High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-A/1615/2014dismissed

Daro v. Sukha And ORS

2015-07-23Mr. Justice Surinder Singh Grewal,Mrs Justice Daya Chaudhary13 pages

!! " #$%% ! & '&()*+, -#./,# # #&( '&()*+, -#./,0-/. 1 2#3%4% 2 %!! # # # .% 5! 6 *%3 % % ! !!# 789 :%519) 1 ) %:32!!3%

%#; 23 #!+% 9)# )%:6%;

#$% 331% 69!( :%2;<% !%;#

6%#

6% #

; #

76%#

# 6%#

%/19)/1)%:%; !!%6;

%!! =%2%!!3%!! 6%%!%%%%; < /

>/(

863 1##!+%%!%;#

8 ?/1 .% !6

;

%#'&#!+%%%# ?

? (%!6%5! .% 5!

? % % 3 6% % !%!%< .% # %;$%!%23 >% 236 %62 ! 6%% 6

? (63%5!% 6$!! .%5!!! ?

.% #

! % ;2 % % 5!%!! .%%5! <3%!)%)9%3!: / 6;2%!%%6%< ;

%1 !5 %6; .% 65!!%! )%)9%3!: .%!! 6 %62 5! 6%%6;3 >!5 2 6@

.%!6; %6%%5!A!! .%5! %!!A5! 3% %63234 .%#!+% 4!% #%6%63%%6$ /%6%23

%6)!)95: >5% 5 %% 6%%655 /%;!2; !3 ;$;

%1% .%36%%%5!

!%3%%%6%%%23! .% %5! 5

.5+%5 )!)%% .% %5; 6%% %!66% #$% 9! ( : ! % 5!%5 5!3%3%% ;B ;$%%%%5!6 .% 5!36%%#% 3%6(6.5 + 46#%?

83%%% 63%% /%55 #$%9!( : 56%))9!( :356% $523%1%9!( :656% )) 4649( :65+5! %

@9( :6#$%5! %5%% %5!%$3 .%5!% 5 55; 5 5 % % / % 55 #$% 9!( :$%5!6%%))%% 6 3%% .%5!6%;6% 3%%%;6%%%53%3%% 6%%3 .% 9!( :$%5!6%$ 523%6%%%%%33%3%% 1%9!( :6$%5!6%%))

%;66%%%%%;$%3%$ 464 @49( :;C%!%% #% %%5!%3%6(

; 4 3 5 )5 5 ) ; % 5! 2%5% .%%5%% 6%%%5!6%%%;6%55 .% 55%%6$6 5%3 %6 .%6%;3%5!%5 ;

!$3!%6!66 5%! .%!%6% 5! 5

#% %332%$% 3%5@%2'! #! +% .%%% .%52%3%6%#$%9!( : !%5!%5 55;5!3%3%%

6%%6!; .%5!%5 55; 63%5%

.%6 6;

%#%3%6( ; 4 .%5!%3>/(

8 1 # #! +% '62 % 6 !%!6226%%5 .% $

3%%6% * 63 35 !6!!% .% 6!!3%5!%5 5!3%3% %6%3%5 .% 6%3%% 2 .% %5!6;3 .%5!% 636%%@% %

%%%@%5! /6! %% ;55%!%;#

? /1;$ % ;!% /!%32 %5!C5(@ 3#3%= '%7

8; ?

! 5 % 6!%% %% %6$!3%% %3%6$6%23%5 /% %6 '5%%6%#$% 46 6#$% 3 46465+ 33 @46#$% 1%6 4 % 6 %% + %5$6%% % @ 95!: .% %%%% 5% '56 4646#%*%356C5 = (6.5*%356C5=

.% !%5%5!

45@ & 2'! #!+% 9= : 5 C5 % 5! ?

8 .%63@6%! 3%365!5 55;6 %6%3$ /653 5C 53%33 3 ! D 62 15!!3%%@ D 6 2 .%@ ( 632 /@(

6$!C .%@66%C% 53%%! 46!@( 6 5%!6;@ ( .%53! !! ;

%56 2 ,C A .%! 35 %63 % @ 6 C%; ,C A* #!!5 !,C A6!!C 6%%@ (

6326%@ ( 6;5! .%!6 #'& 1# #!+%36% 3C 5 .%C !6,C %C 6,C A,,C A> '%3 5%C !%56,C

'15@#3% 1##!+%6C5 = ';3%%3>/3 '%! >/(

831##!+%% !%;#

7 7?/1 !

%>/6,C A6%%6!% *6 #3% 1% #

23 4 6 C5= '!33%!%6%% % .%5! C5%=76%%% ! % % 5!E ; 2 !%3!%,C 7A,C 7A '56;

!6%%6,C 7A, /6%5;5$; % .%3%%

! 5 3%?

8 .%!%!! !%!6%%6,C

7 4%5 #3% #!% 23 4 6 C5 =8 '%%!6%%%% % .5%%#$% .%6%%1% %!2%6%;$ .%6%6%% %65%% 5!% 23! ,C!%!3 %6%6 %%

#$%! %53% /%3

%1% %!(

?,C A

6%%6 .%!,C 6 !! !!%! /% %6%% 95!: .%%%3%% 6% 63% #$%%5 55;% @ .%63% 3 % 63%%5%! .% !%3 2 6 .% # %55

!%;%#

7 6%#

/1;53#$% 1% 9!( :% 6;55% .%1%63!;; #3 4!%2

#$%6 3!;2

.%2%5!5536

45@ & 2'! #!+%6C51= '%26!;

%5%!553

8 26%!!3= /C5 %%% $6!3%@53%;6%%6

$ /%@ 6%%6!% % %%@ 6$ ;%3%% / %%%5%!%%$6! @( 6%! ' 6%%%@ 6%@@ ( @ ( '% ;3%%;%$%@ '$66%5 C %@6 .%56% ! /%2 %%@ ; !%3;

3C%%23%!%;% !; ; .%%6 5

5!91= :

( 91= : 6 .5 #% 91= : % *6 #3%

1% # 91= :

'*$#3%( ?

1 # #!+% 91=:6C5 (62%9!( :

/63%% ?

8% 234 .%#!+% 4!% 2 5!@ 5! 6*3%#3%%;

55 !%;#

6%#

/1 #

%5 5! %%6 5; 9 55:

%#$%9!( :

2 32%5! 6%))6%% %!36!3 .%; 55

? !%; #

/1 6% 55!%;#

6%#

/1 .%

%5 5! 555%;

353%6$6 %625 % A%;

55!%;#

6%#

/1 +

%5 5! 5 55! %;

55 !%;# 6%#

/1 /6% %;;

%# %;2 .%%% !3 %55 .%C5 91= :(91= :6 .%5%9!( :5 # 1 6 .%;2!!3 3%56!%5 /% %% 6 %; 5!% (% 3;

%5!$!%% @ % 5! .% # % 2 5 5%5!3

!( %2;< +2!!3%<3 !( %;! 3%!! %# 32 <3!( /;5%%

323 6!!;

52 6%% ;3%5%3!( .%

2!!;;3 /5 ;%%# % 5%%<!( .% # ;2%5%65% !! 45@9=:

6%53 C5 95!:

%C5!%6%@ 66%%6! %%@ 6$ ;% 3%% /%! %@ 6 %3 3% % .% 6 ;2 ; 6%% % 5!! %%%%%@ 6

%3 /6;2;5!%;%6% ;66326%%%@ 6 %3 >% %@65%6;;

% .%%6%@ !! ;$ .%%%@ %!!;$ % .% ; % 5 % # % !2 * 95!:%C5

%%%5%)*%) 93#!5;:%55; #%!%%6!33;6%% ! /6;2%6555;%%!3 3525!%!C% % ( % !! % 6 ;C 1= E %62 %

!%%55;%5%6%%% %!%%6!33! 6%% #%91= :%%55;% 5%6%%% (%

!6% 6% %%6 % 6%; 6! /6;2; 5!%; % 6% % @ 95!:

%66%%% 3%6 !%66%% 26%%

6;3$ /6;%6% %66%6; 95!:5 62% >5% 6%;%% 6 5! % % 6 2 % ;

% A .%2; %! 6% 2 ;%%%!%5; !2 .%2%!6%;; 6%%;;632%9!( : +%!!;5%%% ?

6%!!6 ?

65!

;

%5 %5 %;55;;55; 3!%5!)6% % ;5%! 45@9=:6%% 653 5C 5%3%33 3 !632

/!%%5!%6 55; % 5% 5 6% % < % ; 36!3;6%5!% 9!( :6%!5 /5 55;%%!33525! 5! 5! % !C % % .% ;2%# %%6 6%6 ;6% 3%6!%6%5! 562% 95!:6%%6$ 2 !; 5!;

45@91=:%C5%6% @66%6!%%! %%@

6$ ;%3%% .%;2% ;;

%# 6;2%%! % @ 6 % 3 % 3% % % 5! .% 6 ;2 ; 6%% % 5!! %%%3%%%@ 6 %3 / 3%53% %55!6%3!3;6 %!!!!%55!5 / 5 ; % % ! % 6 ! % ?

? % % 23

? * %# %

6%<653%! )%)9%3!:;25%!%%

%1 !5 %6; % %5!!%! )%)9%3!: .%!! 65! ; 3 % / 5 ; % % 5!%3%%%%6C%% 6%%!%655%6$6

'62 2 %%%2;$%6 %2; %3%%%66!

%3%%%%% 5!E %62 % 3 6 5 6%% % ; ;%!% %35;

5! .%5%%5 % ; !! ;

% # 6%% ;

% * %# %$ 266%%!!2$;!;265

;%265 ;$ 6;36% %%%;! /%5 65 %% # %!!$32!!3%< !(

9# # #&(:

- 0, 90-/.: - 0,