High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-A/894/2016dismissed

Deepak v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2016-05-18Mr. Justice S.J. Vazifdar,Mrs Justice Daya Chaudhary6 pages

!!"

# $""%&'

*!+,-,

) )!./ ( (0.)1!+, $ !,".(0!(), 23 4

4 4 53 4

+!,!() +4+-( 6 06.'

)!/.+)1! ()4

4 1!&(,) )&.(-(0!+ !')&.(789:+ ,;!!(/&%!0; ()!!"

# ,!!#&(<%!

6!)./&%!)1!

''.="

(&(< ""!

< &(,) '>-&)) %./+!,".(0!().,4

(07 6&0!&="-<(!0?-0<=!()0 )!044"

,,!0; )1!%!

+(!000&)&.( !,,&.(,-0<! +&4 ((-),1!%% +.-(0847 4=4 .(744A )1!

%.(< @&)1 1&, / )1!+ *&?

&(<1 @ , /!!0&(< ))%! (!

+ )1!&+ 1.-,!4 &, (!&<1;.-+ +!,".(0!() .47 B=&

%.(< @&)1 1&, @&/! 9+!,".(0!() .4: ,.(

,1'

=! )1!+! (0,) +)!0 -,&(< &(,.%!()

;-,&6! % (<- <!4 1! ,#!0 1&, / )1!+ )1 ) )1! @.-%0 (.) %%.@ 1&= ). "

,, )1! 0+ &( @ )!+4 !,".(0!() .47

""+&,!0 )1 ) )1! @!+! '

++&(< "&,).% (0 @.-%0 #&%% )1!&+ !()&+!/ =&%4.@!6!+ 1&,/ )1!++!,&,)!0 (0).%0)1 ))1!

)!+ @.-%0 "

,, )1+.-<1 )1! 0+ &( .(%4 .(,!>-!()% +!,".(0!().4'

-<1)1.%0./1&,/ )1!+*&?

&(<1/+.= ;

'# (0 +!,".(0!() .47 ,#!0 1&, ,.( ). /&+! -".( 1&=4

!,-%) ()% /&+!0,1.)1&)&()1!,).= '1 (0+&<1)%!<./1&, / )1!+4 ""+!1!(0&(< 0 (<!+ )1! () + ( ).@ +0, 1.=!4 !,".(0!().47)..#"&,).%/+.=1&,,.( (0/&+!0 7,1.),-".(1&=@1&'11&))1!0..+./1&,1.-,!4 #&(<

++ (<!=!() ./ '.(6!

('! )1! %.(< @&)1 1&, =.)1!+,1&/)!01&,/ )1!+).+ -= !()+! +& ;-)0-! ).1&,'+&)&'

%'.(0&)&.( 1!@ ,+!/!++!0). .1) #4 .@!6!+ )1! 0=&))!0 1&= ). 6 .,"&) % +&4

".( +!'!&") ./ +-> /+.= !(!+ % .,"&) % +& ;.-) 1.,"&) %&C )&.(./&(?-+!0*&?

&(<1@&)1<-(,1.)&(?-+ +"

&(<1 ./ .%&'! ) )&.( D1.% %.(< @&)1 .)1!+ ".%&'! .//&'& %,+!

'1!0+ -= !()+! +& (0,.-<1)."&(&.( ./)1!0.').+4.@!6!+ )1!&(?-+!0@ ,0!'% +!0(.)/&)). = #! ,) )!=!()4 !,-%) ()% .( )1! ,) )!=!() ./

() /.+= @ , +!<&,)!+!04 (6!,)&< )&.( @ '.==!('!04

) )!=!(), ./ +!%!6 @&)(!,,!, @!+! +!'.+0!04 !,".(0!() .,4 (0 7 @!+! ++!,)!04 1!&+ 0&,'%.,-+! ,) )!=!(), @!+! +!'.+0!04 -+,- () )1!+!). +!,".(0!() .47 <.) +!'.6!+!0 '.-()+ = 0! "&,).%

%%!<!0%-,!0&()1!'+&=!4(&)& %%

,1,.(./)1! "+&6 )! +!,".(0!(), /.-(0 ?-6!(&%! ;-) 0-+&(<

&(6!,)&< )&.( 1!@ ,/.-(0= ?.+ ))1!)&=!./'.==&,,&.( ./ '+&=! )1!+!/.+! 1! @ %,. "+.0-'!0 ;!/.+! )1! +!

<&,)+ )! +&4 ( '.="%!)&.( ./ &(6!,)&< )&.( /&( +!".+) -(0!+ !')&.( 87 + @ , "+!,!()!0 /.+ "+.,!'-)&(< +!,".(0!() .,4 (0 7 (0 )1!&+ ,.(

,1 -(0!+ !')&.(, 78E7 ;!/.+! )1! +!

<&,)+ )!4 ('.==&)=!()./)1!'

,! )1!@!+!'1 +<! ,1!!)!0 ,,-'1 ;!,&0!,-(0!+ !')&.(A./)1!+=,')4 -+&(< )1! "!(0!(' ./ "+.'!!0&(<, ;!/.+! )1! )+& % .-+) /)!+ 1.%0&(< ( !(>-&+

,1 @ 0!'% +!0?-6!(&%!6&0!.+0!+0 )!044A (01&,'

,! ,,!()).)1!-6!(&%!-,)&'!.

+04 ""+ &, % ./ !6&0!('! (0 1!

+&(< ;.)1 )1! ,&0!, )1! )+& % .-+) 0&0 (.) /&(0 &),!%/ '.(6&('!0 @&)1 )1! "+.,!'-)&.('

,! (0)1-, '>-&))!0+!,".(0!().,4 (07 6&0!&="-<(!0?-0<=!()0 )!0444 3!

+(!0 '.-(,!% /.+ )1! () '.()!(0!0 )1 ) )1!)+& %.-+)1 ,(.) ""+!'& )!0)1!"+.,!'-)&.(!6&0!('! &( "+.,"!')&6! = ((!+ (0 1 , @+.(<% '>-&))!0 +!,".(0!().,4 (0741!.'-% +6!+,&.(&(&),!()&+!) ,'.(,&,)!()@&)1)1!=!0&'

%!6&0!('!4 /)!+ <&6&(< .-+ )1.-<1)/-% '.(,&0!+ )&.( ). )1! ,-;=&,,&.(,./%!

+(!0'.-(,!%/.+)1! () @!/&(0)1!

"+!,!() )&.( '.="%!)!% =!+&)%!,, /.+ )1! +!

,.(, ). /.%%.@4 9:

. / + , )1! %%!< )&.( ./ +!'!&") ./ <-( ,1.) &(?-+&!,;*&?

&(<1&,'.('!+(!0 )1!, =! +!

))+&;-)!0 ).

,1 9?-6!(&%!: / '&(< )+& ;!/.+!-6!(&%!-,)&'!.

+04 9: 1!+! +! = )!+& % 0&,'+!"

('&!, &( ;!)@!!( )1! ( ++ )&.( ./ )1! )@. !!@&)(!,,!,4 1! %! +(!0 '.-(,!%1 ,'&)!0)1!;!%.@0&,'+!"

('&!,/.+.-+ '.(,&0!+ )&.( &4!4 9&: F !!"

# 0!".,!0 )1 ) 1&,/ )1!+@ ,'

-<1)1.%0./;+!,".(0!().4 =%!,1 (0 )1!(

,1 /&+!0 )@. ,1.), -".( 1&= @1!+!

, FA *&?

&(<1 9/ )1!+ ./

F !!"

#: )!,)&/&!0 )1 ) +!,".(0!() .4 =%!,1'

-<1)1.%0./1&= ;-))1!+!

/)!+,1! %!/)1&= (0)1!(

,1/&+!0)@.,1.),-".( 1&= =!

(&(<)1!+!; ))1!)&=!./ %%!<!0/&+&(< ;

,1 )1! &(?-+!0 *&?

&(<1 @ , (.) -<1)1.%0./;+!,".(0!().4D =%!,149&&: ''.+0&(< ). F !!"

# 1! + ).@ +0, 1&, 1.-,! 0-! ). /&+! += ,1.) (0 +!,".(0!() .47 3 B=&

( )..# )1! "&,).% /+.=

,1 (0 /&+!0 )@.E)1+!! ,1.), -".( 1&=

1!( ++.@%!,'

"!0 ,)1!,1.),1&))1!0..+./ 1&, 1.-,!4 .()+ + ). &) FA *&?

&(<1 9&(?-+!0: )!,)&/&!0 )1 ) +!,".(0!() .47 3 B=&

( 1 0 /&+!0 )@.)1+!! ,1.), -".( 1&=4 .@!6!+ &( '+.,, !B =&( )&.( )1&, @&)(!,, 0!".,!0 )1 ) +!,".(0!() .,4 (0 7 0&0 (.) -,!

( &(?-+ ). 1&=4 1!

/.+!, &0 '.()+ 0&')&.(, +!% )! ). ,&<(&/&'

,"!') ./ )1! ,!4 97: 1! 1&))&(< ./ )@.)1+!! /&+! ,1.), ) )1! 0..+ ./ )1!1.-,!./)1!'.="% &( ()0.!,(.)1.%0@ )!+ &( ,=-'1 , (. -,!0 ,1!%% ./ )1! <-( ,1.) .+ ;-%%!)@ ,+!'.6!+!0/+.=)1!,".)4 F +"

&(<1 @1. 1 0 "+!"

+!0 +.-<1 ,&)! "% ( 1 )!,)&/&!0)1 ),&('!1!0&0(.)/&(0 (;-%%!)= +# .()1!0..+./)1! () )1!+!/.+! 1!0&0(.) =!()&.( )1! , =! &( )1! ,".) =!=.4 ! %,. 0!".,!0 )1 ) &(?-+!0 *&?

&(<1 1 0 +!'!&6!0 .(% )@. ;-%%!) &(?-+&!, @1&'1 @!+! ))+&;-)!0 ). ?-6!(&%!

,1 (0 1 0 +!'.6!+!0 .(% )@. -,!0,1!%%/+.=)1!,".)4 9: . &(0!"!(0!() @&)(!,, @ ,,.'& )!0 ) )1! )&=!./ %%!<!00&,'%.,-+!,) )!=!()./+!,".(0!()

.473 B=&

(.++!'.6!+./'.-()+= 0! "&,).%4 1-, )1! +!'.6!+ %%!<!0% ,1.@( /+.= 1&=&,1&<1%0.-;)/-%4 1-, )1!+! &, (. !6&0!('! /.+ '.(6&')&.( ./ +!,".(0!() .,4 (0 7 -(0!+ !')&.(, 78 +!

0 @&)1 ,!')&.(7 !')&.(A./)1!+=,')4 %% )1! / '), (0 '&+'-=,) ('!, 0&,'+!"

('&!, "+.6! / %,! &="%&'

)&.( ./ +!,".(0!() .,4 (0 74 1! .;,!+6 )&.(,&()1 )+!< +0= 0!;)1!)+& %.-+) %,.%!

0 ).)1!&(/!+!('!)1 ))1!"+.,!'-)&.('

,!&( %%"+.;

;&%&)&!, &,/ %,!4 ( 6&!@ ./ )1! /.+!, &0 0&,'-,,&.( @! /&(0 (. =!+&)&()1!"+!,!() )&.( (0 )1!+!/.+! )1!, =!&, 1!+!;0&,=&,,!043!

6!). ""!

%&,0!'%&(!04 94 4: : D