K.R. Singla v. Ketan Sharda



  
     
  




  

 

!"#

$$# %&' !(&)  

$)


     
   ! *& +

,,,,, "#$%& &"'()"#*  +'",- 

-($$#(#)($&$$#')&! 
.& &"&#/#$$#"(0$'") &)&))  $)12#&)3')#"&4&#5 ()"&(56(&125(&#'&(7')(&$) ') 0$#')&!&)6(!.(+"1# 8&'0 5
&(&59( :

;:1#!'$&0'& .%
$,$%/012 03"340", 5%  3"3"%$6"'"3 /4*

7+- 
 +
'0203",-

* &  )&1# )')0$&/&$&! ) 
. & 5#'))((/0(&"(#$$#')&! & 1&('&!  #/$&() <')"0')&



-(&&(1/)&& )1#1&)##6

4&#25(/0&00'(/1#' &"($&&$$#6((1&'0&1) 122)$&) 8(5/0 ')&!( 5  5$2&((#)& (7'$&6(('&)(0$ (00)12$&6((&")( 50#25(')56((7'(1 )('&) !)#25(&"(/0&00'1 $#)$&6((&"(')6(( '&)/56(50&&"($&& $$#')&! .(&

$& /)&0((&"($&&$$# ')&! .0&&"()1"

'1<)    2 )  !0#&#25    /0    &05  6(/&  1  (  '&    (  &05 ')##20'(/&"($&&$$# -(&)#25&(&((*&#0 ('"(&($&/'1  6('0)"2)$&)1'###) 12  (  /0      5  6((  >$&  # #')(#"#&$&/))/0 6($&&$$# (&&25"&)&7'#5 (!5(&'"((*'1#*&'&$&& $$#/(0$#)$&&'( $$#5('"('&'($$#6((#/ ('& ;6/&5#62&2&( !&0$#$&&$$# ?'6(

 0      /0@  &"(    $&&    $$#5  ( A"$##/$$#&0( ;"('&')&! 
.(& 6'#)1 &&26((1))12(*&#012 &($&/! (& 4'&(#25(*&#0(0))! &'0&1(/0@&"($&&$$# <'(6(&"&)0$#&(! #"$$# ((&()5(*&#0( &)($&/! /" '$&&&"(&(/0$&& $$#("&')0)(&0$&) 0$#

4(#25(/#/0(!&$ ')&!( $'' 121 -(1'(0$##)')& ($&/('&$&/0$# $&!(& )!.(  12>$&&$&($&/( & (0&&#'()0) &)&0# -(&&5(0$#5 6((/0)('&(7'0'1 &')1/0&0($&/! &)6( ()/0')&! 
6(&

 4'&(&5  $$#2"  (  )&    $&$/  /&&'#"5 ;:1#!'$&0'& 0'$4/8'"/$ $5$31$ 3/$,,0:$34$ 5% "# ;12"'

'8'"

'0203", <<$", 8

9

)0/&
'0203", <<$", 8

> ($40($(

> 7* 6(##&2"(

. <')"0(##1$$#1#&&$/#25((#)')&

 -()#&')#"6('1/ &"(512(#"#'&5)&)1$&$/'#     >$&#2  &  12  &2  0$#  0)    (/ &&$/$& -(#"#0>0C+/' 4''&4&080$&15+*&&C)" (6#6'"(&"'#6(##6)( $5&&6($&'0$$&$/2)( $&'0$"&##2)$&'#(&&2 (6  12    >$&  $&/    (  '  &    ( &&$/2    (&6  )&1#  (&'"(  &2 0$#  -(    1'  '(  '  6'#)  (/  ( 7'"/)&"(50$61'&)& 0$&  >"  1#"  ;6/&5  6(    ) &)&"$&"&)(&$&$# $&/'17'#2/&&'#)12()#&"& 1(5(7'(/&&'#"&A#2)& )12)'#5&&$/ &0% 0% ?

$4"1%$ 0/ 0% %$//,$( ,") /&"/ /&$ ,") ($4,"'$( ?@ /&0%
81'/ 0% '$/'8%<$4/05$ "3( 0% 38'2",,@ "%%12$( /8 ?

-($&6#2)'&&'#0'1 ')  6(  (        <')"0  #1(:2$3/ 8'

($40%083 )&04& 03/$'<'$/% "

%/"/1/$ 8'

<'850%083 /&$'$89 ($4,"'$% /&$ 2$"303:

/&$ %/"/1/$ "% 0/ %&81,( ?$ 483%/'1$( 9'82 /&$ ("/$ 0/% $3"4/2$3/ 3 8/&$'

)8'(%* /&$ #1(:2$3/ ($4,"'$% )&"/ /&$ ,$:0%,"/1'$ &"( %"0( "/ /&$ /02$ )&$3 /&$ ,") )"% <'821,:"/$( "3( /&$'$98'$* 0/ &"% '$/'8%<$4/05$ $99$4/(&&25('&(&'# 6(($&'0)1$&$/'#>$&#20) &&$/ D(##6&0(05()& <')"0'"$&$##6$$#1###

 &&$/("$)21&)& &'06((1')(0"( #66((>)&0($(&)' &$&/ D((1)#&)1(#6(#) 0'1(#)(/#621(#6(#) -( #'#0&0(&#(()'2( '&C$&'6#61'0) >$')(#)C 
0$())) .

-(&&5/6(<')"0&)&)12(;:1# !'$&0  '&   
$,$%/012 03"340",
'$&  ) 0'$4/8'"/$ $5$31$ 3/$,,0:$34$
'$&5  #&)  !  3')"5  &)5   )&)&($&#/$$#$$##)')&! & )&'(0($$&$&'&&)$# 0&

"&2)&))(0$#$$&1A)( &&)(#&)!3')"5&)5&(6(

$)5&)"#2 *)"$$#525# ))$)

+  !-


 D((&!$A"E ) FE+ D((& $&1# FE+