Naval Kishore v. Vinod Kumar Kapoor And ORS
!"
# $%&%!'( ) )
( *+ ) , , ,
, , -
)
.
/ !
" " #" $ %&''%(') *+ , " -. /
*+
0
' 1 +
,
2# *
$
'33 %(( %(3 %'( 4%) 44)14-. % !
*
0 "/ 2 5 "
&5"
"
5 !
6 0 5
'7
'8 2 /
*
/
0 -, +%(''
2 /
+
'
# &5" 9 $ +
:$/
* +
%('%%('( ;
*+0
'<
0 - * ;
.
* $ + *
"
.
.
!
0 2 / ' "
" .
*
.
*+ "*++" .
9'&(%%(''
/ "
/
= (((0 /*+
0
/ 2 " 0 "/*+
" >
"
;
0 :
*
!
'&(%%(''
" :
/
2 + *0 $ + ''1%(''
*
:
/
"
/ 2"+ *++"
:
%('% *
6 +.
/
"!
/ *
"
? '33 %(( %(3 %'( 4%) 44)14-. 5
+
* !
"
'33 %(( %(3 %'( 4%) 44) 14-. 1 -
00
/ * ;.>':
; .>%:
"
4
1'1.
./
" / 0 / 0 +:
.
.@ -- *
; /
!2
/
!
0 + ;
*
.@ --
/ !
+
.
. @ -- ,
2# +/
*
+
" /
'&(%%('':
;0
5 /
/
"%5"
"&5"
"
%('%%('(* "
2 '=13'
*
*+ :
/
/ / ; *+
!
"
#
!
$
%
& ! '
'
&
'
(
!
!
)
!
* )
+
,
#
'
& -
. .
'
%
!
$
!
) # !
/
& $-
. .
!
) '
)
' !
'
&
&
$
'
!
'
$
* $
!
'
& .
!
.
& * .
-
.
!
. .
'
!
#
'
2 +
!
'
& $
!
$
$
#
3 4
3 * ' 5
#
'
!
*
)
!
!
!
(
'
! ! !
)
!
* )
+
,
!1
' !
'
$
) !
'
-
0 " & -
0/ ; .>0':
" .>0%!
+
* +
*+
0 + 0/ *
;
*
"
/
/
*+ ,<
*
*+
+ +
<
$
4%)11) -.* "
0
* "+
# + *+ 0
+
*
# " >
!2
* " " *
"
*
.
+ !2
"
*
<.
7 8!
+
''(=%('' /
2 '&(%%('' !
"+ *
* *+ 0 3
" " "$
*+ .
:
A*
.
@"" /
-'3B1 .
%((CC
0
4%1
!
"
# "
"
"
"
"
$
"
%" &
"
'
"
"
(
" " )
"
"
*
% % + ," -./0 # $ .-23$#1-./*445
D
-'34=.'=' 7')8-
.
/
E"
"
"/ "$ /
*
*+
$
F " .
/ "
" /
" *
+
+ * "
F # " !
'3=%01 .'31%('-'3=% .=%
+#
" #* '3=1 .4'& -'3=1 .)B / *
:" .
"
$ / * # +
F
+* "
A-
*
$*
+
F"
+
F
F
"
F-
"
*
*
*
*
/
+ / "
;* /
:" .
" $!
+/
*
0
78 4%17'8 .
*
:" .
" / " $ " * * G
*
/
F
+ / 2 *+ *
$ F !
""
*+ ;
F* "
F *
/ * "+
+ !
.
/ " # -'3B'
.)'=: * " !
#* - '3B% . 413H
+ *
"#" $ :" .
+
"
!
$ / / 2
/
*+
:" .
/#
"
" *
* +
* *
+ /2 *+ .
/
-/
" $ / / *
*
"
*+ " :" .
5
'1B/ /
+*
/
"
*+ :" .
+ /
"
*
!
:
A*
.
I. +
@"
%((%748.7.
8)=(
0
! ! "
#
5 " " 7'3)4718 ..
)B%8 6
" J9 !
5
$%&' $%() %*( KD L
5
!
:
A*
.
I #
G %((37%8.7.
8&'%
0 6 #
7
88#8
1)%0 .-/ * -5.
9 9
1)% (
"
:" (
1)1
1)4 "
1)=
0 7
"
1)B
1)) "
% "
1)& % "
" "
( 3 9.52 $ &&%
&
4 :
&
.6 % ; " " *
*
"
%
4#
< %
*
,
" 6 D* -/ 46 -/
" "7
.
; " " *
*
:
&
. "
.= &
&
4 (
/#
"
"
"
"
" "
6=
&
/
"
(
( "
"
(
" " #
&
/
"
" &
&
4
6. Whereas Sections 379-380 cover special cases of appeals, other sections lay down procedure to be followed by appellate courts.
#" "
* 2-2 9 9
"
>
""
*
%
"
8. Bare reading of Section 378 of the present Code (appeal in case of acquittal) quoted above, makes it clear that no restrictions have been imposed by t
?
&
"
) "
& "
+
!
)
#
@@@ @@@ @@@ ,- +
.
) / #0**'$0(11$ (&020**'$-( )-%3(
2 $%(4
$0(!
.
5 %&',
$,(6
7
7 7
7 7
7 7 77 # 7
) 7 7
$-( 4
+
!
)
$3("
KD L !
:
A*
.
IG
5 "
J
%('(7=8.7.
8=1(
0
!
"
:
$"
:
"
"
"
# "
&
""
5 "/ " 4AA.. %4
:"
# " :"
"
:
# * 5 *
-5.4%5-. 5*6
@# ---%446 ,/ "
: +4AAA/%/2/ #
, 5
4AA.%6- #* " 4AA.
%45 #* " 4AA.% 62 4AA.%645
+G!/ ? 4AA/%/A
KD L
/
!
:
A*
.
"* 2 7%(%'8= ..%%%
6 4)
"
"
1)& *
# 5*
4AA-% 2-
1)& *
-5.# 4-
3& %0
!
!
9 !
#
: #
)
!
$6 ;#1 ) < 5$%&'3( ,)0%& *
5 $%&&*(-) %' ? $0**,(%)' %
" $0**-(%*) && 5
" ?$0** (&)',% ?
" $0**'(%,)%*0
11
$0**=(3)3,34 $0**&(%*)0*
2 + $0**&(% )&= " :$0*%*(0)--3(
%, -
/ "D
4"1%&,-500'
2$"4
-*-( >
$%(
?
@$0(
#
@$,( @ $-(
?
A /
%
"+ % $#1 -6/% )
% % *: $#1-65% 4 B ;
$ % B $#1-.% 4AA + B % ) -5A4%/6A %"
% + --2 6 % /4 )% % B *4AA4/%26 % ; %: 74AA5.%566
6 # % +74AA5/%/6
% * /.4 /43 $
4 !
.
* -5.
(
"
. C (
D
" E D
D
"
E D
D "
7 E
"
(
%
" D
E "
"
/$ " "
"
F "
" "
:
"
" %
"
"
6#
G #; 0 % H *4AA2A%/6A
E "
"
"
5- #
4AA--%.2 ("
:"
3% .5/ 4A4A I
"
G
2 #% H * ) 4AA-/%45
"
: :"
"
3% 42 429
!
J
!
" J
:
J !
:"
" : J
"
J
( "
%
9$
< % 4AA-A%/A
%&
!
B
"
7 "
4?
4A
394A
( "
7
K "
" "
9 9
"
C 1:
+"+ < $"-2//%.6 ,(
( L
& "&$
$ ;
=M% --4%4%.4 1
M *
,--/% .%6 ; <
" * 4AA % 6A $ % 4AA-A%4A;"
)+ 1
% $ * 4AA-A%. "
.#
+ % ""
*
---4%A
)
"
.# C : B% % +7 4A-6%/.
% .52 * -5.
"-64
#.
3 9. $
"
H" > -52%442 #
&
5
"
:"
A 3 %
4..9A L
&
"
L " %
> "
%
> "
" "
"
9 . #%"
% +--26%/4
&
"
" "
? "
2 3% /9
? :"
" "
?
"
1"
) < % ;:
---%446 '
: &
:" "
)
& "
:
:" N ?
7 #
:"
" :"
"
"
J :"
#
!
:"
)
"
:"
" "
: J
:"
("
:"
9 . #+ 1"7
H % + ---.%.A-
"
>
%
>
%
>
%
> :
K"
&
"
"
"
%
> . .
#$ % H * $#1-66%2A5 6
3$#1 2A-& A
#
:"
"
"
:" >
#
% /5 * "
:"
#
"
7 &
"
7
:"
"
#
:
"
# 7
"
"
:" %
) "
%:% % $#1-64%64J?
+
% H * $#1-6.%44#
: "
. / #+ ;1 % $ * -5-% .66
:
7
:
"
:
9 K L ! .
I
52 %('=748 .7.
8=3=M
0 6 #
"
" #
"
K #
$ C
+ ;
1 = 4AA4/ 11 56A
#
"
J "
KD L ! .
I 2
: + J
%('3748.7.
8%34M
0 .
?
"
"
F "
" F"
:
"
" %
"
7 & "
?
KD L & !
#" :
A*
.
.
/ .
/
/
/
$
$+
*
+
* +
/
.
$
/
*
/
* *
.
* " $
*+
!
.
+ * .
!
.
:
/
/
#" " +
" *
*+"
"
;"
*+2"
*
.
/ * / / /
/ " 3 - /
* /
*+ :
C*
.
.
/2 *+ !
.
/ $"
* /*
* *
$
*
/ '( !
.
/ /
#" !
.
"
*+
, ,
) )
2
>
2"
N
>
*
N