High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/15639/1998allowed

Inderpal Sijngh Sawhney v. Haryana State Elect.Board.

2015-02-18Mr. Justice T.H.B. Chalapathi8 pages

!"#$%%$

&# '(&)&))&(* + "-# &+./ -*0/.+ !1.- + &+./.".0+ !1.- "-

4 "5 .55+ ! .5. ",- -2 +!

+ !.- ! %6$

7""

9:;3.,, "-><.+!

?2 <=<

.- " " -2 3.= ,.4 ? $$

$ ?., !

! - -2

+<=3.,, "5."">,3 .@ "5+!

2 2.,.33+.2 !-2 , 0+- <= ?.= ",-."-?+ - 3 - - " 0"!

+ +- 4 , %% 9%%:

",- -0- " "! .,

@ "5.?+ - "-2 ".-0+ +- +.+ 2

+.4,,

@,.?+ - "-2 ".-0+ /."!./0, ! + - "5-2

"-<.+!-5+."--2

--2 +?

? -2.++ .+, ,.4.+= "-2

.4"5? -2 ,- - /- "?., ,,0 !."!30+,0."--2 - ?+ -- ,-.- "-2.,<

!"< 2.4 "-><.+!

!2 ,+ 34 .- "

."!-2 "-><.+! ! -,+ A "!

+--2

34 .- "2 .

?+ -3 - - "?.,.!/ -- ++ 504.+2 .+ "5 <=-2 1 , " "2 -2 ,0+-2.- ,2?-2 ,0+- ,, !

% /.-- + ( ! 0", 4 + -2 + 34.

, + 4 ."

//0" .- "!.- !$$6

9 -"- "!-2.-"

3.= ,.4 "0/ +0, .- 5+ , /34=

"40! "5 -2

.- 5+=?2 2?.,!+.? "5-2 ,./ 3.=,.4 , $$9> ? -2, $9>.,,3 .43.= ?.,/!

"-><.+!

-, ?

?.,"A0,- .- "? -2-2 "-> <.+!-!

"= 8.-4=-2 ,./

---2 +

0+-2 +,0</ -,-2.--2 +,0</ -- !"0/ +0,+ "-.- ", ."! ".44=-2 /305"

!+!

+!.- !%6$

9:?., ,,0 !?2 2?.,A0,-."">,3 .@ "5."!+=3- +!

+ ( ! 0", 4 + -2 + ?04! "- "! -2.- +?.,"-,

@ "5."="

?3.=,.4 <0-2 ?.,,

@ "5"4=

! 3.=,.4

?2 22.!.4+ .!=<

"5+."- !- 8.-4= , / 4.+4=, -0.- /34=

, "-><.+!",033+- 2 , "- "- "

+34.

,+ 4 ."

"-2

A0!5/ "- "'<4 )03+ 0+-- -4 !.,C

E%$$7:;) : ?2 2?., 44?

!<=-2 ,0+- "-2

- -4 !.,C D, E%$$ ;)%$."!C D, E %$67%; ) $6 ".44= 4 0", +3+.=, +, -- "5., !

/305"

!+!

<= .44? "5-2 3+ "-?+ -3 - - " + "-+.

4 ! 0", 4 + -2 + "-><.+!

,0</ -,-2.-.,3 ++!

+!.- !$

3- !-2

+ .33 "-/ "-"-2 3,- ( 5.4,, ,-."- "-2

3.= ,.4 , $$9> ."! " 1 ? -2 , 0""! - ".4 .

3-."

+ .33 "-/ +?., ,-33 !-.5 -.-

+."=/!

+,--2 .1 +/ "-,-.@ " "3.+.

?+ -- ",-.- -"- "!-2.--2 "-.- "!.- $

9:?.,"-+

+."!2

/ 52-2.1 5--2 ,4 -- +.4"5? -2-2 /305"

!//0" .- ".-2 , +,".44 "!

+) -.+= ?2 2?04!"-"

+."= + 52- " -2 + "+ - ? 44 5 1 ."= .0, .- " - -2

+ 3+.=, +! ,/ ,,.4 ?+ -3 - - " .1 "52 .+!-2 3.+- .

04 3 +0,.4 + +! ., ."! 5 1 "5 -2052- ", !

+.- " - -2 "- "- ", +. , -2 , 0+- ,

", !

!3 " "-2.- "-2 5 1 .-, -0.- "

",-."-?+ - - - "!

,-< .44?

44? "5/+ -2.""

.,", - ,."0"! ,30- .-"+ +!-2.-.

+A " "5<=-2

+ " $

$ 7""

> ; " /34 ."

2 , .33 "-/ "-+!

+!.- !$$:

$7""

>%;

"-> <.+! -, /1 !-2 ."/.4= "-2 3.=,.4 , $$9> ?2 2?.,< "5!+.?"<=-2 +2 ,."/.4= "+ 1 , " 3.=,.4 ?.,+ /1 !<=/!

= "5-2 3.=,.4 ?

1 !

//0" .- " !.- ! $$6

9 D !

-2 , //0" .- "

.4"5 ? -2 ."-2 + //0" .- " !.- $:$%

9 744=;

-2 ,1 +=3.=,.4 , 6$> % $$9> .+4 +!+.?"<= 30-=)03 + "- "!

+,".4,, ,-."-

))0"-."-."! +4 .!+.

-,/."

--.4.- 5+ ,< "5

"3.+. ?+ -3 ?.,/!

!--2 3.=,.4 ,%$$$> %$$9>? -2,$$9>3 +/"-2.,,3 .43.= 2 .- "?.,+!

/ ." "5 <=?2 "-2 +A "

!2 ,3,- ( 5.4,, ,-."-"

2 ,3.=,.4 052--2.1

",%$$$> %$$? -2 ,$$9>.,,3 .43.= ",- .! , $$9>?

, "

-2 ,/!

.- " 3.=,.4 -@34.

.4 --4 .

+A " "5

2 ?., 044= A0,-

! " ,0</ -- "5 2 , "0/ +0, "-.- ",

@ "55+."-

,%$$$>

%$$9> - ,

/, -2.- "0/ +0, + "-.- ", /.!

<= -2

"-", !

/3 "-.0-2+ -=?

".44=-2 /305"

!+!

+!.- !%6$

7""

9:;./ - < ,,0 "!

+) -.+=7F;

) ."2@04.!

"= "5

--2 + 2 /305"

!+!

++ .!,.,0"!

+#> C -0+"

! "+ 5 ".4-)2+ )).?2"

= ( 5.4 ,, ,-."-? -2+ /.+@,-2.--2 5.+! "53.= ,.4 ? $."!,343.=?.,", !

."! "- .

3- ! <= -2 .0-2+ -= 2?

5.+! "5,343.=., ,0"!

+", !

+.- " )!9>%69

+) -.+=7F;)."2@04.E <.+ .! "5 .<1 ,. ! /305"

!+!

+?04!

,2? -2.- - ?., . +=3- ."! "">,3 .@ "5 +!

+ "

/305"

! +!

+ ?., 5 "5 - 1 , - -2 + ? -2 1 4 ", G0 /3 "- .0-2+ -= ?., !0-= <0"! - 5 1

.,", ?2 4 3.,, "5 -2 /305"

! +!

+ ?

, "

/305"

!+!

+ , ."">,3 .@ "5 ."!+=3- "

- .""- <

,0,-. "

! 1 .+50/ "-+. , + "-><.+! , .

3- ! + -2 ,.@ .+50/ "- -2.- -2

"-.- " !.- ! $

9: ,0</ -- ! <= -2

+?.,"-+

/3 "-.0-2+ -= -? 44"- /3+1 "-><.+!"/ + -,- ,,,. !

< .0, +,-4= ,3

.1 +/ "--.@ "<=-2 + "3.+.

" 2 ,+ 34 .- "2.,5"

0"! ,30- ! "-2 A "!

+ !<= "---2 34 .- " +) "!4= !0+ "5 0+, 2 .+ "5 ?2 ".3 "- !G0 ,- "?.,30--4 0", "-><.+!.,-?2=-2 + ,"-

2 2.!".",?

+."!+ 52-4=, < .0, - , . /.-- + + +! "

, / 4.+4= , -0.-

/34=

,!+.? "5-2 ,1 +=3.=,.4

?2 2?.,< "5!+.?"<= 2.1

"5+."- !-2

+.4"

04!"-2.1

", "54 !0-.1 "5,. !

-2.- -2 ,0+-

4,"2 , -.- "-"40!

-2.-.- "

"-><.+! ?., .+< -+.+= ., ?

44 ., ! ,+ / ".-+= ?2 2 .""-< ,0,-. "

! " .- +?.,"-4. / "5."=+ 1 , " "-2 3.= ,.4 3,- ( 5.4,, ,-."-,./.-- + .- 2 ?.,

@ "5"4=-2

?2 22.,.4+ .!= <

"5+."- !--2 +, / 4.+4=, -0.- /34=

,- ,.4,"

!"+.+50 !., "< 2.4 "-><.+!-2.- "

5 1 " +0/,-."

+?.,"- +

,%$$$> %$$9>? -2,$$9>., ,3 .43.="!

+-2 +0/,-."

-."< ,.

4="40!

-2.--2 +?.,

+ 52- !.- 2 ,A " "5-2

-2.- , +/$

-, .0, 3.=,.4 , $$9>2.!<

"/!

!- ,%$$$> %$$9>?

$ 2 .<1 ,. ! 1 ? -.@ " <= -2 , 0+- .4, "!, ,033+- +/ -2 A0!5/ "- "'<4 )03+ 0+- "

)33.4', ., 7,03+.;2 1."-<, +1.- ",/.!

<=-2

"'<4 )03+ 0+- "3.+.% A0!5/ ?2 2."<

5. "

044= 44?

! "-2 ,.,

.!.,0"!

+#>

! " #$ % " &

) )

)

" *)$

)

" & "" "$ +++,-. % $ '

# & $

%/ $ "

) " ) % " 0$) "

$ 0

) !1!1 (21 ( "

*)$ "" "$ +3+,-, ) .+,-, " 4 &$$ 6 %

) % " $ $) "

*)$ $ % # "

" & '

" ) $

) "

*)$ ) $

) % "

) $$ % 5 " ) # )$ ) % # $ " & " " $ )

)

)$ ) % $ "

) % #

%/ $ "

% % $ 6 &

) ) *)$ 7'(8

"" "$ +++,-. 5 6 $ ) " *)$

$ " *)$

$ 9 2 .<1 ,. !A0!5/ "-+ "!

"'<4 )03+

0+-2.,.4,<

44?

!<=-2 ,0+- "" 4*0/.+55.+?.4', ., 7,03+.;."!C&0,,.! (.4.+5',., 7,03+.; "-+.+=A0! .43+

"-2.,<

" - !.--2 <.+

.--2 2."!, "-><.+! -2 +.+50/ "-?.,+. , ! ", !

+ "5-2 04 .+ +0/,-."

, "- .<1

034 !? -2-2 .,", / "- "

-2 , 0+- ,

", !

! 3 " " -2.- , "

/305"

! .- " "40! "5 -2

+""

9:2.,<

0"!-< 1 4.- 1 +- 4 ,6."!

",- -0- " "! .

,./ .""-< ,0,-. "

."! , <=, -., !

.-0+.4 ", G0 , ?04! 44? 2 + , 4.+

,%$$$>

%$$9>? -2,$$9>.,,3 .43.= + 52- !.- 2 ,A " "5 $

$? -2.44", G0 "- .4<

-,( --2 "-> .0-2+ -=!-2 "

04.-." .+4=!.- <0- "."=., ? -2 ".

+ ! -?/"-2, !.-

3- . +-

!3=

-2 ,+!

+) "

2.,<

5.44=2 4!<=-2 "-><.+!

+ , + ,-"-2 .++ .+, ,.4.+=.--2 +.- H3 +.""0/

!.- ./0"-< ./ !0

- 44-2 .-0.43.=/ "- "

04 ,"-!"

? -2 ",- 304.- !3 + !

+? 44< + "- ,-.--2 +.- %H3 +.""0/ ,04-."-4= ? -2-2 .<1 ,. !<, +1.- ",/.!

."!

! + - ", ,,0 3+ "-?+ -3 - - ",-."!,.44?

? -2"+!

+.,-,-,

$%%$ ,!