← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/581/2020dismissed

Varun v. State Of Haryana

2022-02-04Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur12 pages

 

    

 

 !

""##  !  $ %

"    

 

& 

 '( )*+ ,  ""##

& "

& -( (( + .+ $ %

/-(# (" + ,  0"#

1( !2(   2 

 





!  !   #  00  "!(4# !  5 5+

56+



7&  )( 

7&

$), + #   8!2  + "  # ,9,9    ) ( 2+ #% 2 !  !+ + ! $--  40 #  " #0 

 #!  #     ) ( 2 2  !  !+ #   # 8!2  + , !  ! :! 00 ( 2 

!" 

1( !2( "  2    ) ;

#  ,2 ! + 0" ,  !+ (  

 =



5 5 7&

 1 ! 2 2 ! 0" 0  )( 

7& "   %  "%   +

>

!# "%0 + ( (## ! ( ! 2 2 ! 0" 0  "   0(

=





7&

 1 ! 2 2 ! 0" 0  )( 

7& "  , %   "%   +

>

!# "%0 + ( (## ! ( ! 2 2 ! 0" 0  "  < 0(

=



7&

 1 ! 2 2 ! 0" 0  )( 

7& "  , %   "%   +

>

!# "%0 + ( (## ! ( ! 2 2 ! 0" 0  "  < 0(

## !4,  (## ! ! #%

, 22 , ,  ,

!" + 22 , :! ( )( + 40 0"+ (0

1( !2( !2  ""# 4  ( ! + ( - !#0    ) , 

2 " ! 

+ 0"# ( &# 0, 0"# 4  "#+ + (  ,##2 '( +   ?! !-( 





+ 4!  & %!2 4 ( $-- + "()  !+ 0+ ! 2 !+ -(    (!  # *!  ## 004  0#%+  " -#2 #  (!  

1(% # 0( ,- ,+ )( 2  !4# + 0 "!  

$ !2( #) *+ )( 2 ( (# 2 )( ,- ,+ 2, 42 (0

 !#  +  % 0"# ## (0 (!  0!! 2  4  4<+ ) 0 #+ -"

("

 + ) !2 -+ 0  #+ + 4+ 0"  !0

   +

> )  4!   

! 2, 42 (# 



 0"# ,2  

!" + ,22  # "  !  ;5 & 4  00# ! + # 00 !  !   # #   8!2+ ?! !-( 

@ " ,2 " ! + " ! #+ 0 5 " ! )

 #!  2 " ! ,+ ! 0  ) !  55 &

#0 + 4 # 0"#+ -  !  ,

!  " ! )  )

;

#  !# "" 2  22 , ,+ + " ! ,+ 40 #+ ,2 ! +  0  )-+ !#   0 4 ,  , 42 " ! 22 , ,

#   !#  2!+ 0"!2 ,  , )## 0 + 4 )(#0+  "" #   ,  +   ,  42 !"(# ( ! 

2 " !  + " &A5  *

( 0 0"  ( <0(+ (  +



 4! >

& )( ( 2 (#+ ( (0 ,##2 '( + )(   +  0+ ( 2 0( #) "  #2)( ( + ( !  !+ $--   , ( (0

( 00! ( + ! $--  (#2 -  + 4( !   2,2

 42 (

 ! ##2 #,  4#) ( " + )( + ! $--  ##2 #"

(

( " , ( 2!  B C<

& )(( 40  ) 0# "   

(   ( 0+ ! $--  " -# -  0+  (0  + )2 22 4#9+ ! ! + ("

 + ("

!2 -+ #0 ( )(( ! %  ) ( 

# )  -"+ ( )  ## 4! 

( !   (+ 00 ! 2 !  0 (+ 0 ##-  -## !

@! ( 0 + ( # (  #, 0 ( ( #) ( &#+ 4 ( #) *(  -!

)  " + (%   <2!(  + !00   4 2

4, 0 &A5 04 ( <0 ( 0%  4 ! ! 0"!2 ,  ,+ !# (+ ,#% !!##% )(  ( !2(  <0+ ! (

! 2 !  (  <0+ #   !# ! 4#(2+   ( <0( :! "  #, + ( ( #) ( &#+ 4 ( #) *( -!+ 42 4( #  " <!#+ 0!(+ ( 0 ( " ,! 0   ) 2+ ( # " 

!"  )  #, 0 ( ,#4#  ! 

$), + (  402 # 4,   )!#   2  %  0 #!+ ( :!   % (  0"  ( <0(+ )( + (  4!  # !+ ( 402 0"##% #

  0-2 4, #!+   &A;

 ( &#+ ( #) &A5+ ! 2 !  <0

 (+ 02 !##  4  

!" +   <0( &A5  *

#   !# )(# !2  <0 &A;+ (!2( 0  ,  

+ ( !2( "!2  "" !22  (0+ !   # (0+ (   !# ) ! + %   40 !#+ +   !22+ 40  &A;+  %  0 4!# (  0 

:!#%+ (  < 0"#   4    &A5+

&A;

1(  + 0   :! ( " ,! 0   ) 2+ ( &A5  02+ &A;

,#4# #,  ! + )!# + 42 % ! (  + &A;

  !# ) !    " ! + 40 + !"+  &A5+ &A;+   ! 4 ( 2!!   ,

@! ( 0 + 0# , !"" 2  &A5+ &A;

0"   &A5+ <  

( " ( <0(+ ( " , B 40  ) ( :! *!  *+ )(( C<

&

2

( ( <0(+ " , *!  !0  C<

& (  +  ( 4 ! 2 "   *

( 

* ( "  "! ( 2! + "  B+ "" !0 )(  !""  &A5 *+ ( 0   ( <0(



     

 

    !



"  # $  

%&  '

(

)

* "   

+

) ,  !   !  -..&

 /.) /"

#&.

-.'

  

%!

 0   1 - 

 

)

"

"

 .

/. 2 '  

+

) , 

3 '    

.

 / . 



 4!!

+

  /  4

) $.  /+

.)  ' 

)

3 ' 5  #

 .

6 7'

 '

.  . 

 /.& 8 "



+  !

  '

)

  ) /.&

3 '   3

 $."

'

&   8 "



+  !

 

 '

)

 

/ '

3 '   3

 $."

'

&   

+ 2 .

 

  



/ 

.







)

 ' 8 "



+  .

 

  



/  . 







 ' 8 "



+ :

$.  / .  .

/ / 

. 

 .)  $.   ;

.   + /.)  )



)  ) <#

 

 / "

 '  =3!2  /  '"

) . 4  .  ) .

! :

  <# 

  .>>

=3!

)   / "

 <# 

    !

  '

?



  0 " &A5+   4 +  &A5+ &A;

:! !  ! #2 *! + "  ,0 

*

1(  + 2 " ! +  2#% " ,

" ! :! + " , #+  4! ! ( 4( &A5+ &A;

0!( + 4( )( 00 '

" 2  #0+ ! ! + ("

 + ("

!2 -+ # 0+ #0 ( )(( ! %  ) ( 

# ( )  -"

  ,! + " ! #+ !"+  &AD+ )(

 <0(+ 



 )( ( " @ 

 + & &()+ ( ,  0 4!  22   ! 2 ,##2 '( 

$ " !4:!#%+ ( "#%    4 2 2  / 6; 5 ,##2 '( + ( 22   40 !

$ " , "  )(( C<

& 2

1(!2(+ ( !4*  # 2 ! <0+ (), + 4, !0   (0+ <0(+ 0 !(  %+  % !22 40 0 (0  40 4,!#% 0 (0+ "  )(( C<

& 2+ #  ##% " " 

1(  + ( !2(  &AD+ " ! ! " ,2  &A5+ &A;

:!    ! 2 ,##2 '( 

&A

" , !0 "2 "# ! +  ! + ##2  " 4!  2!% 42+  4!  " )+  4 - #2( + 4!  ) + 4!   )4+ 4!  #(+ "!2 (0  "  " #+ #2 (0 )( # ?

$  "   " # ( " "  00 C<

&

$ " , 0-2 #!  0 0"  C<

&6 ( ! $-- + )( + 4,  002 

!" + # ( ( #  0 + %+ ! ( (  !  , %+  &A 0(4<+ %

:!   #!  0+ &A

 ( ( , + "! 0( 4<  " #+ ( #  )( # '+ ( " "  , % 00 )(( C<

&;

2

@! ( 0 + &A

  " ! 0 #!  0 (0+ 04 C<

&56+ )( + (  " " 

!" 

@! ( 0 + &A

  ! C<

&56 ( #+ ( ( #  0  %+ 0(4< ! 00  - )% ! $-- 

 , +  #+ (  2  !  0 

"! ! #!  0+ ",#% 0 $-- + !  !+ ",#% 04 C<

&6+ &56+ 4( # ,22    0+ 4# " "  ( ",  ,22  +  00+ + 0"  C<

&

&A

<0( "  0- (    



 

)  :

 .

 -.'

 1

'

+

 

 

'

 

'

     !

   







 

+  '  '   

  '

  .   ; ! :.

% .     . 

" ; :   ) /. 

)."

&    /.  ).

      /&

)  

  .

     7 :   )

/.

/. 

)   .    .

      :   )   /     .

     * :   ) 

/.    ;

  .

      :   )    / 

 

  .

      :   ) /.   

 ' 

 

) 

 ' /. 

  

) +  *   

  .

   

 :   )

/.

/.      .

      :   )  /.   /  

 2

  .

    2 :   )  / .

       .

     :   )  /. 

/

  ;

  .

     ; :   ) 

.)  &



/.

  7



  .

     7 :   )  '

/3  *   .

   

"

  .   .

'   ?

5

&A

!4*  # 2 !  <0 #   !#

$), + ! 2   !  ( + #   !#+ !4# # &A %  0, ) % !22+ )( " #% " "  00

!" + > )( " #% -2  "+   0+ 4, 0  " ,

:!# 4,+ )( 40 04 )( !0+ !  +   % < (>( ,# 2! + 00  + #!  0  +  )( !  + "!  0  0"+ " "  "! ! #!  0  + ( " "  !#%+ > +  " "   ! + 0"!# 402 <  (0

1(  + 4#% #   !# #%   )2 #!  0  E 4  )2 00  +  ## ( !2( ", 00+ 0 (   0+ 4# ( !   ) 

  + &A

" , 2 " ! + ( !2(  ( 2 2 !+  04#% " ,

  , 0"  "  @B  + 04 C<

&D

C<

&D   4 ,+ + 0 ,22 

4 ,   C<

&D   ( 

5 :

+  '

  @  

    .

   !

 '

@ , .

# ' #@ +

) ,  4



.  /+





"

"

+  



  ' A

) /+   '



'

  B 4 .   +)

/.  ' &)      "



 

3

 

 

)   & 



 "



 . 4 '



/ 

#  #*

   & B 4 '

    +) ! 

  / 

  ' 

 &)

 C.'/

    /.



"

/.  

.   ' 4  )

 )  /

")    '





.



"

/. 4 !

!

  )  

  

 4 /

& 

'& 



  

 4 '

  +)   "

)

 !%

 ) 

.

/.

'

 /.   

")  .  

 '

 ) '



    



.

")  .  

 ' 



+

 &    /.

/ 

  /  

'

 

   ' B 4 '

C *  '  '



./  /



.

&  



 ' 4 

  /

 

.



"

/. 



+

 &    .)

 /



 2B 4 '

 ;

  

 / .

/"

 

 "



  '

 

  "

 4 '

 

 "

'

"

/ 

  /  &   '

/

 

 4 '   

"

/. 



+

 &    /.

/

 /  

'

   ' B 4 '

   +)    '

&) '



.

 /.  

 )  

) 

.

  

"

/.

")   '

 



)   /.

/ A

   &



  )   /.

  

 



+

 &    /.

/ 

  /  

'

 

   ' ;B

 &

 

.)  & 



.

/.  

 '

 . 



+

 &    /.

/

'

  7B

 !

< DC#

/ 

/ .  .

 

 "

/. < .



 +) E

)/ B <



& '

)

>.

'  

.

") .   '

?

4, 4 , 0"##% !""   &A5+ &A;+ 4 # !""   &A



@! ( 0 + " !# " 0 @B  + 0    #%+ " )(   (  +  #% " ! 2!# !+



  !"#$!

#$  !  &



   . .

 /



 3/   2 ;

  1





 3/ *  # .







 3/ F 6

  ,,#% # ( + :! " #+ #+ -   ( ! 0 # 402  <(4  

 :!#%+ " -#2 -  #  &A5+ &A;

" 0>0  + !+  2#% " ,

;

 , + )(  " <2 C<

& + " )(   ( 

  !

" !#$ %&'

"& '

'  "

.

 /.   '

&

3/  / 

. ) '

&

3/EB  + 5 /. & '

&

3/ 



"

.

 /.  

)

 '

&

3/7  3 '

"

"

.  

' C   

 .) .

/ /+

 

/+ '

3/?

 #2  , (   !2 !# 4 4 , 0     <0

:!   !+   + )(( !  #,  :!# (   !2+ 40 0"##% 4#



,) 4,+  # #%  4# ( 2 2 ! 2#% " ,

"" # ,+ #   # 8!2+  + ! % ##2#%  " , %  % 0 ""   ""  ,  

D

:! 0"!2 ,  ,+ :! ( )( + 0"+ !, #   # 8!2  +  0+ 0

""# 0

  4  )  ()(

&2 0##! ""# +  %+  + "



 

()(**(**     +,"+,!-., /&'01!, - ',23 ,-1 %&& '() *+$