Oriental Insurance Company v. Jagtar Singh





  
  













 
  !"#$ $$$$$  %  &'&(    $$$$$  # 


 





  !"#$ $$$$$  %  '

( # (    $$$$$  # !
"#$%&
!
'()*+ &
)(!+&!
,(-*

) *$ $+$(,

-#.

 / ( $  / ( #$ )./0/
,.12
'
( , .   #   (. , /# ,! 
  !"#$ (&&(0# # ,! *   

#  , - + 1( 2 /#    3( , 45 &&

/
67-8889: 

: #2   $;6<= /;>>?5#
6-;8-8889:  : #2   $;6<@ /;>>?5$(& (0# (&

#(#. #.( -0(

 #(

#0 ( #&.##.& $ 6$ *#  ,& &   $ :A8<= 2 /# 3( 45 #0((  0 .

.#  ( 

# 0( ( 

1   68$8;$;>>6-  &  #( B +  # B    & '&($

  C( 

#& /#&     $ 7    0((  (# #.  0 ( #&  .# #.& ( /

#-(,  ,.# ?7#?= /0#/  0):       

 

  !    " #$% "

"  

"    !  &"'   &(  )      

    '  *+     !!,  !  

       " 

     

$    )  )  $  !!

 ,      +   )        )+  % )  

 !  -

. !



  

$    ! /0 &  )  " 1123  !    4"  5

$    ""

   )  

$"        !"

", 

 ! /0&2   

$  5 

 - . -,. -

. 

 

    

 6 5

$   1 ! 7     % 

5893,)  : ;,:

$'   

 



     

 $    , 

 

   ! "  , $   

"

 

     $ , 

       



  

    

0   "

 ,  

$$  

    

""

, !"

 ) " "

!   , " "

  # !  "

  ,      

  )  " ,  

  

    

$  ,        ) 

  "

   )  

  , !  <       ""

 )  

$"     

 

   

  % 

  "!  

  , ,  

  ,  

    "

  !  ,      0"

   



   8 

$    $ 

8'   !!   

  /0 &= !!    ,

 ,   

!     

    1

  8  

$    ,      !  ",  

$        

$   

"!



  "

     $%5 *74! %  &(

  !

, !   

  0!   !    

 

"       $ > "     !   

!!   
  $

$ 

    ! 

      ,

   - .  ! 

  )   

$     

$       "   $      -

.        

 ,  "

  ,    !  "!

   5  

  '"!    !   

  , ?

    $)  !  )) "

 

$  " 

 >

    4" 

$  !    "

  )   

 %  ! 

"  "!

     "

    )  " !



@ ?$ "#

 /  (   ( & # ( #.& /#. 0  .# , /1$  ( 0 , /  #

#  / 

! # (   0  ( D#   

. 



 !, / #.# 0

$   ( # ,.   ( 
 

          

2    

  !

" ## ! " # $  %  & 

  '() *'   

 +) 

!,"-*#

 A$ .&  /  #  $ 6:

 (# #. 0  # /E$ :;$( #.&     (  / (# 1($ C(  &  C:6-  (# ( # ( (  

# ,! (  / (# 1($ (   0 &   # (,!#. /(

10(0( (00 1&  $ "
3

3/


/4
355
16
5
6
3
7
.0

54

"
8/
11/0
/
9

: /
9
16


6
/
0/87
1/
/
10
9

/
:7
5
0/87
6

"
8/
;./0


355/
5
0/87
6
7
1/1/0
:9
0/8/
 5
/.<
35
354
5
3
3/<7

6/2
3
<
/
7. (  / ( 0 ( 0 ( #.&   #

# ,! ( 0   &   # ,! ( / /  0&  / $      /     // - ' & &- /  0( (   ,&  $ ;>?;6( 0 (., #-#.&  $ ;>?;6 0  #  (   #( "  / " (#$  8;$8;$;><>   $ =A>?@ 0 # 0(  ,&  $ ;>?;6 2E$ :;5 #   (. ,  #  6@$;6$;><>- 0 /1$  '   0 

,# ,! C:?- 0 +   - #.

 0( ( .#( // /   // -'&&$ C(  .#! . / (  ! C:; $+$

 ',(0-*&- 
  !#

C:? #.

 $+$  - 0(  (.  .# (   2E$

:;5/1- F  0(

##(,  /  (&(

  (#.&  0/1$

 ( -.( ! /#. 

 (#- 0(   #  C:6-   // $  .  # ,/  (   &  ( !   & (   #$0 .0 / 0(( 0&  #$( ! /(0 //   #0/ (#.& 0/1$ 7$ "#, 0(!& ( ,. 

. 

+( 

-/0/ * 2 ( ,.#( ( #/ #& ! , (- (        / ,&    #/! (  #$ 
 ( - 0  0( /# B  0  0(  #  $ 6:#. ( 0( ##( # $60( #&&# .# #.&   ( ( (# ./#  (    !& # $;(( 0.#$(  .  #  0    ( #.&   #  $ 6 0 .# # ( (#  

# ! /& .  !$
(, ! #& .# -(, (

#&.  0(

 #&((

 !(/#   . ( # $;0 ( #&.##.&  (  / 

# #  #  $ 6  , .# /   ,!  !(

$

  =$   0 # # 0  (  / % &

 '()*

 

, ! "  /3- (
    ! (   ! (



(/ , (   ,##

.!&(&( #/ ,

/#

#  !$ @$
 .0 / ! , . #

 -   /# ,!
  !( (E((

.! &( & (  #  /  (

 #  (  /  , /  #

#  /  !$   ( (    

 # #0# #,!(,  #/# (E(
  !  !



( (.(&( 

.(/  #$ 9

2
























)(!+&!
,(-*
B1

















'(,&