← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/18484/1996dismissed

Prem Singh Mor v. Hseb Etc.

2024-09-30Mr. Justice Jasgurpreet Singh Puri12 pages

    

     

    



!"#$%"&'('#)*++,, -"./')01 #- +++"!'!'#)"- 2//  -3 ) /! !"4"&!-'&'!3 # -%  +++"(5#)%")!



*  6 7 +/ // 





    

    

 //  8+

- 4   !

"        #       $$%     & '(    )( !!

*+ $**,-. !$/#0 ( 0 ( 11

  1 !!

*+ $**, 1 

1  0  ( 0

 1 

1  $2 !44!)# 

$

5    &  

(    #       #1          

       0  6

       7$2 !44!

1 

1   0807 # 

,

  1  1 0   0    9  &   #1 (



 %%-2/-:/-#/;-/ #< !43$   0#( 0

(&

  #1 6

  ( <0(1 ( (    #< !43$ " & '  <0$**:   ( #< !43$   ((  8. &

8(11& 8(-1 /( 8.8( 0  !2+** !,+**=  

'0. !$!!

*+ $**, # ( 0 !2+** !,+**= #1#(0  

!!

*+ $**,#

 1  (

 . !$

:

5&#11 0

   #( 0  !2+** !,+**= !!

*+ $**,-. !$/ #(1

 1



0!44!11

 

!!

*+ $**,  0    10#(# 

 1$2 !44!

6

(#    #1 

.

  : 

1  > :-/

1 #1#

8=87#)#  0

 08070   7#(#0( 

#(0 7? 0 111

"     

1    -.   :/      $2 !44!

 #1   . 2  # 0   

1$2 !44!     1         *, !443           #  0 #

1  

1#1#

8=8  -8/       7  

(      

    

1

&)0  1

1

  01   1 =

 7 1(!, *2 !443

5             #1     1    (#0  1  1 #1  %%-2/-:/-#/;-/  #0 &0

& 0

# (   8.  0 #( 0 6

(& 0

 #1

 6

  (<0 #1 0 

1 8=87  <10 #1

## 

 #) 8=8#(# 1    # 0. 2  #1) 

1 1 ((  0

        0    (0    1 0        &    <   #

#  

%

5       (       0    #0    #1. 2   (   (( )  0)  1  & 8(  (#0 

 

 1   (8()  ( 

0      )         (  8(   #0 871(!, *2 !443  # #  (#0 

0

 1  (8(

"  1 . % *, !443 #1  (                  1 #      (#0 

0

 1

9  0

 8((@( 0 ( 8( +

5 #1( 0 

   

 (  &

 1. !

*3 $*** " 7 A   & *:

*+ $**+

 ( 0 &



 0 !2+** !,+**=  1 0

4*$3 !233*=  #      

      0  7    # 8  "91!$ $**,0 

   ( 0   &

  0 !2+** !,+**=  1 0 4*$3 !233*=  1 11

 0 0  ( !2+** !,+**=  1 #0 0# 1  #!$0  #( 

1

  11             -.   !$/    #  (  #0  

( #(

 0 0

 10!44!

5  ( 0 #0& #1

  &

0 08. 8(= (8(#(  1 0 

   #( 1

1 (

#)  

 0  1

   %%-2/-:/ -#/;-/

#  

,

5#1#  0

!2+** !,+**= #( .  !$  (   1

 &

 #   0 )#( <   # ( )<  ##0  1( (( 0 1  # 

#( 

 ##1  A7 (1 &

     

 

  !"#  !$ !$

!"%-. $/ #01#1##  #1  

        (  11           !$  0 (  (# &

'  

!*

"( 

 0

0!44!  %%-2/-:/-#/;-/ <

  ( 1  

  (<0 %%-2/-:/-#/;-/  #0&     

    

:



  ! "# !    $                "# !   %&' !

   (   !&

     

    !(     %&) !!

     &



 0 

)#

#(    8.          0          &

8. <0  -/

0 #(

( &

 #1  6

  (<0

!$

"      

       0  6

        1( 0 8.8(= (8( 1' &   ##10((  )  0 8.8(= (8( "  #

#0 

#   )

  (<0# ( <0##( & 6   :-/ 

1-. :/ 

11#

  8=87 

1 $2 !44!  0. 2  *, !443 &:-/ . :. 2   ...

...

...

...

 ! * 

((   '"+", &*   !

-   .    "&  ,            

, &*  ! /  

   , 0

(((& ### ### ### ### '# 12

.'3*'4''""5"*&,'36& %%7"36"34&

8+",/29 :; 6 <:&8&=8&   ,  !      !(  4&  3'2;9>  !    <2 

  (  !  6  "&+ ?&" &   ( !  6 7

   /!&   !       #  

 ( ! 4&& +3'2@28 + ;9>+A&77  ;

&;;&:=& 6 . #  6 (. 8# $          

!         

 6 7

& 3



         6 (    !    #    (%  ';= :7 6$5 ';=

3 6 6 (8# $     (      

          !7

 7 & &1&&?$  B"11   (   6 ( "" & 1 6 (      7

!  !

          

(    !  4&.&;+"/28:>  9 &8&=;   !   (   <2 C* 

((   '"+'""

" , &C &1&&?

  ( '"+'""

" 

       "+?&  " &  

7

    

 '&"&     (  '"+'"" "   ! , (  ;:& &=8&7          0* 

( (

 '"+'" " , C

  

(  

   ( 

( ($   & 

!,  (  ;:& &=8&

 +2.", 1$ & !:

1#(  ( 0   0     88( 1(( 1      ( 0)   8.  8(  #             0  #   *, !443. 21(#0

 1 " ) #   

 #)  08. 8( (8( &( 0#  #0 #0( #)  8.8( (8(#   0

 1 



!2

  1# %%-2/-:/-#/0# (

  8. 5&

 ##8.   8=8.  8(= (  8(    #     8.1  1( 0 5& #1 0 0 !3

" 1  (   )(#1 . % *, !443(#0 

!%

>1 ( 0

  . !$# !!

*+ $**,

 #( 0 !2+** !,+** 1# 1(#(  

!44!# 

0!44!

 "(1#0 &1##0 " . !$# #0(( 0

!2+** !,+** #  1   1#(  #  (  

 &



  &



#0  0 # 4*$3 !233* " -.!$/  

 B>6@8 98>8 "'6>&6 6 "'6> 5'

'"8A

 4& >8+"+'

(&+/&6 <;;&>&9@@:

, 6.1/5(  

&>&9@@>  

!   

2           111  3&;

>@@2

@@2;:>@@(#  3&=@982 ;

88@ -

!.,  1  " &      /!&  !     &; +; +9@@

1  ;9&8&9@@:! 

    1 (11 (3&=@982 ;

88@3&;

>@@2 @@2;:>@@ ( 

 (&1&&?(( &'   !    ( !3&=@982;

88@ & +2D &+/&

, %" +'

(& .1/51$  !+

' #(  . !$( 0  # ((1)< 0 0  #    1   #          1  #0 0 

 ( 0.( 

  (  &

  111  &



#0  0      4*$3 !233*  "     (    )     <  (   0  ( # (#  1 0 !2+** !,+**# 0 (1 0 1    # 0)#(((0 

!,

'  1&

 01  1 #

!4 &)0  1 

 // ++,,    - ;"(1 @ (=  B=> @ #  B=>