Sharad Jain v. State Of Haryana & ORS

   



   
   

  !"#$#%&'&() *+

,-!.!$!&( //0&%!("

1#.'2'

,"!"#!.3!(!!($ "-#.'

 #'/($#("'

 )  45  ,
,,,   45  ,
1,


.#'#(") .,,&(!./2.6$7%!"#."-#!//0&%!(" ,,,!.(6 -#  0#!.(#$  2$&%&!0  !9&'".!"# 
'"  0!''6 !:2(!  !9!.  !" !9!$-.&6  7&$#  -#.  ;2$9:#("  !($  .$#.  $!"#$    *  -!'  !%<2&""#$ .#'/($#("'   !($   &( ! %:/0!&(" %!'#=/."#'"/#"&"&(  &0#$ >3 "-# !//0&%!("!00#9&(9%::&''&(#(%#'/2(&'-!>0#2($#.,#%"&('66 *6 !($?*.#!$@&"-,#%"&("-#
($&!( #(!0$# 4
4A.

'-." .&:&(!0&'%!//0&%!"&(

-!'>##(&0#$>3 ,-!.!$!&(6%:/0!&(!("=!//0&%!("6'##B&(90#!7#"!//#!0!9!&('""-#'!&$ !%<2&""!0.#'/($#("'!($ !'#   ?  $!"#$      @!'  .#9&'"#.#$  !9!&('"

.#'/($#("'!($."-##(%#/2(&'-!>0#2($#.,#%"&('66 *6  6 !($ ?*  .#!$ @&"- ,#%"&(  
"#. &(7#'"&9!"&(6 !

%!(%#00!"&(.#/."@!''2>:&""#$>3"-# 0&%# 0&%#,"!"&(2.&!6&'".&%"

!:2(!!9!. ,-!.!$!&(6%:/0!&(!("=!//0&%!("6!99.&#7#$!9!&('""-# %!(%#00!"&(.#/."6&0#$!/."#'"/#"&"&(!00#9&(9%::&''&(#(%#'

/2(&'-!>0#2($#.,#%"&('66*6 !($?*.#!$@&"-,#%"&( -#/."#'"/#"&"&("-!"@!'&0#$@!'".#!"#$!'!%:/0!&(" -#  0#!.(#$  2$&%&!0  !9&'".!"# 
'"  0!''6 !:2(!  !9!.  !" !9!$-.&!"#..#%.$&(9/.#0&:&(!.3#7&$#(%#7&$#.$#.$!"#$+  '2::(#$.#'/($#("'!($"!%#".&!0."-##(%#'2($#.,#%"&(' 66 6?*.#!$@&"-,#%"&(
-#'!&$'2::(&(9.$#.6&( 7&#@"-#>'#.7!"&('"-#0#!.(#$$$&"&(!0,#''&('2$9#6!:2(! !9!.!"!9!$-.&&("-#.$#.$!"#$+ 6@!'.#%('&$#.#$!($!.#'- '2::(&(9.$#.@!'/!''#$(*  %!00&(92/("-#!%%2'#$"!%# ".&!0."-#!.#'!&$#(%#'-#!%%2'#$!//#!.#$!($@#.##(0!.9#$( >!&0(*  -#/.#%-!.9##7&$#(%#@!'"-#(.#%.$#$@-&%-@!' %0'#$(



 ? -#!%%2'#$@#.#%-!.9#$(*  *."-# #(%#'2($#.,#%"&('66*6 .#!$@&"-,#%"&(

("-# !"#.%-!.9##7&$#(%#6"20!&(C?!($"-#%:/0!&(!(",-!.!$!&(C* @#.#2."-#.%.''#D!:&(#$>3"-#0#!.(#$$##(%#%2('#0-#%:/0!&(!(" %0'#$-&'#7&$#(%#!"#.%-!.9#( + *
($##(%#.E!:!0,-!.:!6 C @!'2."-#.#D!:&(#$,"!"#:#("'"-#!%%2'#$2($#.,#%"&(  "-#$#.&:&(!0 .%#$2.# F.

GA.'-." @#.#.#%.$#$&(@-&%- "-#3/0#!$#$"-#&.!0'#!//0&%!"&( -#%:/0!&(!("&(-&'/."#'"/#"&"&(!00#9#$"-!"-#@!'%!00#$ >3"-#,  0&%#,"!"&(,!$!.!:2(!!9!.!""-# 0&%#,"!"&(( H .#9!.$&(9 H$!"#$H ."-##(%#'2($#.

,#%"&('  *6  6  ?*  !($   
  0$9#$  !9!&('"  "-#  !%%2'#$   -# %:/0!&(!("@#("""-# 0&%#,"!"&(!"!>2"?/:!($@-&0#.#"2.(&(9 -#'!@!7#-&%0#%:&(9"@!.$'-&:-#!%%2'#$9"$@(.:"-#'!&$ 7#-&%0#!($!""!%B#$-&:%%.$&(9""-#7#.'&("-#%:/0!&(!("6-#'!@

!9.##(%02.I2!0&'7#-&%0#@&"-

%:&(9.:-&'.("'&$#.:

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

$:#("&(#$&(-&'/."#'" /#"&"&("-!""-#7#-&%0#&(@-&%-"-#!%%2'#$@#.#'&""&(9-!$%:#.:-&' .("  '&$#   "-#.  $&'%.#/!(%&#'  @#.#  !0'  ("&%#$  &(  "-#  %!'#    "-# %:/0!&(!("6@-&%--!'.#'20"#$&("-#!%<2&""!0.#'/($#("'!

#'/($#("'!($6&("#.:'"-#;2$9:#("!($.$#. !9!&('"@-&%-0#!7#"!//#!0&'>#&(9/.!3#$.-!7#>##(!%<2&""#$!($"-# %!(%#00!"&(.#/."&0#$>3"-#/0&%#-!'>##(!%%#/"#$ "#. &0&(9 "-#!//0&%!"&('##B&(90#!7#"!//#!06  ?    

 -!'  >##(  &0#$  >3  ,-!.!$  !&(6  %:/0!&(!("6  '##B&(9 /#.:&''&("/.#/(#"-#-#!.&(9"-#!//0&%!"&(.0#!7#!($9.!("-&: "-#0&>#."3"@&"-$.!@"-#'!:#&(7&#@"-#%:/.:&'#$!"#$ +

@-&%--!'>##(#("#.#$&(">#"@##("-#/!."&#'-#%:/.:&'#((#D2.#  -!'>##(/0!%#$(.#%.$
("#.:'"-#%:/.:&'# ((#D2.# !

:#("&(-!'>##(:!$#@&"-.#'/#%""%!'# H$!"#$H 

.#9&'"#.#$  !"  0&%#  ,"!"&(  ,!$!. !:2(!  !9!.  .  "-#  #(%#'  2($#. ,#%"&('6*6?*!($

"&'&("-#'!&$%!'#"-!"!/."#'"/#"&"&( @!'!0'/#($&(9J>#'&$#'6!:#("&(-!'>##(:!$#""-#/.#'#("%.&:&(!0 :&'%  !//0&%!"&(  !($  "-#.  %.&:&(!0  :&'%  !//0&%!"&('  "-!"  !.#  /#($&(9 %%.$&(9""-#%:/.:&'# ((#D2.# "-#!%%2'#$!9.##$"/!3!( !:2(" ' ?66=",-!.!$!&(6%:/0!&(!(",2'-:! !(&"-# &.'"/!."3&''2#$"@%-#<2#'.!(!:2(" '?66=#!%-.:-#.

>!(B!%%2("@&"-"-# 2(;!>!"&(!0!(B&(!72.='!9$!:>! &:>#.@-&%-,-!.!$!&(&'"-#/./.&#". #'&$#'6$#"!&0'"-#. %-#<2#'"-!"-!7#>##(&''2#$&(!72."-#'#%($/!."3!.#:#("&(#$
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

 ((#D2.# 6&"@20$ >#  ;2'"  !($  #D/#$&#("  "  9.!("  0&>#."3  "  "-#  !//0&%!("  "  @&"-$.!@  -&' !//0&%!"&('##B&(90#!7#"!//#!0 %%.$&(9036"-# ?

'##B&(9/.#/(#:#("

"-#-#!.&(9"-#!//#!0!($.!00@&(9"-#!//0&%!(""@&"-$.!@"-# !//#!0&'!00@#$!($"-#!//0&%!"&(  

'##B&(9

    0#!7#"!//#!0&'$&':&''#$!'@&"-$.!@(

,,,!.( 2$9#

7(##'--&(9!( 2$9#

*+

.##:!

"#) C-#"-#.'/#!B&(9=.#!'(#$)#' C-#"-#. #/."!>0# )