High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-A/771/2018dismissed

Santosh Devi Tayagi v. State Of Haryana And ANR

2022-05-19Mr. Justice Jasjit Singh Bedi50 pages

-1-

"#$# %& '( )( * % $+ ,# - .#

(( //0#"

% 1//00 %

23$4$ *

3- %

% +3

((($/ %6% $ & 78 ( *

* *

""""

* * 9 (

%&%''%&( )!

& + , )! - ) $

&.( &/'0

) ,

' #)

# )

1(2%%%%-

) 34 5

) ! $ ) 0/.6/7. .%&''%&/

1(2%%%%-

8 9 3+

, #

$ ) 3 :

) 0 9 3

* # , )

-2-

%'%&'%&2

3;< , =#

'%%&'%&2 ) !

! '/%''%&7 )! *

) &.(0

/ >

&.(0

'?%.'%&2

+A& ! B@+A&

- B@+& +$ B@+'

1 B@+.

B@+/ 3 BC+2 D B@+( +!1

3# + B@+6 +!

, '.%7'%&/ B@+6 +!

, '/%7'%&/

3-+ +!

! '%&'-&/

-3- #

! %/%&'%&? ? # .&.++

) 3E

3-& +!*

) ! '%%(-%6

3-'

+!1 +

3-.

+!9 +

3-/ +!

3-2 +!B +

3-?

+!:1

3-7 +!+ 4#

! !5 B@ &F '

+ F

) + 1

B@ . + !

F >.'1 '++ D E

B@ ?

+!! >.'1 '++

3-C +!

3-C +! 8?1 &7++

3-G +!! 8?1 &7++

3-H +!! 8.'1 '++ B@ +!:

''%6'%%( )! :

* B@9

) E 0'/? %2%2'%&/ #

)! + %&%''%&( 7

)

%&%''%&(

-4- ( # $

))

) ) , )!

$ !)

! D ) ! ) !

6 , ) &% 9

) ! @

&&(4 5 0

) ,

"# &.60

- $%

-5- &

# && # I) +

)

) ) - , ;:(( %

23$4$ %#- // %9 ; ((

3#<#% 0 );)=9 J) + (&

)

) + $% , &

- +

, &

! + $% .

* . / 0 1 12 344 $!5.5 . !6(4+. 344 (!+..( 7 # (Emphasis Supplied)

-6- ,;(*( - %

% % > %# 23$4$ *

:3 ?

((

3#<#% 0 ) ;=

) J) + - ;3%

+ !$%

$48

9 :;

::. : . & <&! =

0!>5 < 344? 6!5.5 .!3$?# @ 344?!3+..A

B + 63 2 > 5 -

= CC

" "

" !

# $%&'

( !

" " " $& + 6 D-

- .

* :

: : : + $ D- ! C

-7BC-

. 9

9 0 C -

9 B '

) ) ) )

* + %

! ,!

! -

$$-0 1 . 1 1E0

;

- . %%% 3!

5.5 .!(?@ %%%!$+..$?A

B 2 9

+ !

,! (

-8-

(

* +

! !

# !

$?* C

& C

*** *** *** 63-

-96$&5 -: -> >9 $ $(%F :

: B-

7 7 -

7 B

-11<** .) 51

61E- (! * :

C 2 "

9 7

8 .

D! -

7 7

B 66/

+ ! -

. :

: + $%

-106?&/ 01 12 344 $!

5.5 . !6(4@ 344!(+..(A $C) 1 . + $ $% -

)

7 $C) 1 B

C 9

& '

- B

9 B *

9 9

-11-

BB #.

6F & = ! > . 0:+ G - @ 344$!$ +..3$3A

+ $% -

+ $ - * '

+ '

6 & H > 5 .

D 1 @-&5%(+.$(A + 5 )

. )

(

% / B1

-12- 8

B KB L # J) + ;1$ :4< @/ 3 $ 23$4$ 1$ *+ 3<

3/ $9 '

((

3#<#% 0 ;

% & '

+ $ -

+ $% - &

+ -

* +

+ -

! !

! + $% -

+ $

-13-

& D-

! B

3!B

! $! B

! *

B 2

B 7

B+ 6 D- C

C B !:

:C8 - .

B & .

& .

4+ -

-14- + $% -

:+ $

D -

+ $% -

+ $ -

+ $% -

7 9 " " % " " 0 % "

" "

" # $%

-15-

% !

,! !

! ,!

! %

-16-

# $%

0 %

,! !

0 %

)

(

00#

(

! % 5 00#,06

% 5

-17- 00#,06

00#,06 3

1 1

% .00# 8 09# 0

4B 5 # J) + ; %.

23$4$ + %9

((

3#<#% 0 ?;= -

-18- %<'

+ $ -

+ $% - 8

: + $ -

: 7 C '

. = !> . 0:+ G 344$ 3!5.5 . !$ 3446 !- 9. ?? 344$!$+..3$3

IJ&& + $ 63 - - (( % 2

- C '

C '

* '

C '

+ $%

-19-

2 .

IJ&& -

C '

+ $- + $

7 : B 4&

+ $% - 9 9

9 &

9 : 9

C . H ) 1 0

= / 344 ! 5.5 . !(%?344 !5.5 .!6%344 !5-) 3F% 344!6+..?6

+1+ ) 3%C$3

$66?!

B3%+ $ - G

-20- ! ! '

" ! '

$4*

+ $% -

+ $% - &

$ *

+ $%

9 *

9 +

$3-

9 /

-21- $6K

: &

+ $% -

B6?8

7&*

+ $% +

-22-

+ $% - : :

:@+$4H )1

. & 9 9 C K / 0 1 12 344 $! 5.5 . ! 6(4 344!(+..( 5

) 33C 3$!

B331 + $$%'

. :

& 9

! +

C 9

-233$& '

. 9

9 *

9 9 B

3 * C ;

H 5 *75

K E< 344 $!5.5 . !

34?344 $!5.5 .!$$(344 6!5-)?6344 !+(4 B+ ! , &

. C9

-24- 9

B * 9 1 1E0

;

- . %%$!$+..$? 3! B 2 9

+ !

* C 9 &

+ ! *

-25- 9

9 C9

9 B & 9

H )1

! $8 ;;*.> -;. E !> 3443 !5.5 . !$ 3443!+..3$6 %! B*

+ $% .

* :

-26- '

+ $

B # ( ! ,

0 % !

; < = * +

0 % !

8 + $ -

+ $% /

+ $

L 9

-27-

;

0 )

)

> ?

4B 5 # J) + ; $ 0#%.

23$4$ 46#A $ // '

((

3#<#% 0

= - @' 2

* + 0

/, *+3! 0 %

-28-

(

*+ !

*+(

4B 5 &' :

) )

) )#

) @

-@ ) ) ) )@ < ) )! !-@

)

, !

)@ < )

) )

&. , $

@ ! ))#

1(2 3 ) 3

-29-

'.%7'%&/

) )

) 3 $ 3 -@

@ ! @

- @

1(2 3)! )

- #

! )@

@ )!

)) 3

! ))

! ) ))

) ! )) $ ) A

) D )

1&( 3

, !

) ) 1(2 3 ) )!

)

) ! ! ) $ 1(2 3

@ !

! !

) ) < 1(2 3 )

)! !

-30-

! ) ))

)

! ) ) -@

)!+ J) +

+ - # J) + ;(( ..

3B 23$4$ *

+ $+ '?

* = - (!+ 63$ !

! !

/ . :

* '

/ .

/. -

. /.

-31-

+ C

/ .

* . ++

* H

%$6!>5(&-$%-&5%$6.33F , ;

-&5%6?.? F!& .

B .

B+ 2 + * + %?3C$ +.5 %$ 34 -&5 %?3 +. ?3 + -2 ++ 2 %?$+.56 -&5%?$+.F( /.

-32-

:& '

B B B&

9 /.

C ! 63$ ! .-

/ .

> 5 ++

7 '

B * 9 B

+ ++ 52 -&5%( +.F?/ +*+ 2 -&5%(3 +.6$%" '

/ .

* '

/. 2

7 . & '

-33-

/. 1

- $(

# J) + C( % %- 23$4$ :(( .+ , % #39 ; (((

3#<#% 0 ) =9 - @.

: (

= 8

A *0&#*+ &.'+ 4 B3 = *0&.

*+.9+ KB L # J) + ;*

$ + % 23$4$ + % '

(((

3#<#% 0

= -

-34- ?& 7 .

II&I + $F3C $%6! .

. %F$

.B!

+ $F3 9

. + $F$

+ $F6

+ $F?

+ $F(!+ $FF

+ $F +

* '

9 B$F -

CC ! + C 3! 2

C $! ?!

+ =

. + 3!& '

0+ D

0+ D -

%6( 3? %6(!

. - .

-35- . =

C $!

$!,

C ! C 3! 9

/. 6!& '

/. ?!,

C 6!

9 9

(! &

C 6!

C ! C 3!

6. Whereas Sections 379-380 cover special cases of appeals, other sections lay down procedure to be followed by appellate courts.

. . %

B .B!

/ .

) .

. +

-36-

8. Bare reading of Section 378 of the present Code (appeal in case of acquittal) quoted above, makes it clear that no restrictions have been imposed by t

1 '

(

MMM MMM MMM # -

3 ;

'99&*'+88*

+ 0'/ '99&*#+ #6+

-37- *+%

*'+

C 0&

*+D !

" " "" "" " "

1" !

*#+%

*6+(

-38-

KB L # J) + C84% < 23$4$ +4/

*#%.+

+3$9 ) (((

3#<#% 0 ) =9 - @.

- 2

+1 ++ ; 344$ $!

+..3!*

2 '

. +2 + 1 +

; %F$ 3!+..F%$!

5 1 0

-39- + = 2 %%( %!+..33?!

) ++ / 3444 6!+..66!

52H )+

1 344$ !+..?%!

+ 2H+ 344$ !+..3F!

+ 2+ 344$ !+..?!

+ 344$ !+..

?3F! +>* + 3446 !

+..64! KB L # J) +

; .A+4$+ % 2( *

) * =9

?31

+ $F .. /.

?3& 1 + H 344!%+..

% .

+ $F .. %F$& 3 %

C '

> 1

-40-

*D =

18 7 C*0&6+'0 A = *009+#& C

7 C *'99+&. F A C*'99#+9.00=

7 C*'99.+0& 7 8 D *'99&+9' 8

D 8 8 *'99+666% *'990+9'9. C

1 8 % C*'990+. 0 8

C*'99+'##6+

(

; $

%(80#C''& C /*(%

#9#+ @G

H*'+

H*+ H *#+

? 6*

. +* H + -&5 %?6+. 1++ 2-&5%?F+.

3( ;=- + ; -&5%($+.

H ; + 1 %F4!3+..6?4

+ + H %%! ? +.. 63

1 ++ ; 3443!6+..?+ =+2*7 344F!$+..F??!

-41- ?&.

+ H 7 344F!6+..

. +..6$3 63! !-

3! *. . %F$

$! J 9 N

O N

O N O

N 7 O 9

+ N O

6!-

+ '

?!&

-42- '

# (&= >+ 344!4+..6?4 .

O '

F&+ 52 , 344%!%+..$( . 9 2 . +.. $F6 34!34P '

# &+ 1 344%!6+..3F .

/. *

+.. 3( 3!B !*/. :

" !*/. :

" !*

" !*/. : 2 2

-43- ! * .

/. " !* . 9

+ . / . '

B- . 0 + 344%!4+..64 0

)

(

! ?338

B34* 9 7 L *

J 52

H0- %6!6+..($?

D9 *9 <

C- -

= , E + %%3+

3!+..$3 *5 E ..D %%6 +

$!+..((?

= 0 /

344!+..?4 - + 344%!4+..

-4434(= 1H 5+ - 344%!

4+..($(!B

! ?3$&

. H +.

%%%!3+..4

?$& J2;++ H 7

34%!?+..6$( . + $F.. %F$ / .

* . . %?3 & $ B$- '

. ) %F!+..33&

/ /.

. /.

. 4 +.. 3$$!B4<

/ . C

< /.

+ )

-45-

+ )

B $&+ + H %%!?+..63

/. '

/ . '

. /. '

/. 8

. +.. 6(!B 8 2

/. 8 /. . 5 1 0 + = 2 %%(!

% +.. 33? G '

/. C

-46- 1

Q8 7 &

2 &

: 2 1

9 B $3&H5 7 + H %%%!$+..$4%

/. ) '

+ ) '

+ )

* .

+ )

-47-

L '

* .

/. '

+ ) $$&- + -&5%??+.4F ?

. -&5

4%C4! B?&

) &

+ 6F .. 2 '

& . /.

7 C

-48- '

2 +

+ 2 ++ -&5%?3+.?3"8 H + -&5%?$+.33!&

/ . 2

$6&H= 5+ - %F%!+..$??

B K L # + C:

% % %6 23$4$ :

< E$+#9 ) ; (((

3#<#% 0 )')=9 - ?&

& . '

L &

-49- - J H=5, 3443 6!5.5 . !

F?4

. '

& '

. KB L # + CE+

23$4$ *

3- %

% +39

; (((

3#<#% 0 ';= - $8

. '

K 2

. + '

. 8

. # KB L &2 #:

J) + + + -

! )

-50-

) ! + $

) ) ) + ) $

)! #

+ !)

+ :

! )

)! @

)

&? ,

)

)! I) + + -

) ))

! )) 3)!#

+ $

) ) )

) $

)

&7 , ) +

+ )!

* * '( )( *

F+ +3 $/ E#%.13 $ %6&

$1 F+ +3 3/ 3

A0&