Jai Singh v. Jasmer Singh & ORS
!"#$!%&'&"()**+ &,&(-.
********//0&%( '
1!2'3'
'4!2,&(-.($" .!2'
******* !'/"($!( '
) 56 * , 7 6, 2!'!( ) 2*,"4 .,&(&8$9"% !8 #"2//0&%( * * * 6, 8* .&'"2$!2:&00$&'/"'!"#//0&% &"(#&0!$;<//0&%( 3($!2 ,!% &"( = 2** *#"2-2( "#0!9! "//!0-&(' >3$-4!( "# %?3& 0 $ !$ **8 /''!$ ;< 3$&%&0 -&' 2 ! ' 0''8 2&(-2.89&$!:.&%.%"4/0&( & 0!$'
8#&0!$3($!2,!% &"('=8== 2!$:& .,!% &"(= "0&%!, &"(2&(-2.8:'$&'4&''!$* ,."2 #% '8:.&%.2!2!?3&2!$ ";!(" &%!$#"2 .!/32/"'!"# $&'/"'0"#/2!'!( //0&% &"(82! . 0($"#//0&%( %"4/0&(( ($ 0($"#%%3'!$$>"&(!%." .!28'& 3 !$&( .!2!9!(3!!' !7320&*
"4/0&(( %0&4' . .!.$/0( !$'"4!!3%0</ 3' 2!!'0"(-:& . %"44"(;"3($2<;"3 '&@<!2';%A($%3 .!'! 2!!'# !2A!!/&(- .! 2"" &( % &(/2&08*.!2!# !28%"//&%!2!%.!$ " .!.!&-. "#
#!! &( .!4"( ."#3(!8* (**8:.!(%"4/0&(( :!( "
.&'#&!0$'8.!#"3($ . %"//&%!"#B 2!!'.$$2&!$3/($%"4/0! !0< $4-!$*!(22 !$0"'' ".&';2" .!2!.2,&(-.8:." "0$.&4 . "(**8 ;"3 )8:.!(.!.$-"(! "/! 2"0/34/ " /32%.'!$&!'!0#"2 2% "28.!.$'!!(%%3'!$'/2<&(-'"4! .&(-:& . '/2</34/&( .!0($"#%"4/0&(( * (!.2400'":& (!''!$ .!
"%%322!(%!* "4/0&(( 2!/"2 !$ .!4 !2 "/"0&%! "(=**8 :.&%.2!%"2$!$ "*+8$ !$=**8;3 $&$(" A!(<% &"(&( .!4 !2* "4/0&(( 0'"-" $4-!2!/"2 #2"4 (-!"2!' ##&%!2 "(**8:."2!/"2 !$ . 0"''"#%"//&%!&'%3'!$;<'/2<"#'"4! /"&'"("3' /!' &%&$!* "4/0&(( '3##!2!$ 0"'' " .! 3(! "#
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
"4/0&(( %0&4' . "(!.2400'":& (!''!$ .! "%%322!(%!*.! 2&0 "32 .'$&';!0&!9!$ !' &4"(<"#.240"( .! -2"3($ . .! %0&4' . .! ': %%3'!$ '/2&(A0&(- $(-!2"3' /!' &%&$!"(/0( '#2"4$&' (%!"#"(!%2! :2"(-0<' !$ ";!"(!
A&0"4! !2&(>3$-4!( "# 2&0 "32 *9!(#2"4 .!$&' (%!"#"(!%2!8 .240:&00(" ;!;0! " !00:. :';!&(-'/2<!$"('&$/0( '* "2!"9!28&#.240.$'!!( . /!' &%&$!.';!!('/2<!$"( .! !3%0</ 3' 2!!';<%%3'!$8;!0"(-&(- "%"4/0&(( 8 .!2!&'("2!'"( :.<.!$&$(" &(#"24%"4/0&(( ;"3 '4!*
23%&0&( .&'%'!&' !' &4"(<"#(A,&(-. C 82! &2!$ 7(3(-"8:."9&'& !$ .!'/" ($ /2!/2!$ .!2!/"2 . %"4/0&(( %2! !$0" "#";' %0!':.!(%%3'!$:'-! &(-$!42% &"(2!/"2 /2!/2!$* !2!/"2 !$ . !3%0</ 3' 2!!'8' ($&(-"( .!'/" 8:!2! /0( !$&( .!#&!0$'8;!0"(-&(- "%%3'!$8'& 3 !$&(A.'2"*
8+8 :.&%.'/!22!9!(3!2!%"2$ @* 8/0%!$"(#&0!8&'&( .!(4!"# %%3'!$($(" &( .!(4!"#%"4/0&(( * .!0!2(!$%"3('!0#"2//0&%( .'''&0!$ .!2!/"2 "# 2! &2!$7(3(-"8'<&(- . .!$&$(" A!/ :2&:& ..&4($(" $!42% &"(:'%"($3% !$'/!22!%"2$* 4"# .!9&!: . & .'%"4!&(!9&$!(%!"#(A,&(-.
C 82! &2!$7(3(-" . %"4/0&(( %2! !$0" "#";' %0!':.!( .!:'%"($3% &(-$!42% &"(8:.&%.'.":' . %"4/0&(( :'/2!'!( .!'/" *!$&$(" #&0!(<";>!% &"( " .!2!/"2 "#2! &!$7(3(-"* ;!&(-'"8# !2//2!%& &(- .!!9&$!(%!"(#&0!8 2&0 "32 .' A!("(!
"# :"/"''&;0!9&!:'*.&' "32 %((" 2!/0%!$& '9&!::& . .!9&!:
A!(;< 2&0 "32 *.!2!&'("-2"3($ "&( !2#!2!&( .!>3$-4!( "# %?3& 0$ !$**8/''!$;<0!2(!$3$&%&0-&' 2 !' 0''8
= 2&(-2.* !(%!8//0&% &"(#"20!9! "//!0-&(' >3$-4!( "# %?3& 0&'$&'4&''!$*
6,
**+ '>A' C.! .!2'/!A&(-"2$!2 ) !'
"
C.! .!22!/"2 ;0!
) !'
"