3<#     

  

# 

   







  

      

   #    

 &

  

 % 

   &

 

! "   &

 

 





         

   

 &

   

# 



  

 

    

 

 

! 4! '

  19  !/<<226#    

*&

 9

&     



 @  ! 4#  < <! E    

 



  

 

          & 

 

  



   !7 6! '

  D!,!!+

<<24#   

 

 

  & 

       9







9

&  

 

$

  !"  & 

 @!6# 6J   " $

   K

 

  

   



  

8 

 " $

   K



 

 



&

 8



 "

    $

 



  

       

 &    9

8  "$

  K9

& &

   9 

 











  8  "     &   

   

  





 $

  8   "         * &  





  

 

  

 $

      

! J( &   

     

= !  <<2<<! 2! "#  

     && 

  

 * 

     &

 & #

9

& 

  

 #      

 

    

! "        

 &

 &



    

   

  K  

     &

 

! '

 

 

 &

  



         

#    



 

 !J &   3!! B 

       

  





 <   

#  

@ J<!"

       

  

    

* 

 &     ;





&  &  !"

&  

 

J



 

J#    

      



 &  

 



!:

19

-&-

!= ( &

263#.* 

"*

? A &A(

( 

 ! G   /  > 

 22    # "

1 > ,

!.22!3# G =

!$ & , <<3<#(!  <<2<<

G&

+-

1 !   (!,!<<2<!J &    3!! '

   #  



   

  - 

! && 

  ,  222<#  

 

  



       





 

      

#       ! +     & 



        

        

# 





  



 



 

! 3! '

   :

9  0   

 !    - ;# <2 3  #      

   



     

 46 !,!!# 24



   $

 

 



! "   

    

     

   & 23

 ! '

   #

 

 

@ J! (

 

 &

 

     

D&  F  2466! '

      # $

 

 



   

     

A 

  

 



  ! $ #  $

  # 

 

#

  

        

   ! 

 &

 9

&   $

   #     



<

@!J <! ?

    

    

 



  

# $

  



A 

 

 





  

&



! ?

  #  $

     

 

& 

 

  

 F

   &     

 

!"   

   

      

F

&     

&

   &   

 



 

   

 &    !J !  '

 &  !    - 226 3  # $

      

  

     

      

 A 

  

 



  #  #  $

  

 



 

         



 

 

      



   

     ! 

 &

       $

 

 

   

       # 



  

   

           

  &

 &

#     

 

   

      $

   !B 

 &

  

    $

  #    

6

@! J 6! B    9

&  

 

 

    $

    

 &

  &



!B

 $

  

   

 &

 

      

1&+=  !  G9 2223

)!  



 

         





 

       



   

    # 

 9

 

 

   

     $

     

   

  9

&   &

  

    

! +     

&    9

  



 9

& 

LB 

;#

!'



#

    #          





 9

&          

    

 #    

 

 

        





 

  

       



      

  &

   



  9

&      &

 

 &

8  

        9

& 

 !'

  #  

 



     K9

&   

 ! + 





  &







 9

&    



   & 

 &

#

 

      

       

   



9

 8 

   9

&     

 

   

 # 



   

 

 

 

! $

  

  

 

#    

 *&

 9

&  

 

  !J !! '

-!1&;  D

 !  - 222<2#  

      &  

      

     $

  

 

 

   F

 

 

  

#      

   

   

   $

   

 



    

F





   



 





      

F



  

! "        

F



9



 

  C&   

  



   #  $

   #  #   



 A   

 

 



! "      

  

    

 



  

 

      

  

 

 

&

  



 

!"       





&      &

  



 

      $

  



     

        

F

! !! '

(  !  D!,!('12336<4#

 3#     

 

@('1!6<2A<! J3! '

             9

&      

  

# $

   







& 

 



    

 

 &





 9

&    F

!'

 

#



        

    

 

 4 !,!! &





 9

&  

 





 

  ! '

 

     



$

  

 

   



  





&



#  # ;

      &



   

;   

    9

&  

                

 &

  

  

 

 !'

  

        

    

 



    

    

 

      

   

# 9

 

   &



 

       

  

 



   

     

       

  



 

 

          

! '       

#;

 



 &

# 

&

 

 



#  9

&





!



  

 +# & #9

!  ('12338B   - !  D!,!('123  '

 

# 

  



 

    $

  

9



 







&



! !! '

-!G 1

!  (!,!242 33#            



    

 



 # 9  

 

 





;   

       #

 

   $

  





  9

#   &



9

  



!J M&  N !,   .

 /   9*'186(7 "

& "

6&   78+8! ' 3! '

  & # 

 

       



 

 

 &  

  ! '

  

 &

 

 

           

   C

!'



  

! (

:!-!G!1  / #<<11 &

43<

     



 

 

   #      



  

     !'

   

# 

&

  8  &



#



 

    

       

#      

 



 

    

  

  

! M.&  N  ! ,  " /       :    *'1+6(7"

& "

6&   7*+(! ' ! B  

     #    



 &



    

   

 &

     !I   # &



   

  & 

  I

&  

   &

 9       

&



  

    

&   !

 #   

  

#  &

 

  

 

;  A

   # & 

 

   

  !B 





  

 



 #     

 

 

      !7 M.&  N   !,    "

 " :","

  -   &    ,  !       &   "

 -     "   

&    @ "

 "

  -                "      !     "  "      =   A

 =  " " &     & "  "    

&     '

& &   G >  =

  8  .%09*/( ,,$%0

   > .%00)/< ,,%9

     8  .$))(/% ,,96%#  "

   .$))</%) ,,600> "  8  .$))6/0

,,9(%  8   

 ".$))9/%( ,,%)$







&.$))1/* ,,*(*  .$))0/%) ,,$)6 

=   &        .$))0/ %6 ,, 01  

"  :

 .$)%)/$ ,,<<*/H   ! "      &:F   ,"  "

 

  "    "

 -     

I  '

/   :" ,   "        - &       "

  

-  / 3 "   "

 - :",      " /     ,  :" ,  " &    "  "     &    ,   & "         ,    "

 "           "  / ! :",    "

   -     &    J&      " K / !  , &  "

  -             "       ,

&      /

 ?   L      "  F L"   "F L& "   FLF L" "  =F

 ?    ,     "

 -    " 

 L "

"F       , -    ,     "/ ! "     &  ,          "      & ""  ?"  

   &  ="     A  

  !"

&     J "

"K

" "&"     & ' 3          "         &  :F    , 3         ,   

 &"

& &&    3     & ,           3       "    ,      '

      "

  ," "  "     & ,     "  "        3          &    ,     &    ,&     A !,   "

! ,   "      &  60  37 ' <0  5       0< ; :<

< .$+

B#%CD.

$% !& $D :<

< .

+.

=, & $D