High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-A/2205/2017disposed of

Jasbir Singh v. Inderjit Singh And ANR.

2020-03-06Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan17 pages

$$%&$$%% ' ( )* + #

$* ,

-./ !"#0 *.

$$%&$$%%

, !

#%(1%0 *. $* -

2 +*$ !"#0 30 ,(+

4 %5 * $ $ ( 5 6) -

(* !

70 7

), ** ,% ! !* 0 9 9 :

;< , :$% + #* !"#0 * '%%" ,*# 3%

1# * 5(" # , :

;

,(+ ! $ =* >$( #%

*0 1#% :$% ( "

#: /"

%. %"

, :

" 3*1% !# : $ % 1 /0

1# : # , :

!"#0 :

# , :

% :$* 9'!

6=;!!!

- ,4 ?

0 1# :$%

1 # : 5% :/ ,% "

- ,47;8 8

9#5 * # ( +( 5 # '%%" ,*# 3%

(

,0 1# #5 1 (

/%% 15 :

( * '%%" #0 , :

#* ( / : :$*0 # )* %. %( "

* . * . # "%" : 1#( %1"

# : :

#* # :$* , :

(%%50 %% *1 *0 1# :$* " 1 * %*

, :

( * " .( +( *( %% * ** $

2 :$* % *%5 *:"*

9# "

- ,4' *:"* $$* ( /%% #* $% (

9# * . 15 :

$ %."

" :% 6)0 ." *

9# ).""

# @) A :$* :$% 1 $% *

9# )

$ $ * ("# $% $% *

2 ** : 1

2 " $ $ * B( $ " * (( % *# , :

2 " $ : :

<: *(* ** *5

(* *"%5 *

!. % *(: 1 / $

:$% ." # :%0 #%% " $ $ * %* ( )%%B " 9 9 0 1# ($$%* $ *(: %* ($ #%% $ .** (* !

* $ :"

# " :*

6*"

$ : # " (* !

7 0 7

), :* " (*0

1##0 $%** "(%5 %:* %

( "

( $ ( .*0 $ ( <:* :5 ?

1 $ *% %1 ,C + !"#:$% $ .** 5 1 ( * ,C % ". (% . *

2 !1* $ .* : :$% ;< ,0 . 5 :: .* 1## %% * *"

.#% / $ ;< ,C &0 $$% ** * * *("

$ : :

<: ** *5 ** ;< ,C &4

,C7 : !"#0 : :# :#%%5 * :$* .%.* * $ .* $ ;< ,C7& ;< ,C7&4 $.%5

,C 2 ** ** *5 **

2 $ .* * B( $ ;< ,C& : " ** #:

;< ,C&4

,C !) 2 1* $% !"#0 1# * ( ." # *$* " *"

:0 $ ."

. ( *(:

2 >(%1* ,% *$* " *"

*$ $ $ 5 #:

)

,C?

!: #(+0 *%

1# *(* $ : :

<: ** *5 ** , :

*$* # .* %%1"

+( $ = * 1(* . / /(%%

D* %5"

( * : $ (*"

(

!# $ +( 5 $ . "# %1 %"

D* %5"

:(% 0 .% ($( * ( *

!# $ .* $5 $ : :

** ;< ,C?&

!# $* ( *# # *( *:" .% "

0 1## ( ( *# * 5 ( (

C# $ ( .* " %(**

!: ** (* !

, 1## %% :"

(: $$ "

" 1 $( #:

( ** :0 *"

%%5 .%.* #

( "

* .*0 " 1 : ** C

6 *5 0 : $ *(* (* E

! "# $%

& %

' & %

' '

(' )

*+ + % '

',( #"

- ."."% + '

% + + % +%

+% / '

' % +

' ' ('

1+ % %

2 3 4 "# $+" % +

5 + 6

' 1

' ! "# $+.7##+

+ %

0+ ' % + ' % '%

' % + 8#

+ 1+

"9$ '

% + %

, ".$9 $

(

+ 8 ' 2

+ 5+ %+ 2 ( # <:* :# C0 1# : % "

$ *(* *5 E ! "# $+ %

+ % + % + +

' :

% % + %

' '

% %

% '

% %

' + 5 %

% ' '

% '8

+ + ' '

'+.7##

+ %

3 %+

'6 %

% %

' ! "# $ 3 4 "# $ % '

'% +

1+ 5 % '% % % 4 "# $+ + "9$ ; %

% %

' '

',".$9 $

' '

+ %

% %

+ %

<= C# * .* " %(**

# "

"(:0 % * **%

(*% " 0 9 9 %(** %#* *

(

, ** #0 (* *# , :

* ."

.#% # "%" : :("

(%$% #:*

C# 0 # *0 # : %5 %* $ . (* *

*"%50 #%* "(%5 (* !

7 7

), .* *"%5 / (*50 .* +(*": **

# "

$ B((:

0 .* * . *0 * %%1

! "#$!% #

), !* (* " ) :#

7 ), !* (* " ) 5 $5 & *(% $5: ( # (* " ) $ * *5

), !* (* " ) :# $5 & *(% $5: ( # (* " ) $ * *5

9# 1 * * ( ( %5

9# % "" .* +(*": . * $ * $$% ( !0 1## "* **%

(*"

0 9 9 0 1# * +(*": . * $* " 15 $ $$% B(* # " :* " #:

9# :$% # #%%"* (# +(*": $* !

9 9 15 %"

$ =. $$% # ( 0 1## "

* $* - &(* ) #. # * % * (% $ * ""

# ("# * ) * :$("* +(*": $* **%

(*"0 9 9 (% (* *

9# +(*": $* 9 % " * ( :

5 %%"%5 :5

) * ($ $ $ $$ % .* $ %10 1# :$%%5 $$ " * +(*": $* !

9 9 $$%

) #1 %/ %5 : #% $ %1 $ $ %5

"."

( (%5 0 *%*0 %"% .%* +(*": ( %5 *0 $ B("

(*0 1# "(% ((%%5 $ .* $ ( %*"

("# " ."

4# 5 10 :%5 +

(%%5 ($$ * $ ( " * : *0 " %%5 "

* / $% ( # "%" * ."

(*0 :(# "

* . . 5 #"# $* 1#( %1"

9#("#0 #5 1 <:* %"# #% ( #5 (%* # * 5 : % $

1 : . * # :0 # " * B(% *% * 1 (* ( *( % :: 50 (% $" : * $1 .0 $ $ :: F . * *.*(%

) * / * * / $%

1# : +

1 ** ( 7

%: 5

) . 5 *(% :: :( *% $" (# %"

) * $ # 1 ( % $ % ( ". #:

1 #5 %

) ,C + !"#0 1# :% :# 5 : $ "

: $%

9# * / $% (

,G *$* ,C + !"#0 #5 :* $ ( & #( #5 * %/ , :

+( * *

9#5 :* :(% - ?

1## : $0 1# $% .* # ( ?

9# *( +

:% :/"

:$ . % , :

!"#0 # # %."

(** # ""

$% $ : " *"

;. # 10 +

1 $ $0 # #5 (%* #. $%5 :$ * $ 1# (# # : #5 (%* #. $%5 #("# "

5 " * : #$$"

* "."

*% *"

.#%

+ #."

% 5(" # * (%* (: (%* <$* 1(%* #/ /"

($ % 5 .%.* # 1 "%5

9# . 5 : ** $%0 + :*

$ 1# % *0 " #1 % $ $ *

) * :* # %15 *.( $ 1# # % %. ( $ $% *# (# %. ("# / $(# (%50 # # 5"

(% (%$ .%. $ $%

9# 0 + (%* <$* #%* (% $ .%. # 1 "%5

= * **%

(*"0 # :* :(# :* 6) * $ * "* " #:

** :

5 10 # 0 *5 %#*

4( "

". %%5 :.* ) * :* # )* + $* " : ** (* !

, 1## # : ($ . 0 1## %%5 (."

(%.%

= * 9 % ( # *% (# *$ . 5 $$ $ $ $ :

) # * #("# )* + <: * " $% :

( * ( %* "

5 $ " *"

"."

: ( * %%5

6( # : 0 * *( "

<: ". $$% !!, ( %* $ . * %1

9# 9 % " # "#%5 * # * * ""

)* (

1# #* #0 # %%5 1#( (: 1#( %1"

# * . / )* :

% * # 5 #*

9 % " 0 *: $%(% ( $% %%5 . / :

% * 1# B( % *5 ""

#* %%5 #"#

$* ""

%1 $*0 # %5 %%5 1(%* . / :

"# * :

% * %%"*

9# . ($ * $$ 1 #5 $

1 <:* #:

*0 C :# !"#0 <: * * 1 :$* 1## , :

<$ * / $% #( # 15 $%

2 (% %% (: %%5

%#("# :% ( #.5 $ ( $ . "(% 5* #*1 % *( ( : :0 <$* * % $%(% <$% " *"

%%"* % :$%

2 # %* * 5 (# <$%

6( # : 0 $* 1 "%5 # 0 # 1(%* #. /$ B( *:% 1 * . #""

. #* :"# #. % + %0 * #:

$$ "

C 0 $* ,6 % ( #1 #. "* : #"# $% (# ($ *$ : 1 "%5 :* #

2 % : " #1 # #"

5 $% % :$% %/ :

9# :*% .* # *(%5 (% .*

9# ." # # *(* :$ % :

9# )

.%. # 1 "%5 # #%% #:

9# # .** **(* $ ( $ ( 5 : % $

) * :* # 1#% *("

$ ( 5 " * *5 (*0 % * **%

(*" # :* * $ * " *(*

% *5 .*0 # 5 *"

9#("#0 6) " ** %%50 : (*&* . # ( # " (: # $ (% #

9# 1 *: 1 * ."

(% *50 #("#0 # : ($ 5 "

# ($ : %%50 % # # 1 15 # :# ( #"

# 0 #:% * ."

. $ 1 . 0 # * 5 * . $( $ # $ :$5"

1# (%* * .

9# . %%5 *:"* *

) #:

<$% 1# # $ * ."

0 #:0 ( % " *

) ($$%: 5 : " ** :$%

* *5 * :*

$ 1# (* *

%#("#0 % * (% $$ "

$*&(* "(* :$% ** 5 5#"

" * ($$%: 5 : ( : %5 ( (# :0 *5 "

* . *"

.#% %. : * " "* *(* .0 #:% 1# %: "

* . : # $ #:

4# 5 1 *0 :%5 +

** $ 1# * ."

%. :0 "

* ."

. / # : 5% # # :$* , :

!"#0 $ ("

9# 0 : *1 :

.#% ** #:

9#(0 *( % :* ( *5

;. #("#0 % * (% * 5 1 :* :$ .: # : # / * ( ) * # ( % <$% :"

:(# 1 1# $ $ # (* #

;. # 10 1# $ # ( : <$ 1# %"

"%0 *5 $ " #* :* # %5 "F* %

(#0 *5 5 1 ( %5 *

: .#% $(% 15 $* 1#( %1"

# 0 1#( "

5 # * ( 1 5$ # "%" * ."

6 :

.* **(* % $ (0 : ( # 1 ( $ * ."

* *.% : 0 # 1"

( 1* # :$* ** :

#*0 $ ** %% *1 ( * +( 1## ((:*

= * (% $* - &(* * (%* ($ "(: :$* :%5 *:"* :

* 1## (%% 5 1 # *"

21. 0 ) :

:$ * #

9# < *:" :$* * *$* 1# $ # 1# $* :$* :

#0 ** :$* %% *1 1## :"# #. (%* :+ *:" :$* * * " #1 # :$* *

9# :$("* +(*": $* !

9 9 "

(: *$ +(*( $$ #0 %5 $ $ %5 $$ .* $ %1 (*0 : * %"% .%* +(*":

$* 9 % " * 15 $ $ $$%

9# %* 5 %5 $ %0 (* *# $ 1 "(%

!(# 5$ $ * . * $(#:0 # :5 / % :

# * *(%" # "%" 1#% * ."

# .#%

C# (# .0 $ $$% %%1*

$5 +(*": 9 % " * ( %% 1 " )* + / #:

(*5 * #:

+% (* "

" # $%!

" #