High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/8818/2023allowed

Ojas Medical Services Private Limited And Others v. State Of Haryna And Others

2024-05-10Mr. Justice Sandeep Moudgil22 pages

!"#$$%

"#"&#'

!"#$($%

) *+,$ - ,- ,, + **** !

" #$" %& ' " ()"

( *+"

,-. -.#!

/"&!0123 $ /01 #"

% 23- ++

& " 4 +'

5 6%"

7 " -.80-8-. / 9% 01

& +* "5%

&" ,-.% 0:;/.1++ 6%"

7" <= ,88:.

.080-8-. % 0-84>-;?-@82-82;32@0:8; =+ 7

)

"5% /-1 > " " 8;80-8-- "

,.4%&" 7" &%7" "

" '

,-4# ' 7"

% " "

" % !"

" ,-!

7 & +=) !"!

"7 008--8--&%" ' 7% ! &"

#" &%:'" "

& +

%7 "5%

- 2 - 0;8;-8-- / 9% .1

& -

& " )+ "5% !" ! " ,-!5

+=)40?!

"% " ' ! %

" " ) ' !"

" ' +=)

! % 028@-8-- / 9% 21 & " +" ' )

, 7

7 %'4+

%7 "5%

7" " 4

,-.

& " )

+%'

<%'% .2" +%' !"

! % #"

% 0:;/.1++! ' & ,-. !"

" !

-.80-8-. / 9% 01

7 "

7 <= 7 " /.1 % "

" " +% & ! & 7 7 7 <=

" '

& % "

" ,- .! 7% 7 "

' " 9'

)

> , 7

7 % & " +

%7 "5% "

7 6% "

% " " %7

7 7 <= & 5

" '

& '

7 7 " "

% &

& " % ' +% / 1

1 !"#$

#%& '()*/

1%&%+%"

- 3 - %,%

#/ 0%1%

')2%%#344!"

" & "

" & 7 7 <= '

7 7 " " "

6% & % &

& ' ( '

"& "'

"' !"' & % ' % & 7

7 ! " % "

6% '

!%7" /21 = 7% " " ,-. 7 %' "

7 " "

% '% % " ' "" %"

" %7 " "

% 0:;/.1++ -.80-8-. !

"%! 7" 6% " '

& !

& 7 %

! " " " '

7 4

% &

% 7' 5 7 A

% 0:;/.1++ /:1 #" %" 7%' " " ' & "

" 7" <= & ,- . "

7 &% % '4!

7 7 ' & & & 5'

7" 7 % " '

9 '"

%" %7 " "

" 0:;/01/.1++& 7 " <=

- 4 - /;1 % " ,-. "

!" "& "" ' & " " 7 -.80-8-.

7 <= % % " % .?@++ ' & & " *% 7 "5% = %" %&'

"" !%

0:;/01 '% " "

0;8;-8--!' &" ,- . & " )+ "5% / 9% 4-21 !"

" ! !'5

"5%

) "

7" +% % 7' 5." 6,"$ .

,," " 6,"$ 1 %

')' ) "

% 0:;/.1++ % 7 " ' ' & !"

% &" 7 7 <= ''

7 "

7 !"'

7 ' " <= " %

% /@1 *+"

,-. " ' 7% "" 7 &

&" !

7 # 5 " !%

% 7 +=) 8@80-8--!

%" ' " ; '" "

" ! " !

6% & % "% "

% '7 &

&& " # 5 ! & "

' ";'"!"

"! %

& "

> , 7

7 !"

% "" #5

- 5 - !7 &

%' !

"" '

' "

!7% "

7" " " #=

' ?;-8--/ 9% 4--1 ,-!

40? 0-0-8-- % " " ' 6% "%7"

7 /31 #" %" 7%' & " ,-. "" )

> <, 7

7 " ' 7 8383-8-- 7 .083-8-- "

" "

"! ! 7 " <= .080-8-."

> 7 6%

" " "

! %

7 7 ' "

" 7 &

7 $ @0-8-.

% "+'

# '+" !+=) @0-8-- "! " & & "+=) " &

" 7+

0? =

<%'& # % @0-8--!7 /?1 #" 9 ' &" ,-. ""

7'5 B'

7 C "

% ! %

7%' !" " !

" 7% 7 % "" '

%' "

,," "!7#."8"%, .

# & 1%

') (( !9. 5##" 7 % . # , .

# !" ." 1 2 .

4 " " 7

7 '

! %

- 6 - 23-++!% & " %" 9" "

" " % "

" 7 "

& " 7 7 7 "! 9

%' ' % " " 7 " "%7" 7 & "

& 7 % " % /081 % 038@-8-. " &

& ,0 7" 7 <= 7 ! % '

" &

% 0;0++= %" ' ""

-88--8-. "

7 %% %7 "

7 " <= /001 % " 7 "%7" " /0-1 = :. /% 1 " % " ' %

& " 9+%!!" "

&% 7 <= %

7 ' 7" ''

7 A& % 0:2" ++!" " !" "

" ''

7 A& &%" <= %

7 " 7 " 7" "

% #" + % > " "

" !" !"

6% & % !

%' " "% 7 D'

7 E " '7" !"

6% '& ' & 7 <=

- 7 - /0.1 = '5 % 7' " % ' +% ;

!"#$:. !"

" "

" '5

& " " '%& &

"" ! 7

7 " C !"

"! & ' 6% " &

!% "

' "

7 "

" =%" "

" 7

' "

% 5 % % = & " % % &" '

' "

7 !"

" & F 7%

& "

7% " % "%' F"% " = ' & 7' "

7!"

" % & !% " #" 9+%%" "

"" 7

7 B %C B& "C B % '7 C " "

" "7 !

" "

%' & 6%

% "!" 7 7 !'"

% " 7 ' 5!" " "

!% % '7 " C

'&) &

' 7 %

' " '

% ' ' 7 %7 " C

, 7

7 % " #" 9+%

7 ' 4

- 8 -

" # $% & " '(( ((( ( ) * + + ," & , - , ,* .

- 9 - + ' / , * , " * , 1 * , + , / ," 3( 4 5678 - 69) 69: 1 " - ; *; :

( (&0<2+1%= , ( ( * ( ( & 0<2+ 1%= / ( (

- 10 - >, " , / 1 / /021 ,

7 " " " /%7

1 & 7 %& % " 7 7

!& %

" 5!

7 '

!" " " "

% '

'%" 7

7 !

" ' ! % " %& " '

% '&' ' ' "' 7 7" ' % %% 7 % % ' % 7

& "

" 9+% % "

?&@* 1

$ 1 A & $ B=1&

- 11 - = / *

3( + C , D /0:1 #

" " % " ' % !

" "

7" 7 7

7 " " 5 % '

&% #" %" " ! "

7 % " "

% 7 ' " "

7 " '% "! 7

7 " % ""

7" 7

' !"

" & &

! " % " 7 7

7 % "& /0;1 "

7 !% &

"" 7%' & " " !" "& " ' 7% "

- 12 - % "

% 0:;/.1++!% "! " "

"& ' " %

" %

F ' % 0:2/01 0:2/.1 ++ "% "

% 0:;/.1++ & % 7" & "

!&" % ' +%=

0%7 . :. /% 1 /0@1 = 0%7 . :.

& ' .0 !" " & ' "

% 0:2/01 0:2/.1 ++ &

% 0:;/.1 ++ " &

7 " ' " &

% "

% 0:; /.1 ++ %' "

6% &

=!% & 5 0:2/01 0:2/.1++" 9 !"

" % 4 <#%(')

@ > E . , , & $ #%('3) +

- 13 -

& % > = D /031 =" %&'

" " ' !

,-" 7

% 0:2/01 0:2/.1 " & ' % " %' " &

"" ' % "

%" "!""

= '

" 0:2/01 0:2/.1++ ' 7

7 A& "& 7

! 7"

4 4+"7 " %& % " ' "

& " &55 "

' < ='

!" "

' &% 7 A& = " % 7 < ='

" " '

0:2/.1++ !" " 77 ' " %& % " ' ! 7 & " %

!" 7

7 A& ' %="

7"& ' "

!" " "

0:2/01 0:2/.1! 5 " % " ,- % "

+%"

6% " !"

- 14 - &%" ' G "% 9"% 7" ' "

"! % 0:;/.1++ /0?1

& % 0:;/.1++ % % = 6%

5 7 & #"

9+% 0%7 . :. /% 1" !

% 9 "

7" "

0:2/01 0:2/.1++ " !

" " '

% "

! % 0:;/.1" + +

% "

"!" +%" "

% && 7% ?1 & 6: 0 =%= , "B B , - , ,

, , + + )): = 1 3 , - &

62 0 & 6: 0 3

- 15 - & 6: 0 , 1 , B & 6: 0

B - A A F B ;1D /-81 #"

6% ' % 0:2/.1 ++

7 "

' & % "

!% "

#" +%%7" "

%" " & % "

" 4

0:2/.1 ++ !% & %& !"

" !% "

7 & " +% H "

%' % %"

7 & " +% 7 " !% '%&% ! /-01 " % ' !" !" " 7"+%!% & %

7 ' " " %" 7 " <=

' " % D

E "

% "

7 &"

7 77 % 7" "

- 16 - 6%"

% 23-++ %

--;" + % =

7& " 7"+%I /--1 ="

7 !% & 6% "

% ' +% #/ 0%

8"&%44==')33( !" " " 7" +% ! % 23-++

--; " + % =

6%" " <= !

7 %

7 " % %

& !!" " 7"+% 9

" ! % 23- ++ " &% "

" %" !

% " %

- , , ) - ;1 >" & 6:

= * B & 66 ) = - ;1 , - ;1 >G > B & 66 ) =

- 17 - - ;1 " :

-* = + A = +

- A , /-.1 = +##%" .

#12 .

' )(3 " % ' +% "

" " " ! " 7" +% % 23-++ *" %& %

" !"

" 9 &% "

" %7 % " + % " %

% " " ! "%7"!

%7"& 9

7 %

% % !" % " 9

& "

! "

/-21 = !9. 5##" 7 % . # , /% 1 " % ' +% "

" !" % " 4 !% % '

7 %

" 7" +% 9

" ! % 23-++

--; " + % =

'6%"" <=

7 '" %" 7 =%" % "" +%

- 18 - "% & ! 7"

7" 7 6%"

7 " <=

!" %

' 7 "

7 "

7 " <=

" " % 7" % "

% " " + +

% /-:1 +'

7& 5" " & %

% " " ,- ! 5

"5% 8;8@80-8-- % " " %7" !

40? !

"% % 7 ! 5

008--8-- !

" &

@0;20?4 ! 7 & " !"

"! %

&" ,-. ,-! '

J % ) ' %' .?28884! '&% " !

,- ,-."

" 7 % 7 '

& " ! % " <= !% "!"" 7

'5 % " % -;?-@82-82;32@00-84>:8;=+ ' %

& %'

/-;1 <%" ' " ,-."

"" '5 7 %

& %%" " !

0:2/01 0:2/.1++ '% "" !

7" " %

" ''

7 A& , " " ' "!"

" "

% 5 7 A " !" " " %

! '

7 "

- 19 -

7 A& 6% ' 0:2/.1 ++J " " ,-."

& +

%7 "5% " )+ "5%

& %

% .2 +%'

" ' !"

C% 0:2/01/.1++"& ' &" % ' +% 0%7 . :. /% 1#"& 7" ' &" % " " 6% '

! 0%7 . :. /% 1 '

! '

& % 7" /-@1 #"%7" % ,-."

! %

7%' "

! 0%7 . :. /% 1" & ' " " <= % & 6%"

0:2/01 /.1

& ""

7%' "& !

" 9"% % 7' !>!>**4> ?!%."%7 /@ .

#/ 0%:

0;8.-8--/

:::@1" & %% 7' &+

> ""

+% /-31 " "

% " 6%

088--8-. / 9% 081 " '

& % & " +

%7 "5% -88;-8-- !" " & 7

' % 4 ?1 3 E""

- 20 - B = G =EH1! G 5 1 &;+ 7#

E D /-?1 <'" % "

> KJ6%

' "" ! %

7" ,-

% 7 "

' '

' "

! %

" ' 7 !!

" ''

#" " '

9 " ' &" 4"

0< % " %7 -.80-8-. & +* "5% !% "! " & 7

7 7 <= '

7 7 " " %

%' " 9 +% ;

!"#$:. /% 1!" " &

% !"

7 " & % " &

! !"

" ! %& 6% '

5@ :.%.#!#,#%#. .

.%";"%%7 '4)* #"& 7"

"" <= % " & 7 &" % % !

" "

!&" 9+% ;

!"#$:. % "" ' & 6%"

- 21 -

# %7

!%.$ 0 '4

) *44 !" " % ' +% 9'

" %

" 7" +% % 23- ++

"7 " 9

" 7" +% % 23- ++ "

" " 7" +%

6%"

' "

% "

% !% & &% " " %"" %

6% " "

7 %7" & 6%"

#" 7 " 7"+%K " ! &"

' 7 "

% %&

% !"

" " %

7%7" & '

7 ! "' % 0) #" 9 !" %& 7" 9

" 94

! %

--;" + % " "

! % 23-++ !

" & 9 " % ' +% " %

7 9"%

' 5 !" % " ! 9

& & "

+% " !"

" &"

"" & %

8"&%%,2"# . /..1 ="

7"" &

! 9'

7 " " % 7

+% "

" " ' 7

" " %

'% "" "

"" 6% '

% 0:2/01/.1++ &

% " ' 6% ' " % % "

% 0:;/.1++ 7 <=

- 22 - " ' 7'

7 &" !"

%'& % " %

% '

7 ' '

% +

%7 " ( ' "

" 7 % "

" &

'% 7

7 % 0:;/.1++

%% '

" %7 /.21

7 "

" %7

-.80-8-. / 9% 01 & +* "5% !

6% <= ,:. .080-8-. 7

)

"5% " &6%"

$($% " -.#!

/"&!012

&!0

1. Whether speaking/reasoned?

Yes/No

2. Whether reportable?

Yes/No